Crust Around The Corner

0

73

50

2 months ago

Oh yes, this place is a total gem! The crust is that perfect balance of thin and crusty (aka; "undercarriage ") that we all crave, with real cheese that doesn't leave a puddle on the plate. Joe, the owner, couldn't be nicer and helps create a warm and welcoming vibe to one of my favorite pizzerias on Long Island! Plenty of parking all cards, highly recommended. A true 7.8 if you're watching Dave. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tommy C.

0

3

1

5 months ago

Who says you can't go home again? After several months of not eating here I decided to get a couple slices. January 2 was the day because they were closed New Years Day. Exactly the same as my last visit. Pizza was soggy, not crispy. Needed two hands and a fork because the cheese and toppings slid off the slice as soon as I picked it up. Garbage by the front door full, bathroom garbage pail overflowing. Same tired, dirty baseboards and a bathroom I can't even describe. Using a Porta Potty at a construction site would be more appealing. To the owner, why bother owning a business if you're not going to take pride in it? read more

Crust Around The Corner - 4:45 AM. Too difficult to turn the OPEN sign off? - Pizza Near Me - East Moriches, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joelc73 ..

1

67

0

3 months ago

Had a cheese pie and it was fine. Not life changing nor terrible. Fine for a quick slice when you don't feel like driving further.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

George W.

0

22

16

4 months ago

delicious pete za. super fresh, saw joe himself whipping that dough around and around. speaking of joe, he's a blessing to this earth--so fun and sweet def chat it up with him. 20 bucks for a crispy pie and top tier hospitality. highly recommend, i will be back. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rhiannon K.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Crust has the best pizza around. Their dough is home-made just like their delicious sauce! Too many places on Long Island use large-scale production pizza dough and generic sauce these days, and it just doesn't taste as good as it used to. They're still doing it the right way at Crust. The owner and his daughter are so kind and welcoming, it's really nice to go into a local place and be treated like a neighbor instead of a stranger. They're always cooking up something special, and definitely don't miss out on their milkshakes (the Oreo is the best)!!! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 2

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Colleen F.

0

3

0

2 years ago

Love popping into Crust on a weeknight! The employees are so friendly and welcoming, always feel like family. The pizza crust is the best around and my daughter absolutely LOVES the garlic knots. I order delivery from them on occasion and the delivery is always prompt and with a big friendly smile! Definitely recommend! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 2

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Hector M.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Have been there quite a few times, and there pizza or food is awesome. The owner, plus the new guy that is there are great. Everyone should try this place you won't be disappointed. Keep up the good work guys read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 2

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Alison A.

20

201

353

4 years ago

Sorry I was busy to take pictures. Yesterday was my son's third birthday and all he wanted was pepperoni pizza. I promised him we would be able to make it together, I always make the pizza and the Stromboli homemade for birthdays especially. Unfortunately, my son's newborn sister kept me up most of the night. We decided to try this restaurant for pizza. I called up explaining when I needed the delivery to be in time for the guests and they delivered exactly when I asked. I ordered one pepperoni pizza, half plain/Half mushroom pizza, pepperoni Stromboli, mozzarella sticks, and garlic bread. Everything arrived hot. Very good pizza and delicious crust. Thank you for saving the day! (Also, very friendly man helped me place my order and decide what to get) read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Scott S.

0

2

1

2 years ago

Finally! they got rid of the pizza pirate!!!! Best friendliest pizza spot in town!!! gentleman makin the pizza now is a propie man!!! and finally on toogoodtogo! keep it up! Honey garlic chicken slice!!!!! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Karin R.

11

29

7

2 years ago

It's really a shame because the pizza here is excellent -- but the service can be god awful especially after an experience I just had. I came in wanting a pie with a special message spelled out in toppings. Not only was the man behind the counter extremely gruff, rude and careless with a nasty attitude, but the pizza came out absolutely terrible. So much so, that I had to go elsewhere to get what I needed, and not only was a treated amazingly by the other place, but their pizza was also great. This man at Crust put a damp cloud over a happy occasion and should really be ashamed of the way he conducted himself. Really is unfortunate because like I said, the pizza is great, but this experience caused them to definitely lose our business. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 2

Tracy K.

