We take my brother-in-law here every year for his birthday. he lives in a nearby home for adults, and he absolutely loves Gia's. Everything is excellent--the food, service and atmosphere are superb. my husband is a real pain in the butt when it comes to restaurants. Cafe Gia's gets HIGH marks from him--it is the rare place that meets all of his demands. read more

This is the second time I've ordered a sausage and pepper hero and requested light sauce and fewer peppers. Unfortunately, the sandwich was overloaded with peppers and sauce, with very little sausage. I used to really enjoy Café Gia, but this has been disappointing and is making me lose interest. It feels like they give you what they want rather than what you actually order. read more

Cafe Gia - Sausage and Peppers - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

It's such a pretty pizza place with nice ambiance they sell this garlic bread with mozzarella, sliced onions and tomatoes and it is Devine! The workers are very friendly, we came at a time they were giving away the dessert for free. read more

Good price for bec (came with juice or coffee which you dont see anymore) Coffee was hot and fresh, service was great, same cute place, i would definitely come back read more

6pm on a Thursday night. No house pie ready. No Vodka Grandma ready and none in the oven. The vodka Grandma slices probably their best slice here. Only reason I come... I can understand if it was 9:00 at night but it's dinner time on a Thursday night not having house pies and specialty ready is unacceptable. read more

Honestly this place is just always underwhelming. We've been here 4 times since we've moved to Bellport & tried numerous dishes & they were all so overly boring. Nothing seasoned the salads were so bland & even the pizza is meh. Now we'll literally only stop in for a slice once in a while if we're starving or don't want to drive further for better pizza. Service is also underwhelming & unmemorable. Ambiance is also underwhelming. read more

Still the same. I keep coming back because the food is good. But I think I am done now for good because again I went in there and they messed up my order and I had to go back two times to get it right, very inconvenient . Always like high schoolers who don't care working there. read more

Everything is always fresh.. restaurant and pizza both excellent...best chicken rolls around.

Top 5 most incompetent pizza places I have EVER been too. You have a front end employee cursing at other employees and customers for their orders, the same idiot yells about "how customers are so stupid" but he must of been talking about himself because my CHICKEN ROLL & SINGLE SLICE OF PIZZA was sitting on the shelf for 40 minutes while I sat there patiently. I reminded them of my phone number 5 TIMES but the overgrown orange hair airhead nor the other incompetent employees didn't notice until again 40 minutes came & past, 3 rushes came and went. Not a single apology for THEIR moronic mistake & they threw the box at food at me. 13 dollars dragged into 40 minutes making it the biggest waste of time I have ever spent at a pizza parlor. At least a bad pizza place can keep track of what you order. Cafe Gias cannot hit the mark in even the most basic of customer service. Will never be returning to this sorry excuse of a pizzeria. Oh chicken roll is soggy at this point & I asked for it well done. This isn't well done and the pizza looks like GARBAGE. Thank you for the waste of time bozos! read more

Cafe Gia - Terrible slice of pizza & a clearly not well done chicken roll. 40 minute pizza wait for this trash :) - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

See all

Cafe Gia is a hometown classic for my hubby who grew up and lived just around the corner for most of his life. Although we've moved out of state in the last few years, Cafe Gia is one of our must-stop-spots while in town visiting family. We miss our New York pizza so much while we're away and Cafe Gia's pizza does the job to happily satisfy us. Offering both sit down and take out services, Cafe Gia has something for almost everyone. Their pizza and window display items boasts a wide variety of classic and specialty pizza, which offers a vast and unique selection for diners. Some of our favorite items are the pepperoni pinwheel, Chicken Marsala slice, chicken roll, a classic plain slice, their garlic knots (sooooo good), and their bruschetta (also to die for). These are just a few of the items we love at Cafe Gia because honestly, we haven't had a bad item yet from their to go display. Service is consistently friendly and efficient. Even at times we have come by when they've been busy, they do a great job of moving the line along with patience and a smile. There are several other establishments in the nearby radius serving a similar menu and fare, but Cafe Gia's tasty pizzas, speciality items, and service stand out for my husband and me. Looking forward to our next visit to enjoy another slice of "home" soon. read more

