Ziti chicken slice is sooo good. Super friendly staff of…read moreyoung folks who work hard to give you the best. Try the Sicilian pizza too!

We just use them to cater for a family reunion of 31 very picky Italian's . Everything was perfect…read more We had eggplant Parmesan, chicken, piccata, pizzas, and Greek salad. Everything we had was delicious and prepared perfectly and and each tray can easily be 25 people. I would highly recommend this place for a very good pizzas and casual Italian food. Also, the young man who took my order was very precise and then when I picked up, the order was very very helpful and making sure everything was done as requested and help me get it into my car.

Brix & Rye is in a class all its own. This small speakeasy is dark on the inside and…read morewell-appointed. The cocktails are nothing short of amazing! If cocktails are your thing, you don't want to miss this place. They also serve pizzas, which looked amazing. Be sure to visit this establishment, you won't be disappointed!

Came here on a snowy Monday night to get a few beers and pizza. The staff was friendly and served…read moreus a few local beers and we got a margarita pizza from 1943 which had a thin crispy crust and tasty sauce and ingredients. Nice intimate space to bring your date!

Pizzas are made fresh to order and was so delicious. Pizzas cook quick inside the huge oven! Nice,…read morethin pies, and they are made as a personal size pizza (14"). The crust still had the perfect ratio of dough making it fluffy, thin, and not crunchy. The white pie with the truffled ricotta and roasted mushrooms is a must try if you love anything truffle. It was loaded with flavors of garlic, mushrooms and the perfect amount of truffle. I'm so glad I ordered this pie! This will definitely be a spot we will visit again in the summer time. Inside is small, but they have additional seating outside.

I stopped by with my mom for lunch when I was in town visiting and absolutely loved everything…read moreabout the food here! The service was great, seating was easy and wasn't too busy for a Saturday. We split the burrata and the red pie with mozzarella, ricotta, red onion, and meatballs and it was delectable. You really can't beat the pizza here!

Run, do not walk to Eddie's! This is hard to get a reservation to so do so in advance if you like…read moreyour toes in the sand and belly happy! What a beautiful place with great staff and delicious food. My favorite here was the fried oyster roll and taking a heap of pictures by the water. It makes me curious to stay here at the motel. It says temporarily closed so hopefully this is just for the season. I can't wait to go back next summer.

Love, love, loved our dinner experience at Eddie's…read more Beachside dining, cute decor, friendly service, great food and cocktails... did I mentioned beachside dining? We started with dozens and dozens of raw oysters. Highly rec. We also loved the grilled summer mushrooms with maitake vinegar, rosemary, and whipped tahini (YURRRRM, we ordered two plates), margherita 'zas, and lamb skewers. Def get the spicy marg (see pic!) Can't wait to go back on my next visit to the North Fork.

Was there after 8pm and was told no more whole pie orders so picked from what was available…read more Anyway, we only wanted slices for a quick bite. Liked the crust, thin but not soggy. Cheese toppings on the white pizza was kind of dry. Slices are around $4-4.75 each. Tables on one side, counter/stools on the other.

Super yummy pizza! They are open until 10pm which is great…read more Our original game plan was to get Mexican but after the insanely long wait 2 doors down we decided to bring pizza in. We had cheese, pepperoni, a spicy pepperoni and a sausage one. They were all fabulous and yummy. Will def be returning next time we're in town :)

Not only is this restaurant one of the only places open for dinner during the offseason but it's…read moredelicious and affordable too. My family and I had planned on dining at another restaurant that had hours posted online that weren't correct or even applicable because they were closed. We were fortunate enough to remember shelter island slice from a summer a few years back and it didn't disappoint. Fast, friendly, and clean establishment that we will definitely be returning to.

Huge fan of the SI Slice! I had a couple slices after the Shelter Island Bucks game with a few of…read morethe players. This place does it right and the are proud sponsors of the SI Bucks. Large & delicious pizza slices you can choose from right at the front window when you walk in and served hot. The buffalo chicken (not very spicy), the pepperoni (a beautiful NY slice), the chicken bacon ranch (a home run)! The pasta dishes look amazing! One of the players I was with ordered a dish and it smelled fantastic! Open seats inside and outside. TVs to watch current events and games as well.

Amazing food, service and atmosphere! The Margaritas were delicious! Highly recommend.read more

The service was speedy and attentive. Conveniently located in the downtown of Greenport. They are…read morethe epitome of TexMex restaurants. I also loved the pay for song jukebox. Next touch to the playlist. Outside of the flavorful rice, the menu wasn't too exciting. I found it salty and unfinished. I will say the ambiance and the drinks were satisfying at a fair price. I can see it being a hit in the summer months.

We are a group of 4 that booked last minute on resy for 7:30pm dining in the dining room since the…read moreoutdoor was too cold. We arrived early and were told our table is still finishing up. We didn't wait that long afterwards since our reservation is at 7:30pm. The staff was on top of it, giving us water and bread then giving us more bread. I also appreciate how the staff apologize because they are understaffed today which is understandable but the wait for everything was not bad. We left around 8:45pm. Food: Linguine with clam sauce was great, def will get it again. Calamari was great, the batter was not thick and the calamari was not overdone Baked clams and Salmon was ok decent Shrimp scampi will be the one I won't order again because it was too bland imo. Not enough lemon/sour, not enough garlic and I wish there was cheese. Overall great location, parking, and experience. Everyone was extremely friendly and hardworking. Even the receptionist had to set the tables and I appreciate it.

Very slow service due to being way understaffed, mediocre, bland, over priced food, The…read morerestaurant isn't managed well. Won't be back.

We had a lovely dinner last night. The food was delicious and the view is amazing…read more I would have given it more stars but a few things bothered me. I had a delicious Caesar salad but had to ask for pepper. Rather than the server bringing a grinder she simply brought over a small pepper shaker. The mussels were good and they come with French fries but we had to request ketchup for the three of us who ordered this meal. If they wanted to up their game they good had fries ground pepper or have salt and pepper on every table. Ketchup is a staple with fries for most and we shouldn't have to ask for it. Lastly I requested a second bottle of sparkling water and needed to ask twice for it. So overall nice place but the attention to details could improve

I go to Greenport every summer and this is officially a "must" going forward. Let me preface this…read morewith - I never stayed at the hotel but I did attend a summer ball there in 2023. Unfortunately, the 2025 ball was canceled but I was able to get a dining experience at the restaurant here. I loved the sunset views and the awesome service we received. The place is beautiful and the food is also delicious and very light. I would definitely recommend giving it a go. I tried various appetizers and entries, my favorites were fish and the fruit salad. A good mention is the cheese cake, which was very flavorful. One star off for small portions but it was perfect for our girl group. Definitely a Greenport staple.

Poor service and bad food. Not sure if the oil they used was old or just bad, but the flavor…read moretainted anything fried. And the soy sauce tasted bad, which made the sushi less enjoyable. The salad dressing was pretty good. I don't think we'll be going back.

Great place for takeout, rolls were easy and filling, and service was kind and friendly!read more