4996

1225

3576

8 years ago

Small town east end Pizza shop that makes standard and creative Pizza. When I stopped in I saw trays of just made meatballs cooling in the back and gave a hero a try. While waiting the owner cut a slice of their garlic knot slice pizza in two and gave them to me to try and bring one out for my friend waiting in the car. Lots of delicious flavor on what was a nice crispy chewy crust. They are really good at old fashioned Italian style Pizza & Heros. Generous with ingredients & hospitality. That's Italian! Stop in and try this nice local place. read more

Crust Around The Corner - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - East Moriches, New York

Crust Around The Corner - two slices of pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Moriches, New York

Crust Around The Corner - two hot dogs in a tin - Pizza Near Me - East Moriches, New York

Crust Around The Corner - Pizza Near Me - East Moriches, New York

See all

Helpful 9

Thanks 0

Love this 9

Oh no 0

Dj M.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Iv been coming to Crust Around The Corner for years . They always deliver a warm, inviting atmosphere paired with outstanding service and delicious food. If you're looking for a place where you can relax with family and friends over a wonderful pizza, this gem truly fits the bill. I highly recommend giving them a visit! You'll not only leave with a satisfied appetite but also with a smile, thanks to the friendly faces that make this family-run establishment so special. A+ A+ A+ read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Logan L.

0

5

3

2 years ago

The food was quite delectable and exquisitely tasteful. My tastebuds were like they were dancing with the love of their life. read more

Crust Around The Corner - a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Moriches, New York

Crust Around The Corner - a deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Moriches, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Erica W.

Elite 19

91

233

556

8 years ago

Finally, thin pizza that's not afraid to leave the bubbles in the dough! I think the sauce was a little lacking in salt but overall very very good. We ordered a pizza, wings, and knots delivered on super bowl Sunday. The wings and knots were PERFECT. Seriously wasn't expecting that. The garlic knots were crisp on the outside and fluffy/chewy on the inside. And the wings were crisp and flavorful. I'm always iffy about wings from pizza places but these were fantastic. The service was great too. The woman on the phone was very sweet and patient, and the food took not much more than a half hour to get here. read more

Helpful 5

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rob P.

125

289

644

7 years ago

Good average pizza. Clean, friendly atmosphere & very fair prices. The sauce had a nice taste but could of used a bit more on the pizza. The crust & underside of the pizza was a slightly thicker & more bread-like than I prefer. I know 3 stars can be perceived to be good or bad but I'd lean to the good side for this one. read more

Crust Around The Corner - Cheese - Pizza Near Me - East Moriches, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Justin G.

0

1

0

2 years ago

I hired them for catering an engagement party. They showed up on time with all the food. The trays were still hot when they showed up. The chicken Francese was really good and we had them make the big chocolate chip cookies and they went so fast I was only able to get one. I would definitely use them again. Long story short good food good service good cookies. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Deanna E.

0

1

0

2 years ago

I came here having to go to bathroom. After driving for a while. I was polite and did nothing wrong to the girl behind the counter. She was so rude. I asked "do you have a bathroom and can I use it." She says "no it's for customers only and says there's other places you can use." (In a snarky way) then I said okay I really have to go can you tell Me where these places are? And With the nastiest attitude and rolling her eyes at me she says"There's 4 other stores in this parking lot use one of them." I said okay thank you have a good day. She says nothing and rolls her eyes at me again. ( I prefer to be kind to nasty people maybe they'll see the error of there ways) In the parking lot there is a florist a hairdresser and that's pretty much it. So most people will choose the food place to ask first. I would assume. All I did was ask to use the bathroom. If this is how she treats people asking a simple question I can imagine how many people she's nasty to. She's in customer service you are suppose to be nice to everyone. Especially when they did nothing to you. This could be the best pizza in the world and I would never go here simply because it's an uncomfortable experience. They lost a future customer. It's a shame. I'm not sure what I did to deserve such negative treatment but I sure won't ever go near this place again. And I'm not mad at all that I wasn't aloud to use the bathroom, that's the establishments right to only allow customers to use the bathroom. I'm upset that this girl treated me poorly. A simple sorry customers only would have sufficed. And I would have said okay thank you and moved on. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Marxbry M.

