Mema's

If I could give more than 5 stars, I would! I recently threw a party for 120 people at my home and…read moreworked with Dom from Pizzaiolo in Commack--and let me tell you, he was an absolute lifesaver. From start to finish, Dom made the entire process stress-free. He helped me figure out the perfect menu, the right quantities, and even recommended appetizers that ended up being a huge hit. On the day of the party, Dom went above and beyond by arranging two separate deliveries--one for appetizers and another for the main dishes a few hours later--so we didn't have to worry about keeping the food warm. That level of service alone deserves five stars! And the food? OUTSTANDING. From the garlic knot meatball parm sliders (which disappeared in minutes!) to the creamy penne alla vodka, everything exceeded my expectations. My guests, who came from all over the country to celebrate my parents' 50th anniversary, could not stop raving about the food. Dom was easy to talk to, flexible, and truly cared about making our event perfect. I can't recommend Pizzaiolo and Dom enough. If you're planning a party (or just looking for some good food), this is the place to call--you won't be disappointed!

Best Pizza in long island queens brooklyn new york united states the world. Family owned and…read moreoperated friendly staff. Cozy but plenty of seats.

Ala vodka and pepperoni

See all

MaBella

4.6(250 reviews)

1.6 mi

I had an engagement party for my daughter last night at my home. I searched for restaurants who…read morecater and came across Mabella. I knew they had great reviews so I took a chance and ordered food. Without hesitation, this was hands down the most delicious Italian food I have ever had!!! Maria took my order on a day the restaurant was not open yet. She was extremely helpful with how much food I needed. She did not over sell me on quantity where as most others would try to sell more. When food arrived, I met Frank who was also very helpful in setting up the trays in an order in which guests would choose from. It was an absolute pleasure meeting them both!!! Very professional and great people! Thank you very much to Maria and Frank!!!! Did I mention the food was absolutely AMAZING!!!!!

Came here for dinner to celebrate an exciting milestone, and had an okay meal but would try other…read moreItalian restaurants vs rushing to come back. The hostess was super nice, but our servers were okay. We didn't have reservations but were seated quickly since there was a cancellation. The restaurant is cozy and not too loud. We ordered an arugula salad and a Manhattan tartufo (dessert) to share. I ordered spaghetti and meatballs as my entree. Everything was alright--the spaghetti was probably my favorite dish. We also received complimentary bread which was nice.

Swordfish

See all

Outside

Mario's Pizzeria

3.4(160 reviews)

2.5 mi

"Stopped into Mario's for lunch and grabbed a chicken Caesar salad slice--with a little side of…read moreCaesar dressing--for under seven dollars. Frankly, it's easily one of the best chicken Caesar salad slices on Long Island. The rest of the menu is fantastic too, and the staff is always welcoming and friendly. Overall, it's a great experience every time--well worth the trip!"

Mario's is a pizzeria that is in my family's rotation of local pizza spots on a Friday night…read more The place is nice and modern - plenty of seating even on a busy Friday night. I like how they bring the food over to the table. Pizza is good - always offers a wide variety. I feel like my slice could have been a little hotter and in the oven a little longer today, but maybe that's just me being picky. Garlic knots were tasty. Great garlic taste and not oily at all. I don't like oily knots. I wish they had the fancy coca-cola soda machines. I like having the option to choose from a variety of sodas/teas, etc.

See all

La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.7(365 reviews)

2.5 mi

First time here, it is my friends favorite lunch spot at work so we met up for a quick bite. At…read morefirst glance you'd think basic pizzeria in strip mall. Do not let the outside deceive you! This place is beautiful and the service fast. Plenty of hands behind the counter to help and tons of variety. I got a chicken Cesar salad slice, they offered to heat up, I declined. AND AN EPIC GARLIC KNOT. I wasn't keen on the dressing for the Cesar slice (I wanted to love it but didn't) but to each his own on that. The chicken was magnificently diced up on it and had a great portion. I'd define you go back and try some more of their specialty slices. I meandered to the bathroom and got to see their beautiful dining area as well that includes a bar. It looks like a perfect set up for a private party as well.

