Regular slice on Uber Eats only $3 and it's nearly the size of the box! Antipasto and Greek salads were great as well. Good prices! read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Regular slice and a sausage roll. - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

I can't express how ultimately disappointed by my order of pepperoni and bacon chicken ranch pizza. The pepperoni pie was undercooked and had no flavor or spice of any kind. The bacon chicken ranch pizza was smothered by this mysterious yellow ranch that was soaked into the dough. Needless to say I wouldn't recommend this establishment, the pizza is undercooked and sloppy read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Bacon chicken Chicken Bacon Ranch Pieranch - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

See all

Pizza was great- everyone was so friendly and helpful they even made us some fresh garlic knots! They have vegan cheese which is great to have in the neighborhood too! read more

The Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza just tastes like Miracle Whip. Its terrible. I can't stand that taste and it overpowers everything else. The crust was good. It had a large amount of chicken the cheese seemed good. Everything else was fine. But that Miracle Whip was a terrible choice. Had a grandma's slice and a regular pepperoni which were both good. Pasta was good. Stuffed garlic knots were good. Even had some decent soup. Just dont get the CBR!!! read more

Great pizza, Good size Pizza for a good price. thin size pizza, they also have lunch combos with reasonable prices.

Ordered a large pie half meatball, half sausage, brought it home and the pie was undercooked with waaay too much cheese and the sausage was sliced into slivers, julienned, not good. Not going back there until they get a pizzaiolo in there. It's too bad, previous two owners had very good pizza. read more

Easily the best pizza I've had in my life and the people are so nice! Would definitely come here again, best pizza in east islip read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

Most amazing food. Best staff on earth. Family friendly. Taste like pizza from Italy. Highly recommend read more

Tried Reno's at the recommendation of a friend. The Pizza was excellent and the service was friendly. Next time we will try the seasame crust and the wings. We will definitely be returning. read more

The food is amazing! Restaurant quality. The marinara sauce is sweet and savory. It's a family business and they are always polite and professional. You can sit in and eat your food comfortably or take out. The beautiful aroma of garlic permeates the shop and it lets you know how good it will taste. read more

Great pizza every time! I have eaten at most local pizzerias and Reno's is the best hands down! 5 Stars

Let me start off by saying the pizza was standard LI fare and probably warrants 3 stars but the service brought it down quite a bit. The mother in law ordered a few pies, garlic knots and a calzone for a party at the nursing home/rehab center a block away. Unfortunately the woman taking the order did not hear our order correctly at all. None of the plain pies were put in the order and the number of garlic knots was doubled! The place tried to argue that she never ordered the plain pies but we all heard it. The hubby had to wait an extra 15 min for the left-out pies to be cooked. I can tell you I won't be stopping here again if I'm back in this area. read more

Renzos is a pizzeria I've been visiting since my childhood back in the 80's! I used to eat here with my family as a child! I feel that their regular slices are very good. The combination of cheese, bread, and sauce is pleasant to eat! It's not overly spicy, but could use more sauce. Please make the regular slices even larger. My favorite item to purchase would be their Sicilian slices! It's better than most other Sicilian slices I've tried from other pizzerias. It reminds me of a pizza turned into a baked bread. I think it's really good. The bread is usually nice, and thick. The sauce is good, as well as the cheese. It's surely my favorite pizza to purchase. It just needs more olive oil to keep the bread/cheese from drying out. I used to know the original owners of this restaurant very well! The new owner(Roberto) is very nice too. Keep up the good work! read more

Great vodka sauce, excellent grandma's pizza & margherita pizza as well as chicken Francaise . Staff & owners very friendly.

It is one the best pizzerias in town. I like the taste and it really is a NY style pizza they make them the best. read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Regular slice and chicken parm - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

I went into a local pizzeria and noticed the smell right away. I was expecting the smell of tomato sauce, garlic and basil, but what i got was definitely not a pleasant odor. Nevertheless, i ordered shrimp scampi. The person behind the counter asked if i wanted red sauce. I replied no. I want scampi sauce. She replied many people want it with red sauce, to which i replied...then that is NOT a scampi sauce. I know i should have left at that point, but i didn't. When i got home with my order, i noticed no scampi sauce just oil and garlic. My shrimp was very under cooked and the pasta was overcooked. My first time there will be my last. read more