0

5

0

3 years ago

One of the worst pizzas I've had in a loooong time. So bad that when you open the box you wish you picked up a frozen pizza while you were at Whole Foods instead of ordering from here. One star because the place is still new and nice inside read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Andrea B.

0

11

3

6 years ago

Super friendly atmosphere. Sauntered over here while just driving around my new home & had the most delicious sausage, pepperoni and spinach slice. Healthy enough for me ;) Definitely stop in ! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dennis A.

0

20

1

6 years ago

I recently moved out here. Ive tried a few places. Most were good but I have to say Crust Around the corner is my fave. Awsome crust, delicious sauce. Highly recommend. Stromboli is awsome too. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

George M.

0

23

32

8 years ago

This is only the second time trying this new pizza joint. First time, after it had just open, left me not needing to get back there anytime soon. I decided to give them another try after a friend had said their pies have improved and I'm happy for the tip! I got a large cheese pie and asked the crust to be cooked well done. Nice big bubbles, crust was thin and crispy, pleasant tasting sauce and cheese. Oh yeah, and a couple dollars cheaper than the other options around town. I will branch out to try their other styles and toppings slowly. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Garret Y.

10

20

2

7 years ago

First time coming and WON'T be my last. The atmosphere was amazing. I ordered the margarita pizza which was to die for. It's not like other places so keep that in mind BUT it was delicious. By far the best pizza place I've ate in awhile. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael R.

65

17

0

8 years ago

Underrated pizza place. I always say you can judge a pizza place by their plain slice and they have a really good one. With all the floppy crusts around (especially when taking out) this time place stands out and is true to its name. GREAT CRUST! Really nice owners too. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Jack W.

0

1

0

2 years ago

everytime I've gone in the dude missing a leg behind the front is nothing but rude, + the pizza is over priced too. im sitting here eating from my last purchase ever with them. the pizza is cold and we only just picked it up a few minutes ago. + it's extremely small, almost looks like someone cut the middle out of it. constantly extremely disappointed and will not be trying again. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Feed M E.

19

22

0

9 years ago

Ordered the "Standard" 2 regular slices and a medium Diet Pepsi. $7.33 The things I look for: A crisp crust........Check Enough Cheese...well, ok Enough Sauce......well, ok Taste.....................Mmmm there wasn't any. I like a Sicilian slice once in a while, however first thing I notice that was very sparse of cheese. There are two other places not to far away. Much Much better. One has the "Standard" for $5.00. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Sunita S.

Elite 23

107

289

205

6 years ago

Ugh, ordered a grandma and a margherita pizza. I don't know where they learned to make pizza, but raw tomato and thick slices of unbaked mozzarella don't belong anywhere on either one of these pizzas. I will definitely not go back here. The pizza is some weird concoction of bread and sauce, that's not pizza sauce, that tey call pizza. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Karen W.

20

187

308

9 years ago

I went in to have a couple of slices after getting my hair done. Clean and friendly staff. Great place for lunch and they deliver. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Den P.

5

124

21

8 years ago

This is my new go to pizzeria in the Center/East Moriches area. They are super friendly and make excellent pizza and food. We especially love the pizza patio nights in the summer. If you haven't hit this spot yet you should, especially since Alitalia has changed owners and the pizza and sauce are different(not in a good way)! read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

William W.