See all

We came to Café Gia for our Easter Sunday dinner. This restaurant was picked out by other people in our family, and I'm not gonna lie I was a little apprehensive after reading some of the reviews previously left here. I do have to say that overall we had a pleasant experience and I will definitely come back here again. It's nothing too fancy, a pizzeria with a nice dining area which is usually our scene anyway. But all in all we had a nice holiday as a family. Reservations were made by other family members and we were set up at a big table closer to the entrance to the right when you walk in. The long rectangular table fit us all very comfortably and we were able to see each other clearly. A round of drinks were ordered, mostly non-alcoholic and we also decided to start with a few appetizers. The bruschetta looked amazing and it tasted as amazing as it looked. Chunks of fresh tomato and onion where very tasty and placed on top of fresh mozzarella and a crisp piece of a baguette. We also decided to try their fried calamari as well and although not the best I've ever had it was good nonetheless. It wasn't rubbery, but I think it did lack a little bit of flavor. We were also brought out fresh baked pizza bread to start with as well. My son loved the bread and the bruschetta, and I could totally understand why. A paper insert was given with our menu that had Easter dinner specials on it. My eyes went straight to the Beef Braciola. I haven't had this in a very long time and no one can make it greater than my grandmother who has been gone for almost 10 years now. I knew I had to try it being that it was their special, and I'm a sucker for special. This came with a meatball as well as a bowl of linguine. I absolutely loved the size of the meatball as it was a perfect size to share with my son. The Braciola was very well-made. No egg like we would traditionally have with it, but very flavorful and very tender. Those are the two major components of this dish. We barely made a dent in any of our meals. The portion was great and we definitely have enough left over for lunch and dinner the next day. We decided to also stick around for dessert and some cannolis were had as well as a pistachio tartufo. The cannoli was outrageous. I don't remember last time I had a cannoli, but this one was definitely one of the better ones I've had in a long time. The tartufo was amazing, and cut into four equal parts perfect for sharing. I couldn't resist in ordering the Oreo cheesecake to go. Haven't had a chance to try it yet, but I'm sure it's just as delicious. Two things I want to note before I close out this review. One is that the service wasn't terrible, but it wasn't great. I understand we were a big group, but there weren't many people in this restaurant and at times it was hard to find someone to help us. It looked like a lot of the servers were hanging out in the back towards the bar, and I understand that was a holiday and it probably sucks to work on a holiday and I so very much appreciate them being there but if the staff checked in one or two more times it would've been a lot better. The second thing was there was no changing table in the women's bathroom. After grabbing all my supplies to do a diaper change, and waiting until someone came out of the bathroom I then noticed that I would not be able to change him there. We had to walk back through the restaurant and change him in the car outside. I was under the impression that this was a requirement for restaurants, and if it's not they should have a changing station regardless. If you have a dining room that allows children this should be a must. read more

Cafe Gia - Easter Special Beef Braciola - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

Ordered over the phone for pick up . muscles in garlic and wine sauce and a margarita pie. When I arrived they handed me muscles marinara and no pie asked where the pie was and I was told you didn't order it... so I had to wait for a pie to be made and didn't bother with the muscles . No apology made. Not going back read more

Overall this restaurant is fairly good. I came tonight and it was crowded Waiters and busboys were running around being attentive. The meal started with s pizza bread basket and the little pizzas were pretty good and tasty. I did ask for parmigiana cheese but was told they ran out. However, I ordered a Ceaser salad and Chicken Franchaise. I also ordered a side of angel hair pasta in the same sauce. The salad was fresh and tasty with pieces of Romano cheese and parmigiana. I asked to have the lettuce finely chopped and they obliged. The croutons were unfortunately stale and greasy, but I did enjoy the salad overall with the dressing on the side. After about 15 minutes the main dish came out. It was very good and fresh. The sauce was a bit thicker than I am used to but it was good and enjoyable. I usually do add parmigiana cheese but I didn't have to with this dish. The pasta was also tasty, but because of the thickness of the sauce, the pasta became a bit pasty. Overall, this is a nice restaurant and obviously very popular. I will definitely come again. The pricing was fair, I felt. There are two pricings. One for credit cards and one for cash, but I didn't feel grossly overcharged by using a credit card. read more

See all

This place is a amazing great calm vibe Italian setting great food I had the Alfredo with chicken and an iced tea

One of the few places you can get sfincione pizza. If you havent had it ,its the true sicilian style with breadcrumbs on the top, with sauce and onions. It's very light and airy ,must try it. Here, I think they call it old fashioned pizza. I haven't yet eaten in the restaurant ,but it has a nice atmosphere and the kids that work here are nice and respectful. read more

Not sure what happened to this place. The pizza has changed and it definitely is not good anymore. The food from the kitchen is inconsistent too. Not sure if I will return anytime soon. read more

