had a very nice waiter. I ordered a blackberry margarita and it was delicious. Food came out at a good time and was also very delicious. Very nice of them to box the food also for leftovers. Highly recommend this place. very nice inside too! read more

This place is a model of disorganization, and I will surely never return.. It's not hard to handle six customers, in the span of 5 minutes but somehow these people find a way to make it is difficult as they can. read more

One of my favorite spots on the East End of Long Island to grab a slice or two. There is a big selection of traditional and gourmet slices to get. The gourmet slices are massive and can definitely feed two. The garlic knots are also well cooked and not overly garlic. Staff is very nice and service is always great and quick. The place has a casual front and formal back if you want to dine in. Overall, this place is consistently good and I will continue to come. read more

Michelangelo Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Food great, waitstaff great, front of house great, large pies are 16" (which is a medium pie) bartender not so great.

Sat for dinner in the dining room in the middle of the week and was absolutely blown away by the friendly staff and quality food. Our group all had large meals,, appetizer sampler, salad and it was excellent! Don't let the modest front tables deceive you, this is more than a pizza place! Sit down and enjoy a great family friendly Italian meal. Great portions and quality and smiling happy staff goes a long way these days! read more

5/4/22 Just back from Florida, we needed to bring in a few things from the local market and have dinner. We chose to go to the Mattituck market and Michaelangelo pizzeria next door. We enjoyed a wonderful meal that included a seafood pasta that hubby enjoyed very much. It included a variety of seafood including mussels clams, shrimp and a lobster tail! One of the specials that were offered this evening was a pork chop Milanese with a wonderful salad on top. The pork was juicy, tender and flavorful We both enjoyed our dinner and settled back into life on the east end. It was great seeing Brenda and our server Alicia could not have been more attentive. read more

Michelangelo Pizzeria - Seafood pasta with spaghetti. - Pizza Near Me - Mattituck, New York

It was my second time there the first time I was like wow it's pretty good pizza left happy went in again and there was a line we didn't have problem waiting we waited ordered food three slices 1x penne pasta to go with EXTRA BREAD and 1 drink then, we wanted a refill we had to wait in line again fine, wasn't bothered. We finished our slices and then they called us for our penne pasta and when we look we asked for extra bread she looked at the bread cut it into 3 pieces and said it was the extra and I was baffled it was. 10" pasta plate with three tiny pieces of bread and I also asked for extra there was no extra I'm like the bread will be eaten in three bites it's only good for fast food but it were to order to go I don't recommend they'll just overcharge you and give you less then expected. I was disappointed because I thought I found a good place for once boy was I wrong. They charged me for extra bread when all they did was cut the bread that normally comes with. read more

Michelangelo Pizzeria - The extra bread in question - Pizza Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Getting too expensive. Ordered a Caesar salad with shrimp and after waiting for a very long time I went up to the counter to pay and was shocked when the girl said $38! 4 shrimp on lettuce with parm. That seems excessive to me and I won't be able to go back. Locals are taking the hit for all the new traffic on the North Fork. It was a tasty salad but $38 is crazy for 1 salad. read more

Not bad, got a chicken parm hero. It's a regular style pizzeria/restaurant for out east, nice pieces of chicken, fresh bread, over all it was pretty good. The pizza here is just OK but there isn't a whole lot to report. Have a Happy New Year! read more

Michelangelo Pizzeria - Chicken parm hero - Pizza Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Mattituck so lucky to have this restaurant and pizzeria... Food is always delicious!!! Wait staff is par excellence!!! Many a family party was held here and created a lovely memory!!!! Don't miss out on this dining experience!!!!! read more

I had the worst veggie pizza ever. It had huge pieces of broccoli, a lot of spinach, squash and some mushrooms and garlic. Not a tasty combination! We pay $30 for a soggy pizza. I had to scrap the vegetables away from the crust. I do not recommend the vegetable pizza. read more

Excellent pizzeria on the north fork, great for take out and to sit and eat inside for a date night or romantic dinner

Words can't even describe how terrible, disgustingly rude and disrespectful the staff that worked on June 5th, 2023 treats their PAYING customers. Like if you want to be judged, overpriced and mistreated please go buy food here. literally never have i experienced this and i'm from mattituck. They didn't even give me my whole order, like where's my salad? I was literally standing there when the blinded male and female cooks walked out and talked about my order. like i literally rather go to out Lenny's, Sergio's, Roma's, Grana's, Primavera's or even Domino's pizzeria. i can guarantee these places will provide muchhh better service for a PAYING customer! like it is absolutely insane if your boss lets this sh*t happen. literally whoever is reading this, go somewhere else. trust me. i even recommended better places ^ so don't waste your time or MONEY! read more

UPDATE: I'm allergic to some meat products, so I ordered a spinach roll. I got home, took a bite and it's STUFFED with pepperoni! If I hadn't spit it out immediately, I could have gotten really sick. So now they get one star instead of 2. Wish I could give 0. 2 stars instead of 1 because it's my fault I keep coming back here, but this is the last time. EVERY time I ordered takeout this year, it was TWICE as long as they told me on the phone. Usually because they completely forgot to cook part of my order. And the staff isn't never apologetic at all. They also don't tell you why it's taking so long, they just say "5 minutes" and walk away and you're left standing for another 20 minutes waiting, while the rest of your order gets cold. Done with this place. read more

