We catered the food for a party. The food was excellant as always . We had it delivered and it was right on time .Annette B.

What a top notch restaurant. The owner greets you with a smile and a thank you ! Our server was Sam and she was terrific. The food was outstanding as usual. Strong. Consistent Solid food. A mastic favorite !!!! read more

We had the same disappointing experience as Rob B. and several others. The food arrived cold and was mediocre at best. The owner apologized, but nothing was done to address it. It's just not the same restaurant it was a few years ago. The quality has slipped, and it feels like they've simply stopped caring. read more

Mama Lisa is fantastic!! The food is fresh and the honest take great pride and the quality of their food and preparation also, of course presentation..... date night, a family Sunday meal or just dinner with a friend. This restaurant is definitely a mess. They've been around for 25+ years.... The owners are from Naples. They know what they're doing. Trust me.! The photos below was just lunch!! oh just a quick note the fried calamari is to die for!! read more

See all

I went to this restaurant with six other people we were all very happy with our food choices. The food was absolutely delicious. The waiter and the bus boys were on point. The atmosphere was quite inviting. I can't wait for my next meal at this spectacular Intalian resturant. read more

I asked Mama Lisa to cater my wife's birthday party at a nearby marina. Wow, I was super pleased with the quality and quantity of the food delivered. The mussels marinara was such a treat! Their marinara sauce is no joke! It was good tasty and chunky, and the mussels were apparently hand picked for the dish. Delicious! Other worthy call outs were the broccoli rabe and grilled chicken, then the stuffed shells. Guys and girls, the dock party was a hit, all guests complimenting the food all evening, and I had the pleasure of enjoying leftovers for the next two days. Great, fresh food which arrived hot and delicious. The food makes the party. Great job! read more

Been coming here for years! The service is incredible, the food and sauces are all good. The bar, incredible. Amazing 12/10

Buddhist delicious. The restaurant is very clean. The service is very good. Never had a bad meal there. I would recommend it to everyone.

Was super busy for Mother's Day. I ordered dinner for my mom last minute and the order was done super fast !They gave extra bread which is so nice and I always appreciate. The food was great so it helps a lot when I had to work and couldn't cook myself. The staff is always so nice and very hard working. Thanks!! read more

I think it was pretty good I had the Chicken franchise. It was wonderfully prepared. The ambiance was also super nice at the place lots of people it was very packed and I am glad I stopped by to try them and took food to go. Next time I'll try dining in read more

See all

Pizza is the best local pizza around, much better than most of the Shirley mastic pizza places, quality and taste of the pizza is above all around it read more

Went back recently. It seemed like maybe they were short staffed, although the restaurant wasn't busy. It took 40 minutes to be brought a soda and offered drink besides water. The food was good...big portions. And the wait staff was very nice. read more

Our singular experience which may not be what is the norm: We had a fine experience at the beginning of our meal but when the entrees arrived, my wife's was no where to be found. After waiting for 10 minutes, the manager came over and asked how everything was going and we asked where the entree was. She came back after checking in the kitchen and stated that the entree was being re-fired as the original was served to another table. After another 10 minutes, my wife's entree arrived as our dishes were being cleared. The waitress finally returned and remarked that my wife was eating while we were all done and we informed her that her food had just arrived. This means that the waitress and the manager did not discuss the problem at our table or the solutions being set up. The manager informed us that the kitchen was preparing a dessert tray for us complimentary for the ill-served entree. The waitress came asked several times if we wanted to see the dessert menu or if we wanted anything further. We informed her that the manager was preparing a dessert for us. She went away and 10 minutes later, the manager arrived with a plate of zeppoli and cannoli but no higher end desserts. Considering my wife watched us all eat and then just packed her dinner away rather than eat it, this plate was a small consolation. As this was our anniversary celebration dinner with our adult children, I was extremely displeased and disappointed in our experience at Mama Lisa Restaurant. I am not willing to return at this point since this experience was underwhelming in comparison to the investment detailed on our check. read more

We place an order off their website and was told it would take 20 minutes. An hour and a half later we still have not received our order.

Sorry Mama Lisa's... we have been driving an hour for the great food, nice atmosphere, and attentive staff for several years now. Our Sunday early supper today was less than relaxing... energetic rock music via satellite radio with talking commentary is NOT dinner or even lunch music in an establishment as yours and cheapened the atmosphere totally... read more

Italian Comfort Food. Large portions, Agreeable and Friendly Staff. Best Italian restaurant in the Area.

