Really cool pizza spot tucked away off the main strip in Greenport. Its warm and inviting…read moreatmosphere with the brick oven is probably the best pizza spot in town! I would've loved to stay for dine-in but had to bring lunch back to our Airbnb. The pizza only took a few minutes to cook. And it was up there in delicious-ness with some of the best NYC pizza! Perfectly thin, crispy crust without being dry, overcooked or burnt. The cheese and sauce had perfect balance of salt and tang, and not dry, not too greasy either. Toppings were fresh and just the right amount of toppings so it wasn't too heavy and not stingy either.

Food and service are great. Innovative salads and pizzas, great wait staff, etc. very accommodating…read moreand comfortable.

Was there after 8pm and was told no more whole pie orders so picked from what was available…read more Anyway, we only wanted slices for a quick bite. Liked the crust, thin but not soggy. Cheese toppings on the white pizza was kind of dry. Slices are around $4-4.75 each. Tables on one side, counter/stools on the other.

Super yummy pizza! They are open until 10pm which is great…read more Our original game plan was to get Mexican but after the insanely long wait 2 doors down we decided to bring pizza in. We had cheese, pepperoni, a spicy pepperoni and a sausage one. They were all fabulous and yummy. Will def be returning next time we're in town :)

There is nothing better than New York pizza. I was thrilled to be able to get a slice while on Long…read moreIsland. La Capricciosa Pizza was a great choice. The pizza came out hot and it was delicious. They had several options to choose from so we all got what we wanted. No complaints from the group. We were all happy. Thank you!

Decent spot for a slice. They come out pretty quick. I had the spinach artichoke and it was good…read morenot great, the marg was the best one we had.

Firehouse was sold a few years ago.. Original proprietor and fire truck long gone…read more Seems to be a hybrid of a new owners pizza shop and other options. Went in saw cold thin slices and left. Rarely see cars. To bring back Firehouse Pizza, bring in a real deal Pizza maker.

The opposite of Long Island/ New York Pizza…read more It used to be good, but it sold to new owners a while back that dont know how to make good pizza Got 2 plain slices and they were hard and bland; no taste

Love the gluten free options for my husband! When you walk in, it feels like a family reunion with…read morehow comfortable they make you feel.

So much hype around this place and fell flat for me…read more Maybe because it was before closing around 8:15, the quality that I was expecting from pics of the meatball pie was not the same. I saw big slices of meatball all over pie earlier when walking by and in the pictures, what I got was like crushed up all in the center and very floppy/sloppy soupy... was falling apart The taste and ingredients were def good but not my kinda pie I guess. Just more disappointed that I didn't get what looked to be amazing walker and why I went in the first place. I felt like I got the end of the night scraps

Warning. Big change…read moreafter new owners took over the once reliable Pizza Place three years ago. One of the slices smelled way too fishy too eat for a calamari slice. Brought in to let them know. The som of the owner hid sheepishly by the ovens and .the manager came over to tell me he wouldn't exchange. They took it and Threw it out but no exchange or refund. Be warned. Food service requires trust that management will keep things fresh and stand behind their foos. Not here. Not meant to be in food service. Pies LOOKED good but Calamari was clearly not fresh and come to think of it the cheese seemed a little too white like some melting spread. There were lots of refrigerated rolls not selling but kept in the case. Pies were moving and tasted ok but would NOT return.

This place has a pizza oven but it is not pizza they are serving. Not even close and not good at…read moreall. I stopped here on my way out east for a slice and received an extremely hot slice of poorly prepared, cheap ingredients with an over abundance of flour. I had asked that the slices be just warmed, so my young daughter could eat it and the man nodded, and sent out these boiling hot slices. Also, I did not feel welcome here at all. I received no smiles from anyone, no hello, no goodbye or even a thank you for coming. Not recommended.

Me and my hubby went today for lunch,The food and the service was excellent!!! Everyone was so nice…read moreand friendly and the food was so fresh and delicious I had the sausage and peppers pizza Such a beautiful view outside too with the pond and the ducks would definitely recommend!!

Never again. I never cared for this place too much growing up and I can't even less for it now…read more You're better off picking up a frozen pizza at the grocery store.. Very bready pizza, unremarkable sauce. Can't be bothered to throw in a side of marinara sauce with their garlic knots. Their pizza and their heroes are just slopped with a tasteless mozzarella. Meatball hero? Was there any meat in their at all? Consistency tasted of mostly bread crumbs. No thanks. 6 knots, meatball hero, chicken Parm hero, regular pie, half pepperoni $62 Really nice staff though and great parking.

Best pizza on Long Island by far ,Super nice and friendly staff.Nice spot to sit and have a amazing…read moreslice

How is the electric bike? Your priority should be the pizzeria. Invest just a little money into…read morethe restaurant. It's been a few years and the bathroom still looks like this. I must edit this review. Tired old red and white checkered vinyl tablecloths have been replaced with green and white checkered tablecloths. I will ignore the dead bugs on the windowsills and the baseboards which needed replacing last decade. Still two stars because the food hasn't killed me yet.