I can't believe I haven't written a review about one of my favorite local No Frills spots. The Food speaks for itself for its delicious, sauce/cheese/topping- they don't cheap out here! They're cheese slices good but they're real hidden jam is the upside down slice and I'm not a "sauce person" but give me that square pie upside down all day long... garlic, knots or flavorful and stink up your car so that's a good sign that there's actually garlic on there. The our zones are incredible. They make a really damn good calzone. I picked up a rice bowl for my husband and he's never had one from here and all is yours so I will post about that in an updated review. They recently did renovations, but still kept that pizzeria feel where everybody tries to get all bougie and stuff. They did the upgrades necessary, but still kept it quintessential to what a pizza place should be. Now down to the service and yes, the food matters primarily, but the service does matter if you get bad service! You will never get bad service here! The staff are so friendly they know everybody by name and what they essentially order! It's a family run business and the father is amazing but these two kids really shine above anybody I've ever seen in customer service with a restaurant! Nick and Lucas are incredible kids/man that know how to make a dining experience feel like you're at home! These incredible guys have managed to know their customer base learn everything about their customers and provide you with an instant experience asking about how your day at work is that whatever job you work and it's not just for me I see they do it with everybody and that's really what makes you feel like you're at home when you go to Albert's I'm super proud to support this business because the food is great, the service is great and unlike Olive Garden when you're here, you're actually family If I got the worst slice of pizza of my life, which I never have, I would still give a 4/5 stars just for the experience, but the pizza is a 10 out of 10!! They know what it is to run a restaurant and I'm glad to see the future generations taking hold of that :) such a beautiful thing to witness read more

Ain't nothing better than calling a pizzeria on a Friday they picking up on the second ring and saying please hold and then keep you on hold for four minutes. I get it. You're busy but four minutes you can't service a customer wanting to place an order for a pizza . I'll never eat here again. read more

Albert's Pizza - The amount of time I was on hold before I hung up four minutes - Pizza Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

This is a good little pizza place. The inside is nice, it's clean and they have a few small tables if you want to sit to eat. Service was quick and friendly. Pricing was fair Definitely mom & pop pizzeria vibe in here, which is nice. I got a chicken bacon ranch slice and a sweet chili chicken. Both were good and I enjoyed how they were a little crispy on the bottom. The chili chicken was a particular treat because I haven't seen this speciality slice elsewhere. My wife got a plain slice. She said it was fine (not her favorite plain slice around, but solid for the quick lunch we were grabbing). I'd grab slices from here again! read more

Albert's Pizza - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice, Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza Slice, Regular Cheese Pizza Slice, Root Beer. - Pizza Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

These folks are the best people I've encountered in a long time!! Thank you, I went to my car and cried happy tears, just appreciating being treated so kindly during a hard time. My kids and I will only eat your pizzas. THANK YOU read more

At this point in time living in Ronkonkoma, I've come to know where I like to get my pizza from around the area. There's my go-to spot, but a good runner up would be Albert's Pizza, which has become the occasional alternative option in the pizza realm for my wife and I. You see we've had Albert's a handful of times now (most recently last night) and we've found their pizza to definitely be tasty and worthy of return visits. Their recent-ish hype came from their positive message pizza boxes back during Covid along with an owner switch and a consistently delicious upside pizza (a la L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn). All are fine and dandy, but it's the pizza itself that should bring you back and that last factor (the upside down slice) is definitely a big reason why we return. That and they have a few deals on the Slice app that are worthy of checking out (we've done this in the past a couple of times). Though for last night it was just slices we were looking for and so around 6 o'clock or so we found Alberts to have a somewhat decent variety of slice options in their semi-small and straightforward pizza interior. My wife and I chose to each get an upside slice and then we split a fried eggplant slice, a sausage and broccoli rabe slice, and a spinach pinwheel. The worker behind the counter was very friendly and offered to cut each piece in half for us to more easily share. What was also kind of awesome was the selection of Alberts branded sodas in the fridge. We got a vanilla cream bottle to split and once our pizza was warmed up we made our way home to dive in. Starting with the slices, they honestly were all pretty great. The upside down slice is square in shape and had a good sauce to it (as it usually does) while that sausage and broccoli rabe slice was meaty and a little bitter as it should be. The eggplant slice was fantastic and, though really nothing out of the ordinary, the spinach pinwheel was tasty enough. Oh and that soda? Perhaps a little sweet, but definitely had a vanilla flavor to it which balanced out the meal. Overall, Alberts is worthy of four stars and perhaps it can get that fifth (it's close!). They have some quality choices and friendly staff which makes them a formidable pizza spot in the Ronkonkoma area and for sure a favorite. read more