Awful AWFUL FOOD QUALITY AND SERVICE!!!!! I ordered…read moresomething very simple and basic and my Chicken came out DRY as dust, chewy and rubber.. I couldnt even finish it! (Greens House salad with grilled chicken). Overall sloppy presented meals, oversized quantity and very overcrowded tables! Our table got there around 6pm and we were seated right away.. contrary to their food service which ended up being 30-45 mins waiting for our food! Again AWFUL!

Buffalo Wings, Pasta, Eggplant Parmigiana

Broccoli Rabe

See all

Dinner area with bar *chefs kiss

Emilio's Pizzeria & Ristorante

3.1(622 reviews)

1.2 mi

Love the owner. Always accommodating. Food delicious . Def recommend. Family style as well.read more

We were a party of 20 for a weekday lunch. We had excellent service and the food was amazing…read more Those of us who had classic Italian entrees and appetizers were very pleased with our choices. Service was excellent. Outstanding choices were the eggplant parm stack appetizer and the pasta dishes. The meatballs and red sauce are magnificent and just like in make at home. We all went home and took a nap.

Pappadella Super Veggie

See all

Chicken Parmigiana (Sandwich)

Three Bambinos Pizzeria

4.4(52 reviews)

1.0 mi

I had food delivered and it was there at the promised time…read more I love the chicken franchese hero. I ordered extra sauce on the side is amazing. The buffalo wings are also very good.

4-11-25. My first time here. Ordered a chicken Marsala…read moreslice and a regular slice. Both were delicious. Prices are on par with the competition. Staff was fast and friendly. There's a decent amount of seating if you choose to dine in. If I'm in the area I certainly wouldn't mind returning.

Regular slice

See all

Filetto’s

4.3(61 reviews)

3.1 mi

Damn good pizza. Great variety, freshness, and taste. Adding random text or my review will be…read moretoo short but what I wrote sums it up.

The 12" coal fired pizza is very good. Will definitely order again. Didn't love the pasta with…read moreclams pasta was overcooked and mushy.

Choice of drinks, fountain or bottled

Half-filled cannoli.

See all

What an amazing Espresso Martini made by Vinny

Gino’s

3.5(102 reviews)

2.2 mi

This is a solid Italian restaurant for pizza and pasta. We come here whenever we are in town, and…read morethe food is always pretty solid. Sometimes we even order the pizza (usually pepperoni and margarita) here to pack and bring back to the west coast. Sometimes though, the bread can be a little burnt. Just like the bread rolls were this time around. But this place has good deals and different varieties of pizza, pasta, and salads.

The worst service ever! I placed an order for pick up and was told to pick it up in twenty minutes…read more Once I arrived the order wasnt ready after twenty-seven minutes of myself arriving for pick up. Then the order is sitting in the counter and im just standing waiting there instead of them having common sense and see thag people are waiting for food. All they need to do is ask who order what to keep the food pick up moving along. I arrived home and I get A loaf of bread on top of a take out food catching bacteria. How unprofessional! Never again going to order from this place. I'm officially going to Mario's Pizza on Commack RD.

Chipotle chix slice

See all

A loaf of bread on top of a take out food catching bacteria.

Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria

3.9(171 reviews)

1.3 mi

Love the food here. They offer different seafood options as well as italian favorites. They will…read moreaccomodate changes on the menu to your specific preference. Nice staff. Bring your own bottle of wine. They dont mind. Enjoy!

I came to Taormina on a whim as I was in the mood for pizza and in the area! A fresh pie was just…read moretaken out, so I got a slice, still piping hot, lucky me! It was really good pizza and they don't skimp on the cheese! I had the Napolitano but all other pizza displayed was fresh, not sitting out for hours like some places I have been to. I will be back for more or possibly dinner! I got a good feel for this place, even if only by my one slice of really tasty pizza!!

Interior

See all

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

3.4(223 reviews)

1.6 mi

After attending a comedy show, we left hungry. We found Anthony's on Yelp and decided to try them…read moreout. We ordered a chicken specialty which was a Chicken Focaccia Sandwich and it was really good. The place was closing so the service was fast and all the staff was welcoming.

