First time eating here. Bella was our server. She was great! We had the chicken verdi and rigatoni bolognese. Both dishes were very good. Bread basket was tasty also. Give it a try!!! read more

See all

I use to order every day literally lunch sometimes dinner but tonight I walked in hoping to grab a slice and the clown working didn't have the decency to even look up work I asked him for some slices ! You just lost a customer a very faithful one too ! read more

Very disappointed in cafe Gia .. I spent nearly 100$ this past nite . My Greek salad was a NO SHOW , there was no prosciutto in the Ala Vodka , the rice ball came but with no dipping sauce . There was absolutely no good outcome ... talking to someone who said was manager ... a Store Credit of 12.95 for the Greek salad . Any good management would have comped at least 1/2 the amount of total delivery ! Will never order here again read more

food is good. but the staff is the most incompetent bunch of children you will encounter and never get an order correct

Tried giving them another chance, placed an order, come 25 minutes later no order on que, this place has gone to shit. Management is poor , customer service is poor, hire people with experience because it reflects the shit show your running. cafe junk read more

Cafe Gia - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

Been here several time in the distant past, however, something has changed. The whole atmosphere was different, service was just kind of blah. Simple order of a few sides and a salad got totally messed up. Hoping this was just a one day thing and not something that will happen everytime. read more

Staff is slow and not friendly at all. They are very unorganized and skipped over me online and helped other customers behind me on the same line. I walked out. Very rude and unprofessional!! read more

So I'm normally not one to write reviews at all, especially not negative ones, but I gotta say I'm disappointed with my experience this time. The first time I was here, I came with my elderly grandmother and parents on Christmas Eve a few years back (pre-COVID) as a treat to get her out of her Rehab Center, and the service along with the food was GREAT! That being said, this time around, I came with the same company for Mother's Day. My mom made a reservation a few days in advance and specified that we would have a person with a wheelchair, so she requested a table. When we arrived, the hostess said the person who took our reservation did not specify a table, so the only option we had was a booth... fine--but we were worried about servers bumping into her since she was in the aisle. There was definitely difficulty with space! Once we ordered, we were told there were no mozzi sticks (bummer), but it was 4pm on Mother's Day--not sure how that happened! Fast forward almost TWO HOURS later, still no food. They were definitely understaffed and the management certainly was not doing well. They seemed to have been helping out the carry out area before serving the in house guests! I never blame the servers because I know how it feels to be the messenger! Clearly, management was struggling! When I got my food, the eggplant parm was very very thin so I was basically just eating breading. My pasta was also a bit undercooked. That being said, the flavor was definitely there! Finally, the restaurant seemed to have gotten into a flow and the crowds calmed down. We decided to stay for dessert because my grandmother wanted a cannoli and it was Mother's Day after all! Our server was very apologetic about the whole evening and came through with dessert! All in all, just very disappointed in my experience this time, especially since it was a holiday and the restaurant should've prepared for that. I hope that Cafe Gia improves their management/customer service so that we can happily come back, considering it's my grandmother's favorite restaurant close to her rehab center! As of right now, I don't believe we will be coming back! read more

Strip Mall location, Modern ambiance, Young friendly staff. Cafe Gia is casual dining but feels high end. sleek modern ambiance and a fully stocked bar would make this a nice spot to take a date or come after work if you're wanting to see a game. It's got a flat screen TV but doesn't feel like a sports bar. The counter has a nice selection of specialty slice, Calzones, and Pizza Roll / Stromboli type edibles. The food we ordered we did take out. Large Pie. 1/2 cheese 1/2 Pepperoni and onions and an order of Fried Calamari. great stuff. The calamari wasn't rubbery the breading was not overpowering. The Marinara was tasty for dipping and the lemon was a nice touch. The Pizza was outstanding. a nice thin yet not floppy crust. worth mentioning is the sauce, cheese and toppings were melded into the crust "handle" this was true pizza craftsmanship. Surprisingly a little more oily than anticipated but I don't mind that, it's a good thing. Pepperoni was mild no spice but good flavor. onions were sauteed and complimented the pepperoni. Per slice a well balanced cheese to sauce. sauce was subtle and earthy. I will be back and do recommend Cafe Gia to anyone. read more