0

4

0

6 years ago

Awesome family and staff there with sweet tasty food always ready for a bite. Always remember my face when I come in for their superb Grandma pizza, and tasty garlic knots. Their sauce is superb and make the pizza a great delight to devour! Big Fan! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mary Lou C.

121

42

3

6 years ago

This is without a doubt THE BEST PIZZA on Long Island! The crust is thin and crispy. Yum! The sauce is delicious and the amount of cheese is perfect! As an aside, the owner is just friendly and adorable! This is a restaurant for the whole family or for an evening out for 2. Don't make the mistake of passing this place up. Can I add 10 stars? well I guess that I can. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sherry C.

0

2

0

9 years ago

Great pizza and excellent meals! Owners; friendly and accommodating! Service with a smile! Definitely a must. So glad I found this restaurant! Delicious read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

James G.

0

1

7 years ago

I'm born and raised in a Sicilian family. Hands down, this is the best Bruschetta pie on Long Island. The ingredients are super fresh, red onion, basil, garlic, vinaigrette dressing and fresh mozzarella. This is our FAVORITE pie ! We also order regular pies all the time which are also delicious ! They deliver promptly and always are pleasant. Love this place ! read more

Crust Around The Corner - Bruschetta pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Moriches, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dennis P.

3

94

6

7 years ago

Ordered delivery at 7:43pm. Got a call back at 8:15 pm saying the order was cancelled because the restaurant was closing soon. What a terrible way to do business. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Jayel S.

119

58

14

9 years ago

So happy this place opened near us! The pizza is excellent and so are the rice balls! Our new go to pizzeria, we probably order once a week or so, and the quality is consistent and delicious. Fast delivery as well read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joseph M.

34

79

1

9 years ago

Enjoyed the Grandma Pizza. Great Sauce and perfect dough. Tasted homemade. Owner and Staff family friendly.

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rappin Rodney M.

297

233

14

9 years ago

Very good pizza, great service , family run and delivery !!!!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jerey C.

87

3

0

6 years ago

The customer service was okay walked in they said hello then nobody acknowledged me with a "will be right with you" so I sat there for a few more minutes. The pizza was okay nothing special and the knots were shaped more like balls. Might be worth it to some but I personally won't be coming back. Also the owner was yelling at somebody for being late, definitely not the right approach in front of your customers. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Bruce C.

8

69

0

9 years ago

They have really great pizza, thin crust great sauce, they don't used the salty cheese. There pizza is as good if not better then anybody else in the area. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Susan K.

0

20

0

7 years ago

Many better pizza places around Center Moriches area but nice people and friendly atmosphere. Slices sold are old and often not edible anymore. Full fresh pie are average. Good location easy in and out. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kristen W.

Elite 17

41

63

8

9 years ago

Wow, is the pizza here DELICIOUS! If I was brave enough to climb on my roof, I'd shout it from the rooftop. Crust: check, cheese: check, sauce: check, seasoning: check. Pizza is my favorite thing to eat so I take my pizza eating an reviews seriously. This place is a home run. Why are you still reading this and not ordering a pizza from Crust Around the Corner? read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 2

See more reviews

More info about Crust Around The Corner

345 Montauk Hwy
Ste E
East Moriches, NY 11940
Directions
(631) 400-9955
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order

Full menu

Hours

What time does Crust Around The Corner open?

Crust Around The Corner opens at 11:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Crust Around The Corner close?

Crust Around The Corner closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Crust Around The Corner take Bitcoin?

No, Crust Around The Corner does not take Bitcoin.

Does Crust Around The Corner take credit cards?

Yes, Crust Around The Corner takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Crust Around The Corner have catering options?

Yes, Crust Around The Corner does have catering options.

Does Crust Around The Corner serve alcohol?

Yes, Crust Around The Corner serves alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Crust Around The Corner allow dogs?

No, Crust Around The Corner does not allow dogs.

Does Crust Around The Corner have TVs?