Stopped in for Happy Hour, it was packed! The bartender gave us a menu, $5 drinks, $5 food. It said…read moreTito's on the menu so we ordered a cosmo and espresso martini and i specifically pointed to the $5 menu. I guess it wasn't clear, someone who was a regular, then told me that those drinks were not going to be $5. When the bartender came back with the drinks I asked and he said that martini type drinks were excluded. Ok well that was nowhere to be seen on the menu. Next round we ordered a vodka soda with a little cranberry and a vodka lemonade, this time I made it a point to ask if those were included and he said yes. We also ordered a small pizza and a flatbread that had artichoke. Both were good, nothing special. Fun place to hang out for happy hour!

$9.99 on tables

See all

On the corner of the NW Corner of Jericho and Townline Road.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Katie B.

6 years ago

We originally found this gem during covid when they had pizza kits. My girls and I absolutely fell in love with this amazing food. We were trying to pull together a small social distanced graduation party for my youngest who missed out on an actual graduation. I was so afraid I would have so many leftovers as usually college kids don't really sit and eat. This was not the case. These could kids not get enough of this food. Everything was eaten. The tins were completely empty of all the pastas, not a garlic knot even left. The macaroni and cheese, the chicken fingers, the chicken parmigiana hero, the penne with vodka sauce. ALL OF IT WAS GONE! We were actually disappointed there was no leftovers. Do yourself a fever and try Memas, the staff, the cooks, the Owners all could could not have been nicer. So worth the drive for us. We are customers for life !!!! read more

Michelle R.

1 year ago

Mema's in Commack is absolutely wonderful! The food is always fresh and delicious, and the portions are so generous. The staff is warm, welcoming, and makes you feel right at home. Everything from the pasta dishes to the salads and desserts is made with such care. I would definitely recommend Mema's for anyone looking for a great meal and a friendly atmosphere. read more

Pancake L.

4 years ago

Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, Pizza, read more

Kevin F.

10 years ago

This place has amazing pizza. I always order delivery here. The pizza and crust is the absolute best. My favorite part about this place though is the cute delivery boy named Dave. read more

Chris B.

6 years ago

My fried calamari didn't taste good so I went back and the owner, Jono, changed it for a chicken francaise free of charge. Very personable and amazing service. read more

Lina D.

3 years ago

Excellent food and service as always. A staple in our household. Came here to say thank you!!!!

Y R.

8 years ago

Best Pizza in the neighborhood!

Mema's - pizza - Updated November 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Commack, New York Restaurants near Mema's

BEST of Commack, New York Coffee near Mema's

BEST of Commack, New York Things to Do near Mema's

BEST of Commack, New York Breakfast near Mema's

BEST of Commack, New York Dinner near Mema's

BEST of Commack, New York Desserts near Mema's

BEST of Commack, New York Parking near Mema's

BEST of Commack, New York Burgers near Mema's

BEST of Commack, New York Shopping near Mema's

BEST of Commack, New York Movie Theatre near Mema's

Best of Commack

Things to do in Commack

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Mema's also viewed

Amore Pizza

3.5

(71 reviews)

I have been eating Amore pizza for years. I used to live in Whitestone and would go there all the…read moretime. I have since moved to Nassau County and I go back to Amore every chance I get! The pie is delicious. Sauce is great. I love how the cheese melts into the sauce and that thin crust! Amore pizza is perfection!

The food here is delicious and the customer service is unmatched. I love ordering from this place.read more

Branchinelli's Pizza & Restaurant

(436 reviews)

Branchinellis always has great food. They make a very good pizza and they have the best pepperoni…read morein the area. The restaurant is always clean and the counter staff is friendly. I typically recommend the Sicilian pizza but the round is good as well. The staff is always friendly and their prices are good. There is plenty of parking and it's a huge space so you're never waiting very long at all.