See all

I've been going to Cafe Gia for years now there's food is usually good. But I'm posting this particular review bc I will never eat there again. I bought one of their pre-made chicken Paninis it has grilled chicken breast, mozzarella & broccoli rabe. Well the bottom bread was so wet when you picked it up it literally went limp,just soaked. The top panini bread was so hard u could of played hockey with it and the chicken breast was black, BURNT TO A CRISP! I Tried to call them when I got home but they were closed already. So the following day I brought it back in to explain the dilemma. The younger,tall, darker skinned girl wish I knew her name so I didn't have to use description. Was so rude to me, rolling her eyes, waving and flicking her hands making sighing noises. I wasn't as disturbed or disappointed in the food as much, but how I was treated was so disrespectful and uncalled for. The manager never even reprimanded her for her toxic behavior towards customers. So in closing if they screw up your order don't bring the food back (not that they ever give receipts) bc they will treat u like crap. Which is unacceptable especially when you've been a loyal customer for many years. Such BS.... read more

Cafe Gia - Chicken Panini with soggy, saturated bottom bread. Rock hard hockey puck top bread and don't forget the burnt to a crisp black chicken.... - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

The pizza here is delicious, but that's not why I am here with you, writing this review. One of the greatest things that I have ever put in my mouth is the Buffalo Chicken Roll from Cafe Gia's. I lived near this place for only about 3 months, and I probs went to Gia's 15-20 times. Each time being better then the time before. I will never forget Cafe Gia's. Thank you Chris read more

Cafe Gia - Buffalo rolls. Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

Well, well! We do have to say, we were pleasantly surprised the change around at CafeGia! Their service was right on the point, the receipt was provided along with exact price stated on the menu and most importantly had a very delicious, classic Margarita pizza pie! Not so many restaurants do it right but we finally have found the place. Glad we gave Cafe Gia another chance and looking forward to try out other dishes on the menu soon! Thank you for listening! We knew you had it in you when you try harder! read more

See all

Fantastic! This is by far the best pizza in the Bellport area. I have had pretty much every type of slice you can have there and they are all great, my favorites would be the buffalo chicken slice and white spinach slice. If you are in the Bellport area and are hungry then you must stop by Cafe Gia for slices! read more

Warning In my salad I bought here, a bug crawled out of the bunch of salad. Disgusting. So picture this next time you eat there read more

Cafe Gia - Bug - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

See all

Pretty solid Italian place, lunch was ok. Here are my gripes: I got a side of pasta, which they put cheese on. I can't eat cheese, so I couldn't eat my side. They seated our party of six by the back area where the bathrooms and an exit to the alley are. It was bitterly cold and staff kept opening the back door, resulting in a lovely burst of cold. Really ruins your enjoyment of the meal. Flies. It's FEBRUARY, so why so many flies? read more

Tried Cafe Gia for the first time on Friday night and the food wasn't the best...I had the calzone and I've definitely had better elsewhere they were kind of bland ...the girl behind the counter was rude and that was also a turn off...not sure if I'll be trying them again....I hope they were having a off night and this is not regular service. read more

Went there for lunch today. Grandma slice was ice cold and tasted like the oven. Regular slice was ok but had a whole bunch of burnt crusties under the slice. Only thing good was the garlic knots even tho they were ice cold. Never going back read more

Al though the eat in menu is a bit pricey i'd definitely recommend trying the pasta but with the chicken in it. The waitress was very nice and caring. I'd definitely come here again and plus its local to me. The stuffed shells were amazingly delicious and presented well. Everything came out freshly cooked, hot, and ready to eat. read more

Cafe Gia - Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken Baked Stuffed Shells (5) - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

See all

Bad service , don't waste your precious time, they make you wait, at the end all they say is still preparing wasted my 30 minutes for nothing stay away !!! read more

The best penne pasta pizza ever! Everything else is great too. Fast service and nice atmosphere

i spent $40 on a gluten free pizza and some gluten free mozzarella sticks. the pizza i got was mid, i've had better. but the mozzarella sticks were terrible, i got a blob of cheese. definitely not worth the money. read more

Cafe Gia - gluten free mozzarella sticks - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

The meat balls were full of bread, flavor would be on point if they didn't have so much bread, the sausage was wayyyyy over cooked to the point of couldn't even eat, but they did not charge so at least they tried to make up for it, minestrone was so so.... read more

WONDERFUL PIZZA! My favorite is the buffalo chicken. I normally order my food to go but the inside is very nice maybe after COVID I will dine in here to try something other than pizza. read more

