I liked the crust of the pre-made slices. Was I over the moon or did I feel like I experienced spectacular NY pizza? No, but it was good. We only ordered a traditional pizza fresh and I ordered a pre-made white pizza -- the crust was extra crisp on the bottom which was nice. Staff was super friendly! Interior? standard pizza place with a nice dining room/seating area. It's bigger than it seems inside. read more

See all

Order a whole pizza to share. The service was good, food was good. I personally like a bit extra crispy at the bottom, however maybe I should start saying that? read more

Pizza Village - Pizza Near Me - Montauk, New York

This is our favorite place in Montauk and we have been here multiple times this week. The staff are super friendly, prices are reasonable, and the pizza is so good! I have also had the clam chowder, garlic and broccoli spaghetti, and a salad. The inside has a fun and rustic vibe too. Even though there are a lot of great restaurants in the area we just love this one so much we can't help but keep coming back! read more

See all

OVERPRICED and UNDERWHELMING. My husband and I got into Montauk around 9pm after an 8-hr drive. This spot was the only thing open and with decent enough reviews we decided why not. I paid $80 for 1 L pizza and a caesar salad, AFTER checking the website's menu and prices and calling in my pick-up order. Insane. I requested bacon instead of ham chunks on a hawaiian pizza and the phone rep (likely the owner I saw in person who told me "well I'm not sure who you spoke with but they should've told you") decided he'd customize a pizza and add each topping individually, $23 for a cheese pie, $3 for bacon, $3 for pineapple, $8 for mozzarella, and some amount for pizza sauce. Like, WHAT?! My husband paid and when I saw the bill I walked right back to ask WTF?! The guy explained "oh those prices online are wrong, we've been trying to have that menu taken down" to which I say "how would your customer know that?!" And each of his responses was more nonsensical than the last- "well how would we sustain this place with those outdated prices" (being $29 for a L hawaiian). Mind you, those prices are THEIR menu from THEIR website. The WORST customer service, and for that alone I wouldn't give em another dime. I'd say the pizza was aight, but after paying THAT and having experiencing gooodt pizza place to place, no way it could live up to $50/pie. I won't even get started on the caesar with the dry chicken breast and a pinch of parmesan. They made writing this shitty review so easy for me it's unbelievable. read more

Great pizza! It's not quite NYC pizza but it's really good. Great lunch spot or take out dinner.

For the prices they charge the food should be real And fresh. I ordered a chicken roll. The chicken was only on the outside of the roll. There was nothing in the middle. Not to mention the chicken is not fresh chicken cutlet or breast. It is chicken patties that you buy frozen in the store so is the equivalent of putting chicken nuggets on this. Never again. read more

Pizza Village - "Chicken roll" - Pizza Near Me - Montauk, New York

Great location, friendly and quick service. Grabbed a couple slices which weren't bad but i wouldnt come back unless i was starving. Pizza is pretty sub par. Could be crispier, cheese and dough was gummy, sauce didn't have much flavor. read more

Who makes lasagna without lasagna noodles they do that is ridiculous and charge me $23 for that

The positive things are: conveniently located, casual vibe, very pleasant staff, and excellent service. The pizza was good, but nothing special - it just really hits the spot when you have been busy all day and you are starving! read more

Amazing!! went here for lunch and it was so amazing and worth the price. i got a massive meatball sub for 12 bucks and my boyfriend got chicken parmesan and it was DELICIOUS. then we ordered too good to go and it was well worth the price and the food was fresh and yummy read more

Loved the gluten free pizza! Very helpful discussing my food allergies. Will definitely go back.

Ooo carbs I love you. It's hard for me to say those words to a human male but to some flaky, doughy bread with sauces generously drenched on it....Oo baby I love you like my Pinterest board of love shack fancy, black G-wagons and "quaint" beach houses. Side note there's nothing quaint about Marine blvd in Amagansett and I love it The pizza here is straight up "football pizza" as Dave would say. It's great late at night or for an afternoon sobering snack. Come here. Eat. Enjoy read more

See all

Some dog came in randomly and the food was good but the service was ridiculous I would not recommend

We ordered twice when staying at MYC. The pizza was good! Pretty thin crust which we love.

