Stopped in for a few slices the other day with our family that grew up here 50 years ago. Was very happy to see the place hadn't changed much and they quickly serves sll 10 or so of us. The service was great and the pizza was great! Keep up the great work guys read more

Anthony's Pizza is a small family own business which supports a lot of community associations which is wonderful. It's a no frills place not conducive for a restaurant sit down type of place. Everything is made fresh so it tastes good. The aroma of fresh dough permeates the establishment. The only issue we had was that the pasta in our entree was overcooked, it was very soft and mushy. We couldn't eat it. If you're in the neighborhood give this place a try. read more

See all

Great food The pizza is solid and the workers there are very nice A classic local spot that is always open read more

I've lived down the block from this restaurant for three years and I only just started trying them about a month or two ago. I've been missing out on a lot. Their pizza is fantastic and their meatball parm heroes are to die for.. Can't wait to try more. read more

Love their pizza We usually have my kid pick pie up on way home from work but it's nice spot to bring little one for a quick bite. One of the few clean yet affordable pizzerias left. read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Islip, New York

Everything!! Ordered 2 spaghetti dinners , plus other stuff ! Horrible , don't waste ur money !

This is our local pizzeria. We love their sauce. They make a great plain and pepperoni pizza. They have great sales on Mondays and Tuesdays. If you pay cash the pizza is cheaper. It's a small place and the parking lot is even smaller. Coming in and out can be difficultwith a busy road. The owner is a really nice guy and does lots for the community. His staff is always nice and cheerful. My favorite slice is the spinach slice. It has lots of flavor and I'm not sure which extra cheesy adds but it gives it a nice tangy taste. Just wish they had their pinwheels especially pepperoni ones more often. They sell out so quick because they're so good. read more

Anthony's is amazing! We tried the Sicilian Round" and it was absolutely incredible! The dough was fresh, tasty, light and airy with a touch of crispiness on the edges ... sauce was homemade and robust , the mozzarella cheese was excellent quality! What a delicious experience. Come down to Anthony's Pizza and pasta on the corner of Muncie Road and Udall Road in West Islip you won't be disappointed! He offers many different types of pizza and fresh Italian entrées to choose from in addition to catering for your next upcoming event or special occasion! Worth the trip!! read more

See all

Service here is fantastic! Anthony and the girl behind the counter were working so swiftly and it did not go unnoticed. Food is amazing and I look forward to coming back here when I need a warm, flavorful, comforting slice of pizza in a timely matter. read more

The people are nice and food is good. The service is really good. Y'all should come check this place out read more

See all

This place incredible, whether you want a slice, a pie, an entree or something catered you can't go wrong!! Owner does so much in the community too. read more

Pizza, service, & pricing is amazing! I live right next to Mulberry Street Pizza, and have lately been unimpressed by their service(always rude and feel rushed to make an order, even though we USED TO order there regularly) and how overpriced their pizza is. So I tried another local pizza shop by me, Anthony's Pizza and Pasta, and I'm SO glad I did. Anthony's pizza beats Mulberry street by a long shot. Their pizza is authentic and delicious, best in the area. Their service is always great and the people are kind, and they have great pricing. We are happy to be new regulars to this pizza shop. Everything we order is always amazing. Thanks guys! read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - White Pie - Pizza Near Me - West Islip, New York

Came here on a Wednesday with Lulu, yes if dog is servers help dogs, they allow them in.. Lorenzo, and Courtney behind the counter was excellent sufficient fast. Great service. The pizza was absolutely delicious and I will definitely be coming back. read more

Anthony makes a pretty good pie. Their chicken wings are super good. read more

Pizza is mediocre, just okay. The boy behind the counter could use a few lessons in manner, too. Not friendly whatsoever.

My family enjoys their pepperoni pizza often, they don't skimp out on the meat! I just wish they offered gluten free pizza! Crust is thin and the review from my family is 'lots of cheese, pepperoni and not soggy!'. It's right on Udall and easy to get in, grab a pie or a slice and be on your way! In October they had a breast cancer awareness pizza, and contributed to breast cancer research which I thought was pretty incredible for a small local spot. read more

My family has been getting pizza here for the last 20 years or so. We get it because we live nearby, and my parents seem to like it all right, but it's my least favorite pizza place. The pizza is usually undercooked but somehow burnt on the bottom, and the cheese seems to all come off with the first bite no matter what. The garlic knots are usually a little too greasy and make my stomach hurt. Still, they say even bad pizza is still pretty good, so try it for yourself. Some people seem to like it. read more

I absolutely love Anthony's Pizza! They've been here for years and the family/owner is so hard working! They honestly work so hard to keep and are so neighborhood oriented. I love their positive attitude every time you go in and their pizza is hot and delicious! Love them! read more

Upon further review and my first time returning to this location in about a half a decade. This place is awesome. seasme seed crust?? I love You!! Crispy, perfect and Beautiful. The sauce is great and total explosion of flavor. Im happy I have returned and the owner said to me..."weren't you here yesterday?" YES I WAS!.... YES I WAS. The Sicilian can be passed up on but anything round here is a must. Best chicken parm slice and a tasty pinwheel. Not a clean place but they are in the midst of an overhaul. read more

The pizza is good and all but this schmuck at the counter was mad at me for asking for a slice after he put in my friends pizza and cursed at me at first it was funny so I was like joking around with him and he got triggered and said "I'm gonna leave that there for a while" as in he's gonna give me a burnt slice and he gave me a slice that was semi burnt but still edible I'm guessing out of anger? Then kicked us out for taking to many napkins (¯―¯) read more