Pizza is good but get their apps! Their bruschetta toasts are a hit for us and TRY THE SOUPS! Their cream of asparagus is my absolute favorite. They aren't always the friendliest probably because they are consistently busy but their food is also consistent. read more

Clean, good food, sometimes service is a little slow but that's because they are looking for help, like everyone else is. I love their Broccoli Rabe and sausage with lots of garlic, it's to die for. They have a fantastic menu with a lot of great appetizers as well. They also have a marvelous Pizza selection. Cocktails, wine and soda as well. I will miss them as I'm leaving for Florida to live. read more

Fantastic dinner tonight 2 lb lobster oregano Absolutely delicious Service was great thanks Matt read more

Cafe Gia - Wow it was the best enough to share - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

I've eaten here many times, and while it's not my first choice among the countless pizzerias in the area it's usually a pretty safe bet for a decent meal. Usually a nice selection of specialty slices (their buffalo slices are pretty good). The meatball and chicken parm hero's are also pretty good as well. Nothing spectacular but good enough to get again. Fair prices, clean restaurant good selection of dishes, & decent food. read more

A large 3 topping pizza is 39 dollars, and there is a markup if you're paying with a card. There are better pizza joints around the corner.

When in a few times wanting garlic knots with my order but for some reason they never have them. Either around 12-1pm or 7pm they don't have knots. read more

The honey mustard sauce is absolutely delicious. I had asked about purchasing it.I was told it was $8.64 a pint.seems a little high but absolutely I ordered it.well I got a half a pint for $8.64 that's completely ridiculous. I went back and asked them to fill the pint because that's what I paid for. The dirty looks I got from the staff I'm not sure if they did something to it when they went back to fill it. The staff is completely 100% unprofessional the fact that you charge people for a pint and give them a half a pint , their business practice is absolutely disgusting. read more

I went in with my two boys for a few slices. The service was very friendly and helpful right away. Outstanding margarita and grandma slices. I don't eat pizza often, but when I do I want the pizza to knock it outta the park! And this place did it. read more

Nothing special, prices are high for the quality of the food and they seem to mess up orders. Do NOT get the pesto, it's thick, pasty and not enjoyable. I've never ever seen a pesto done so wrong. Going to be looking for another place, even though convenient so far as proximity to my home it's just not worth it anymore. No problem to drive further for better food. read more

Love the food Go there often However Last few times i went in just to sit with pizza and a chicken roll or hero the plastic utensils are really cheap ones i broke three forks just trying to cut They should get the black stronger forks back and get rid of these weak white ones and back to the original paper plates those brown ones are thin and when u cut you get the paper plate in your food ! That's all love the food though read more

I really like this place. I feel the food is way under rated. The prices snd portions are great. Last night we took our family of 6 to dinner for my birthday!! SAMMIE our waitress was great. I asked the chef to add prosciutto and mozzarella to my chicken franchise and they did. The penne with oil and garlic was outstanding. Everyone including my teo little girls loved the food. My who is doing keto requested a certain dish and they catered that to her as well..if not eating in restaurant they have some great pizza... the Buffalo slice is one of the best! read more

Was in town for a baseball tournament and if it were up to me we would have eaten here every night! Service and food was incredible!! We were a table of 10 who came in late on a week night and they had no problem accommodating us! Our waitress Anna was friendly and attentive. Everyone's food was 10/10. They start you off with a bread basket which I would have been happy with that alone, it was my 2 years olds favorite. The pizza bread (I'm not sure the correct name) was amazing. The Caesar salad was good and the dressing was even better! The pasta broccoli was super flavorful, my husband loved the stuffed ravioli in vodka sauce, my 14 year old inhaled the chicken parm and penne. Each meal could easily be split between 2 people. The servings were huge. I don't know if we'll ever be back to yaphank but I'd come just to eat at cafe Gia again! read more

Call in your order because they are super busy during lunch! I love the variety of pizza they have, and I always get a Greek salad with no onions, extra olives, and I get it chopped. Get the Caesar dressing it's the best! Say hi to Sal! read more

I've been going to Cafe Gia on and off for many years. I've never had a bad meal here. Coworkers and I ordered lunch here a couple weeks ago and everything was very good. My Greek salad slice was pretty skimpy, usually it comes loaded with salad on top. I had to ask one of the young guys that work the counter to please put more salad on it. Some had fallen off onto the tray. Psshhh I'll take that thank you! lol. I tried my coworkers Caesar salad and it was delicious. Just the right amount of dressing and garlic. I'm definitely ordering it next time. I didn't get to try the pepperoni pinwheel or rice balls from the order but heard they were good. Rice balls are huge. Place gets super busy and employees handle it pretty well. Most seem to be friendly enough. read more