We tried it for take-out on a rainy, chilly August night. We had eggplant parm with spaghetti, small salad, ziti primavera with sausage, and a cannoli. Boring bread came with the dinner but there were small packages of what appeared to be fresh ground parm. Overall, like food I might make on a lazy night when I didn't want to cook. My partner enjoyed the ingredient-rich eggplant; not the best, but good. Thought the sauce could have used a touch of sugar as it was acidic. There was enough for the next day. I had the sausage & veggie ziti. A huge portion with enough sausage to make 3 night's dinners. There was some broccoli, peppers, onions and 1 olive slice. Primavara should had big chunks of some of the wonderful seasonal veggies. But the sausage was not cooked properly. It should have been fried/grilled/baked. There was no crusty bite to it. The cannoli was ok. Shell was dense and the filling too smooth and sweet. But it was freshly filled when we ordered so the shell wasn't soggy. The person taking the order was a new employee and had to ask the others for the answers to my questions. And for some reason, I was a pain asking a lot about preparation. But the business shouldn't have someone who knows nothing about the food to answer the take-out line. The prices were very reasonable. Looked like it would be unpleasant to eat in. read more

Very very poor service. Server only took one persons order before fleeing the table. Had to ask another server to finish our order... Server took plates off the table as they were being used. Felt very rushed. Food was mediocre. After all these mistakes, the check came with only half of our food on it. Had to go to the counter to pay, where the worker gave much attitude for us trying to pay for the rest of our food... Regret our choice in dining here! read more

The staff is really friendly. Pizza was made in a fairly reasonable time. Also to note they only accept cash. Each pie is was $23ish way too expensive for what it was. The Hawaiian was definitely a big disappointment. It was too wet and on top of that everything slid off when you tried to pull a slice off. They could do a better job cutting it but definitely wouldnt help much because it's still wet at the end of the day. However the chicken parmesan was the highlight, super delicious but it too was slightly wet. I think I would go back again next time to split the chicken parmesan and maybe try something else. Definitely staying away with the Hawaiian. read more

Pizza Village - Wet Hawaiian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Got pizza twice from here the last few days. The first night asked for pizza extra well done and picked it up, the plain pie was better than the one with toppings. The pizza was good enough so... Ordered again tonight for something simple and it was delivered quickly. Asked for extra well done and what we got was a disgusting pile of soup in the middle five inches of the pizza - yuck, a mess. Not worth the calories or the dollars - dumped half the pizza in the garbage. Maybe don't get pizza from here. read more

My parents came with me to this pizzeria and the food was amazing I personally got the chicken parmigiana and had some of the cedar salad with grilled chicken, the chicken parm was given in a huge serving of chicken so much it dwarfed the amount of spaghetti. I ended up finishing my parmigiana swiftly and moved onto the Caesar salad, it was good but the chicken felt a little dry. Besides the huge serving of chicken dwarfing the spaghetti and the chicken on the salad being a little dry it was an amazing experience and left me needing to write a review of this place. I saw the old reviews and ratings, so I ask if the place is under new management, and it is, you NEED to come try this place out! read more

So glad we gave this place another try. Pizza was delivered quickly and was delicious. Cash only ! read more

Pizza Village - Pizza Near Me - Montauk, New York

This pizza is pretty bad, not much more to say. I ordered a sausage slice and they tossed a handful of microwave sausage pieces on top. Chuckie cheese does way better. read more

Pizza Village - Sausage slice - Pizza Near Me - Montauk, New York

It's so good, the people were so beautifully with my family and the pizza is really nice they have a lot types of pizza

Stopped by here as we hit the road to head back home from Montauk. Got the perfect slice of cheese pizza and a cold drink for the ride home. Nice people & yummy pizza! Happy to support small business. Thanks Pizza Village! read more

See all

Great little no frills Pizza joint. I absolutely love their dough/crust and cheese. Friendly staff. I was in town for 48 hours and ate here 4 times! Check it out! read more

Pizza Village - Outside of building - Pizza Near Me - Montauk, New York

they don't even answer the phone when they fail to deliver. they just wait for you to give up. AVOID

We were walking by and decided to go in and get pizza. The place is very small but cute and the staff is super friendly and nice. We tried 3 different slices and they were all really good. The crust was nice and thin with right amount of ingredients on it. Will totally go back here for more loved it. read more

See all

I am a self-proclaimed pizza snob... This pizza is AMAZING! True NY pizza right in the heart of town. Cons - Could use a facelift and more space. read more

The pizza is decent. Their menu beyond pizza... I don't say this lightly, it's absolutely disgusting. Go to IGA and get a can of Chef Boyardee for a tenth of the price, and I promise you, you will be much more satisfied. Their food is consistently terrible. I'm a firm believer that even the worst Italian restaurant can make a decent chicken parm. They can't even do that well. I've been in NYC and Montauk my entire life and I can tell you for certainty, it's the worst Italian food I ever had. read more

Good pizza, chill local atmosphere. A nice break from gurneys. Monsey was so sweet and accommodating. 10/10!

