* Service - 5 - Very friendly and quick. * Food - 4 - late evening counter slices, to go. Really good! Sicilian square slice - cheesy, crispy, medium thickness and density. Margaritas slice triangular, thin soggy, garlicky and generous sauce and cheese, decent amount of basil. Both pretty delicious. * Location - Next to Hampton inn Commack. * Ambiance - Seating area was empty, the ambiance seemed nice. Very clean and tidy. read more

Had a spinach/artichoke and an eggplant slice while passing through, both were spectacular. The guy at the counter was nice and helpful. Place had a full bar and nice seating area, definitely more than a take out spot, would pop in again if I'm in that area. read more

Stopped in for two cannolis. I've had them before and they were great. Tasted good this time--that is, what I could taste. Supposed to be filled to the top coming out of each end. Overflowing. The first one was worse than this one. Tsk tsk tsk. Do better. $13 for two cannolis, you can fill them like you're supposed to. read more

Filetto’s - Half-filled cannoli. - Italian Near Me - Commack, New York

Stopped by and ordered take for lunch. Chicken parm was delicious, nice and hearty, pizza was fresh. And portobello wrap was excellent. Service was great, staff were pleasant. Enjoyed lunch. Thank you. Will go back and check our dinner one day. read more

Stopped in for a quick slice during lunch while in the area .This was my first time here after reading the positive reviews they received. All the staff were pleasant and greeted us with a smile. The restaurant is neat and clean with plenty of seating . Everything displayed looked inviting . They were just bringing out an eggplant rollatini pie which looked amazing! One of my favorites! So that's what I ordered ! It was so delicious with a delicate marinade sauce and perfectly baked with an abundance of cheese ! Yum! Will definitely be back ! read more

See all

Found Filetto's while shopping in the area. I was greeting by friendly staff, a clean restaurant and a large dining room. After browsing the selections, I asked if they had an eggplant slice. To my delight, there was a fresh eggplant rollatini pie finishing up in the oven. One slice, please! It was delicious, flavorful, and perfectly made. The eggplant did not have breadcrumbs, which is how my family makes it and it was a pleasant surprise! I look forward to coming back and trying their other menu items read more

Filetto’s - Italian Near Me - Commack, New York

I go here.. basically every Tuesday and Thursday.. I get the same thing all the time. Two grandma slices and they know exactly how I like it "not too hot". I think they have the best Grandma slice around..and now I've been getting the vodka slice.. .. it's awesome. The staff and all the workers are super cool and polite. I'm planning to bring my family there for a dinner very soon. This is a very good spot 100% read more

Filetto's in Commack is a strong four star spot and a great choice for a casual but enjoyable Italian meal. The ambience is warm, clean, and comfortable with a relaxed neighborhood feel that makes it easy to settle in. It's not overly fancy, but it definitely feels welcoming and well kept, which sets the tone for a good dining experience. The service was consistently good during my visit. The staff was friendly, attentive, and quick without being pushy. Our server checked in at the right times, made solid recommendations, and made sure everything arrived as expected. It's the kind of service that makes the meal move smoothly and shows that the team cares about the guest experience. The food was very enjoyable. The menu has plenty of Italian favorites and everything we tried had solid flavor and was served hot and fresh. Portions were generous without feeling overwhelming. It's the kind of place where you can rely on the classics being prepared well, whether it's pasta, pizza, or one of their chicken dishes. Nothing felt rushed or under seasoned, which is always appreciated. Overall Filetto's is a dependable and pleasant restaurant with good service, good ambience, and quality food. It delivers on what you expect from a neighborhood Italian spot and makes you want to come back. A very solid four star experience all around. read more

Food is very good whether dining in or taking out. Take out is always ready on time. read more

3rd time here and always a delight! We've had the same server every time and she never disappoints! Her name is Liz and she is very informed of the menu, accommodating and attentive! Today she came with a refill without me having to ask and also hooked us up with the regular marinara in case we weren't satisfied with the Fra Diavolo sauce we picked (which we LOVED!) Liz always has a smile on her face and takes good care of us! Ambiance- still enjoy the ambiance. Also everyone there is so friendly and acknowledging. Everytime I walk out of here the front staff always go out of their way to say thank you for coming. Here's what we had: Appetizers: -Bread and butter- FRESH bread and so tasty! -Fried Calamari- with Fra Diavolo sauce (spicy Marinara) so AMAZING! The calamari was perfectly cooked and the breading is not overly thick and heavy which I particularly enjoyed! The Fra Diavolo sauce and Marinara sauce are both sooooo FRESH and TASTY!! This coming from someone who doesn't normally enjoy marinara with calamari. Today I have been made a believer if this combination!! The Fra Diavolo sauce isn't overly spicy by the way- definitely doable and spice may even be so subtle you forget it's there. It doesn't take too much away from the taste of the sauce itself. The Fra Diavolo sauce was our personal favorite because it adds another layer to your marinara sauce, although both were delectable!! Entrees: -Farfalle Leonardo: (Bow tie-shaped pasta tossed with shrimp, portabella mushrooms and garden peas sauteed in a flame-roasted pepper creamy pink sauce.) soooo DELICIOUS from first bite to finish! I thoroughly enjoyed the sauce and accompanied with the mushrooms and red pepper it had really nice flavor. The pasta was cooked perfectly. Only comment is shrimp was a bit tougher than I'd like but other than that: PERFECT! -Aragosta Ravioli: (Lobster filled homemade jumbo ravioli topped with shrimp and bits of lobster meat in a light seafood pink sauce.) so AMAZING! The sauce is unique in that it has a certain layer to it that adds depth to the dish. Also the ravioli was definitely homemade and stuffed with a tender mix of lobster meat and also topped with beautiful pieces of lobster meat. Such an awesome experience as always and will definitely be back to try all of the above again and hopefully more! YUM. read more

