Great find! Becoming my favorite pizza stop. Easy online ordering or call in for fast pickup.

We just moved to the area a year and a half ago, and the reason I found out about this restaurant is because family was coming over to visit us in our new home and brought over two pizzas and a menu. Well, my husband and I have been hooked ever since. During the pandemic we tried to order from them once a week, and I have used them for catering now numerous times. The food and the pizza is so delicious. I just used them for a huge catering order yesterday and everyone could not stop talking about how delicious all the items were. I will always use them for all my parties and holidays. read more

Mema's - Just looking at this photo is making me hungry. Yay for leftovers! - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

My favorite thing to order: DIY PIZZA KITS so everyone can customize their own pie & no one is left unhappy. See photos for how the pizzas come out. Phenomenal every time & a great family activity to do together. Great memories. Staff is extremely friendly. Glad to support local read more

See all

The pizza here is really good and so are the calzones. But, if you're tired of cooking at home and want awesome family style takeout, this is it. They have the family special Monday -Thursday. For $38.95 you get a 1/2 tray of chicken that you pick from a list. Then, a 1/2 tray of pasta and a half tray of a side. You also get garlic knots. We chose the chicken parm, penne alla vodka and the ceasar salad for our side. Excellent! You can add a pizza for around $10.95, if you need to. We had leftovers for the next day. read more

See all

It's ok. Not bad. Cute little pizzeria. I've gotten food a few times and it's fine. You decide. Pizza is personal.

Excellent Catering by Mema's Pizza last week, Eggplant Parmigiana, Sausage and Peppers, Chicken Marsala came with Caesar Salad and Delicious Garlic Knots , Highly Recommend Them and they Delivered it, Thank you Again read more

Food is delicious!!! We cater from them all the time for all our parties! Their cookies are great especially their oatmeal cookies are amazing! The pizza is delicious as well!!! Best Italian food in LI. read more

Love this place. Anything we have ordered has been delicious. Owner and workers are all so friendly and helpful. Best pizza around and love their penne a la vodka too. read more

Nice local pizza place! They offer Vegan options here which is amazing! Prices are a bit steep for what you get, but overall I recommend.

I tried the Sicilian pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was fairly cheap and was good tasting. Nothing unique. Just good new York pizza.

After reading so many positive reviews on a local FB page we stopped in to have a bite. We ordered a pie, baked clams, meatballs and chicken soup. The pizza was good, baked clams were good but really small, meatballs are absolutely delicious and moist. The staff is very friendly and attentive.....the problem was the soup. I would have given it 4 stars except for the soup. It came out with no broth and what broth was there was gritty.....don't know how to explain it. Then I took a bite of the chicken and there was a lot and it had a horrible after taste and smell....it was starting to go bad. I should have said something while I was there but they were so nice I just couldn't. Everything else tastes great and service was great. I just know if I go back I won't order soup. read more

We love you Mema's. I upped my review to 5 stars now. Consistent, fresh, and delicious. We always order delivery. Mema's never disappoints. We ordered delivery and it came within the stated time and they got our order correct. We had one specialty pie: Sausage, garlic, broccoli rabe, fresh mozzarella. Flavorful, large slices of sausage (no skimping here), plenty of mozzarella cheese. Everyone enjoyed this pizza. One star knocked off because as my sister was eating a piece of this pizza, she bit down on a thin piece of METAL! Obviously a piece from a can or something fell onto the pie. Not good. Luckily there wasn't anything else in/on the other pies, salad or mozzarella sticks. Regular cheese pie: enjoyed the taste of the sauce, a good balance of sauce and cheese. Cooked to order perfectly (requested lightly baked). Meatball pie: tons of chopped meatballs topped this pie. Flavorful just like the regular cheese pie with an added bonus of tasty meatballs. Fried eggplant pizza: tons of fried eggplant pieces. They do not skimp on the toppings! Mozzarella sticks: I didn't get a chance to take a pic because everyone grabbed one as soon as we opened the container! Crispy, cheesy, not greasy, pretty much your standard mozzarella stick. Nice tomato dipping sauce on the side. Insalata campagna: I didn't get a pic. I forgot because was too busy eating! This salad was delicious. Field greens, Gorgonzola cheese but we substituted with feta cheese instead. Also plentiful amount of walnuts, cranberries, tomatoes. Light, fresh vinaigrette dressing. Get the cheese stuffed garlic knots!! Delicious!!! read more

They have a really great selection. Not only do they have chicken bacon ranch, they also have chicken bacon honey mustard. Not only do they have a regular ziti slice, they only have a Mac & cheese slice. Also, the Mac and cheese itself it probably the best Mac & cheese I've ever had. The employees were all very nice!!!! read more

