Restaurant offers some of the best tasting pizza I have eaten in a long time. Aside from the basic cheese slices there are a good selection of specialty slices to satisfy any appetite. Service is friendly and the price structure is a little above average pizza slice pricing elsewhere. I'd suggest taking on the go or weather permitting seat outside as the in dining area is extremely small and confining plus you are a stones throw away from both the front door and counter area. There is a dining area with table service in the rear of the restaurant that provides a more conducive experience for those choosing that dining option. Located near the AMC Theater it does get busy with movie goers ( I went on a Saturday) but there is plenty of parking. Overall great tasting pizza at reasonable prices. read more

Base my reviews off what you pay: Stick to just pizza here, restaurant leaves room for improvement. Price - $80-$100 Food - 2/5 - pretty lackluster for the price. Service - 3/5 - fine and on par. Ambiance - 2/5 - no complaints but crammed. Overall - 2/5 - if you stick to just pizza here Sole Mio is great, Bruschetta Slice is awesome. But restaurant leaves a lot desired. Food was pretty bad for the price, overly salty and tasted like it came premade. Service was fine, on par, and no complaints. Waiter was a little pushy but nothing over the top. Ambiance was fine too but definitely feel crammed inside. Only saving grace was the Bruschetta Sole Mio dish which was great, otherwise food would probably be a 1. Best Dish - Bruschetta Sole Mio read more

Favorite choice, the pear salad with grilled chicken on top. Another place that's absolutely packed, but the service is quick and the food is amazing ! They are definitely doing something right! When you choose to dine in, you will not be disappointed. The servers are attentive and gracious and make you feel as if you're the only one there. You are not overlooked . everything on the menu has been is delicious. read more

Great pizza slices with a large variety to choose from. Hooked on their stracciatella soup with meatballs. Delicious cheesy garlicky knots that are chewy and soft when you bite into them. Service is always fast and friendly. read more

O Sole Mio - Pizza Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

See all

This is the second time we've visited this place, and the pizza is exquisite--a small spot, but relaxing and family-friendly.

My birthday lunch with my family went really well. The food is ALWAYS great and so is the service. The only thing I noticed was the size of the portions have shrunk considerably. We used to leave with a doggy bag, but now we were still a little hungry when we left. read more

Delicious food and great service. Good prices. The back dining area is quaint and cozy, somehow completely apart from the bustling pizza counter. A great spot before a movie or for a dinner out! read more

See all

1/26/25 update: Another awesome dinner at O Sole Mio. Tonight I had a craving for linguini garlic oil & anchovies. I insisted that the do not use any broth when making the dish. The dish came out perfectly!!!! I enjoyed it so much and told the waiter that it was too good to eat in one sitting so I had him wrap the second half it up. The linguini was aldente and the garlic had a nice roasted flavor and was creamy soft! My wife had the Cavatelli Roselle with mushrooms, subdued tomatoes, asparagus and spinach. She said it was amazing! For the appetizer, she ordered the honey spice cauliflower which she loved! It looked like sesame chicken too! lol. Manuel did a great job working out table! read more

See all

Neighborhood pizzeria's are my jam. This one is in a strip mall but was busy for lunch so it must be good. The grandpa square was lovely. The thin square also had a crunch to hit that was hard not to like. They have all sorts of specialty sliced as well. The dining room was busy for lunch which is a good sign. I would for sure come back for a slice. read more

See all

Without a doubt this is the best Italian restaurant in the area. Food is always excellent. The service is great. And the prices are reasonable. What I like that about this restaurant is the consistency. The meals are always excellent, portions are large. read more

Went back to this pizzeria in stony brook. Best part is they have alot of gluten free dishes which it was a PLUS! Usually their basket of bread comes with fresh garlic bread, other types of bread and usually their garlic bread was delicious but this time it tasted stale , but the other slice bread was delicious. Came with olive oil, olives, roasted garlic to dip your bread in. Their dishes were huge. Even bf couldn't even finish it. Gluten free Grilled chicken Parmigiana Fresh mozzarella and basil in a light marinara sauce.  Pasta alla Vodka with bowtie pasta House specialty. Pink cream and vodka sauce with a touch of meat. Delicious Great for private parties Private Parking lot Accepts Cash/card Gluten free dishes Outdoor dining Vegetarian dishes read more

