Now this is a family favorite! Excellent flavor - Good Quality - Cost effective! They have onsite seating as well as carry out or delivery options. Everything from the sandwiches to the pasta dishes all the way to the pizza and apps everything is like eating from grandmas kitchen! Haven't had a bad dish yet! Just finished a sandwich and had to let everyone know to add this to your lunch/dinner rotation! read more

We live nearby so we've done takeout from here a bunch of times, and honestly, it's just okay. It's the definition of a standard neighborhood pizza joint--nothing blows you away, but it's fine if you don't feel like cooking. The regular slice is decent, a little greasy sometimes but the crust has a good crunch to it. We tried the specialty pies a few times and they can be a hit or miss. The chicken parm slice is usually pretty good, but the garlic knots we got last time were super dry and felt like they'd been sitting out for a while. Service is usually quick enough when picking up, but the parking lot can be a total pain during the dinner rush depending on how busy the other stores in the plaza are. It's not a place I'd go out of my way for if I wanted a really killer dinner, but for a quick, convenient weeknight slice, it does the job. read more

Very good dinners and pizza. Delivery also comes fast and the food hot. The antipasto salad is very yummy as well and the small is very big! read more

Great food and so many different meals to pick from. Both my husband and grandson can always find something they will devour.

my bestfriend, my mom and I were tired after work so we stopped in for a quick dinner hungry. we got seated and the staff is friendly however, we got the bread and after eating some it was moldy. At first they were being super understanding and we felt bad because we just wanted to see the rest of the tray to feel a bit more confident about the food we just ordered. we decided after speaking to the manager we were going to go simply to not take the chance and as we were walking over we overheard him cursing and yelling about the situation and being so rude to us not knowing we heard him. unprovoked we apologized for nothing out of embarrassment and left. NEVER AGAIN. read more

Good local pizza place. We got a larger pue to go and it really was a LARGE. They have a legit menu which includes many dinners besides pizza. This is great because mist pizza places just serve pizza and not entrees. There's several items on the menu that we want to try. read more

See all

The service was fast and friendly. There with a large open service area you can order and wait for without feeling like you're in the way. Completely opposite of the regular mom and pop strip mall type pizzeria, where you're crammed in a little galley way. Immediately greeted when we came in as well, our order was taken without being pushed and accommodated when we asked for some slices to be cut in half. We split a Greek slice, and warmed it up on suggestion in the oven. Definitely worth it. I tried the garlic cheese sticks and Buffalo slice as well. Buffalo slice was not as anticipated (did not make my eyes sweat) but that doesn't mean it wasn't good just a personal preference. It was more blue cheesy than Buffalo. They had a large seating space and a big window front to look out. People were coming and going at a steady pace. read more

See all

I chose this restaurant because they had gluten-free options and had a dish that I enjoyed on a previous visit without any issues. Chicken franchise with a side of gluten free pasta. Unfortunately, my second visit was a very different experience. I ordered the same meal and became extremely ill afterward with what appeared to be gluten exposure. The pasta I had was a little more firm than it was on the previous visit, so I think they gave me the non-gluten-free pasta, but I can't be sure. If you have celiac disease or a severe gluten sensitivity, I would recommend exercising caution. If you plan on staying for more than two hours, bring a bucket. read more

This place is a must try in the west Babylon area. Dishing up pies and slices fresh out the oven. This slice had everything we wanted in a ny / long island slice good sauce to cheese ratio. Authentic flavor. Slightly crispy undercarriage. Staff was very delightful. Price was awesome. We will definitely be back to try other menu items. read more

See all

This used to be such a prime pizza spot but not anymore. Not sure if owners changed but it had been a few years since we had last visited and not only was food not good but staff was just not friendly and didn't seem to give any care to what they did. Basic stuff like pizza was just bad. Staff didn't smile or act at all friendly. Was really odd. Nothing like what it used to be. Never going back. Too many other options with better food and staff that seems to want business read more

We were in town visiting friends and wanted to try some New York pizza. We were so impressed we forgot to take pictures! Fast, easy, and reliable. We were able to pick up our pies within 30 minutes on a Friday night. Our friend ordered the gluten free za and was talking about it the rest of the weekend just how good it was. read more

Very good neighborhood pizzeria. All the usual slices, a few very good specialty slices, riceballs, calzones, chicken or veggie paninis and a full sit down menu with waitress service for a bigger lunch and dinner! Service is always great as they accommodate any request you have and the ambiance is very nice and laid back. When your in the area be sure to stop in and grab a few slices or that pasta dish that your in the mood for. Thank you Pizzaiola! read more

Pizzaiola - Pizzaiola, North Babylon - Pizza Near Me - North Babylon, New York

See all

We've been coming here for more than fifteen years. The food and service have always been excellent! My favorite dish is the fusilli casalinga. Fusilli pasta with grilled chicken and broccoli rabe in a light garlic and oil brodino. Absolutely delicious!! read more

They make my favorite regular slice on the Island. The owner grew up in Italy and makes one of the best REGULAR SLICES that I have had outside of NYC. The tomato sauce and mozzarella taste so fresh and are premium in quality. The dough compliments all ingredients well. The other pizza types, like the Sicilian and the Grandma's, I do not care for. read more

See all

These guys are good but too damn expensive, sad how pizza from a local pizzeria was once a working class friendly food, not no more

We were short 5 bucks he paid it for us. Then he gave us six free garlic knots. The food was great.

