The Everest of pizza ,Hot Honey Pepperoni , simple and perfect brick oven fired personal pizza. Simone puts all his love in it. Scotto's, a long tradition in the hamptons and an iconic family with roots to our community always delivers the full gamut of Italian cuisine with a warm friendly hand. Here for the weekend , grab a pie (most certainly the perfectly balance Hot Honey Pepperoni) and stock up with the highest quality Italian fare and aged meat. read more

Scotto's Italian Pork Store - Hot Honey Pepperoni - Delis Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Scotto's recently catered our party and I would STRONGLY recommend you use another caterer! They were non -responsive and rude throughout the process and they misrepresented what they could provide. Their portions were unacceptable and the presentation of the food was weak; the salmon was a cut into tiny pieces as was the skirt steak. It looked cheap. . They charged a small fortune to provide set up staff that left early and didn't help with clean up. They omitted some dessert items, which was documented in an email, and claimed we had canceled them. They are clearly a food "drop off" service and don't know a thing about event planning. They lead you to believe otherwise. I regret using them and would NEVER recommend their services read more

Local favorite, friendly, clean, lunch specials, little spot to eat outside in a covered area

Delicious pizza right along the main street area. They have so many different items on their menu, but the pizza I ordered was very good. It tasted fresh, flavorful, and amazing. The service was quick and efficient and the pizza and salad didn't take long to make as we took it to-go. The inside had plenty of seating on a weekday and it wasn't too busy. read more

Scotto's Italian Pork Store - La Margarita Pizza - Delis Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Used to be our favorite pizza in town, until today. Photos show the difference between a couple years ago and today. I have many photos of their pizzas which I would use to brag to my friends; until today. We usually get a half mushroom, half pepperoni and they have been divine. Until today. They switched from using thick pepperoni to skinny sticks, and only are using about 25% of what they used to. And the price is higher (which I would not care about if they didn't go so miserly on the pepperoni.) Probably will stop going there, after being a regular customer for about 2 decades. Extremely disappointed read more

Scotto's Italian Pork Store - The old way - Delis Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

This place was recommended by a friend as a local place with home cooked - esque meals. I have to say that it did have a very comfort food vibe to it. The food is overall very gluttonous in a greasy way but on a freezing day, it hits the spot! Food: we ordered the white pizza, rice balls, calamari, and pasta. The white pizza was delicious and filled with ricotta which I love. The rice balls had beef in them, which was not specified in the menu. The pasta was very oily and could have used more salt but still good. Service: honestly not the best. They had confirmed the order and then told us they didn't have something we ordered. We did delivery and it took over an hour to get our food. Also they have us the wrong receipt and we're deceptive about prices read more

See all

Well, hold down the fort if you want the best sausage the best pork and Italian food. Scott is the place to go. They've been a family owned business for decades and decades the best food and a real Italian family that knows how to make your pallet dance. It's the perfect opera of Food.. read more

Ordered an Italian hero to-go and could not believe how huge this thing was. It legit took me three days to finish, it was that stacked with cold cuts, cheese, hot peppers and oil and vinegar. Scotto's itself is a small shop with a variety of sandwich, pizza and prepared food options. There's seating here if you'd rather stay and enjoy your food, but the bulk of their business seems to be to-go orders. I stopped in right before they were closing and was able to get my sandwich quickly made. Their freezer options of premade meals were also tempting - they have any kind of pasta you could possibly want along with Italian staples like chicken and eggplant parm ready to go -- all you have to do is stick them in the oven. The salad options (macaroni, potato, marinated mushrooms, etc.) were a little lacking in my opinion, but this could also be because I went at the end of the day. If you're ordering a sandwich from here, don't let the sticker shock deter you. Yes, this sandwich was $20 but again, it could feed three reasonably sized people. read more

Scotto's Italian Pork Store - Half of an Italian Hero - Delis Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

The food is great, but super overpriced...I mean crazy expensive. It's mainly for takeout, although the have an indoor dining space. During the summer they have small table on the sidewalk which is really nice. There are other options in town that are less expensive and equally, if not better in food quality. read more

I used to come here all the time went back for an eggplant with fries mozzarella and tomato sand it was like 16 dollars and had no flavor...