See all

This is one of my favorite pizza/restaurants on Long Island and I've been coming here for years and never been disappointed. To start the restaurant is super quiet and nice, staff is helpful and quick to take orders and bring delicious food to the table. Portions are huge, I never leave without a take out box. This time we stopped by for lunch and ordered a variety of items, we tried the bolognese that came with a delicious cup of pasta fragiole soup! The Italian submarine was tasty and packed with meats, slice of pepperoni pizza and my usual order of the veggie Stromboli served with a side of marinara sauce. We were in heaven, we were so stuffed by the time we were done with lunch, a trip to O Sole Mío never disappoints. read more

See all

From the minute you walk in to the door you are greeted with smiles , the staff can't do enough for you .anything you ask for they accommodate The food is amazing I have never had a bad dinner there , 5 stars read more

Disclaimer: I usually do not like eating out for Italian food. This is a cute Italian spot in LI with so many options. It took me a while to choose what I wanted because of the sheer number of options to choose from. The starter bread may have been the best part- they gave us flatbreads, garlic knots, and something else I can't recall. As for my main dish, I ended up getting the parpadelle, which was delicious BUT I thought it was very very salty. Portion sizes were huge, so I had some leftovers for the next day. I would come back with a big group, but not sure if I would come for a date night. read more

Crowded and crazy but worth the trip. The food is excellent and the service is top notch. Surprisingly delighted by their espresso martinis. read more

This is a solid place to stop for a slice before or after (or both tbh) seeing a movie at the AMC in the same shopping center. The pizza is hot and crispy and good. The seating is terrible but it's not like you're going to be there all that long. Would take a dinner to go but would not dine in because it's very cramped. read more

O Sole Mio - Assortment of slices - Pizza Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

An old favorite. Casual, modern decor, friendly, efficient service and good food. Sorry, no pics this time. I recommend this restaurant enjoy! read more

This place is ALWAYS great for families, and date night. We've come here for years, love it!! read more

Came here for lunch and got a grandma and a grandma with breadcrumbs. This is not my first time having O Sole Mio--the catering has been a staple parties for years. Was a little disappointed with this visit. The slices were barely heated up, leaving some parts cold. The breadcrumbs slice was also a little bit gaggy and the regular grandma was just okay. read more

O Sole Mio - Grandma Slice - Pizza Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

Truthfully was one of the best Alfredo sauces I've ever had. The freshness of the pasta mixed with the creamy sauce was an amazing combination. This place is one of my wife and I's favorites and they never disappoint. read more

O Sole Mio - Pasta Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

This place has amazing food. Great customer service recommend this place. welcomes you like family. Absolutely amazing staff. Definitely recommend that place. If you love Italian food, this is the place to go. read more

Have been here a few times and it is convenient. Today we came for lunch. Both my husband and I ordered sandwiches. The bread was really hard and was like day old bread. Hard to believe after they had severed us amazing rolls prior to our meal. I brought this to the waiters attention. He told be that paninis are always served on hard bread. They did not apologize or try to make things right. read more

Love this place! Had my usual chicken parm, with whole wheat penne pasta, and tartufo. Can't go wrong! The servers are wonderful. Food is served quickly. Great place to go for food with family or friends read more

O Sole Mio - Tartufo - Pizza Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

See all

We used to enjoy dining here a couple of years ago, but our recent visit was very disappointing. The quality of the food has noticeably declined. The sauce tasted bland--like it came straight from a can of tomato sauce and the shrimp bisque was lacking real seafood flavor and seemed the soup was just tomato soup with some shrimp and spinach tossed in last minute. My husband ordered the veal with capers and lemon garlic sauce. While the portion was very small 2 thin slices the flavor just didn't justify the $30 price tag. Overall, the food felt mediocre and uninspired. Service was okay, but not enough to make up for the underwhelming meal. For a $135 dinner for two, we expected much better. Sadly, the restaurant has changed--and not for the better. We won't be returning. Let me know if you'd like it to sound more casual, more critical, or a little softer in tone. read more

