I'd give 0 stars if possible. I placed an order through the website. It never showed up. I called the number on their website multiple times. No one picks up. I found an alternate number. You get a recording. It tells you to hold for a manager, rings off the hook and then disconnects. Terrible business practice!!! And I still got charged read more

Gino's would get a five star from me, if they hadn't been so rude to me the only time I went there! The food is great, it's pizza, that's what it tastes like. The place is kind of small, so it doesn't have much ambiance. It has those tacky 80's orange seats and don't get me wrong, I love the color orange, so it's not a jab at the color. lol I had gone with my friends here to celebrate my friend's birthday, and I had finished my pizza, and I was sitting at one of the tables talking to a friend. I had already thrown out my empty pizza plate and all that was left was a napkin that was on the table. So I'm talking to my friend when this man that works there comes over and gives me an attitude for having the napkin on the table and told me to throw it out. 1. I was going to throw it out when I left. 2. I was still at the table, what if I was still using it? I was just so insulted, he was so rude for no reason. I worked retail for 8 years, I always clean up after myself. I would have understood if I was leaving the establishment and left the napkin there, but I wasn't, I was still at the table talking to my friend. At least be nice about it too, he was just so rude! I have no desire in going back. I just recently went to Delfiores Pizza across the street and not only do they have a great atmosphere, but their workers are nice! Another friend of mine had a similar situation where one of the guys there was nasty to her just because she asked if dogs were allowed inside. I definitely do not recommend! read more

Nice guys... Great pizza, and they are not scared of cameras... Keep it up boys...

Just stopped by for a couple of slices after a doctors appointment in the area. We had two specialty slices and two rice balls. Yes, price there is a little high, however it was absolutely worth it. Pizza had crisp bottoms and sauce with a ton of flavor. Rice balls were full of flavor and crispy crust. A lot of flavor went in to all of the food and it's easy to tell. Also, the kind lady cut the specialty slices in half so it was easier to eat. read more

We stopped by on a Friday evening for dinner. We ordered a pizza, half mushroom, a chicken parm wrap (almost like a calzone). Everything was delicious. The sauce they serve on the side is savory. It's not heavy. It's a light tasty tomato sauce. The chicken parm calzone-ish wrap was fabulous. We all fought over it. They were super nice and served 6 garlic knots on the house. The staff is warm and welcoming. We will definitely be back. They do a brisk takeout business, but there were several diners eating inside. The place is not that big and you avoid the mayhem that you might find at other pizzerias on the weekend. Definitely try them out. By the way, this was my go to pizza place when I grew up in Patchogue a millennium ago. It was good then and it's better now. read more

I ordered a grandma pie for a small Friendsgiving we gathered for. Bringing a food from my heritage. The grandma pie hit the mark , and was a big hit , for an appetizer, when they double cut the pizza into small squares. When I walked in I was greeted with a warm hello accompanied with a SMILE. Good old fashion customer service. Love it !! Vinny Sr introduced himself and said this is my Son Vinny Jr. He was the one who cooked my pizza. Lol. Great on time pickup as well. They are in the middle of the Village, was a tad hard to find a spot to park , if you call they will tell you to park ( somewhere , I will not say because I don't want anyone taking there secret parking spot ). Regardless great place to stop in and grab a slice before heading to any of the bars or theater. read more

Gino's Pizzeria - Example of different pizza. They do GLUTEN FREE too ! - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

Service quality price ridiculous Pizza nasty flop now never had it like that attitude when you go in there if you don't say the right thing go to Dominica right across from the courthouse much better pizza than anything in the village said to see a business go to crap read more

Gonna give you a no frills review for a no frills pizza place . Location is a bit bigger than the outside suggests. Ordered a buffalo pizza pie to go. The staff was really friendly, answered all our questions. Pizza itself was good! Buffalo chicken had a nice tang to it. Good chunks of chicken and cheese. Would be down to try this place again! read more

I have found gino's plain slice to be the best of any locally. For me, the plain slice is what matters most in a pizzeria. If you love a good plain slice, go to ginos. Always delicious. read more

I lived in Patchogue all of my life and the pizza was always good. This was not good at all. hard has a rock and would not do anything about it. I know the dad and never had a hard time. I think this was the son. He hung up the phone on me. I am 62 and this person does not know how to run a business. Does he not know that my company orders 15 pies when we have a meeting. We will now go to Mama Bella"s. I will put this on Facebook with my 2,000 friends and will pass it around. No one should be hung up on. He should of said sorry and gave me a new pie. All my life I went there. No one in Patchogue should go there any more. I will be telling every one what he did to me. read more

Gino's Pizzeria - Worst pizza ever !! - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