Mema's - Clockwise: Plain, chicken bacon ranch, Sicilian, mac&cheese, and ziti - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

Pizza needs more oven time, pretty generic and what'd you imagine "pizza" to look and taste like. What can you expect from a bunch of liberals from the north shore? The price was valid tho, crust was good so bonus points. read more

Do not like the pizza had it awhile ago and left us with nothing to be impressed. Gave it a second go and tried the food on take out. Was pretty tasty and would go back to have it again. read more

So many pizzerias to try in Commack. On a whim tried Mema's and was pleasantly surprised. First of all when you walk in the staff is so pleasant and the smell of the pizzas coming out of the oven is like heaven. The pizza is just perfect with the right amount of sauce and cheese. The crust is perfect with a crispy edge. Will definitely make this one of our go to pizzerias on Long Island! read more

We have catered from Mema's several times for both of our boy's High School graduation parties, birthday parties, intimate gatherings etc. We have always been so happy and loved everything from the food to the presentation and more importantly the service that Jono and his staff provide. Jono takes great pride in his restaurant and making sure everything is perfect. He helped choose our menu, gave honest advice from 200 people to 20, he can handle it all. We are about to plan our next party with him and we know we will love every bite and the process too! Thank you Mema's!! Kim Filardi, September 2021 read more

Very disappointing. They just lost all my business. I will not get into details but treating customers like dollar signs is no way to treat people in the Commack community that keep your place running. read more

Our Christmas Eve gathering was a great success especially because of the great food .My 3 year old Great-Grandsons loved the mac and cheese and meatballs.The went over big with the grownups too as well as the Chicken Mona Lisa ,Eggplant Parmesan and the rice balls and roasted potatoes and green bean! Also a Caesar salad helped round out the meal! read more

Eh idk- the girl at the counter was so rude And clearly didn't care to be at work last night so I didnt even bother asking questions i had. We were going to eat something while we waited but didn't get the chance to even say anything. Apparently they keep your card on file?? We went up to get a drink and she asked if it was the same card we said yes- and she just charged the card. Made us very uncomfortable. We waited for our pie- they all kept staring at us completely obvious to where we were ready to get a refund and leave. We got our food- as well as those spinach roll things SUPER OILY. Never seen so much oil in my life. Would probably not go back, if we didn't get bad vibes I'd probably go back to try but no thank you. read more

They need to taste their food, worst rice ball i ever tried, center of calzone was cold, covered Spinach knots with excess oil. Very disapointing. read more

I placed an order online for grilled chicken. When I picked up my order and came home, I was given fried chicken, not grilled. I called up to see if there was something that can be done because I can't eat fried chicken for health reasons and the people on the phone told me outright that I was wrong because I checked the box that said "chicken breast" and that means fried. Never once did they apologize or try to do anything to help me; all they kept saying was that it was my own fault, even though the receipt clearly says grilled chicken. Tl;dr: Horrible service, argued with customer, customer is not always right read more

Love the pizza and the people who work there are so very nice. I will keep coming back. I got a sausage and pepper Pizza and a Greek salad and both were out of this world read more

See all

Saw a local ad for Mena's went to check it out. Ordered the family style dinner wow!! Had chicken francais , penne with broccoli, sautéed broccoli. Came in large portions, food was delicious. Would highly recommend. A perfect meal for 4, hot and ready to serve. Definitely going back to try the pizza. read more

I love simplicity! The ease and little effort of ordering online pizzas for a packed pool party full of kids took the stress out of everything! New to the area trying out local places to find "our spot" has me wanting more Mema's! Try the Pepperoni pizza, it has a kick that's a burst of flavor! Delish! read more

My husband and I were SO impressed. We have a newborn and didn't want to leave the house. They delivered the family special. It was absolutely delicious and we will definitely have leftovers for a few meals. The delivery man was so nice I wish I had more money to tip! Keep up the great work! read more

Tried Memas for the 1st time because they advertised a family style chicken parm special which came with penne pasta and garlic knots. We also added an order of sautéed broccoli and OMG everything was so tasty, cooked perfectly and delicioso!! I had it for lunch the next day and it was just as tasty as the night before. Very reasonable prices and highly recommended for local families!! Moto bene Mema's!! We will be back many times read more

This place was good for a quick meal. The chicken slice was really good. REALLY good customer service. I don't recommend the mussels because they were a little raw. Really really good experience. read more