See all

We've been looking for the best pizza going to a different location every week Albert's Pizza in Ronkonkoma is the winner in the Shop Rite shopping center. A full 18" pie, nice crust, sauce and cheese. My go to place every week. It's better than Ginos in Ronkonkoma. Measure pizzas from other locations! read more

I ordered a chicken mozz roasted pepper hero, and this is what I received. ONE VERY TINY slice of chicken, ONE slice of cheese, a couple of peppers... Very stingy and very underwhelming. It was mostly bread. I was shocked by the 1 tiniest piece of chicken!! Not worth the price, and you'll still be hungry after. They're also not great at following instruction. Ignored my delivery instructions and went to the wrong part of the home and disturbed another tenant which was frustrating. I asked for well done pizza and it was actually extremely lightly cooked. I also asked for balsamic dressing for the hero which they forgot. Despite not being well done, their pizza was delicious though. My advice is to stick to the pizza and maybe order for pickup :) read more

Albert's Pizza - Chicken mozzarella with roasted peppers - Pizza Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

The pizza took over an hour to deliver and was 30 mins late. Me and my friend found peices of hair in our pizzas, they were 2 seperate slices and looked nothing like ours. read more

Veal cutlet dinner the best. Delicious pizza made perfect. Chicken cutlet heroes are a crowd pleaser. Staff is very nice and friendly.

i ordered take out. when I received my order after an hour and a half. which when ordered said 15 to 30 minutes.My one item was had the wrong sauce on it the other item was burnt both items were cold. I called to complain and was told they were busy. so after a bit of discussion. They said they would refund my money. This happened on June 1st. it is now June 5th at 10 pm and still no refund. definitely would not recommend this pizzis place. This is also not the first time i've received poor service from them. read more

Boy was I wrong about this place. Too busy or they don't care about customers delivery requests. Why say they can take instructions when they really don't care to. Just call when you are here and we'll come up to get the order. I guess that was too difficult to do because they scared my mil by banging on the door. She's very old and was so nervous she went down a flight of stairs that she hasn't been down in years. We were terribly worried for her and then we get a call that delivery is here. My husband was so upset about his mother that he told the guy Michael that he really messed up. With that Michael asked if he was a tough guy and that we shouldn't use them anymore. Instead of just apologizing. When I called they were uncaring and very rude. I guess they don't need more business Karma is coming read more

Alberts has been a go-to for me for a very long time. The staff at the Ronkonkoma location is always very professional, polite, and friendly. The restaurant is always clean and fast-paced. The upside-down pizza is on point every time i order it, however, I have recently been venturing out, getting different dishes and all are equally as good. My favorite part of going to Alberts is that their pizza sauce still tastes the same 25 years later. read more

I have, like all of us, been to many pizza places. Especially on Long Island. This is my favorite spot. The pizza is different from everywhere else. It's absolutely delicious. My kids love it and they don't normally like "square" pizza. The sauce is fantastic. I always order extra because it heats up really well for leftovers. If you haven't tried this place yet, please do. It's run by a young man and his family, I believe. I live in Pennsylvania but everytime we come to visit my parents, we stop here for some pies. I can't see how you could not like this pizza. It's amazing read more

The pizza is really good, but the service is kind of weird? Placed an order for delivery and gave my card number over the phone. The girl said "your card declined because you have insufficient funds in your account" ??? I chuckled a bit and said that's what the machines telling you? That I have no money in my account? It's a credit card... I gave her the number again and she said oh this time it went thru... it went through because you entered the number incorrectly the first time, not because I had "no money"... also the soda I ordered with it was already opened, the seal was broken and the liquid was below the expiration date... their food is great but they have some awkward people there read more