My husband and son just finished having a nice dinner in the dining area of Michelangelo's in Mattituck. Our waitress was very sweet. As we were leaving we remembered to buy something for my mother. We ordered a white slice of pizza to go. A young tall girl (with pretty blue eyes) turned to her coworker in the front of the pizza oven and made fun of us. It was so obvious. I told her coworker I saw all that and her friend wasn't very nice. This ruined our evening. Having a food business in Manhattan for over 45 years we understand this is not a reflection of the boss. read more

They charge a 4% fee to use your credit card... Ridiculous. Wonder why?! Hmm. Like everyone else, I go to plenty of restaurants, stores, etc and never get charged a fee, let alone 4%. read more

One star because our pizza was hot. Otherwise it was probably one of the worst pizzas I have had in years. Burnt crust, greasy and salty. $30 for a plain cheese pizza. Never again read more

What has happened to Michaengelo's? We have lived here for years and order take out every few months. We ordered tonite and got the wrong order, raw bread, and no salads. Also, the food that we got was not good. Did they switch owners? Will not order again. We spent a lot of money for food we will not eat. read more

Placed pickup order with name & phone number and was advised a pickup time. Upon arrival I was advised that they did not have my order or any record of it. I did not appreciate the attitude given by the man in charge who did not care about the inconvenience or trying to be accommodating whatsoever. Very disappointing and will not return. read more

This is always the best pizzeria in town, insanely great tasting pizza. I recommend the Margherita and Buffalo slices. The pricing is not great, but in my eyes it's always worth it, they have a high end restaurant in the back, they also have stellar food, as i always get their fettuccine Alfredo, never disappoints. read more

Excellent overall! Carrie the waitress was amazing and so nice! The food was great! Will definitely be returning!

Truly outstanding, every time I go! The absolute best. I eat out every week and this is my favorite of all I've been to. Truly.

The food is good and the servers are super nice, however there is an extremely dishonest practice of showing a "cash discount" on the menu that is only advertised by size 6 font and not mentioned anywhere else. You think you're paying one thing then when you go to pay with CC end up paying another thing (which most customers don't notice due to the deceptive layout of the check). It's advertised as being "to keep prices competitive" but if that was really the case they would be clear about the credit card up charge. Let's call it what it is - a dirty business practice aimed at getting more money out of unsuspecting customers. I work in customer marketing and this type of practice is one of the most disrespectful ways you can treat your patrons. I won't eat here again and encourage others to speak out against dirty business practices like this. read more

I've been coming here my whole life, and was super surprised and disappointed to see they've added a 4% credit card surcharge "as an incentive to our customers". It's a sneaky way to grab extra money and it's ILLEGAL for merchants to set a blanket surcharge in New York State. I'll be sticking with Roma Pizza in Cutchogue from now on. read more

Michelangelo Pizzeria - Cash "discount"--really a credit card surcharge - Pizza Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Sadly I decided to give them another chance, and this is what I got, firsts, the wedge salad comes with slab bacon, I can forgive the lack of slab bacon though they either need to change the menu or at least let a person know when they are out... Let's address the real issue, the half gallon of dressing... The hell? And also, the severe lack of cheese on the pizza, personally I am done with this restaurant. read more

Michelangelo Pizzeria - This clearly shows the amount of dressing I got. - Pizza Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

First time at this restaurant recommended by cedar house b and b. Everything from service to food was great. Our waitress Brenda served with a smile and made us feel at home! read more

This place has gone downhill! Terrible service, food is fake Italian. Who doesn't have fresh parmesan cheese ? Go to Olive Garden, at least you know what to expect there. read more

We had a party of 9 for dinner. Everyone loved their meals. The service was prompt, courteous and perfectly timed. Very pleased and will return read more

Michelangelo Pizzeria - Grilled swordfish special - Pizza Near Me - Mattituck, New York

We have been living a mile away for 18 years now. Finally....whoever owns or is making the pizzas here has gotten it right. We were going all the way to Jamesport for years before this. My son just happened to order here. ... otherwise we would still be going the 4 miles there. Such an improvement. read more

I stumbled upon this pizzeria during the middle of our journey through wine country. We were starting to feel like things could get boozey and out of control if we didn't get a bite to eat. So we drove around until I saw a strip mall and thought, "There has to be a pizzeria in there. This is Long Island! There's a pizzeria in EVERY strip mall." -- And lo and behold... I was correct. It seems to be a popular spot with a good selection of pies and clean seating area. There's also a restaurant in the back. My eggplant parm slice came out of the oven piping hot. The crust was perfectly charred and crunchy/chewy. The sauce had a good flavor and the cheese was super melty. YUM. I recommend it! read more

Michelangelo Pizzeria - Eggplant Parm Slice - Pizza Near Me - Mattituck, New York