Yes, Crust Around The Corner has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Crust Around The Corner have bike parking?

Yes, Crust Around The Corner has bike parking.

Does Crust Around The Corner have outdoor seating?

Yes, Crust Around The Corner has outdoor seating options.

Does Crust Around The Corner have parking?

Yes, Crust Around The Corner has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Crust Around The Corner wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Crust Around The Corner is wheelchair accessible.

Does Crust Around The Corner have free WiFi?

Yes, Crust Around The Corner has free WiFi.

From the Business

History

Established in 2016.

Stop in and I'll tell you all about it.

Review Highlights - Crust Around The Corner

“Joe, the owner, couldn't be nicer and helps create a warm and welcoming vibe to one of my favorite pizzerias on Long Island!”

Mentioned in 4 reviews

You might also consider

ITA Kitchen East Moriches

3.3(90 reviews)

1.3 mi

Date night with my husband, and we decided to come here as we had a gift card. Area outside was…read morevery spacious and open with heaters to keep us warm. View of water was nice, and even better nice sunset. Service was excellent, we had a very attentive waitress. Did not have to wait too long for our food. We ended up doing all specials. We shared the seafood stuffed mushrooms as an appetizer. For dinner my husband had the pasta with sausage and broccoli rabe. I had the halibut with shrimp. Both delicious. Somehow we had room for dessert. We ordered the RAINBOW COOKIE ICE CREAM SUNDAE for two. When that arrived, our jaws dropped. Thing was huge. More than enough for two people. And so dangerously good. This place was a drive for us but I would come back again for a special occasion.

This was a special treat in more ways than one. First I never heard of this restaurant so when we…read morearrived it really piqued my interest. Back up one step. My children took us here for our anniversary and refused to tell us before hand the name of the restaurant. So getting to it is a long drive down a road with gated homes until you reach the end and a waterfront restaurant. My daughter made the reservation and for us to sit on the patio. At first I was concerned because it has been very hot lately and the sun was strong. Well have no fear. Tables have large umbrellas and early evening gave us a gentle breeze. Okay the food: we all had something different and everyone mentioned how good it was. Another step back... They have valet parking which set the perfect mood for me. So my wife had chicken parm. Please forgive her. Not that it wasn't good, but a waterfront restaurant specializing in seafood. Come on my love. I had flounder encrusted with lobster. Beyond heavenly. Oh yes we shared baked clams. OMG. We usually judge a new restaurant by their baked clams and these were on point. The bill: I have no idea. My kids paid . It brought me to tears. When we have dinner out with the kids I always pay so this made me delirious. Finally the views. Spectacular just spectacular. Yes I recommend ITA and I will definitely by back. Unfortunately I'll be paying but it will be worth it.

Inside

NOT FROM ITA, GO TO BREWOLOGY IN SPEONK

See all

La Volpe Ristorante

4.0(34 reviews)

2.4 mi

La Volpe is the standard for traditional southern Italian cuisine. There is nothing they don't do…read morewell here. You don't come here to pinch Pennie's, you come here to immerse and indulge. Fried Calamari with zucchini is melt-in-your-mouth tender, brick oven pizza's are BETTER than Rome. Fillet Mignon Au Poivre is the best I've ever had, as is the Branzino! But my favorite is the Chicken Dijonaise. It's been on the menu for over 25 years for a reason! Cocktails are expertly prepared, and the service is professional. If you have to wait a bit for your food to come out, that's a good thing! Sit, chill, put your phone down and enjoy your family. Have a conversation, and let them cook. Bravo, (as usual) La Volpe!