Love this place! The service is great, the food is like 'comfort,' food for me too! I love the…read morepizza too... my fav's is their pasta with garlic and oil with a side of chicken.... The eggplant, lasagna-too! It's always busy but the line goes quick! My husband and I have been going to Branchinelli's for over 20 years! Our grandson now comes with us and LOVES their focaccia bread

Three Bambinos Pizzeria

4.4

(52 reviews)

I had food delivered and it was there at the promised time…read more I love the chicken franchese hero. I ordered extra sauce on the side is amazing. The buffalo wings are also very good.

The Pizzeria

4.2

(56 reviews)

Good food and service. Always feel welcome…read more Clean tables Plenty of parking. You can enjoy TV or good view of Main Street.

It gets busy here and for good reason! Their slices are unique and worth a try. I highly suggest…read morethe vodka marguerita. Service is quick, and no surcharge for using a credit card. Two seating areas, so usually a place to eat if you need one.

Short Stop Pizzeria

(51 reviews)

Solid pizza and super friendly staff . The prices are very reasonable . This is my family's go to…read morewhen in KP .

Long Island has a pizza parlor on every corner. It doesn't mean they're all good. If you're looking…read morefor that perfect, no-frills, consistently delicious slice, Short Stop Pizza absolutely delivers. The pizza is exactly what you want it to be...crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right balance of cheese. Every bite tastes fresh and well-made, not rushed or overly greasy like you find in a lot of places. It's the kind of spot where you know you're getting a solid, satisfying meal every time. It even arrives hot with delivery. Beyond the food, iIt feels like a true neighborhood staple, the kind of place you keep coming back to because it never disappoints. Simple, reliable, and genuinely good pizza and subs. Highly recommend.

Rocco's Pizza

3.8

(73 reviews)

Hands down our favorite pizza place in the area. We've been customers for decades…read more No one comes close to their crisp crust that has FLAVOR. Their sauce has the fruitiness of good quality EVOO, and fresh, not jarred garlic. My favorite is the baby eggplant. Unlike most places that do a clunky breaded and friend eggplant, here it is sweet and tender baby eggplant sliced paper thin and sautéed in garlic and EVOO. Heavenly Others we've tried including white pies are equally magnificent. It you want real-deal, tasty from first bite to last pie--this is your place!

Been going to Rocco's when Rocco and family owned and operated. Sadly it's slowly deteriorated to…read morethe point where it's unrecognizable. My meatball marinara had undercooked meatball and overcooked pasta. Pizza has been bad and service stinks. RIP Roccos

The Pie at Salvatore's

4.1

(178 reviews)

My wife and I walked in not knowing they didn't serve pizza but the slice. I convinced her to stay…read moreand order and see how it was. Thankfully we did, because the food was incredible and we were super pleased. I wouldn't say hidden gem, this place is a pizza goldmine! We started with the Caesar salad which was so fresh and delicious. We ordered a small Neapolitan and a small Supreme pizza for dinner & WOW were they delicious. I grew up and Queens & my expectation for pizza is high. This met that and more! The pizza is thin crust & ingredients are so fresh. This is our default "go to" spot in Bay Shore, and we have brought numerous friends and family here. Not one bad meal!

Homey pizzeria, small menu but really good pizza, can bring the entire family. Good wine super…read moreaffordable. Service is excellent. I was craving a salad, the Caesar salad hit the spot. Opted for a glass of Pinot Nior which was fresh. I am a Pinot Nior girl so I can tell when a bottle has been opened for a while. The wine is affordable and does not taste cheap. The garlic bread is a huge portion with a good amount of garlic. I love garlic so it was spot on.

Broadway Pizzeria

4.2

(57 reviews)

Over the years we've tried and frequented many pizza restaurants in the area (Huntington,…read moreCenterport, Northport, Greenlawn), and we've chosen Broadway Pizza to be our weekly go to. In our opinion, they have the best tasting sauce, and the proper sauce-cheese ratio.

Great ny pizza and very friendly team. I almost got an impulse slice of Sicilian because it looked…read moreso good!

Pizzaiolo Gourmet Eatery

(65 reviews)

Best Pizza in long island queens brooklyn new york united states the world. Family owned and…read moreoperated friendly staff. Cozy but plenty of seats.

Francesco's

(42 reviews)