Calzone was good. We came later on in the evening probably around 9:30. Looks like they were cleaning up, but they let us sit in the back still to eat our meal. Definitely a good pizza shop. read more

Pizzaiola - Pizza Near Me - North Babylon, New York

The pizza is excellent. Had sausage and peppers pizza and it was excellent. Same with the mushroom and onions. The grandma pie was good but I like more cheese on it. Will definitely go back. read more

Great, friendly atmosphere and it smells amazing around 100 ft from thr restaurant. We've ordered via Grubhub but I highly recommend picking up the order Togo. Large pie well done is a must and the the pies are huge! Know that you can freeze and reheat in the oven for a few minutes. Sauce isn't too sweet, good crispy dough and hospitable staff! Definitely, a must go if you're in the hood! read more

One of the best pizza restaurants I've ever been to. It's two blocks from my house thank god! My kids and I love it here !

Good food all the time. Good pizza whenever we order. Wait staff is responsive and attentive. They deliver locally. And they do catering for 4 or 40. We have been going here for about 25 years starting with their other location in Oceanside. read more

Best pizza in the deer park area! Love the pizza here. They don't cheap out on cheese & sauce on a regular pie like a lot of other pizzerias in the area do. I get pizza all the time here & have never had a problem. I have had pizza from other pizzerias in the area. I find Pizzaiola the most consistent. High quality ingredients, excellent flavor in the pizza as well as the dishes I've tried. Very welcoming environment! From the moment you walk in the door, and breathe in that Awesome aroma, your taste buds are immediately awakened to thoughts of Fresh Italian ingredients.. and as you look at the menu, your mind wants one of everything!!! It is, in my opinion, The Royalty of Pizza! The staff and personnel from the Top down, are highly trained, with the utmost attention to detail, taste, and Award winning customer service!!! If you want a taste of New York, and The Ultimate Best Italian Pizza and Specialties on Long Island, and the Planet, then definitely hit up Pizzaiola of Deer park. Excellent food , great ownership and customer service read more

Pizzaiola - two pieces of food in a box - Pizza Near Me - North Babylon, New York

See all

I don't usually order Sicilian slices, but I was in the mood for a slice on the thicker side. What I wound up getting was the saddest looking Sicilian I have ever seen. It's not much thicker than a Grandma slice and wasn't even rectangular. It was the rejected corner that nobody would ever choose. No wonder they had it hidden under the counter. read more

Pizzaiola - 2 Neopolitan Pizza Slices, 1 White Slice and the saddest looking Sicilian Slice. - Pizza Near Me - North Babylon, New York

Gabriella was a fantastic server! We appreciated her responsiveness and friendly attitude.

Best pizza in town!! We've been dining here for years and are never disappointed. Friendly staff who have treated my son with autism with extreme kindness. read more

Pizza is good Penne allá vodka was ok definitely could of used more sauce !! It was too dry Fried calamari was delicious!! The girls/staff are nice the owner/ guy is a bit rude I try to order online cause if I keep getting him I'll stop coming .. now w covid though my visits have been pleasant Higher priced than local pizzerias around, Overall good spot ! read more

See all

Mo is absolutely a beautiful hearted soul. I love the staff there. The place is always clean and the pizza is always so fresh! My go to is the hot honey pepperoni slice. It's amazing. Oh yes and I love their rice balls as well. read more

Anyone who reads my reviews of pizza places knows my all important criteria. Well Pizzaiola hits them very well. Best feature: the sauce. Wow. Deliciously sweet and tangy. This is a great pizza sauce. Bravo! Crust is just thin enough to allow you to hold the slice when it is baked well done, as I insist. And the cheese is just a little chewy, tasty and not over played. Every bit of these regular slices was good. I'll be back. read more

Pizzaiola - Nobody is entering the restaurant these days. - Pizza Near Me - North Babylon, New York

It's really a 3.5 Star. Service needs improvement. The waitress do everything which slows things down especially when your trying to get a check. The food taste is delicious but the presentation is not. The Veal was tender & delicious. The Lasagna looks like it came right out of the oven. It was a total flop but it was still delicious. The meatballs are served without tomato sauce. I would prefer them in tomato sauce. The food is delicious & $20 for a nice size dinner with a salad is well worth it. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

Pizzaiola - Veal Felicia - Pizza Near Me - North Babylon, New York

See all

As soon as you walk in into Pizzaiola smells like pure yummines. I moved to Houston, TX and I crave NY's Italian food. I come to Pizzaiola every single time I am in town. The service, the food, the fresh ingredients are absolutely amazing!!!!! The best part, is that I don't feel one bit of guilt for finishing an entire meal .... BY FAR the best calories I eat and I trust me, enjoy every single bite! read more

The food not so good anymore in the last couple of years. This was always my favorite pizza place after moving into the neighborhood 8 yrs ago, now even your pizza sucks . My personal pizzette Quattro stagioni look like a 3yr old made it, the toppings were not distributed evenly. one slice had meat another had olives and one had artichokes. The sauce was bland and watery. This will be my last order from thus place read more

the service is impeccable . the hostesses bri and jenna are always very helpful! the food came out quickly and was very tasty !