We frequent this place mostly on Friday nights.. it's a very busy pizzeria with a table service restaurant as well. Don't let the pizzeria deceive you - this restaurant has nightly specials that can compete with the best Italian eateries. My favorite is their Chilean sea bass and their fried calamari. They have the best sauce and their calamari is always tender and fresh. Last night I had their pasta special which was a cavatelli pasta with shrimp, asparagus, sundries tomatoes in a pink cream sauce... it was by far one of the best pasta dishes I've ever had - better than Carmine's in NYC. Kids can order pasta dishes half size, their soups are homemade, they have specialty pizzas as well they can get by the slice. Service is good for the most part - hostess staff is a little young and can be inconsistent - Glenn is our favorite waiter and never disappoints. read more

Cafe Gia - Cavatelli pasta with baby shrimp, asparagus, sundries tomatoes and a pink cream sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Yaphank, New York

Buyer Beware! They have gone to a new pricing policy which basically says prices on menu are for those paying cash. It is not noticeable on menu nor advised to you before ordering. The Calzone I purchased tonight was on menu for $6.95 but billed after meal @ $8.95. All other items on our bill were higher priced than on menu. It is so easy to pay, for anything, by credit/debit card in this day and age that I have not cash in my pocket for last 7 days. This place needs to stop stealing the sales tax from cash sales and run a legit restaurant that charges same for all types of payment. Otherwise the food was good. read more

Hands down best pizza in the area. Buy by the slice or full pie. Daily slice offerings and specials. Personal fav is classic pepperoni or buffalo chicken. Highly suggest the pizza rolls too. Variation of a calzone, but 100x better. Great staff, very friendly, and very efficient. Can't go wrong here. read more

This place is a solid choice for pizza. Living on Long Island, we're pretty inundated with options. This place is geographically desirable for me, as it is less than a mile from my apartment. Service is fast and friendly, and the shop itself is clean and modern looking. I love their rice balls - but I can never be sure whether or not they'll have them. Pasta dishes I've tried in the past are nothing to write home about, so I skip them. Their plain & grandma slice is good - but not great. Instead, I prefer to go with a specialty slice - they make an awesome chicken, bacon ranch slice & buffalo chicken slice as well. Garlic knots are on point as well. I will continue to visit Cafe Gia as they are my local pizza joint. read more

Amazing food great service. Always come here and absolutely no complaints. 10/10 would recommend.

Our favorite pizza. Dominick, the owner, is down to earth and I've known him for years - stand up guy. Great family atmosphere and pizza food amazing too, I've had the best Italian hero of my life from here lol and their penne alla vodka is my favorite too - there's nothing bad that can be said read more

It's hard for me to leave this review, because I honestly enjoy the food at Cafe Gia. The reason for the 1 star is that whoever is communicating the orders to the cooks cant follow instructions. It has happened to me time and time again. They are extremely simple orders, but if you aren't listening, that's the only way you would get them incorrect. Tonight we happened to be having a rainstorm. My husband went to go pick up two chicken parm heros with extra sauce on the side. I ordered them over the phone with someone and she was about to charge me $30 dollars when I asked why it was so expensive for heroes. She said she accidentally rang us up for 3 heroes. Fine, mistakes happen, but unfortunately they happen a lot here. The heroes were picked up and brought back here and somehow they managed to give us a "sausage parm hero and 1 chicken parm hero". Not really sure how. So I called and was told they could do 3 things for me. 1. Keep the food and eat it 2. Come back and be given the correct order or 3. Refund me. Why didn't they offer to deliver the food to us? We had to go all the way back there to get the correct order when it should have been given to us the first time. That's not right. We also don't live extremely close. So my husband went back to her the correct order and he was told "sorry we are just really busy". I'm glad you are really busy, but if I said that I was really busy at my job and constantly messed stuff up, I wouldn't have a job! They also forgot the extra sauce so he had to go back inside to get that! I'm not understanding now such a SIMPLE order can be messed up to this degree? How? In the past we asked for these same exact heroes with extra sauce and were given zero sauce. How does this happen? We have frequented the other pizza places in the area and they seem to always get it right. It's not a continual issue where it's ALWAYS wrong. My husband asked for a refund because he started getting annoyed and he was told sorry we can't because it's on a card. I have never heard of that. Also, for a place that is SO busy- why are you charging your customers extra money if they pay with a card opposed to cash? This isn't the 1950s. Most people travel with cards. I am disappointed. I loved this place when it first opened years ago. I am getting sick of having an issue WEEKLY when we order simple things. I hope someone contacts me about this and let's me know that something will be done. read more

