We've eaten here a few times and I felt the need to leave a glowing review. Every time the servers are attentive and friendly. The food is always on par. For appetizer we shared Frutta Di Mare appetizer. The fish salad was extremely fresh, light and tasty. Before our entrees, we received tasty house salads. For entrees we had the Flounder Oreganata and Veal Tuscano. The portions were perfect with even enough to take home leftovers. read more

Michaelangelo's Southold - Flounder Oreganata- the fish was fresh and plentiful. The sauce was so good even the non bread eaters had to dip pieces in to taste. - Italian Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

7/20/25 We have been here many times since my last review, but I decided it was time to give them another review. I opted for the flounder franchise which was very fresh and flavorful served with a side of spaghetti and garlic and oil. Hubby opted for the cavatelli bolognese. We both enjoyed our dinner very much. read more

See all

Food (pizza and salad) were great. Service was awful. Asked for plates and didn't receive them until asked 2x and went up to the counter.

Just left the restaurant, about two and half hours later. We went there without a reservation on a Saturday night and we appreciated being seated (larger party, 6 people). After that, though, service was painfully slow at every point. 20 minutes for drinks, no check-in, ate about two hours after sitting. Also didn't bring second round of drinks and messed up my order. I would have understood if they simply apologized but their poor service was just never even acknowledged- let alone a free beer or dessert to make up for it. Sorry, never going back and will tell everyone I know to avoid it. read more

Stopped here for some pizza before going to the vineyards . We decided on a pie with half sausage well done. It was cooked to perfection and it wasn't greasy at all. It was delicious! I even ate the crust which something I never do! Service was friendly too. Our waiting time for a full pie was not long at all, and it was made fresh. There is some seating inside and a good amount of tables outside. For the pie and two sodas it came to $28, which is not bad at all. My boyfriend and I agreed that we will be stopping here more often. read more

Michaelangelo's Southold - People don't know that the phone eats first... - Italian Near Me - Southold, New York

We had an outstanding gourmet dinner. we ordered the flounder. The portions were great. The waitstaff was spot on and friendly.

Take out pizza last night, two pizzas, cheese and sausage. $55. The crust is way too thick and spongy, should be much thinner and crispy for New York style pizza. This is not Kansas City. I'm not going back here. We can make better pizza at our house. read more

I stop here frequently either before or after my visit to vineyards. Sometimes we pick up a pie or two and head on out, sometimes a few slices in the way back. For Long Island it's good pizza. It's not NYC pizza but it's good. The specialty slices are stacked with goodness. Definitely worth stopping by. read more

Michaelangelo's Southold - Spicy chicken and margarita slice. - Italian Near Me - Southold, New York

Their hours on Sunday are supposed to be until 10 PM. But apparently, if the owner decides they feel like closing up early, you get to go without dinner, because they don't have any consideration for their scheduled hours, they just work whenever they feel like it read more

We went there last Sunday 8/17/25. we ordered immediately, served our salad. we waited 1 hour & 10 minutes and never had dinner. The staff apologized that the kitchen had a lot of order and was very busy. I noticed that there wasn't any dinners coming out. There were salads & deserts which the wait staff serves. We we're very disappointed. read more

And the search continues still the very best vegetable slice. I've had anywhere. And I've looked and I've tried and I've looked and I've tried. No one comes close to their vegetable slice! read more

I recently came here for a nice dinner and some great pizza that I had heard of. The staff were quick to get us seated as I had made a reservation prior to coming. The inside of this place is very nice and not very crowded in terms of tables. They have a bar and a very cozy outdoor area as well. The wait staff were okay because despite there being a good amount, the service was slow at first. The place was also not that crowded. Despite this, I was very impressed with the initial bread basket that they gave us as it included several garlic knots! This was a pleasant surprise. We ordered some entrees and they came pretty quickly. This food was very delicious and definitely lived up to all the hype. We also ordered another bread basket. For dessert, the waitress told us the options, but we were not ready and needed a few minutes to decide. Half an hour later the waitress returned to get our order. The dessert was mediocre at best. My cake was fairly dry, but the cannoli was pretty good. Overall, the experience was good although being kind of drawn out near the end. I would definitely recommend this place to visitors if you are in the area. This place is a chain so there are other locations as well. read more

See all

The food is absolutely wonderful. We've been there about a dozen times and have enjoyed every meal.

Yummy food, comfortable outdoor seating, nice servers, had a nice dinner here and would gladly come back. read more

Michaelangelo's Southold - Italian Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

Food is great, the 3.99% markup for credit cards is pretty heavy. Otherwise we were happy. read more

Michaelangelo's Southold - 3.99% markup to pay with a credit card. - Italian Near Me - Southold, New York

Excellent Chix Parm and healthy pour cocktails. Service was attentive and friendly. Nuff Said! Say hi to Tony. read more

Consistently good food. Great service. Reasonably priced. Locals know how wonderful this place is.

