My husband and I were looking for a pizza spot in the area during the latter part of the evening and found our way to Isabella's Pizza. We were cutting it close to closing time, but tried our luck anyways. There were two people working at the time, maybe the owner and his son. They were both so friendly and kind upon us walking in. They greeted us as if they had just opened for the day. They still had several pies out for us to select from, along with other miscellaneous items to add to our order. We were pretty hungry and ordered a bunch of items. Again, both guys were very kind and treated our order with care. They also had no problem with us eating our food inside and never made us feel rushed even though it was nearly their closing time. The service alone was standout and 5-stars. Isabella's Pizza is located in a small strip of shops. They have free parking shared among the businesses. The establishment has several tables and chairs if you'd like to dine in. Their menu offers a variety of items and, even though we came in so late, they had a diverse spread of pies to order some slices. As noted above, we came in pretty hungry and ordered several items to share. These included: - arancinis - plain slice - chicken parm roll - stuffed knots (spinach and pepperoni) - garlic knots Everything was really tasty. Portions were perfect and the price was just right. Definitely a solid find for us in the area! We would definitely return in the future and would ideally look to stop in during the day to really see their full spread and offerings. read more

See all

If you want a run of the mill meatball parm hero that consists of 2 meatballs cut in half for thie proce of $15 I suggest you go here. read more

Isabella's Pizza - Just wanted the meat so I deconstructed it. So much for meat huh and the sauce barely there and bland - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

Been a customer since they opened their doors. They're devoted to providing excellence and they live up to it. Food is prepared fresh daily, staff is polite and everything is delicious read more

See all

Best Pizza in the Islip area. Service is friendly, this place never disappoints. Highly recommend.

Love there specialty slices!!! Salads are HUGE and they do not skimp out if you ask for chicken added! Delivery times and take out orders are fast! It's a small take out and dine in place but it's not a restaurant so it's just a few tables available so if you're looking to sit down during a rush you may not have luck. Definitely recommend read more

I came here today and picked up an eggplant parm hero during my lunch break. My mom has come here many times and always raves about the eggplant. I have had it at her house when we got take out one time a while back. I called ahead and it was prepared quickly. I got there a little early and chatted with Nelson at the counter while waiting. I used to work at this spot MANY years ago when it was under different ownership. We chatted about how it used to look, how long ago it was, and how the place looks so different now, in a good way of course. Friendly service, nice updated decor. Everything appeared clean. Much nicer than when I used to work here (20+years ago.... yikes!). The showcase was fully stocked. The hero was as good as I remembered it from my mom's. I love how the eggplant is not breaded with breadcrumbs. It tastes fresh and tender and you can really get the flavor of the eggplant. The tomato sauce is perfect. Not too much cheese. Even the bread was light and airy. It didn't feel heavy. I ate the whole thing, but didn't feel disgusting after. I will definitely be back to get this again, and maybe try something else, but it will be hard not to get eggplant again! read more

Isabella's Pizza - Eggplant parm hero - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

See all

I've ordered both pizza and catering and both have been fantastic! Service is kind from the counter staff to the delivery drivers. Great take out option. read more

Have always been a big fan however my last two experiences were not good. They changed their pizza sauce and it's now sweet. Hate that. Ordered white pie, they reheated one sitting on the side and placed pepperoni on top. I expect fresh cooked. I will now be returning! read more

This was a huge surprise as this was a little pizzeria in East Islip my hometown. I am looking for the best pizza on Long Island and skipped this restaurant originally but my Grandson had a baseball game nearby and decided to give it a go after the game. Very small pizzeria with not much of a dining area or this would have been a 5 star pizza review. As it was though the pizza was outstanding . No flop , not greasy, crisp and delicious! I give it an 8.1, worth a long drive to get it read more

Isabella'a Pizza at 142 Connetquot Ave. East Islip, NY 11730 is a great takeout place. The name says pizza but all of the entrees I've had are so good. The Chicken Piccata is amazing. The bread they gave me was not just Italian bread but a soft, delicious focaccia. Prices are a bit lower than other Italian restaurants I've gone to since Covid inflation hit. The staff is very capable and really really nice and approachable. Give it a try. It was packed inside but my online order was ready at the requested time. Takeout only but the place is very clean. You'll be happy if you give it a try. read more