I stopped in this place because i was in Hampton Bays. I ordered Chicken soup. The most tasty Chicken soup I have ever had! The young lady who helped me has a warm friendly personality, she told me she just made the soup. I would recommend this place to everybody over on the South Fork of Long Island. The atmosphere in the pizza place is warm and friendly just like the young lady. Thank You! I hope to be back! Delicious food read more

The most random awesome spot for massive, absolutely amazing sandwiches for the beach. I got chick ceasar wrap which wasnt even on the MENU and they made it unbelievably well. Kind of pricey but for that size?????? I'm so in. read more

Great food , the pasta and meats. The home made sausages is out of this world ! Friendly people and great service.

Ordered take out, store completely got my order wrong and when I mentioned that the order was incorrect I was told "that's not what I heard." No apology and no correction of the wrong item. Charged full price for the incorrect order. Will not go back and frankly the food was not great for the price. I won't be returning. read more

We used their pizza truck for an outdoor/work pool party and they were fantastic! They were punctual and professional - and the food kept coming and coming and was delicious! They made our party such a success - we will definitely use them again and highly recommend them! read more

Stopped here for sandwiches shortly after arriving in Hampton Bays on the train. Only one block away from the train station, this deli was the most convenient lunch option on our way to the house we rented. I ordered three custom vegetarian sandwiches for about $16 per sandwich, each of which were large sandwiches. Service was friendly and quick. I noticed in their refrigerated section they had some ready to bake Italian dishes, which would be a very easy dinner if you were doing a house rental like I was. read more

Scotto's Italian Pork Store - Mozzarella custom sandwich - Delis Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

This is the best Deli in the hamptons if you want fresh real Italian bread, mozzarella cheese, great pasta, sandwiches. Just the best fresh Italian deli read more

Scottos is one of the few authentic mom and pop Italian places you can find In the Hampton's. Everything they have is fresh and delicious and they never skimp on the portions. To start they have the best pizza I've had in the Hampton's. Broccoli rabe with sausage and a thin but crunchy crust held together despite the heavy toppings I finished off with the Combo sandwich (mortadella, prosciutto, mozz + pickled peppers and olives on a baguette) which really hit the spot. Haven't had a sandwich like that anywhere else. Not cheap but not too expensive either. The sandwiches are big enough on their own for a meal for the average person. Must try and you will see why it's been there for so long. read more

Scotto's Italian Pork Store - Delis Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Had pizza delivered from Scotto's. Great variety and the pie was great! Generous toppings!

Bought some pre-made manicotti for an easy dinner. Wow! They were awful! Globs of off -tasting cheese with almost no pasta and a little acidy tomato sauce.It was very sloppily tossed into an aluminum tin. This was $19.99. Most of the revolting mess got tossed into the trash. Scotto's , you should be ashamed to sell such half-assed, sub-par food. I won't be back and suggest Francesca's for better food ,better prices and better experience. read more

We all know that prices have risen, however, because prepared to pay through your nose for many items here Fresh mozzarella at $21.99 lb is outrageous. Quality was average. Sausage is $13.99, and was not even fresh. Prices are double and triple in comparison to similar Italian stores. If the quality was outstanding, you could perhaps justify the cost. They are charging premium prices for sub quality products. Nothing special here. I rather pay Citerellas prices and have quality food that's fresh. Will never shop there again. read more

I love Scotto's with all my heart. Truly a staple of Hampton Bays. Great quality food and great cuts of meat. My go to is the prosciutto, mozzarella, tomato on focaccia sandwich. A perfect combo of flavors that you can never go wrong with. If you're checking out yelp before you go in - take my word for it - this place is amazing! Friendly staff and a great warm ambiance! read more

Just love this place. Authentic Italian food always made to order and includes the freshest ingredients. There's no better Italian food around. . read more

There's something about old school Italian aka old world recipes. The old country is alive here. The professionalism, cleanliness, customer service, quality, taste, ease of parking, location and atmosphere are amazing. Also Sesame cookies that mom used to love are prevalent here. The counter staff are ready , willing and able to accommodate any request. A must try. Their baked cookies are an essence of Italy. Definitely make this stop for cookies, salads, pizza, sandwiches, macaroni, sauce and they have a section of to go for the family. Thank you for being especially nice today. #sesamecookie - read more