Had a really delicious meal. Not only that but Vegan too. Great Service all around. A very pleasant place. So nice to find a place open Sunday night off season. read more

Tried them again after last year's bad experience only because another couple requested that we have dinner there. OK, I like to give restaurants another chance since maybe it was an off night. Well some things did improve. Service was excellent. Friendly staff was on top of things but not intrusive. The big problem I had was the food and the popular 4% credit card fee. I had a veal dish which was tasteless and chewy. I did enjoy the bread and complimentary bruschetta but did not appreciate the 4% credit card fee. If the statement by the owner that "all the other North Fork restaurants do this" according to another yelp reviewer than he is a liar. I have never been charged a 4% credit card fee for dinner. Ciao Michaelangelo's of Southold. There are so many better alternatives on the North Fork and you don't have to worry about sneaky fees. read more

Real New York pizza! What can I say- amazing!! Order by the slice or a whole pie. They also have a full restaurant with Italian dishes. Hot and delicious! read more

Michaelangelo's Southold - Large pepperoni pie - Italian Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

Our waiter was very nice, however, it took forever to get our food and my spaghetti and meatballs (which were undercooked and pasty) tasted like chefboyardee. On top of that there was a bunch of penne in my brothers rigatoni dish, the calamari was rubbery and everything tasted like it was frozen and pre packaged...8 years ago I came to Michaelangelos for my grandmas birthday and they served me and my brother burnt pizza pops...this place hasn't gotten any better. read more

Painful... the hostess' clearly don't have a grasp on the job role... after being told there was a 15 min wait they gave away our table by accident, what a mess of using system they are using.. then after waiting an extended time for an outdoor table we were seated inside as a result, , where we were served the saddest and most sloppy serving of calamari, "soggy, under cooked & without cherry peppers even thought they were listed in The description ", the experience was so lacking, I'm annoyed that we actually wasted our night out on this place, the only saving grace was my kids liked the pizza .... I'd say Skip it ! read more

I've been coming here for years. I have had many experiences here and I've spent a to of money Over the years. I've had some good experiences and some bad but I know the restaurant Business is hard so I'm understanding but this last time was the last straw for me and my whole family. I went in and ordered a large Cesar salad with chicken, a small soup 2 slices of pizza and roll. The bill was crazy so i looked at the receipt and they charged me $30 for lettuce that had Parmesan cheese sprinkled on it and a few croutons and old hard chicken. And I'm not exaggerating. I tried to feed the chicken to my little dogs and they walked away. I don't mind paying top dollar for quality food but this was a complete insult! It's lettuce and not even a lot of it. I was charged $14 for a pint of soup. It was cold and gross. I had no idea it was $14. Usually soup is $7 but it was a "special" even though that's not what I asked for. The pizza was ice cold and soggy and and everything was just disgusting. I was very upset that this establishment had fallen so far from where they used to be. The woman behind the counter was very unhelpful. I figured I would talk to the manager the next day and she said the salad shouldn't have been $30 but never offered to replace any of it or make good on any of it. $80 worth of food in the garbage. Nothing to salvage since my dogs wouldn't even eat the chicken. It was late so I wound up going to 7/11 to buy some sandwiches and yogurt. This is very disappointing and hesitated writing this review but in the end I have them multiple chances and they deserve this review. read more

i wish i could put zero stars we ordered 2 slices of pizza (one slice per person) and they came on one plate. when we asked for a second plate they handed us a strangely shaped plate. we sat i the back of the restaurant so we were expecting some free bread with out meal. spoiler alert: NO FREE BREAD!! we even saw neighboring tables receive free bread. wifi is super slow. considering there is terrible service in the surrounding area, i was expecting something that would load. read more

this place sucks. wouldnt give us our bread and the wifi is horrible. they gave us 1 plate with 2 pizza's for obviously 3 people. what sense does that make? cheap and affordable read more

Great pizza , i recommend the Northern margarita - fresh tomatoes, pesto and cheese. Prices were good and you can get lots More than just pizza but the selection of pies is large read more

The pizza here is really good. I do takeout for lunch often... or I did. So the guys behind the counter wear their masks over their chin. I asked them to please cover their mouths and noses, at least for my two slices. (The women are wearing masks, the guys are oppositional). The older guy starts on a rant 'you know they said the masks don't work', belted that at me several times. 'They' being who? Fox News? NYS rates are down because of masks, that's science and it's saved lives, including his. So if you want Covid get your pizza here. Loved this place but not going back until they get their attitude in line with facts and the law. read more

Still one of the best year after year. In addition to being weekly regulars here, my wife and I have had our rehearsal dinner and our daughters christening lunch at Michelangelo's and had them cater (off premises) our engagement party and a 50th birthday party. Tony, Amy, and the staff do a fantastic job! read more