See all

Came here for lunch for pizza. Ordered the baked ziti slice and buffalo chicken slice. Pizza was delicious, crispy, no flop, good undercarriage. Alot of places cant get a crispy undercarriage on a speciallty slice but filettos nailed it. Only drawback was it was a bit expensive but it seemslike the norm nowadays. read more

Found this because of yelp. Some of the best pizza on Long Island. Grandma slice was awesome.

Came here with some coworkers who always order pizza for staff meetings and rave about it so I had higher expectations. I was a bit disappointed but I guess it's a basic pizza place restaurant quality rather than an Italian restaurant quality. The seating area was very nice and clean and the server was friendly but the food was subpar. I ordered the artichokes franchese and prosciutto panini. The artichokes lacked any flavor at all, not even a hint of lemon. The bread for the panini was not toasted and the flavors just didn't hit. I'm not even sure what the dipping sauce was because it had no taste at all. I would give this place another shot tho and try maybe a pasta or shrimp dish. Prices seemed pretty reasonable and it's on the foodie card. read more

Filetto’s - Prosciutto panini - Italian Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Food was delicious, the prices were very good. The restaurant was clean, and the staff was very respectful and helpful. It smelled and tasted amazing. read more

Filetto’s - Location, easy parking plenty of spaces - Italian Near Me - Commack, New York

Excellent value and good quality food you could share a meal and still have leftovers

Very good Italian food and very good service. The Caesar salad was amazing as was the pasta. You could literally taste the cream in the fettuccini Alfredo. Disappointed in the dessert though and that's always my favorite part. It didn't taste fresh at all and I have a taste for these things. read more

Large restaurant. Open. Airy. Designed nice, on the upscale end. Bathrooms are large and well appointed. Employees are very nice and attentive. Many regular customers know the employees. Food is excellent. Good quality, nice portions. Today we enjoyed the paninis, potato croquettes, and a chicken dish. Aperol spritz was great. The complimentary bread basket is very good. I enjoyed my lunch. A solid restaurant I'm adding to my regular list. read more

We went for dinner for first time at the filetto in commack . The place was very clean & nice big dining area. The service was excellent and friendly. All 4 of our dinners were very good, we all ordered different dishes .All very good portions . The spinach salad was very large and delicious, the apps we had were ok. The desserts were also ok .I wasn't impressed with my regular size cannoli,didn't eat most of it. My niece had the mini ones & she didn't say anything & ate it all. The ny cheese cakes were good but small in size.Coffee was good I definitely will return . All staff were great. A good place to come with family and friends read more

My friend and I went there for dinner on Thursday night and had never been there before. What a treat! They had a special Mon-Thursday night for a glass of wine for $5.00. Got the chianti and it was delicious! Ordered baked clams, shrimp francese, veal francese and the creme brulee cheese cake. OMG! Everything was fabulous and reasonable. Service was excellent and they could not do enough for you. We will definitely go back there again and I have told my friends about it too. read more

Would like to update to say the pizza here is truly amazing. The crust is soft, the sauce , delicious, and the pizza reheats well! Also, they have some of the best garlic knots on Long Island! read more

Filetto’s - Chicken Parm Pizza - Italian Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

This restaurant is better than the first Filleto's in Northport! Vinny has outdone himself here! The service is fantastic and the food and drinks were fabulous! Our first visit was just the family, a small party of 8 and our last visit was a party of 25. The staff was not only very accommodating but attentive and NICE! The food was fresh and perfectly prepared! If you have not had the Ala Vodka from Filetto's- you must try it!!! It is better than ANY other- anywhere! I have been telling him to draw it and sell it for years! Order it for your side dish- you won't regret it! Thanks Vin for another great meal read more

Filetto’s - Vinny my love! If you want good food, you need to come here! The food is ALWAYS consistent-call ALWAYS!! Beat food around! - Italian Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Food was really good and it was within walking distance of our hotel. We have to go back this summer for another tournament and will likely eat here again! read more

Review update: Since finding this place, we have come very often. However our last two experiences will definitely make it our last in general. Last week we had a server that was pretty arrogant but in a nice way if that makes sense. She was not attentive and seemed annoyed when we didn't order that much food (which I didn't know one meal per person wasn't a lot of food what do you want us to eat the whole restaurant). Then a few nights ago, our experience made it definite it was our last. The food was great the first few times and last night as well as the week before the food wasn't that great. We took Pizza to go one evening as well and the pizza was so soggy and oily. And I was very annoyed by who I believe was the owner who gave us a hard time with seating arrangements with my baby. Their loss. read more

Great location with plenty of parking and close by to other shops and restaurants. I ordered the fried ravioli, the Madeira pasta, and the Aragosta ravioli to-go. Very nice on the inside, clean and organized. Bathrooms were also clean menu options were plentiful. There's a bar and a separate pizzeria within the restaurant. Definitely recommend. My server Francesca was awesome. She made great recommendations was very knowledgeable and had an awesome personality. Ask for her when you stop by. read more

Filetto’s - a bar filled with bottles of alcohol - Italian Near Me - Commack, New York

Good, consistent pizza and food. Always makes things right when food order is messed up. A family staple.