The food was really good and everyone was really friendly. We had reservations and were seated on time. Most dishes are about $20 and it's a pretty long menu. It was the first restaurant that I went to that boxes your left over food for you. The With portion of food that get, I think things are fairly priced and it's actually a nice little spot. If you enjoy Italian food then it's a nice place to go for a date night. They also do have a bar. Free parking onsite and a parking lot across the street. I am not sure if parking across the street was free. It seems to get bus around 7pm so plan accordingly read more

See all

Eggcellent Cafe delivers classic breakfast done well--their crab cake Benedict is rich and satisfying, with a generous portion of lump crab. The red velvet pancakes are a fun twist, though a bit too sweet for my taste. Service is friendly, but be prepared for long waits on weekends and cash-only payments. Pro Tip: Sit at the counter for quicker service and a view of the open kitchen. Verdict: A solid choice for a hearty brunch, but come early or on weekdays to avoid the rush. read more

Dissapointed..The service was fine. We come here, on average, every month or so. The Valentine's menu was overpriced, but I cut slack because most restaurants do that, and it would have been fine, had it been up to their usual generous & good portions--we had lunch. The first basket of rolls was cold, seemed stale & not worth the calories. I did ask for a replacement and we were brought new ones that were the usual good, fresh & hot ones. My husband had Eggplant parm...he liked it. I ordered shrimp with risotto--super disappointed. It was $30+... not the creamy risotto I've gotten in other places (which I love) . It was more like undercooked white rice-it was hard. It was served with about 5 medium sized shrimp. For comparison, the bigger one, in the pic, is a cooked shrimp I bought from Costco, to add to the leftovers tonight. Of course we will return, it's my husband's favorite place. Could have done a way better job with Valentine's Day though--since it was quite a bit more $$ than on regular days. Just don't order risotto, unless my description sounds appealing to you! read more

Mama Lisa Restaurant - Small bits of asparagus and just a few tomatoes. Could have done better... - Pizza Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

Hello, had my mom's surprise 90 th birthday party here on Sunday. The food was delicious, the service was excellent, staff were friendly and professional. I was so impressed with how well they treated us. Thank you for a great celebration. Will be going back for dinner soon. Thank you Moma Lisa restaurant. star rating 5 star read more

The hostesses could not have been been more accommodating. We had a drink at the bar. Chris is wonderful. Waiter Eric was great as well and the bus boy Rylan was really on top of it; should be promoted to waiter. Food was great. Don't love their house wines, could be better. Really wish they included the salad as they once did cos I'm not paying basically five bucks for iceberg lettuce, a few peppers, and some good Italian dressing, etc. as they were really nice to have as part of the meal. read more

Pretty good food and great service, but it is slightly overpriced. I give it a Solid B+ rating. ------ Ambience: B+ Cleanliness: A Customer Service: A Food: B Price: B- Ambiance/Cleanliness Mama Lisa's Pizza has a warm and cozy vibe, perfect for a relaxed meal. The place was spotless, which is always a big plus in my book. The decor was slightly dated, but that's not necessarily a bad thing when it comes to an Italian restaurant. Customer Service The service here is top-notch. Our waitress was super friendly and ensured we were well taken care of without hovering. She got our orders in quickly, and the food came out at a nice pace--no long waits, just the way I like it. Food I went with the chicken Alfredo, and it was pretty good. The portion was generous, which I appreciated. The flavors were solid, though I think it could've used just a bit more seasoning to really make it pop. As for the White Russian I ordered--let's just say they don't skimp on the pour here, and I'm all for it! Price The prices are a tad on the high side for what you get. The food was tasty, but for the price, I was hoping for something a little more flavorful. Still, it won't break the bank, just something to be aware of. Overall Mama Lisa's Pizza is a solid spot with great service and a nice atmosphere. The food was good, the drinks were strong, and the vibe was comfortable. Prices are a bit up there, but I'd still come back when I'm in the mood for some decent chicken alfredo and a well-made cocktail. read more

This Is Such A Great Place To Eat ! The Dinners Are So Good And Everything Is Always So Fresh ! The Scungilli Fradiavolo Is Way Off The Hook With A Touch Of Basil On The Top And The Bread Is Delicious ! read more

Busy Saturday nite, should have called ahead, Didn't want to wait, went to counter instead. Pretty big menu and pizzas galore, Busy, busy take outs going out the door. We're staying in, tough to pick from menus charm, She suggested a pizza bowl filled with chicken parm. Delicious, delicious with extra sauce to boot, Add in a beverage, not a lot of loot. Under $25 for two of us to share, Just delicious, no fancy flair. Next time your passing, stop in to try, Or in a hurry, take out !...bye bye. read more