This is absolutely the best pizza in town. Actually it's the best pizza anywhere in Patchogue. I just get disappointed when they go on vacation and they close for a week straight. Lol. read more

Grab a pie or a plain slice at this small, no-frills, cash only spot. A plain slice will run you your normal $2.50, it's always tasty and crisp. I've been going since I was a kid yet they have no clue who I am. In contrast to other local spots who remember me after years of absence. I suppose that speaks to the nature of the place; they aren't the friendliest group of pizzaitalians. The grandma is decent but not the best, I tend to stick to the plain slice or a fresh pie with whatever topping mood may strike. They've got pie loyalty card that gets you a freebie after 10, over the years I've had about 50 of those cards marked off once or twice and never remember to use it. Every now and then they'll give me a card with my pie and not even punch it... I will never get a single free pie from the place but I'll always go back. read more

See all

This place has been my favorite pizza joint since I was old enough to walk down to village on my own and buy a slice. Cash only traditional business but man it's so worth it. All the food is incredible. read more

Won't let paying customer use the bathroom...what a shame. Won't give them another dime. Try Aunt Mias off waverly. Rude read more

located on Main street in Patchogue I came only because of the reviews first visit I did not know it was a cash only so my son and I left BUT I knew we would be back I am so glad I didnt let the anger of no plastic get the best of me (I was starved that first time) we returned and returned and then we brought a guy a visiting soldier friend (from the State of Washington via Afghanistan) This is really good pizza I mean really! and one of the best things! THE PRICE 13 bucks for a pie and sodas served fresh and hot in the little dining room in the back Its a throw back to 1985 but who cares the pizza is 5 star read more

Gino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

Great pizza! I always enjoy coming here to eat. The staff is very friendly every time I visit.

The pizza is undercooked the sauce is a little bit sour. The house salad had only two slices of cucumbers and three thin slices of tomato. I'm very disappointed.. I don't think I'll order from here again. read more

I absolutely love Gino's I used to crave their pizza when I was pregnant with my son . They never disappoint with their pizza !

Moved to LI 5 months ago and everyone raves about NY pizza. We had tried many places but didn't think the pizza was "WOW" worthy. That is until we found Gino's. This is my favorite LI pizza yet. read more

Pizza is Inconsistent you could order two pies and one will look totally different from the other and the customer service is terrible all the men in there are miserable read more

Grandma slice, excellent. Regular slice better than average. For Suffolk pizza this place is bad ass. One of the reviews below was comical. Because the yelp review wrote this long review about being called a "fudge packer" and the staff is rude. I was just there today, staff is fine. Pizza rocks for Suffolk county. Thumbs up for the "fudge packers" Lol read more

Gino's has the BEST grandma slice i've ever eatten (~$3.50/slice). Large rectangular slice of cheesy, saucy, tomatoe-y, crispy, soft goodness. They sprinkle some (what i believe is) pesto sauce within it, which makes it taste SO delicious. The seating area is dimly lit and little dingy, but who cares they make delicious pizza! read more

Gino's Pizzeria - YUM - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

The actions/behavior of the men behind the counter is unacceptable. The pizza is not that good to be treated that way. To have an employee be extremely irrational because my husband added something to the order after it was already rung up is unacceptable. You think they would be happy to have more business!?! Not only are they unaware that the customer is always right, but instead they treat there loyal, paying customers like crap- and we were regulars for years!!!!! We will never spend another penny there again. Thanks Gino's for making us look else where....if you want waaay better pizza and to be treated like a human go to Nino's on 112 in Patchogue. read more

Best pizza with the best deals! FYI: CASH only! They do have an atm though They do a 2 cheese slice and soda deal. I love getting their white slices! Thick and crispy. You get a lot for what you pay for! read more

OMG the BEST pizza that I have had in years!! thank you Gino's for coming back ! for years we loved your pizza and than no so much. I waited until for the three deliver to rate to see the consistency and you guys are dead on!! AWESOME!! I will definitely be back again and again!!! So should everyone else reading this. their pizza is amazing! orderEd half meatballs and onion so much cheese and all extras totally delicious!!! thank you so much quick pleasant delivery!!! definitely recommend read more

Best pizza I've had on the island. I love a thicker, chewy crust. Regular pies and specialty pies are both great. The margarita is our favorite specialty. Wings are good too. Love that they deliver now, and delivery is always super quick. read more

Wanted to try a new place, ordered a plain pie. It was so undercooked, you could have eaten the top with a spoon and the mozz slid right off. I had to re-bake the pie. Sauce tasted like hunts regular, nothing special here. Go to Satellite instead! read more