Isabella's Pizza - Chicken Picatta. The bread is amazing! - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

See all

I had the Brooklyn pizza absolutely delicious. Took home two more because I don't live nearby. Also bought a chicken roll. Gonna try that but the pizza was amazing. read more

I have been to Isabella's many times and have never been disappointed . Just back from picking up their delicious eggplant parmigiana entree with linguine. I love eggplant! Omg so, so good! The portion size is enormous and more than plenty for two. If you are having other foods along with it three people can enjoy this. The eggplant is not fried in breadcrumbs so it's not at all greasy. The sauce is perfect, nice and light . I know we have a lot of local pizza places in the area to choose from but this restaurant is worth a try ! read more

See all

Pizza is beyond delicious. Service is correct. Ambiance is just right for a small pizza shop. read more

For a small hole in wall place, they have the best Italian food around. We have eaten their food for years, never had a bad meal ever.

This place is great! The food is always hot & fresh! I love the Rigatoni Bolognese (but, I get it with Angel Hair!). They are very accommodating, excellent customer service! The salads are big & packed! Their pizza is excellent with lots of different choices. My favorites are Chicken Parm, Grandma & the Taco pizza! I also absolutely love their Burgers! They are HUGE and better than other actual burger joints around!! That's what I got this trip, the Bacon Bomber Burger. Super fresh, the bacon is cooked perfectly and the fries are outstanding! It's become one of my favorite places, & I'll be going here for years to come! read more

Isabella's Pizza - The Bacon Bomber Burger! Cheddar & Mozzarella cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions & thousand island. HUGE & Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

Food was amazing Grandma alla Vodka was amazing and bigger than I was expecting for one slice. The plan slice was also amazing, along with the garlic knots. Would totally go back again. read more

This is my go to pizza spot. The owners are hard working and really care about their business. Food is always delicious. Well done!

We tried two grandma slices - portions are generous and the pizza was fantastic. They have a huge selection of specialty slices with sesame seeds in the crust. I'm definitely trying one of the specialty slices next time read more

Exceeded my expectations, but saved our life while we were moving. Big portions and tasty food. Salads are delicious.

We've been living around here for about 2.5 years and we just recently discovered Isabella's thanks to a Facebook group. While living during this pandemic, we decided to give them a try (three times!) and every time has been delicious. So far we have gotten the California wrap, Italian hero, the Chicken Bruschetta wrap,a small regular pie, the antipasto salad, calzone and baked ziti dish. We have been impressed by the quality of food and the fair prices, as well as how easy it is to order and the kindness that everyone exudes when either on the phone with them or in person. They have made this pregnant lady happy. Thank you! read more

Isabella's Pizza - Individual Cheese Calzone and Cold Antipasto - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

The food was outstanding people I met wEre nice.The delivery was outstanding they forgot an item I didn't even know 10min later they brought it back.Did I say how great the food was delicious and hot !!!!!!! read more

Ordered the chicken parm hero and pepperoni stuffed garlic knots and had food poisoning the next day.

Marhgerita Pizza - the sauce is amazing!!! My wife had the asparagus chicken in a light buttery lemon sauce - absolutely delicious. I got fettuccini Alfredo - haven't eaten much from eating the other things and stealing from my wife, but my one taste was excellent. The buttery garlic bread thrown in was a great complement as opposed to the dry stuff we usually get. Very impressed, don't underestimate bc it's a take out place read more

A friend recommended this place for its Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza and I was sold! Love these mom and pop places. Quick and friendly service, affordable and decent large slices. We ordered a Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza pie and it was literally A-MAZING! Seriously one of the best pizzas I've ever had. We also got a Pepperoni pizza pie, which wasn't as good, too salty and greasy. The garlic knots were really good as well. They also have other stuffed garlic knots with pepperoni, sausage, spinach, or cheese. Highly recommend if you're ever in the area! I'm excited to come back and try out their Buffalo, Caesar salad, and Chicken Parm pizza. Heard they also have great chicken bruschetta wraps and hero sandwiches such as chicken bacon ranch, philly cheese steak, meatball, and chicken parm. read more