I'm a pizza girl. I live right up the road from this pizza place and finally decided to try it instead of going to my usual spot.. I love the set up and the pizza. It reminds me of one of my faves in Brooklyn. read more

This place is top notch. I literally found it on accident when I went to go get Starbucks. I'm a pasta lover, so what intrigued me was their pasta night sign for Monday's and Tuesday's and it's literally for 16.99 for a pasta entree, house or ceased salad, mini cannoli and coffee or tea. I ordered baked clams as well and cocoanut shrimp and WOW!! The portions are HUGE AND SO YUMMY made fresh you can taste it!!! They offer free bread with butter while you wait and it is delicious. They have so many Italian dishes I never even knew of, I promised myself I will try every single thing in that menu. Super affordable too! And our server, *chefs kiss* the sweetest angel ever I recommend this spot 10000% I'll be here every week LOL read more

See all

Best Italian restaurant is Commack because they got my favorite soda Diet Dr. Pepper which is hard to find in most restaurants, even most diners! They have there own pasta dishes as well as what you see in every Italian restaurant. They have a few non Italian food to, like French fries and Potato soup! The waiters and waitresses are very friendly and kind! The atmosphere is gorgeous! read more

The pizza was good, and the people who work there are nice. Why the one star review? They are violating New York State law by charging you a 3.5 percent surcharge by using your credit or debit card. A law was recently signed where they either have to display both prices or display the higher credit price and give discount for cash. The person behind the counter told me my total was 11 dollars but charged me $11.85. I have reported this business for violating state law. Link is below for reference. https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-hochul-announces-new-law-clarify-disclosure-credit-card-surcharges-goes-effect-sunday read more

Really delicious Brooklyn style pizza and Italian cuisine. The restaurant's beautifully designed interior makes it the perfect spot for large, small, and solo dining in a friendly cozy neighborhood eatery. The bar offers a wide selection of specialty cocktails in a relaxing friendly atmosphere where everyone knows your name. ... read more

This has to have been the worst rigatoni ala vodka I've ever had. It was bland, flavorless, poorly made. My order was the chicken parm dinner to go and I paid 32.00 for a meal that does not live up to the expectation. I do not recommend getting pasta from here. Chicken parm was okay just not worth the price. Please do better!! read more

Filetto’s - Rigatoni allá vodka with broccoli - Italian Near Me - Commack, New York

Another pizza place in Commack! Aw jeeze how many can there be? Don't pass this one up. The brick oven and the thin crust is one of the best I have had. Excellent service and easy to place a pick up order after a long day at work. read more

Great food! The service was excellent. Highly recommend if you are looking for quick and easy. Very relaxed environment not too fancy more casual. read more

See all

If I could give 0 stars I would Poor communication with the staff, rude and demeaning personalities. This was a bad experience especially to spend over 120 dollars for food. It's just not a good look especially when word of mouth is so powerful to influence others to walk into your business read more

We travel all the way from Holbrook to eat here! The food is delicious especially the baked clams. Our waitress, Liz, was delightful as well as very efficient. The owner Vinnie stopped by our table and thanked us for our business. He is such a pleasure! read more

Food was average calzone needed seasoning and was rather bland. Pizza was average. Not much flavor.

Best pizza place in the area by far. We have tried all the pizza places in the surrounding area. Feel like we've tried them all. lol. From Dix hills to Commack to Deer Park...Filetto's Pizza is the best in the area by far. From the regular slices to the margarita pies to grandma slices to the special pie, everything is always so tasty. And they have also the best rice balls ever and nice pasta selections. We eat pizza couple times a week. (Pizza is the one food i cant live without.. lol) And beside the pizza being great, the place is clean and trendy by the bar and dining area and the owner Vinny and his workers are sooooo kind and personable. Always smiling, definitely a great neighborhood spot. read more

Great food!! Loved cauliflower pizza and gluten free pasta dishes! Service is good as well.

Today I'll give them 3 stars because of the fact that pizza which I ordered La Parma looked not too appealing to me, it looked burned toppings were not to appetizing. It looks like a Kid thrower some confetti on a burnt pizza. read more

See all

Keep giving this place another try hoping it'll be different.... Pasta is always very dry minimal sauce ... Buffalo wings have not even a drop of Buffalo sauce in container dryer then ever. The women said 20 Minutes I came in 15 no reason my heavy cream based pasta should be this dry. read more