I was extremely disappointed with the service here. My boyfriend and I went here to get some pizza. We used to come after watching a movie at the theatre and they were fine. But this place really went downhill. We opened the box to find a huge chunk missing from the White Slice. The dough was extremely thin on the other slices making them fall apart and hard to eat. One of the employees was very rude and obviously didn't care about her job. She let someone take someone else's order with theirs because "no one grabbed it" yet it was just placed there. Every time the phone rang she would shout "would someone answer the damn phone." And when our order was ready she rudely announced our pizzas showing no care for her job. "Here's the white. Spinach, Marsala and whatever slice." She was very unwelcoming. My boyfriend said he felt chaotic and stressed and he doesn't even work there. read more

Michelangelo Pizzeria - White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

This was the WORST dining experiences me and my wife ever had was at this dumphole of a place. There is absolutely nothing professional about this establishment because you will make a reservation for a large party, and then some snot-nose girl will tell you that your reservation was made for an hour later. The food was not relatively good what we tried, little over cooked but not the end of the world. When you sit down you will not be tended to you will not get your water refilled, your bread basket will not be even tended to, and expect eye rolls if you have the nerve to ask for anything as a customer. You will have to ask for everything drinks will come probably if you're lucky once every 40 minutes to an hour. The staff was rude, uncourteous and completely unprofessional. We had a large party, which as adults we made reservations almost a week before, and we had to leave because we were starving. After TWO HOURS (2 hours) of waiting for our entrees , we decided to leave and pay for our drinks and sun-par appetizers. The manager, or whatever Long Island tough guy was running the kitchen there (and trust me there are several) HAD THE NERVE to tell us "he was happy you F@@@S are leaving!" So after being more than patient with being ignored and not served TWO HOURS after we sat down, he were subjected to being disrespected and cursed at. We are a professional, people in our 40's and have traveled the world and have no business being referred to as "F@@@S". Please, please stay clear of this place. It ruined a perfect day for us and we wasted hours to not be fed, disrespected, and treated horrible. No one has the right to call good men and women "F@@@S" and any establishment that promotes that behavior should be closed. read more

Worst service ever. First after being seated waited 20-25 minutes and i had to ask for a menu and a drink. Then got my appetizers after about an hour lastly two hours later still didn't get my dinner. Some service. Will never go back. Ever. read more

The pizza on a good day is subpar while the rest of their Italian food is typically soggy in over salted sauce. I had ordered their gnocchi for delivery. This was an overcooked, lumpy potato that was sticky, mushy, and bland. I had called explaining the issue and the woman had promised to return my phone call - however I had never received a response. She was arguing with my phone call desperately trying to justify why the gnocchi was on is oily overcooked. She then asked me to text her a photo of the dish! After texting it to her, I received no response. Money wasted. I even asked for a possible credit but they could not have cared less. read more

Watch out for the CREDIT CARD SURCHARGE. Was surprised when we paid by credit card and the receipt showed a $3 CHARGE for credit card surcharge. Felt kind of sneaky. Nothing noticed on the menu. Just AFTER the credit card was put through the charge was noticed by us. Hmmmm other restaurants near our home aren't doing this. read more

Worst experience. They took over 20 mins to make a salad and then we get home, and the ingredients were wrong. The rest of our pizza order was sitting there while we waited and ended up being cold by the time we got home. The high school girls that work the counter are so disrespectful. Businesses run this way are meant to go out of business. read more

I come up to visit a family member in Mattituck once a quarter and they very much like going here. In fact they go frequently, order take out! We had even ordered pizza for the kids 2 days before. I have never been impressed -- huge portions of mediocre Americanized Italian. They like it so I go along. This evening was awful. Young waitstaff, barely to be found, drinks went unfilled, had to flag down another after she passed the 3rd time without checking on us. Wedge salad with what looked and tasted like a burnt pork chop thrown on top (bacon??). The kicker was the folks that like to come here ordered baked ziti it was a glob of over cooked pasta with sauce and charred cheese. As kind as the relatives were they did not send it back they told the waitress (who recognized them!!) that they did not enjoy it. Cleared 2 barely touched plates of Ziti. The check came, nothing comped.. I never expected the relatives to protest.... however I went to the manager and explained the situation... could they just go and say something along the lines of sorry you didn't enjoy it,, we hope you will come back... here a dessert.. SOMETHING! ANYTHING to acknowledge these long time customers disappointment. he said SURE SURE... walked away and never said a word to them. read more

Took 30 minutes to make a fucking salad and on top of that with 2 slices they charged $50 for three items,

Wow have things turned around since my last visit. Service was point on, the salad was good but the baked trio...omg delicious

This review relates to the restaurant in Southold (not Mattituck)! The Southold place was passable last time, but last night it was disgusting and I got sick. The sauces tasted funny and several orders were screwed up so we asked for the manager 3 times but he was hiding up front near the pizza oven and would not speak with us when we tracked him, He said that he knew things were screwed up and if we didn't like it we didn't have to come back. Don't worry--we will never go back! Who needs to get food poisoning! read more