Came here after a few beers at Montauk Brewing as we knew some pizza would hit the spot. There is another pizza place that's actually closer to the brewery but it has no seating, Pizza Village has a lot of tables and chairs which is what we were looking for. All the table service here accompanies a waitress which was really nice, we started off with jalapeño poppers and mozzarella sticks. Both were good and came out unbelievably fast. Next we ordered a bunch of slices, which also came out very quickly. I had the chicken bacon ranch and the grandma, The chicken bacon ranch was heavy but filling. The grandmas style was a little different then what I was looking for but was still very good. They have a much larger dinner menu, and I would be interested to see what a meal from here is like. Everything smelled wonderful. All and all it's a nice little spot to stop for something to eat whilst out in Montauk, and there was plenty of parking right out front! read more

Pizza Village - Pizza Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

CASH ONLY: Stopped in on a Saturday afternoon. The pizza wasn't my favorite. The crust wasn't as crunch as I liked. The first bite needed a help from my other hand, very flimsy. I did not enjoy the chicken slices, buffalo must have been next to bbq because a few bites tasted sweet. It may have also been the tomato sauce I was tasting. The regular chicken slice w cheese also was sort of sweet. I'll probably stop in again if I'm around, but im going to try another pizza spot around read more

See all

Above average pizza with a wide variety of topping options including Hawaiian. Depending on your topping selection the pizza bottom can be a bit soggy so for a relatively thin crust this can be somewhat annoying. Yes, it is expensive but it is Montauk and I heard a story about PREVIOUS owners that gouged people in the area with $80 pies during the great blackout of 2003 since they were literally the only place open. So, assuming that lore is even true at least things are not that bad! As others have mentioned it is cash only. There is an Avoiding Tax Machine (ATM) in the place so at least purchases are still possible. For this trip it was a large take out run and they got everything correct, added on what we needed at the moment, but still had to ask for the basics of some red pepper and cheese for optional personalization. For the expense and the fact that this largely a tourist town you would think they would be more proactive with that. read more

Ordered 2 pies delivered. If I could give it negative stars I would. To say it was undercooked is an insult to cooking. Best guess is that it grazed the oven on the way out the door, if that. If you are looking for pizza do yourself a favor and go to the IGA and get some Ellios. What we got doesn't qualify as pizza read more

Pizza Village - Pizza Near Me - Montauk, New York

I legitimately wouldn't even serve this to a dog. The worst pizza ever. ... and they never sent the bottled water or seltzer read more

I came here two nights in a row and had a great time each night. I regret both nights too. The second night a guy bought my gf and I a pizza randomly and then we got in an argument. Good times. read more

2 stars for the very polite staff. Cheese pizza slice crust was droopy with oil, cheese was more chunky tasting than smooth. Specialty sauce was cold under the quickly reheated toppings. Has gone down considerably over the years. Been going here for 20 yrs! Place could use a quick makeover on the inside too. Part of the dining areas looks like you are sitting in a big closet with a work space in it. I wish them well that they may return to how good it was. read more

5/5 pizza, 5/5 people Not only was the pizza amazing but this was the friendliest staff. I left my card at the pizza shop and the staff went above and beyond- they let me know they found my card and sent it to me no questions asked. I'll be back next time! read more

Worst Margarita pie ever. No fresh tomatoes. The sauce tasted terrible. The only good thing about the pizza was the crust. Will not purchase a margarita pie again from here. read more

Pizza Village - two slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Montauk, New York

Not the best pizza. It's kind of bland so I asked for garlic powder, it's better. The crust is hard. Price is fair though- a large pie for around $15. read more

newly remodeled corner pizza place (next to memory motel). nothing fancy. just good pizza go to when/if montauk. other stuffs (side salad) just ok but going for their pizza and it doesn't disappoint. read more