Forgive my semi-belated review of O Sole Mio. It has nothing to do with the place not being tasty and enjoyable, but rather that my Yelping has gotten more sporadic lately, and for that I apologize. You see, my trip to this tasty Italian spot happened back at the beginning of 2023, but the flavors are still fresh in my mind. To be honest, my first experience with Mio was rather mixed. We (my wife and I) had purchased a Too Good to Go deal with them and found a box of meh slices of pizza. Nothing was terrible, but nothing was that great either (hence the leftovers feel of TGTG). I'd probably have waited a lot longer to return here, but the wifey got a gift card from her job for O Sole and so we decided why not give them another (fresher) shot. We did just that on a semi-bustling Thursday night in January. The interior of O Sole Mio isn't vast or exotic, but they have a bright and vibrant theme at play which does enough to liven up their space. Perhaps they aren't vast in size because they save that for their menu. O Sole has plenty of Italian dishes to choose from with many of them sounding like unique and potentially original options. Case in point would be the Pollo Mona Lisa (my order choice). This took chicken and rolled/stuffed it with prosciutto, provolone and mozzarella cheese. It was then lightly breaded, fried and served in a pink cream sauce. Flavorful stuff for sure with the cream sauce potentially being my favorite part of the dish. The wife went more simple and had chicken Francese which I tried a piece of and found it to be tender and a bit tangy as it should be. Pasta also came with these dishes on the side which was a nice touch, as was the bread basket and olive oil dipping plate (with actual olives in it). I'd say the food as a whole was near a five star spot with service coming in a little behind that. Our waiter was totally nice, though not really present once the food was ordered. And the price of things? Not horrible, but also not necessarily cheap either. I'm glad we had a gift card to take a tiny portion of the total bill down. Overall, O Sole Mio is worthy of a trip, gift card or not. Perhaps their pizza is better than we initially experienced (we'll have to give it a genuine try), but either way, if you're looking for some quality Italian food in a semi-cozy and colorful spot then O Sole Mio won't steer you wrong. And now that everyone knows this, I should probably stop writing this review and go work on some other belated ones! read more

See all

Food is always good, the service is hit and miss but never bad. they're just busy and what's to be expected in a busy place. ambiance is good.. read more

My first time trying O Sole Mio and unfortunately it was a rather poor experience. Pros: - Food was tasty. - Plenty of parking since it is in a strip mall. - Great packaging for takeout. There was a good amount of sauce with our order and if it was packed differently, it could have resulted in a big mess in my car. Kudos to whomever wrapped my order! Cons: - Food was pricy! -- $26.99 for just (6) Butternut Squash Ravioli - Takeout quality was sub-par. -- Butternut squash felt either doughy or slightly undercooked. - Prices on website are inaccurate. -- Website say the butternut squash is $24.99, I was charged $26.99 and would have never known it was incorrect unless I had checked and called them to confirm this. - Pickup/Counter area is tight and disorganized. All this being said, I don't want to knock them completely based on my first impression. My wife loves getting their butternut squash ravioli for lunch (4 pieces at $13.99) and perhaps our experience would have been much different if we dined in. Don't think I'd order dinner takeout from here again... but I'd be willing to give them another shot for lunch or a sit-down. read more

See all

I ordered pizza on door dash. When the delivery got to they forgot the pizza. When I called O Sole Mio they were trying to get another DoorDash to deliver the pizza. So because time went by I went to pick up my pizza which now sat on top of the oven for over 45 minutes due to someone's negligence. Instead of making me a new pie they just handed me a pizza which was cold when I got it home. I get they were busy but the least they could have done was make a new pie. I hope o sole mio makes this right. read more

The best pizza! I've tried a wide variety of their specialty pizzas and they all have a thin crust, flavorful sauce, and generous amount of cheese. My personal favorite from O Sole Mio are the salad pizzas. The chicken caesar is phenomenal and contains grilled chicken. It is filling and has the perfect ratio of salad to pizza crust. The service at the front is quick and they offer an option to warm up the pizzas. There are a few tables to sit inside if you pick up food from the front area, but they can be challenging to find unoccupied. I typically enjoy my meal in the outside seating area. read more