Excellent Pizza cooked as we stated we like a crispy crust pizza! We have tried other establishments in the area most are closer to our home, Albert's is the Best We will drive a little further for a better pie! read more

ordered upsidedown pizza 2/27 extra grated cheese on top. always get it that way for years, even when new owners took over. when my order came. it was not what i ordered. i called and said i wanted upside down its not what i received. i was told well you got the sauce its on the bottom,and hung up. I'm 80 cant travel ,rely on delivery. also fixed income i don't order as often because of the price. i also got charged for extra mozzarella cheese i didn't want. always waited to get my upside down pizza i"m so disappointed read more

I used to give 5 stars but not this time. Tonight's pizza tastes like it was already made and they added the topping and put it back in the oven. It was lukewarm and the cheese was like it had been sitting around for a few hours. Very disappointing. read more

If there was Yelp in the 1990's then you would read my 5 Star review as a teenager and it would still ring true today. This place is delicious and every time I eat from here, it brings me back to when I was younger. It is one thing when a place is good....but there is a big difference when a place is consistently good for that long of a time. And that is why I still go to this place to this day. They have good food here in general but my go to is their famous square slice with the sauce on top. It is amazing to be honest. Crispy on the bottom and the crust. Seasoned red sauce on the top of quality cheese peeking through. I also love that you can donate a pie to others and they put them up and if you fit the description....you get a pie! Such a cool thing to do for the neighborhood folks that eat here and everyone needs help sometimes or has a bad day and what tastes better than free pizza? The atmosphere here is great and the owner is nice and friendly when you come through. Whether it is the year 1995 or 2055....Albert's Pizza Square Slice will be in my top 3 slices....dont @ me. lol read more

Placed an order for delivery last night.. Two pies, both well done with light sauce. Absolutely PHENOMENAL. It arrived HOT which made it even better. 7/10. read more

This used to be my go-to pizza place, used to always recommend it to anyone who asked. Just my opinion, but the quality and taste doesn't seem to be as consistent as it used to be, while prices seem to have increased, and I can't justify coming here anymore. To me, the food doesn't taste as fresh as it used to. Pricing also widely differs from what is on their menu - online menu shows the family super saver as $33.50 but the clerks at the restaurant charge and confirm that it is actually $40.00. If you want to use a credit card, it's 3.5% additional on to your bill - which nobody tells you about, at all. I had to notice it myself on my receipt myself after the fact. read more

If you haven't tried Albert's Sauce on Top pizza, you should go, tonight! I grew up on Albert's pizza. I remember as a kid there was a coupon in the local newspaper for a family pizza deal and it was out family tradition to get Albert's pizza on Friday. I was so happy when we moved to Ronkonkoma to see there was on local. Go check it out - and make sure you get the sauce on top! Nothing else like it. read more

don't advertise your open till 10 online if ur gonna lock ur door at 9:30. never worked at a place that closed early before.

What happened to my favorite pizza place? Was scared when I heard there was a new owner. Ordered the square pie and a round pie. Was very disappointed with my order tonight. Sauce taste the same but the crust was awful. Very soggy. No crunch at all. I think they forgot the cheese too! I was never a fan of the round pie but somehow it got worse. There is definitely something wrong with the dough. Please, please, please get things worked out soon. I have been a lifelong fan of Albert's Pizza and can't believe it is gone. The previous owner was very nice, maybe you can get some advice. read more

Best pizza in the area! No contest. The sauce is delish, tastes like real tomatoes. And the cheese is real mozz, not that crap oily stuff most pizza places use. And the crust is crispy with a slight chew. New owners Nick and Tony have really spruced the place up too! You can really tell these guys care about making great pizza. Don't miss out on the upside down slice - just like they make at Spumoni Gardens in Bensonhurst. I will be back! read more

Great pizza and service. The owner Nick was very personable and attentive to all customer needs. I highly recommend this pizzeria.