Michaelangelo's Southold - Italian Near Me - Southold, New York

Terrible service. Ordered ahead and the food wasn't ready. When I got "some" of the food I ordered, it was cold. They didn't even have the garlic knots ready that I ordered. They even admitted that they made a mistake and did nothing about it. Shame on them horrible business. DO NOT GO. read more

The best place ever. They take care of everyone the food is great but the servers are amazing. We love this restaurant. Lauren is the best

We were there last night. With a reservation we were seated promptly. We then waited about 20 minutes for water and bread. Our waitress arrived about 40 minutes after we were seated. Our food arrived at least 30 minutes later. My wife's dinner was great she had the salmon and was pleased with it. I sadly had the veal Marsala. The veal was tough the gravy tasteless. Then to top it off they added an extra glass of wine to our bill which required two employees to correct. Not likely we would return here. read more

This is a local place that has a very nice veneer ( attractive interior and outdoor seating ) but is lacking in some areas. We got the calamari -- pretty good, generous helping and pizza ( quite a disappointment, especially since we intended to have 1943 Pizza but they were closed ). We have had their soups for take out and they are pretty good. Salads as a meal a disappointment. My pet peeve--- when I am charged a fee, especially at a restaurant, for using my credit card!! This is an established restaurant that has no need but to be greedy to charge this fee. Unfortunately, the waitress suffered tonight because the fee was deducted from our intended tip. Maybe that's why you still have a Help Wanted sign outside. read more

The best place ever. They take care of everyone the food is great but the servers are amazing. We love this restaurant. Lauren is the best

I am sorry but don't order from here you will never get what you ordered and the food l that you get is horrible

Reason number 7million that I love my wife. Just spent $65 on two take out dishes from this albatross of an Italian restaurant. My chicken Marsala had two pieces of chicken that were so small that I could finish my entire dinner in 6 bites. The Marsala sauce was brown, tasteless water. My wife's clam sauce was loaded with sand and sitting in white, tasteless water. I know all the amazing reasons we choose to live on the NOFO but the Italian food choices are no longer one of them. Up-island has competition. If you have 16 Italian restaurants all within driving distance of each other you're going to be forced to step up your game or be vanquished. Michaelangelos if you're listening, you no longer exist to me. How you let these dishes leave the kitchen is beyond comprehension. Perhaps it's time to change the sign outside and remove the words "Italian restaurant " if you can't make two of the simplest dishes on this planet than perhaps it's time to simple adjust the sign outside as to not also be in the false advertising business since making good food is clearly not your specialty either. My wife just went into the kitchen and made two new sauces from scratch which saved the day. That's reason #7 million. This is my first review ever, and I hate people that write reviews. That's how bad the food was tonight. Michaelangelos, please start pretending that you're actually in a competitive market where quality is what allows you to be successful rather than the closest other option being 40mins away. ps - Laura is an absolute rockstar so front of the house staff is lights out.. whoever is doing the cooking there's always papa John's read more

Poor service, go to another restaurant waited over 30 minutes for our drinks, waitress forgot we ordered an appetizer, brought it out after we said something and the $20 bake clams were ice cold. When we asked to speak to a manager, we found out our waitress was the manager and instead of coming to see what was going on, she sent other servers out with our order, we refused the order until she came to the table. We where lucky enough to find the owner, who had an aggressive tone and didn't make it right and said it's a holiday week end and they can't go to every table. Other restaurant can use your business, they really don't want it. read more

Some of the best Italian food on the North Fork, simple as that. As locals, we come here quite a bit. Whether it's a planned night out or something in passing, the food is always delicious. read more

We will never be back. We made a reservation for 6:15pm and were seated on time. At 8:00pm I approached a man who I later found out was the owner to request our food, that we still hadn't received to be wrapped up. I kindly explained that I couldn't wait any longer, my two children were basically sleeping at the table. He then decided to try and justify that it was MY fault because I ordered an appetizer. He argued multiple Points that I shouldn't have ordered an appetizer, don't I know that that extends my dining time. My children ordered chicken fingers and raviolis, I don't believe they take 2 hours to prepare. Our food was wrapped as asked and was mediocre at best. Bland. Poorly cooked, a true disappointment. I hope this helps the next family to not waste their time and money. read more

If you are looking for a friendly atmosphere and good Italian food this is the place!! Love their garlic knot basket and their portions are so big i always go home with leftovers. Love that its all family running it too. read more

The owner actually got on the phone and argued with me over 25 dollars. One of the dinners They gave us was chicken parm instead of shrimp parm. I told him I'd like a credit for our next visit. And I'd bring him the un eaten dinner the next day as it was late and at this point our dinner was already ruined on a Saturday night. He said you have to come back RIGHT now at 9pm because I know I gave you shrimp for one of the dinners not chicken. We live in greenport. And we will never order from them again. Disgusting that the OWNER got on the phone and this was his customer service response. AND the chicken parm was dry and overcooked my husband said as I don't eat meat. read more