See all

In my quest to find the best pizza on Long Island I stopped in at Cafe Gia. On my Barstool Portnoy rating system I give it an 8.3. Slice was thin crispy and very flavorful. I asked for well done not burnt and it was near perfect. Love the ambiance inside and this is a hidden gem in East Patchogue. Staff was very receptive and even though I was wearing my Raiders gear and they didn't love that they were very respectful. Great dinner vibe and anyone knows if the rating is over an 8 then it's worth an hour to drive to. Keep rocking guys! read more

This place has pretty good slices especially for a pizzeria this far east. I would say they hit right on the head with a :3 1/2 star rating. Cafe Gia is almost across the street from La Margarita but if the baseline is a cheese slice then Gia wins that battle not to mention the inside of this restaurant is nicer as well. It's only a couple minutes off the expressway so if you're traveling east or west it makes a very convenient pit stop. read more

Cafe Gia - Regular slices - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

We stopped by Friendly's first to eat and we realized that they do not offer Gluten free options. So we left and we came here to check out Gluten Free Calzone and Gluten Free Mozzarella sticks, it's delicious! It actually taste like something good. Not like cardboard. Can't wait to try gluten free pizza soon! read more

food is good. but the staff is the most incompetent bunch of children you will encounter and never get an order correct

I was so hungry. I ordered a large antipasto salad. The cold cuts presentation looked horrible, I needed a knife and ten minutes to prepare my take out lunch before I could eat it. And then the biggest disappointment.... Under that mess was just a bunch of lettuce and pepperchini. No olives. No tomatoes. No cucumbers. I didn't even eat it just beyond disappointing. read more

Cafe Gia - The saddest Antipasto Salad ever! - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

See all

Vodka grandma pie is amazing! Haven't tried the kitchen food yet but the pizza is really good. Big restaurant looked clean every time I went in. Service is good also read more

The food was excellent!!! We had baked clams and Fillet of sole- Organata. Tasted great! The staff was very friendly and efficient. We will go back again! read more

I want to love them, really can't hate them... I'm caught somewhere in the middle. Some thing have such great potential and are ruined by a tiny aspect that's just off... Other basic things are so on point.... Good white slice, great plain... A few good dishes, good service usually, and usually a bit busy. The pizza bread is killer... read more

See all

A local spot for my girlfriend, this was the decision for dinner last night as we wanted a quality Italian meal that we could pick up and take back to her house so as to sit back and relax in the comfort of her home. Gia did pretty well in giving this mouthful of a sentence to us, through a few different dishes. Even though we didn't eat here, we dined in on one other occasion. The place looks like a pizza parlor upon entry, but is then set up with a simple contemporary feel in its decor throughout the rest of the spot. The staff was friendly (even though we were only ordering to go) as one specifically gave us a couple of decent pizza suggestions for sharing. Beyond pizza, Gia offers a nice selection of a variety of pasta dishes, apps and salads, meats and seafood, and plenty more. We decided to order a pasta dish and went with stuffed rigatoni alla vodka. From there we grabbed a sausage and pepper roll and a slice of grandma style pizza, all to go. It didn't take too long for our grub to be ready, and once we obtained it, we were off to return home to chow down. First up, the grandma slice. It was thin-crusted with a nice sauce layered on surrounded by a little cheese. Not the best grandma I've eaten (that sounded weird), but not the worst. Secondly, the roll. A good helping of sausage and pepper twisted inside the bread along with some mozzarella and a side of red sauce for dipping. The ingredients were tasty and made for a quality choice. Lastly, the pasta. The stuffed rigatoni were long and ricotta-filled all placed in a pool of vodka sauce. A side of two different breads was also included which worked well for dipping as there was quite a lot of excess vodka sauce to be had. Overall, Cafe Gia fulfilled a meal to go, through some employee assistance and decision-making, and of course taste. The food wasn't the greatest Italian I've had, but for the area, Gia should be given a try, for any or all menu item choices. read more

See all

I use to order every day literally lunch sometimes dinner but tonight I walked in hoping to grab a slice and the clown working didn't have the decency to even look up work I asked him for some slices ! You just lost a customer a very faithful one too ! read more