See all

Omg what an amazing place with such amazing food and an amazing staff. Raquel and Giuseppe offer such flavorful dishes, large portions and a very friendly atmosphere. If you are in Hampton Bays you have to visit Scotto's. And do not forget to say hi to Tom. read more

See all

Business must be really good at Scotto's Pork Store to turn customers away. I needed to buy a quarter lb each of ground pork, veal and chuck for a very specific recipe. I did not need any more than that. The woman behind the counter said minimum was a half pound of each. So I left. I wanted to give my business to a locally owned business but wound up going into Southampton to that well known gourmet specialty market where they are happy to sell me whatever amount I need. That being said I purchased a bunch of other Italian specialty items at the Gourmet market in Southampton. Scotto's you lost a much bigger sale from me because of your lack of customer service which I expect from a family run business. read more

I don't know her name but the Far Eastern girl working there is extremely rude. Even though I stated my allergy, this was never taken into consideration. Price performance is also bad pizzas not good to much read more

My first time here and ordered the Italian Hero with the works . Well let's just say it was so yummy . It might even be the BEST Italian hero I've ever had . The garlic knots are also huge and delish . Can't wait to go back and try more off the menu . Store was clean and fridge was stocked . The staff were friendly :) read more

Scotto's Italian Pork Store - Italian Hero with the works - Delis Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Stopped in fir a slice of pizza, not much to choose from, pepperoni look like the best out of the bunch, but it wasn't, old pizza with pepperoni on it. For the Scotto's name very disappointed, NOT REALLY ITALIAN FINE FOOD! I'm feeling sick after eating it. Where's the board of health? read more

I love this place even more in January... when every place is moping and depressed - Scotto's is busy because they are good.. the people were all super helpful, even went in the back and gave me some fresh basil for my fresh mozzerella - which I needed out here...... Very accommodating and everything looks and tastes super. People come here for deli, pork store items, pasta's, sauces, and hot food. And pizza! the pizza is only part of what they do.. but they do it better than most pizza stores. Alwasy looks amazing too. read more

Scotto's Italian Pork Store - Scotto's pizza, italian sandwiches with prosciutto fresh mozzerella. etc - Delis Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Great food. Nice owners and staff. Really great local option for pizza and italian specialties

It's my local store and they make so much from scratch including the mozzarella, pizza is amazing as well, everything to be honest is fantastic read more

Delicious Sandwich. It reminds of a sandwich you can get from Little Italy. Old world Italian Pork store and restaurant. read more

Scotto's Italian Pork Store - 1/2 of Italian Hero - Delis Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Ordered in from Scotto's last night. What a great experience. We got 2 pizzas, one Sicilian pie which was amazing and a vegetable stuffed pizza that was incredible. The stuffed pizza had everything in it, loved it... they are very large pizzas!!! read more

Awesome selection of items. So many good things that you won't be able to decide what to get. Surprised this place is not highly reviewed by more people. Would recommend coming here for a slice, fresh eggplant and mozzarella sandwich, or take out plates. Awesome and friendly staff too. Has nice seating area on side of deli. read more

See all

Scotto's Pork Store. A pork store isn't normally on my wish list of places to grab some grub but, I suggest you add it to yours, and here's why; I was "out east" enjoying the beautiful weather and the St. Patrick's parade, when I saw a sign that read, "$1 slices during parade"... they were going like hotcakes and a buck was all it cost, no tax, just a simple dollar for one of the largest slices I've seen. This slice wasn't just large in size, the flavor was as big as can be. Saucy, cheesy, and quite yummy for a buck; seeing just one slice, I would have to imagine ordering an entire pie would be a great deal even at the normal price, above $1 a slice. This pork store is not just that; they have what looks to be, quite an extensive menu for not only catering, but daily dining as well. read more

These days I don't eat as much pizza as I used to, so I look for the best. Sadly their pizza wasn't as good as I hoped. Gave it a few tries (needed to be sure) and it's ok, but not out of this world. read more

Love, love, love their veal Milanese hero! Breaded and fried veal, pickled hot peppers, lettuce and onion, vinegar and oil on a hero! Yummy and feeds the two of us! We have gotten it many times! read more

Good food- Rebecca, our server was a sweet young lady, and the owner was very personable. Will definitely be back.

Stopped in and we split an Italian Hero - very good would definitely come again. Their meats looked great as well.