Chicken roll: actually filled with chicken and a crispy sesame shell... delish Grandma pie: crust: cheese: sauce ratio perfecto & so tasty read more

(Sicilian pizza) Pretty solid pizza. Love the dough. The sauce and cheese both have good flavor. The garlic knots were spot on with what I like, and very nicely priced. The only thing I didn't like was towards the middle of the slice gets soggy because of the weight of the sauce and cheese otherwise good. read more

We ordered 2 half trays from Isabella's for Xmas eve. Picking up the food was seamless, quick and easy. The drive home was difficult, it just smelled so good. The chicken piccata was delicious, and the meatballs were really good in a yummy red sauce. They had a holiday special - order 2 half trays and get 1 half tray of pasta for free. It's a great deal!! We had the penne alla vodka and that was really good too. Plus they gave a tray of garlic bread that I couldn't stop eating. Highly recommend for catering. Will definitely be back to try other things! read more

First time we ordered delivery from them. Was fantastic - portion sizes were large and the food itself was outstanding. We are typically picky about Italian food but I was extremely happy with my chicken Florentine- Greek salad- pasta. On point- good customer service and delivery guy as well. Hoping they have an inside to sit down and eat. read more

They need to put more seasoning to their pizzas, and I've been buying pizza for the last two months and none of the pizzas came well cooked. bad service, Guerrera took so long to attend me. place doesn't seemed sanitary also. 100% not recommend read more

This is my go to spot for pizza on the island. I've ordered several different varieties and everything has been mouth watering good. Get the sesame see crust, it only adds to the high level of amazing eats! This is easily my top vote for best pizza on LI read more

Great pizza ! Been ordering from them for a while now . Last 2 times the cheese has been sliding off the pizza, i don't know if they changed their ingredients or if it happened during the delivery . Going to give it another chance and try the hero's today ! read more

The pizza isn't very good and the customer service is below standard. I wouldn't bother going here again. I'll drive further to another place. read more

I keep going back for more! Their grandma slice has become addictive. They always greet me with a smile.

From the outside, this looks like your typical Long Island pizza place, and from the inside not much is different. But the pizza was killer. The staff was super sweet. Definitely one of the best places in this area. I had the fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, red pepper slices and it was one of the best I've had. I also loved the sesame seeds on the crust. Yes, yes I know, this a bit of a divisive issue on Long Island, but man it was good. read more

Isabella's Pizza - Exterior of the building. - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

See all

Got the port pear salad with grilled chicken added. the only plus to this salad was that it was HUGE! Not enough greens too much goat cheese the menu said candied nuts in the salad... they were not candied and the chicken was cut in thick bulky squares which made it difficult to enjoy. raspberry dressing was to thick to mix into the salad well enough for the dressing to get to every part of the salad. would not get this particular salad again. I think Mary's down the road does a better job with their exact version! read more

Isabella's has great food , staff and fast fast delivery . Nelson and Roy know how to cook . Always have them cater my parties . Never ever had a bad experience . read more

Being new to the area we thought we would try take out from Isabella's. We called in our pizza order and it was ready on time.The person taking our order was friendly and professional. When we got our pizza home it was half olives and half pepperoni but the entire pizza was quite greasy with a thin, harder crust and was quite salty. I am from Buffalo, NY where our pizza is a thick dough with lots of Italian tomato sauce and a softer crust. I thought it was OK, but will try other places in the future just for comparison. Perhaps next time we will try some of the other foods they offer. read more

Great pizza spot. Working in Islip terrace this is a fantastic pizza alternative to Mary's. The buffalo chicken pizza is above average with tasty hunks of chicken. The regular slice is perfectly thin and topped off with a generous amount of cheese making it a super satisfying and filling slice. Unlike other local spots I think they also deliver which is huge. I will be back for sure. read more

Isabella's Pizza - Regular and buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

Some of the best best food I have eaten I would order things that weren't on The menu and they made it for me Try there food you won't be disappointed read more

Nice and friendly staff, various selection of pizza with sesame crust. Do not leave without trying their fried oreos. read more