Good margherita slice and vodka sauce slice with a generous amount of fresh buffalo mozzarella on each slice. The song "California Dreaming" started playing in the middle of my meal. The house/techno version from Star Trek Picard. This sadness, it never ceases. read more

Been going to Pizzaiola for many years. Food has never disappointed. Dining in or out.

I did not call ahead. I walked in and ordered a large pie. I came back exactly 10 minutes later. The person behind the counter said "just a few more minutes" and I said "no problem, no rush." About a minute later I was told my pie was ready. Went to my car, grabbed a slice because I was very hungry, and the pizza was lukewarm, with cold spots in the slice!!! Obviously, I was given a pizza that was meant for someone else and had been sitting for a while. I can only surmise that they did this since I was already on site, possibly because they thought I was in a hurry, but I was really looking forward to a fresh, hot pizza, and would gladly have waited a few more minutes. Instead I had to reheat each slice in my toaster oven. I ate 3 slices from my $22.00 pizza and threw away the rest. Extremely disappointing; will not be returning. read more

I stopped in for a quick slice, stood at the counter a while and no one came up to me to help for a few minutes, I got a margarita slice that wasn't too bad but wasn't too great and they should have told me it was on a whole wheat crust... that was unappealing to me while eating it, would have just gotten the grandma or something. I wouldn't go back with all the other options in the area. read more

Pizzaiola - Pizza Near Me - North Babylon, New York

One of the staples in me and my family's pizza places. Quick service, accommodating last minute orders. Helpful staff and nice dining area. I go here at least once a visit home. read more

I returned to Pizzaiola to sample a little bit more of their fare. Tale of the tape: Garlic Knots Small and bite-sized, they are somewhat doughy on the chew. When heated up proper, they have a good, satisfying amount of garlic flavor, which is unfortunately overshadowed by the heavy consistency of the inside of the knot. I heated mine up at home in a toaster oven for 20 minutes at 275 degrees. It was enough to give a decent crunch to the outside of the knot, yet the inside remained doughy. A slight re-work of these knots to a lighter texture could well make them a very good knot. Grandma Vodka Slice Tasted thick despite the thin crust, it was savory on the bite. However, there is not nearly enough vodka sauce on the slice for one to determine if Pizzaiola's vodkas sauce is any good. This is a shame, as I've had their Penne a la Vodka pasta dish, and it's quite good, though expensive. See my picture, you'll wonder why the cheese to sauce ratio is off, tipped way over to the cheesy side. An effort should be made to bring this slice closer to the sauce side of the Force, especially so since their sauce is respectably good! read more

Pizzaiola - Garlic Knots - decent flavor, texture is too doughy - Pizza Near Me - North Babylon, New York

Three stars isn't necessarily a "bad" review. It's average or A-OK (as Yelp likes to say). And with that knowledge in hand I can say that about Pizzaiola. My good friend and Yelp-dabbler, Aarti R. Iives near this pizza place and had taken out from here a few times, spawning her first ever review (hooray!) and a reason to go when I visited a few weeks ago. It's nestled in the corner of a shopping center, but once inside you do see some style to the place. No plastic booths or sun-worn tables. Things actually look relatively dapper (yes, dapper). The same can't entirely be said about the pizza...well, at least at first glance. Selection wasn't that vast, but I'll give it to them on a semi-late Tuesday night. They did have the friend-favorite buffalo chicken slice so I snagged two of those (one for me and one for my GF who was meeting up with us soon after). I also went for a white slice and grandma slice to round things out for my lady and I. While ordering/waiting, we mildly conversed with one of the employees, though his comedic attitude didn't entirely rub me the right way (and I usually love that stuff!). I also didn't love that he chatted a bit too much and gave our pizza a little unnecessary burn and only supplied us with one cup of blue cheese for the two buff-chick slices. Meh. Back at our friend's place we dove in. That buffalo chicken lived up to the hype and was a meat-filled slice with a little kick to it. As for "grandma", nothing too special. My girlfriend had the white slice and didn't believe it as good this time (she had devoured one prior and found it better then). Perhaps a third trip for her will divulge the truth? Who knows. Overall, what I do know is I wasn't as impressed as I was hoping to be, especially with the pizza. Maybe a sit-down dinner would suffice better? Either way, it's great Aarti R. likes this spot (to each his own, because that's what makes the Yelp world go round), but I can't say I'd make a trip here for any reason other than knowing it's nearby her place. As long as that's "A-OK" then it's all good with me. read more

See all

I came back sooner than I thought. We ate in this time. The food was just as amazing. We had a panini and a personal pizza. They were unbelievably busy on a Thursday night and short handed. They were working hard though and very apologetic. It was not a problem as we were not in a hurry. A very bright spot in the food landscape of Deer Park. read more