Went Saturday night with my family. The food was not good at all. There were 5 of us and 4 of us thought their food was lousy, the 5th liked his. Honestly everything was way under seasoned and the red sauce was just not good. I got a pork cutlet that actually tasted like it was right on the verge of being spoiled. The service was ok the prices were a little high especially for the quality of the food and the quantity but we definitely wouldn't recommend this place and certainly won't be going back. Maybe shorten up the menu a little and focus on making fewer dishes well rather than a bunch of dishes poorly. read more

Mama Lisa's is a stylish Italian restaurant where the pizzeria is separate from the main dining area. We have ordered take out numerous times, and the decent quality of food has been consistent. On a week night we had dined in, we were disappointed by the slow service. Our favorites are the chicken Parmesan, shrimp scampi, and penne a la vodka. read more

Not terrible, not great. Came here yesterday after pumpkin picking out east. Their menu online was extensive and inviting, so we figured we'd try this place out. Upon arriving, I noticed how clean the restaurant was. The pizzeria is to the right while the restaurant is on the left. Lovely interior. We jumped right into entrees an ordered broccoli and garlic in oil, penne a la vodka and a large salad. I was thrilled to hear my entree came with a salad. It was pretty good. All of our entrees were just average. Nothing special. My penne looked delicious but the taste was lacking. Personally, I wouldn't come here again. read more

See all

Honestly every single thing this restaurant makes is to die for. The pizza, the wings, the penne a la vodka, the meatballs, the chicken fingers with that amazing honey mustard, plain grilled chicken with broccoli rabe, the seafood pasta omggg...I mean everything is wonderful. The service is always above & beyond even behind the counter everyone is so kind & helpful. My husband & I moved around here 3 years ago & have catered at least 5 parties from here, & eat here at least once a week. Such a lovely atmosphere & restaurant. We will be customers for life! read more

We usually do take out, but the dine-in experience is also great. The food is almost always excellent and when not, still good. They do mess up my takeout orders about 1/5 of the time, but the food is always good, so we just eat it. We do a lot of family dinners here. read more

Always a positive experience when we dine in. Food specials are well composed and tasty. Very large portions are prepared without sacrificing quality. Clean spacious dining room with a friendly staff. read more

The food is excellent there I recommend it highly I highly recommend Mama Lisa Restaurant I adore Nino the food is delicious dining in or out speciality dishes never a problem when dining in or out cooked to perfection have never been disappointed I recommend all my friends and family since I built my home I suggest you try them you won't be disappointed Nino is the best love this restaurant Suzie G read more

We just had delicious dinners of chicken piccata, and flounder franchese. Our server, Sam was the nicest young woman who was incredibly knowledgeable of the menu and especially the evening' specials. She truly made the experience perfect! read more

The food is delicious and the staff is very friendly. We go with my neighbors for dinner and we keep going back because we love it.

Awesome service and great food The penne ala vodka was awesome The seafood was great. Easy parking and plenty. Reservations honored read more

Order from them all the time. Been customers for over 20 yrs great food great service recommended highly

My pizzas always overcooked and they constantly forget the marinara sauce for the garlic knots and I'm very specific when I order to ensure it's not forgotten but some how still is overall disappointing its an annoying serial of events will not be returning. read more

Foods is good as usual. I usually order take out while seating at the bar but this Sunday I asked for a table which wasn't too bad . The windows blinds was very dirty, you guys needs to clean more . read more

See all

Called MamaLisa to order a Neapolitan pie. Told them I wanted right out of the oven as the last time I did takeout pizza from them a 5 mile drive back to my house it was luke warn. They said 20 min. I arrived 14 minutes later and they wanted to give me the one sitting on top of the oven. Asked how could it be right out of the oven if you told me 20 minutes, I arrive in 14 and it was already in a box! Couldn't get an answer, took it anyway, will never go back! read more

John Carlo was excellent with us. Treated us like family and what an amazing experience, let me tell you that. The food, especially the pizza and the chicken parm, was delicious, and for the price?!! Amazing! Fantastic even! The owner should be incredibly proud of this place. All staff are extremely welcoming and I loved it. read more

I personally don't understand what the problems are in the other reviews. When I came here, the food was perfect. The staff were super attentive and good at what they do. They served the food quickly and fresh. The ambiance was such a nice touch to the food. It's just definitely 5 stars. read more