One of the worst dining experiences we've had in a very long time…read more My family has been coming to this restaurant for 20 years since they opened and before this, to Anton's when they were just a small pizzeria in the King Kullen shopping center. We've celebrated holidays here, hosted parties here, and have always spoken highly of it--which made this experience even more disappointing. We took my mother out for Mother's Day shortly after my father passed away, hoping for a nice family meal. Instead, we were treated terribly from start to finish. We were seated late at a cramped table for three, despite having a reservation. Our server, J***, didn't check on us the entire evening. She didn't tell us the specials until we specifically asked, and then responded sarcastically with, "Oh, you want to hear the specials?" It took an hour just to receive appetizers, and no server initially came over to take our order until we spoke to the mother of the owners, who we didn't see at all. My husband and I would always talk to one of the brothers. We waited excessively for simple things like sweetener and iced tea. At one point, a young staff member told us there was no sweetener available at all. It honestly felt like our server may have been pulled from another role just to "help out," because the service was so disorganized. What made it worse was the complete lack of professionalism from the front staff. The two people seating guests looked miserable and unfriendly. It was apparent they were probably family, because they had no qualms about doing their jobs badly. When we raised concerns, one of the two unhappy women--who was extremely cold and dismissive--actually told us that she waits three hours when she goes out to eat, as though that somehow excused our experience. We also noticed staff talking about us, which was incredibly unprofessional and uncomfortable. What was most frustrating was seeing groups of employees standing around while service was clearly falling apart. Being busy is understandable--(it was used as an excuse for everything going wrong), especially on Mother's Day--but after 20 years in business, a restaurant should know how to handle a busy night without everything unraveling. The food was disappointing as well--my veal was tough--and at no point did anyone apologize, offer any gesture of goodwill (not even a complimentary coffee), or acknowledge how poorly our evening had gone. Not even a simple "Happy Mother's Day" or goodbye as we left and we walked right by the cold, dismissive woman. The actual only highlight of our evening was when a wonderful server named Iverson came over to finish up with us, because clearly having to ask our server for sweetener three times forced her to have a possible meltdown? Unfortunately it was way too late, the damage had already been done. Now that's a charming individual, who is great with people! It certainly would have helped make a difference in our experience. This was especially heartbreaking because this restaurant has meant something to our family for years. Sadly, after this experience, we won't be returning. There are too many other restaurants that know how to treat loyal customers with respect.

Beautiful restaurant

Pizza LaVolpe

See all

Michelangelo Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.5(100 reviews)

1.7 mi

I love this place, and their Veal San Martino is my go-to dish!! We've never had a meal there that…read moredidn't fully satisfy over more than a decade. Last night we placed a delivery order for a special occasion and there was a miscommunication on a dish (on both ends). They took care of us immediately and delivered the replacement order by one of the chefs. We usually never make an issue on mishaps, but I just had to this time. Needless to say, they shined in customer service and the food was fantastic. And I learned a lesson: Ask for what you want even if it isn't on the menu instead of trying to shoehorn in a substitution on something else. We love fettuccine carbonara which wasn't listed, but they made an amazing dish that will take 3 meals to finish up! Thank you folks, this is why we choose local family!!

I'm a huge fan of Michelangelo's! Their food is amazing, love the sauce and the portions huge…read more Tonight I had my usual veal parm with was delicious and HUGE!!! My wife had the rigatoni with grilled chicken tomato spinach and evoo. E never have a ness dinner at Michelangelos! Highly recommended!

Original Michelangelo

Burnt pizza

See all

Burnt pizza

Michelangelo of Speonk

Excellent food and big portion. Friendly owner/server. This place is a gem tucked in. GPS was a bit…read moreconfusing but I'm glad I found this place. Wish lived closer

This is one of my favorite kinds of restaurants- a small, old school pizzeria/Italian restaurant…read morethat punches above its weight. Situated in a strip mall, it's easy to miss. The decor is classic pizzeria with painted scenes of Italy on the walls and Italian adjacent music playing. It's uber casual- the diners were clad in shorts and t shirts with some multigenerational families and a stream of regulars. The staff were nice. Our waitress was very earnest. This is the most inexpensive area restaurant that we have eaten in so far. Beers were $5 or $6. We were started off with a couple of delicious, freshly baked rolls. My wife ordered a garden salad that easily could have fed two. I had the pasta special. For $20, it included a small garden salad, an enormous serving of excellent linguine with white clam sauce and a delicious small cannoli. This place is the perfect antidote to expensive, pretentious restaurants. We expect to be regulars.