Honestly... their pizza's fine but my brother just paid over $10 for a small salad that was nothing but lettuce, 2 slices of cucumber (which were both translucent and rotted) and 2 tomatoes with some chicken. Literally the saddest salad I've ever seen and I was looking forward to a salad all day at work hence why my brother had brought me one. Never in my life felt the need to post a review, until today. I've paid over $15 for salads in the past but those salads were overflowing with content and worth that price. When I asked my brother what he paid for this he told me I didn't even want to know. Unless you're just getting pizza, I definitely don't recommend. read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Rotten cucumber - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

I got a slice of Buffalo Chicken pizza. It was excellent! Lots of chicken, great crust, could have been a little hotter but it was very delicious. The staff was friendly and the place was spacious and clean. Great pizzeria. I will be back. read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

The guy working was very nice. Pinwheel was good, the pizza was good and the price was not bad. Great place to stop for lunch. They have a tv that was tuned to a learning channel, my niece learned about how the states got there shapes while eating lunch. This was my first time here and I will be returning soon. read more

The best grandma pie around! Every slice of every pie I've had there has been excellent- and staff is super nice!

Regular slice is usually really really good Grandma slice wasn't my favorite, and I have tried it a few times. read more

They make amazing grandma slices and are not over priced. Plus the staff are kind and professional. You can tell they care about there job.

Best Pizza in East Islip. Family owned. Staff is always friendly and accommodating. I've been going here forever. Ten pies and get one free! Specialty slices are delicious. read more

Dont know where they got those pictures from.. walked in they had 6 nasty looking pies only. And I was the only one in there on a Saturday night. Way to many other place in our town to get a pie. Skip this place, cause what I got out of the choices was disgusting. read more

Been to this place 3 times. Yeah, I'm good. With so many choices in the East Islip, Islip Terrace, Islip area, why one would choose this place is beyond me. read more

Love Renzo's. I've been eating their pizza since I was a teenager. I've seen pizza places come and go in this town; the one down the block from my old house went out of business and reopened 5 or 6 times over the course of a few years. Every time I come to E.I. to see my family and we order pizza, we always get Renzo's. My favorites are the spinach pizza: chopped spinach with garlic and mozzarella on a sesame seeded crust, and the grandma's pie: chunks of roasted garlic, fresh basil and tomatoes, with mozzarella and romano on a very thin crisp crust. And their regular pie is also amazing. There's a reason why they are probably the only pizza place that has lasted this long in East Islip. read more

I've been a customer for three years, and by far the BEST eggplant slice is served here and any specialty pizzas in general is bomb here.

Never had pizza with sesame seeds on crust. But it was really good! It was thin and crispy. I had a white slice so don't know how good their tomato sauce is. read more

My family and I have been using these guys as our staple go-to-pizzeria for over a decade because they never disappoint. Friendly service, good portions, and most of all, delicious pizza. They're one of the top pizzerias in East Islip as far as I'm concerned. read more

Not the 'best' you can get but what impresses me is the consistency. Everyone knows that pizza by the slice in the restaurant is the best way to eat, but ordering a pie at home is often a crapshoot. Renzo's delivers consistent quality in every circumstance. So while there are places I'd rather go to for a slice, when I'm ordering a full pie (or more than one) Renzo's is the place. Don't get me wrong - their eat in pizza is above average - it's just that I enjoy a few others more. read more

The place has extremely good food, stands out from the other places in the area by far. The staff seems to be really nice, very professional and they seem to care about the people who walk in the door too which is a nice touch. My drinks were always topped off. The pizza has a very unique taste and stands out from the other places in the area. Wonderful pizzeria and I will come back in the future. read more

I haven't been to Renzos in almost a decade but I grew up on that stuff. And LOVED IT. There's a reason why they have been in business for so long. I wonder if that jukebox is still there... read more

The owners wife here is very rude. The whole time I was sitting down waiting for my food, she kept rolling her eyes at me. I ordered a pasta which on the menu said $11.00, she told me my food was ready & her daughter was ringing me up & she whispered charge her $13.00 for the pasta. So unprofessional & made me super uncomfortable. read more

I grew up eating Renzo's Pizza.. It's so good! These guys have been around forever...A++

Robert and staff are the best in the business, ghey take pride in service. Oh yeah the food is just as good. I am a regular and will continue to be so for years to come. read more

Renzos has been my pizza selection for many years, wouldnt take my business elsewhere. Speedy delievery. Some of my favorites are the Chicken Bacon Ranch slice, Cheese steak hero with peppers onions and mushrooms. Very delicious greasy garlic knots. Not to mention they sell Vanilla Coke and Cherry Dr. Pepper. Very friendly staff. to the point where ive been given my pick of a ton of free food with my order when arriving late as they are getting ready to close. This place is like a landmark to me and alot of the country village locals. read more