This pizza locations of Albert's does not need our business. On Friday they tell you if the want your business. This past Friday I call to order a pizza and I was on my way there to place an order by phone and two times they would lt it ring and hang up.I waited till i got out in front of the store to see if it were busy but a saw was one man waiting at the counter, so I call again and each time they let it ring for a minute they hang up on you, so I drove off to Arby's to get an awesome Roast Beef sandwich. Albert's is getting to big so they pick and choose who they want to do business with. They prices have gone up and still thats not good enough for them. From now on the can KMA. read more

I was intrigued by Albert's Pizza after Brian R. said his wife loves their pizza because they don't use canned mushrooms (um... what?). I was futher intrigued when I saw that worstpizza.com wrote a rave review for Albert's (http://www.worstpizza.com/2008/08/alberts-pizza-ronkonkoma-long-island-new-york-best-pizza/). They're known for their Upside-Down Slice, so that's what I had. The crust was excellent, and the sauce was smooth and sweet. BUT the size of the slice was a joke-- so small. My dad had a regular slice, he said it was good but also thought it was too small. We didn't feel any different before eating the pizza and after eating the pizza. Be prepared to order multiple slices, or a whole pie. We also tried their Broccoli & Cheddar Stuffed Knots-- meh. The other pizzas looked like they were sitting out for a while. Service was apathetic. Un-canned mushrooms aren't going to get me to come back. If they adjust the size of their slices-- I'll think about it. read more

See all

Def. Not the same and downhill. Round is like a mediocre birthday party pie and the upside down is unrecognizable. Shouldn't be able to keep the name. Extra star for taking card on phone. read more

Sicilian slice with pesto, plum tomato, topped with mozzarella. Excellent, from the crust up! Top service, too.

Firstly, my order arrived 2 hours late because the restaurant "doesn't use Yelp" and yet, I was able to place my order on here. They obviously need some assistance in order fulfillment and organization. When I called they didn't even apologize. Only after my husband's call did they actually acknowledge the screw up. I give 2 stars only because the square pizza was very good. Other than that, the wings were good but a bit salty and the pepperoni pizza was horribly bland. read more

Great pizza! Garlic knots are yummy! Sometimes service is slow due to young staff that too busy socializing. read more

The BEST pizza hands down! I feel like so many people overlook this place bc it's so small and tucked inside a shopping plaza but the pizza here is delicious! read more

So sad to see such a great pizzeria go down. Ordered a square pie that definitely did not have cheese on it and called to tell them. Guy that answered was incredibly rude and said we need to come down and show him as he did not believe us. Go down and guy comes from the back wanting "to take it outside" so now because you guys can't make a pizza you threaten to fight. It's obvious from the other reviews there's some issues. Hopefully they figure them out before they go under, although with that attitude it seems unlikely. read more

This is probably one of the most arrogant people I ever meet Nobody ever voted them the best on LI but he puts his own sign up say best on Long Island. I will never step foot in that place again. Very mean. Tell you what to order and if you order something different he gets mad. There's a lot of competition around there. Don't you think you would welcome your costumers. The worst. I rather eat frozen pizza read more

Horrible service, cardboard pizza crust and staff have a poor attitude. If you want old pizza served by the grumpiest man on Long Island, Albert's is the place to be. I was also approached for money in the dark and scary parking lot. Worst experience ever. read more

Best inside out pizza hands down! And eggplant dishes. Their sauce is delicious. I've been coming here for years and I've never had any issues! Highly recommend. read more

Alberts pizza has great food for a great price. 2 pies a 2 liter soda dozen knots and order of wings for 36 bucks after tax ... what a bargain. I recently tried an Alzone off there Alzone menu the hot wing blue and it was awesome always ask to hook it up with the garlic butter sauce its a nice touch. The staff is very friendly knowing all the regulars on a first name basis. Overall i give alberts two big thumbs up good job guys looking forward to trying your new dessert the Oreo Alzone. read more

See all

I grew in Lindenhurst, Next to Copiague where the original start, and Love the upside down square Pizza. I'm so glad there's the Alberts's Pizza in Ronkonkoma. If you haven't had the Alberts's upside down square Pizza yet, you gotta try it.. it's Amazingly Delicious.. it's so Good I'll drive out of my way for this Pie. read more

After our "go to" pizza shop appeared to have changed hands and went awful, we've been experimenting with shops local to home. Alberts has won the competition, hands down! The "upside down" pie is delicious! Haven't had any of the issues that some have complained of here. Maybe we're lucky, maybe they are unlucky! read more

I wish I could give this place ZERO STARS. they said 45 minutes for delivery. An HOUR AND A HALF later they show up. Pizza was wrong and looked OLD. like it had been sitting there all damn day. Don't order from here. Pizza is also wayyyyy over priced. read more