See all

Anton Pizzeria

4.0(272 reviews)

2.4 mi

The best pizzeria on Long Island in my opinion. Love stopping in for lunch or dinner with the…read morechildren. The staff are always so helpful, there's always a great selection of top quality food, and they are awesome with my children. Can't ask for better! The place is always clean as well. Pictures from previous visits

Great pizza and awesome meatballs Love the service and…read moreeveryone is so nice! The best beet salad and Marsala !

Mushroom ravioli

Garganelli with fresh tuna in a puttanesca like sauce. Delicious!

See all

Mini rice balls

Sea Cove Italian American Bar and Grill

3.0(166 reviews)

1.9 mi

Food & service are excellent Never disappointed whether…read moredining in or take out. Great Family Restaurant Lucky to have them in town

One of the best Italian restaurants around! You'll never be disappointed! Service and ambiance very…read moregood!

See all

Pennachio's

3.8(109 reviews)

4.3 mi

I have no idea how this place has four stars on yelp!…read more I walked in at 6 PM on a Wednesday after a long drive in traffic. There was not a person in the place and the pizza counter options looked so so but I trusted yelp. I ordered a plain slice, which looked OK before it went in the oven and a buffalo chicken slice. When I opened up the box and saw the plain slice I could tell immediately this was not going to be a good pizza. When you can still see the individual shreds of cheese, it is a good sign that it is cheap cheese. The buffalo chicken slice was surprisingly OK but if you can't deliver a plain cheese slice that's enough for me.

Don't eat here. This restaurant serves absolute garbage. The food is awful. Chicken tastes old…read moreand like it's been soaked in vinegar to hide the fact that it's rancid. heroes are a sloppy mess, the bread is falling apart and cut uneven. the sauce tastes like it was made with cinnamon sticks in it. the pizza is all dough and cheese, no sauce. food arrives cold. the owner laughs when you complain.

Cheap quality Cheese and buffalo slice You can tell a place is using fake cheese products when the cheese doesn't melt

Pizza

See all

Garlic knot & mozzarella sticks

Mama Lisa Restaurant

3.8(537 reviews)

5.0 mi

This Is Such A Great Place To Eat ! The Dinners Are So Good And Everything Is Always So Fresh !…read moreThe Scungilli Fradiavolo Is Way Off The Hook With A Touch Of Basil On The Top And The Bread Is Delicious !

What a top notch restaurant. The owner greets you with a smile and a thank you !…read more Our server was Sam and she was terrific. The food was outstanding as usual. Strong. Consistent Solid food. A mastic favorite !!!!

See all

Eggplant parm deliciousness

Bernie's Family Pizzeria

4.2(57 reviews)

3.4 mi

I am so pleasantly surprised with your Pizzeria. A friend of mine, Shawn S highly recommended you…read morefolks and we finally had the opportunity to have some wonderful food delivered. We had a stuffed pizza, regular pie, antipasto salad. Thank you for that feast. Your sauce on your pizza, sweet and perfectly distributed, the salad fresh. Even your delivery person was so pleasant. Thank you. We will always be back!!! Andre'

The chicken rolls at Bernie's are top tier. So delicious! I love how they're soft and filled to the…read moretop with chicken cutlets. Usually places aren't as generous but Bernie's hooks you up. I highly recommend their chicken rolls, especially during happy hour from 12-5PM Monday through Friday. Get yourself a chicken roll and a small fountain drink of your choice for $8, you can't beat that especially with this heat wave, you're going to need it. I also would give their spinach pinwheel a try as well. Sesame seed roll filled with spinach and ricotta. Mouth watering.