Very big fan of the pizza here and of the location (right down the block from me, so very convenient). We've used Anthony's for several parties and have heard a lot of positive feedback from others. Our own family finds the pizza to be a great flavor. The specialty pies (buffalo chicken, meatball, etc) tend to be pretty loaded and far cheaper than some larger places. I am not a fan of the parking lot signage, as others have mentioned, but businesses do what they have to do keep their accessibility. I've never been unable to get a spot when picking up pizza, so I guess the method might be working. Also, the parking density is very dependent on the time of day. There is a dance school across the street that, when in session, basically fills every parking lot at each corner. read more

You can't go wrong with Anthony's, my family likes to use them specifically because they do so much for the community and the schools, but we are never disappointed when we do. Staff is great, and his catered food is to die for. We always order from them for every occasion, it's basically a family tradition at this point. Great pizza place, great prices, and great people, you can't go wrong! read more

I have to say Anthony pizza is the best in west Islip ! I think all of Anthony's food is good !

Great Pizza..they even do sesame seed crust which I love! Only problem is sometimes the girls at the counter answer the phones with attitude but hey the pizzas still great. read more

One of the worst pizzeria ive ever encountered. Ive eaten here a long time because of convenience. Its terrible

Love this place. Food is very good and reasonably priced. The owner of the place is Anthony and he knows everybody in town. It's like going to the tv show Cheers. You always get a big hello and an inquiry as to how you are doing. My kind of place read more

Just ordered for the first time tonight and will definitely be back. Eggplant parm hero was amazing, as was the meatball and chicken parm heros. Yum! read more

The pizza is delicious! It's not like the fake pizza you get at most of the other local places. It's the kind of pizza, I grew up. Not too much sauce, perfect amount of cheese and baked to perfection! What NY pizza is all about! Friendly staff, clean business! read more

Pizza always great! Love the sauce and always ask to add sesame seed to my crust which is great. Cheese Calzone is also great! Also my favorite garlic knots around here, and i've tried a bunch of different local pizza places. Not always accurate with pick up times or delivery times, but for the most part great all around. I'm a happy repeat customer. read more

Best pizza in town! I will not go anywhere else. my husband Joe always gets our pizza from Anthony's. I had family over, and they were asking where we got our pizza from, it was delicious and fresh. No one can even compare to Anthony's! Thank you! Joan & Joe T read more

Ordered a pizza and wanted something extra on top that I did not know they did not carry. I heard the owner in the background on the phone say call Anthony's coal fire pizza. Never send a customer away. Unfortunately now I go somewhere else for pizza. read more

The owner is a great guy. We moved to the area 2 yrs ago. And love the pizza from day one. And we have used him a few time for catering. Great pricing and great food every time. Everyone loves it when we cater from him. His food is always fresh. and freshly cook. read more

I went in just to buy lotto yes he has lotto I have never eaten pizza the place is dirty the lotto machine was all dirty the person gave me my tickets then a customer came in for a slice the man did not wash his hands gross . read more

I don't recommend this place at all. Horrible service and I got my food delivered. One they were very rude on the phone. And they didn't even get my order correct. Like at least they can make the food good and not look thrown together, if there going to have a attitude like they did. read more

A real local guy, food is awesome and ready when you order it. Sauce tastes great, isn't "fake". Always a friendly atmosphere and clean when you go in. Try all the options of food they offer, especially the white pizza. They also cater! read more

In a pinch, stopped in to pick up pizza dough. Waited 5 minutes for this guy to make change out of a briefcase of money. Owner charges 5$ for the dough, which we all know that you can get it at any pizza place for $2.50-3.00 Max! Go to the car and wife freaks because this guy charged double. She immediately goes back in to tell him to keep it. This guy has the balls to deny it and says that's what everyone charges. My machine is 20,000 etc.... Result? Never drop a dime in that hole in the wall again and will tell as many people as I can this place sucks!!!!! read more

Been going here for years. Solid pizza and the entrees are really good as well. I really enjoy their chicken parm hero.

Great food and great service! The penne ala vodka is absolutely amazing. The best vodka sauce I have ever had. As for the review about the cheese coming off they use one of the best cheeses Grande. They use to display it in their window years ago. As for the girls with the attitude politely confront the owner about it and take care of it! He will most likely address it. read more

Best pizza around town, owner Anthony and employees are all respectful. Wouldn't give this place less then 5 stars, anyone who did doesn't know what real pizza is!! read more

I called and asked if I could place an order to have delivered at a specific time for a kids party. The party was taking place from 6:00-8:00. After placing the order, the person on the phone said it would take 45 minutes. I reminded him that I wanted the food delivered at a certain time. The food arrived 40 minutes earlier than the scheduled time. When I called to discuss the matter, the owner would not get on the phone and the so called manager I spoke to kept asking me to hold on so he could speak to someone else about what to tell me. He eventually said he would send over new pizzas by 6:30 so my guests would not have to eat cold pizza. The new pizzas did not arrive until 7:05. By this time I had already served the cold pizza since the party was over at 8:00. The delivery person told me that Anthony wanted the old pizzas back. He said he was going to go to the car and call Anthony to see what to do and come back in to let me know. After a few minutes I went outside to watch the delivery person drive away. No response or apology for their mistake. I spent $105 for pizza that was not up to par. Sadly the owners and staff did not accept responsibility for their mistake, offer a better solution, or try to make it better. I will not give Anthonys my business again and will inform my friends to avoid this business. read more