O Sole Mio - Greek Salad Slice - Pizza Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

See all

Always have a delicious meal when I come here & it's always crowded with ppl. This time, I went around 9pm & it was empty so I decided to have a reg slice with a small cheese stick & small spinach pocket. All were good only wish the pizza was crispier on the bottom. I did ask him to leave it in the oven longer since I figured it was sitting out for a bit but it definitely wasn't long enough because it was still soft on the bottom but it was hot. They did have many choices of pies to choose from so I'm sure you'll find something to your liking. The staff were all friendly as usual which is always a plus. One last thing, that was a huge plus for me, they had a self serve large cold glass water dispenser infused with orange & lemon slices on top of the counter, oh so good & refreshing!!!! Give it a try if you haven't already! read more

O Sole Mio - #1 Ziti, Ravioli, Stuffed Shell and Manicotti Combo = Delicious!!! It's a large dish, great for sharing and/or great for leftovers! - Pizza Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

Dropped in here for a dinner on Monday: The good: 1.Great Italian waiter 2.The sauces on all our dishes were literally great including a bright tomato sauce that might be GOAT. The truffle cream sauce was really good and light 3.$21 bottle of wine special 4. Complimentary breads to begin dinner Dislikes: Portions way too big The atmosphere was a little too bright for Italian, but that could be me. read more

Been going there since they opened menu got very pricy service is good food is good . read more

O Sole Mio - Pizza Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

Great food, great menu, fair prices and friendly staff. Both the pizza and kitchen fare are top notch.

Victor, Sal and all of the waiters make you feel like family at this neighborhood pizza and pasta restaurant. The salads are fantastic if you are not looking to load up on carbs and they can substitute zoodles for pasta. However, if that's the case, let them know because the bread basket they bring you is irresistible. They also have a full bar and make delicious desserts and coffee. this is not to be missed! read more

Last night my wife and I got takeout. We got two soups and two chicken cutlets Parmesan hero's. Each hero's were 27 dollars each that's unbelievable crazy. Both chicken cutlets hero's were horrible and cold. The chicken cutlets were hard and no sauce on the hero's. The soups were ok. But nothing to write home about. It's not the first time we got cold takeout from them. But the price for the hero's is not right. Over 60 dollars for two soup and two hero's. It's unacceptable !!! read more

Nice seating area for take out orders but kind of disappointed with the food which in the past has always been great. First, our slices weren't heated up enough it we felt bad asking to put our bitten slices back into their oven. Second, the grandma and breadcrumb slices were borne salty and greasy. Not sure if I'll come back again. Sad. read more

O Sole Mio - Pizza Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

I have been here a few times and have always enjoyed whatever I order. I usually go for something in the case like a calzone, roll ups or specialty pie. Grandma is my favorite. We have also ordered pizza to take home a few times. No complaints, always need 2 pies. I like to heat my pizza in oven when i bring it home for the extra crispy. The staff have always been nice to me and the place is clean. read more

So good and the atmosphere is terrific. Our friends brought us here and just walking in I knew I would love. Great energy. Can't wait to return. read more

I never like leaving reviews like this but I need to share what happened to me so no one else has to go through what I'm going through. I've been so severely sick for days since having their salad slice for lunch four days ago. I would not point fingers if I didn't know for certain it was from here, but their food was the only food I had ate that day. My family ordered lunch to stay and dinner to go from here the same day, all different things, and I did not have breakfast or any other meals that day. The food is good (when you're eating it), the vibe is always nice and busy there, I never thought something like this would happen. I am now on antibiotics twice a day with nausea pills with the need for additional testing. Bacteria infection and/or parasites. I don't want to embarrass myself with the details of my symptoms but it's been days of consistent pain, discomfort, dehydration, nausea etc. Please avoid the salad pizzas at all costs, also had buffalo chicken slice. I'm never eating here again personally. Thankfully my family who had a fresh regular pie were fine. read more

This place is so good. Service is always excellent. Place is clean and not too loud. Authentic Italian food. If it was closer, I would go every week! Farfelle del sole is my favorite with the addition of mushrooms! Love the bread on the table with the olive oil sauce for dipping. read more