The pizza is delicious, and the people are nice. That's why I am giving 3 stars. but PLEASE please please buy better quality pasta. This is the 3rd time that I was so dissatisfied with the quality of the pasta, I have tried 3 different types of pasta thinking maybe one would be better than the other but ive come to the conclusion that it's probably stop and shop brand or something. It's very chalky and pasty, and falls apart. The only time I've had pasta that tastes like that was the cheapest brand from the grocery store. Please invest a little bit more to keep customers happy, the sauces are delicious! You can't put delicious sauce on cheap pasta. read more

Hands down one of the best places that I have ever tried!! Their food is absolutely delicious,best garlic knots and penne ala vodka!!!

This is a tried and true. Doesn't disappoint. Food is consistent. Very good food and service, we often order out -- their bruschetta bread is amazing. read more

We were so horrified when we realized one of our entrees were missing from our order!! That was nothing compared to the manager Matt's blasé attitude toward my family members missing meal. They would not even try to remedy the situation. I have never seen such awful customer service. I cannot wait to see a new name hanging on the outside of such a unprofessional and irresponsible food service business. Please do not patronize this store. read more

This is now the second time I have placed a delivery order with cafe gia through doordash and both times they have messed up my orders. Both times there were incorrect items and items missing. So now, for a second time, I have two kids who do not have dinner because one of the meals was missing and the other was made wrong, actually not even close to what it was supposed to be. When I called to explain the situation to cafe gia, all I received was an attitude from the high schooler who answered the phone saying there is nothing they can do and they "thoroughly check all orders" before they go out the door. So blatant lies, great customer service cafe gia. Do yourself a favor and order from somewhere else if you actually want to receive your order and have the items you do receive made correctly. read more

Good food, good pizza, good service. A clean restaurant with a nice variety of foods, including Italian and seafood. I've been in for a sit down meal as well as done pizza for takeout and haven't had a bad experience here. I would recommend Cafe Gia with no concerns. I think they do a great overall job of providing a good dining experience. read more

Cafe Gia Saturday in July. Friend recommend. Food was good, high cost, but plentiful. I want to stop here for a moment. I found one of the nicest things there, was the server Christina who took the order with a smile and when there was a discrepancy, handled it sweetly and smoothly. (an extra star for her) Now, where was I, oh, yea, 2 people could share and that was one of the specials without a salad. Bread was served. Chicken and shrimp was good and noodles in olive oil tasty but rather hard aldente. My friend ordered ravioli parmesan and upon receiving ziti; requested the change and a few minutes later, got a fresh corrected plate. Take home containers were given in paper bags. Along with the Italian sub I ordered to go. (yes Subways is only a few stores away) My husband said it was a good sandwich though. (He liked it better) And I ate anyway, the not so fresh custard egg clair that I had ordered for dessert. It looked good, though I probably would have been better off not eating it. **j read more

Terrible service, they did me and my boys dirty don't eat here, food was cold and tasted musty

After being told to come here for months, I finally gave in today to see what Gia Pizza was about. It's located in a shopping center so parking is not a issue. The biggest surprise was walking in. This place looks like a five star restaurant. Tile floors, dark wood borders, comfortable AC, and very nice soft booths that fill up the restaurant. They play a mash up of different music that is great for all ages if you decided to eat in. The hostesses up front are very polite as they direct traffic. They asked me immediately if I needed help. I walked to the counter and ordered 4 slices (two for me) and mozzarella sticks. The Marsala Slice and the Buffalo Slice were my picks of the day. Once that was out the way I sat at a comfortable booth and waited briefly for my food. Once it was ready it was time to try. My favorite was the Buffalo Slice. Maybe the best slice I ever tried. It was soft and chewy at the same time. It has just the right amount of kick and the chicken was great. They didn't charge for blue cheese which is a nice change and the blue cheese was good as well. The wonderful waitress Jessie brought over my mozzarella sticks as I ate my pizza. The sticks were ok, but not the best. The wonderful hostess bussed my table and we didn't even ask her. What a nice change of pace from normal pizzeria's. I am going to come here more in order to try more menu items. I think Gia Pizza is a great spot to visit, if your around Medford. read more

See all

Pizza has always been consistently good. Restaurant is nice inside with a full bar open at night. But you can also just walk in, grab a slice and sit down. When they get busy and overwhelmed is when everything suffers. Such as the service when my husbands pizza was cold by the time we sat down because we waited forever for 2 single garlic knots. read more