Was in Smithtown for a bit a couple weekends ago and stopped by Mema's because my parents told me it was good. Upon entering, I really liked the style of this place. Definitely not a traditional pizzeria. Open floor plan, real wood covers one of the walls from floor to ceiling as well as the front of the counter, they have one of those coke machines with 100 different combos of soda products and they have beer on tap. I was greeted by two pleasant gentlemen behind the counter. I'd never been there before so I asked for recommendations. One of the countermen recommended the Cajun chicken slice. A lot of their special slices look LOADED with toppings. When I tell you this one had an inch of chicken, cheese and sauce on top, I am not exaggerating. So that's what I opted for. When I picked it up, to my surprise, no flop! The crust was perfectly crispy. No super well done so that it was rock hard and burnt but just well done enough to hold this massive amount of toppings. Let me tell you, it was delish. It was late afternoon and my first meal of the day so I opted for a grandma slice as well and a garlic knot. The counterman asked which kind of garlic know, regular or stuffed. I couldn't decide so he gave me one of each and only charged me for one so I could try it. The grandma slice was great too. The cheese tasted and had the consistency of fresh cheese and the sauce was well seasoned. I complimented them on it and they said they make a fresh batch of sauce every day. On top of the delicious pizza and friendly staff, the prices were cheap! Compared to another local pizzeria which I usually visit when I'm in the area, Mema's has significantly better prices. (I can't remember the exact price as this was a couple weeks ago) Turns out one of the men I was talking to was one of the owners, Edwin. Super nice, memorable guy. He came out from behind the counter and chatted with me for a bit while I ate my grandma slice and garlic knots. The story of Mema's is Edwin and John opened it together. John also opened Don Jono's and Buena Sera in Smithtown way back when. John and Edwin have known each other for years so that's cool. Also, they make gluten free pizza with cauliflower crust. TLDR: Great pizza with a variety of options, great prices, great staff, great atmosphere. Will stop by again when I'm in the area. read more

We long islanders know our pizza and are very picky customers! I can honestly say that Mema's is the best pizza around. The crust is crunchy, the sauce has a sweetness to it, perfect amount of cheese. They are even pleasant when they answer the phone, and they deliver quick! Also highly recommend the sweet chili wings. read more

Their Cajun buffalo pizza is other worldly. I can't even describe it. Everything is so good. Having just renoed everything in the shop it looks better - but it was always clean. Old school taste; I loveeeeeee it !! read more

Stopped in for a few slices yesterday and WOW, their pizza is terrific! I tried a slice each of regular, sicilian and grandma's. The specialty slices are large and they had so many different kinds. Very reasonable prices and a warm and informed staff. Hubby and I will for sure be back to sample more slices and perhaps eat inside. Large TV and plenty of places to sit, Mema's is a place to drop in for quality Italian yumminess! read more

Great pizza and food. Service is nice and they deliver food hot. What more can you ask for. Highly recommend

Always consistent, always good service, always good food. Our weekly go to for pizza & subs.

Very good pizza I have been there 6 times now. My only issue is I rather go there when the owners is working. Much better experience. When he walks out the staff could be we don't Really care. Ice machine always empty Had a bad experience 2 times. Good pizza though. read more

The pizza is very good. They have quite a large selection of specialty pizza if you like that. The pasta is hit or miss. Got a linguini with garlic and broccoli and it was pretty bland. The Penne Alla Vodka was good but it has peas in it. I hate peas and nothing in the description of the dish states peas. I've only done takeout there, but the counter service is good. read more

after campa pizza folded, mema's started and from that moment on, commack has been graced with excellent food, great service and great attitude. When they closed shop to fully renovate, we were a bit disappointed, but hoped the great experiences we were used to would not change but they did; it got BETTER! the dining room is now full service, with great smiling wait staff. it's brand new, with big tv's and great music playing but most of all, mema's (italian for grandmother) makes you feel just like home you will experience a wonderful meal and walk out glad you followed my advice. i've been a resident of commack for 42 years, and i know things food related. go there! read more

Another great meal from Mema's. This time I tried the meal deal and was very impressed with the portion and quality of the food. Taste as usual was fantastic as usual. John the owner always greets with a smile, this time under his mask. Highly recommend both his restaurants. read more

Best Chicken Marsala Pie you will ever have. Get the deep dish crust with it. Something different. Something so tasty. A family favorite for us. You're welcome! read more

I ordered delivery yesterday for the first time. Tried to do it online but their site would not accept my credit card. So I had to call my order in. What's the sense of having online ordering if it doesn't work? My order was a med. pie with extra cheese and onions. Delivery was quick. Only downside was that the topping had all slid to one side of the box. I managed to spread it back out. I think the pie was just too hot to transport. This is one of my pet peeves with pizza delivery. Delivery person was very nice and business like. Pizza was delicious....plenty of onions...just the way I like it. Also ordered a piece of Tirami Su. Very, very good! I would definitely try Mema's again....IF they can get their site to accept credit cards. read more