I dont know what happened to ginos I bought a pie in July and it was sour and did not taste good like the sauce or cheese was bad my son felt sick afterwards I did not eat it I threw my piece away maybe they were having a bad day or something when I went in to pick it up the ac was off I don't know why .I always had a good pie from them read more

WILL NEVER EAT HERE AGAIN. We walked in to this Pizza Shoppe and the Pizza did not look fresh, the counter person was very grumpy/unpleasent. They do not accept card so we had to use the atm that gives a $3 fee. After paying the price he had said before he gave us one slice too short making us go back to the atm and pay the fee again to get the slice. We later learned that the guy scammed us and we paid the full price the first time (6 slices - $18.50 - 2 were specialty). Then we got to the food. The buffalo slice was absolutely terrible - dough was thick and dried out, crust was burnt, cheese tasted off. The cheese slices were alright but nothing special. Any place that is "cash only" most likely launders their money. This place was shadey from the time we walked in, how they treated us, and how the food tasted. DO NOT GO. read more

Best Slice I've had in the area :) My other favorite is Satellites but this is pretty great pizza. I wish the hours were later of course but I don't blame them; they'd be flooded with the bar crowd of Patchogue if they did. Best regular slice and the speciality slices are totally worth but get one they are sooooo filling. read more

I see it now! this place is not over-rated at all. I had a couple o' slices from a fresh pie. Gino's is one of my all time favorites. Nice cheese to sauce ratio. Pepperoni is thick and tasty, meatballs actually tasted like cut meatballs on a pizza, that never happens. read more

Gino's Pizzeria - 1/2 Meatball 1/2 Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

This is a no frills solid pizza joint. The guys behind the counter are not to personable but the pizza is really good. I come here and get the pizza well done and it's just super crispy and great. I recommend also picking up some garlic knots. Come here if u need a quick slice or a pie to go, it's def not the place to sit down in. read more

Gino's Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Time for an update. Still the best. They run a weekly coupon in the Yankee Trader with some nice specials and they offer $8.99 large pies on Sunday, Mondays and Tuesdays. Parking and picking up your order has been a bit more troublesome since the J&R's open'd up across the walkway (http://www.yelp.com/biz/eloise-staudinger-walkway-patchogue#hrid:75bRG7nNLAtJ-8dbPDOaVA/query:eloise%20staudinger) but Gino's was able to get approval for 10 min. parking slot right out front. Great pies, but sometimes a little rushed out of the oven. Get 'em well-done. FYI, local scuttlebutt has Rudy Giuliani eating here when he's in town. read more

Gino's impressed my (very) skeptical Brooklyn friends who not-so-subtly doubted that good pizza could come from anywhere else but the BK. Crust: 8/10 Sauce: 10/10 Cheese: 10/10 Really solid, flavorful pizza at a very reasonable price. Can't say much about the decor, but it's a pizza place. Get in, enjoy your pizza, and move along. read more

Love their pizza, the crust is always crisp and has great taste. I overheard few people talking while at the theater and they said they are ordering a few pies , so it shows people love it. For us we had plain cheese. Not into all the other untraditional things. . Not sure why people complain about no credit cards , do they flip out at so many Chinese restaurants that have cash only? No big deal to me and my gf friend. Keep up the great work read more

I'm hesitant to give a NY pizza place 5 stars because everyone has their own favorite, but I would say this is "as good as it gets" by yelp standards. To make things better, they have Gluten Free pizza, which is plus for my wife since she is allergic to wheat. The guy behind the counter is nice. They could brighten up the eating area a bit... read more

Good pizza. I liked them better than the other two in the immediate area (think L and DF). Great loyalty program and coupons in the local town crier every week. My go-to pizza place in Patchogue. update: been disappointed in ginos recently. Took my business elsewhere. read more

I love walking through the ally to smell your pizza. I have been coming here since I was a kid walking through the little ally inside. I remember looking through the windows and coming there to play your video games. Pole position. My wife and I love your pizza. I will be back Thank you Ginos. read more

Gino's is definitely the best choice for straight pizza in Patchogue. You can get better entrees or pizza creations at other pizzerias, but if you just want a good old fashioned slice of pizza, Gino's can't be beat. Their specialty slices, i.e. Chicken Ranch, Buffalo, Barbecue, etc. are all in the $4 range, but they are gigantic. A modest person could probably make a meal and a half out of them. Regular slices are in the more normal, $2 range. Their crust can't be beat. Has a good flavor to it, but is still crisp yet chewy. As an aside, not sure if they do this for everyone, but if you order to stay, there's a good chance they'll bring you your food. Not an official waiter service, but a nice gesture. read more

Vegetables on the pizza seemed cheap, and of low quality. Mushrooms in particular tasted like they came right out of the can‍