We were in the area and stopped at Walmart, but decided on a quick slice. We never know what to expect at a pizzeria. First impression, clean and counter people were friendly and welcoming. We were impressed to see a hot food bar and noticed many people came in just for that. I just had a regular slice and my husband had a slice with Meatballs. We were very impressed. Not a lot of grease came from the cheese on the pizza, it was excellent flavor and it was a solid slice, it didn't flop - a nice crunch to the crust. They have fountain soda coke products (bonus for me) or bottled drinks. If we lived in the area, we would absolutely come here for pizza and to try the dinners. Prices are also reasonable. read more

See all

Great pizza, great variety, kind service! Shop looks cute but we did takeout so no comment on the ambiance. read more

Ordered pizza and wings for a school party. Set a delivery time for 2 pm when I ordered around 10 am. Ordered 4 pizzas a 5 dozen wings. School ends at 2 pm which is when we started the party. No pizza. 2:10 pm we call and staff says, "It's the holidays" and states delivery is on its way. Delivery finally arrives at 2:30 pm. The driver says, "I'm just the driver" when confronted with the late delivery. Also, there were 2 paper plates included with the order. I called to express my displeasure with the late arrival of the order since we had to clean up and finish the meeting around 2:45 - 2:50 pm. I was told by one person they would make it up to me 'on a future order'. I was then passed to a 'manager' who when I expressed my displeasure of having late food delivery and no paper plates that a manager would speak to me the next day. I said I expected a phone call from the manager to discuss the issue. I was told, "That's not how it works" The students were ok with the pizza but the wings had to be the smallest wings any of us have ever seen. They were half the size of what we expected. Students were ok with them, but not overly impressed. Final verdict: Food was 'aigh't' in the words of the students. Delivery time was not acceptable. Concern from the staff was non-evident. Next time we have a party will take our business elsewhere. read more

We came here to grab a couple of slices late because we had just gotten in after a long flight and we're heading to our hotel. The staff were super friendly! He told us what each of the various kinds of pizza were and they had some interesting pizzas. We went with the classic Sicilian and then something I think they called a Brooklyn slice? They were both very, very tasty!! I wish we had more space to try some of the other things. It's not a place you come for the ambiance but it's clean and fine. If we are ever in Ronkonkoma again, we will come back for more pizza here!! read more

The food is great, the service is friendly and fast and the price is a good place is always clean, always enjoy stopping in for a slice, but they have so much more read more

This is my favorite place to get pizza on the island! The pizza is consistently good. I'm from Cali but make sure I hit this place every time I'm in town read more

Uber eats date: December 31, 2022 I probably spent too much money on uber eats deliveries in one night but I was staying by myself in a hotel with my son for a mini new years eve vacation and I don't like McDonald's so after I ordered my son some nuggets I found an eggplant hero from La Slice. I also got my son a few drink options he's 6 so they were just different soda options and an iced tea. I don't know if it was supposed to be an eggplant parm hero or an eggplant hero that I ordered. If it was the eggplant hero that is my fault if it was supposed to be an eggplant parm hero it could have used a heck of a lot more cheese. Besides being mildly upset about the lack of cheese which may or may not have been my fault the hero was decent and I had half for dinner and half for lunch the next day. read more

Most of the staff is very nice, except for one guy with glasses who is consistently rude and has screwed up my order more than once. I was coming here because it's convenient to my office. Not anymore. The last few times I've ordered over the phone, my order was wrong (thanks guy with glasses), not ready on time, and just plain awful. Like, really bad. I ordered baked ziti; it had about a tablespoon of sauce on top, not mixed in. Basically dry pasta with a tiny amount of cheese. I ordered it again hoping it was a mistake, and specifically asked for extra sauce. The receipt even says "extra sauce". Same thing. It looks like they stirred a spoon from the sauce pot in the pasta to coat it and that's it. The food is pretty much inedible. I wouldn't even feed it to my dog. And if I tried I doubt she'd eat it. Probably the only reason they're in business is because there's no where else to eat in the area besides Panera. read more

It's literally backed up to my truck yard. So super convenient to grab something after work & keep it moving. Completely renovated, they upped the ante by adding Spanish Food & Jamaican Patties in addition to the regular pizzeria menu. I will admit I was a bit skeptical because of the hodge podge of so many different dishes. Buuuuuut this last visit opened my mind & proved to me they could do all dishes well. Bravo La Slice! My son & I thoroughly enjoyed our pasta dishes. Worth a visit if you're in the area. And the customer service is exceptional. Always friendly & smiling whenever I come in and always accommodating to any order changes. 8-21-20 read more

See all

I'm shocked I haven't reviewed this place sooner. The service is friendly and accommodating every single time. The food is on point and perfect every time I've been there. The atmosphere is upbeat and fun. This is not a quiet place. Music is usually playing and their food and service draws a crowd. Good things usually do, so keep that in mind! They have huge slices, specialty slices, and a gigantic case of hot dishes to choose from. I personally have not tried the the stuff in the case, but every time I come I swear I will the next time I'm there. It looks so good!!! I love their salads, and their grandma slices and garlic knots. There is something about the chicken on the Caesar salad slice. It's out of this world. I have never had chicken that's seasoned better. Trust me when I tell you, it's delicious. Not dry, not hard. It's juicy and perfect. I always have to get an extra side of their home made dressing too. It's so good! The guys that run this place are so friendly and chill. They have booths and tables for seating, as well as some high top seating along the windows. I believe they have seating outside in the nicer weather as well. The food is consistent too, which is important, as well as the service. I have never had a bad experience or meal here. I highly recommend. Check them out, you won't be disappointed! read more

been going for the past week working close in the area very good food very service from, lilly, kalie, and eddie very good food and folks recommend to swing by!. read more

It's in a bit of a tight spot next to Walmart, but the food is well worth it. It is the best grandma pizza I've ever had very nice friendly atmosphere. People behind the counter are extremely nice. The food in general is exceptional. read more

Pathetic. You are not god. Don't sign up for too good to go if you aren't going to adhere to the rules. Your employee watched me slide the green arrow across to confirm the pickup. You decided that you needed to impress your staff and act like an A** HOLE. Just remember when the 2 couples walked out after me and asked why you were yelling I told them the truth. And they were disgusted with your SH** attitude. Congrats. You just lost 3 households as customers. And I hope you lose more. Guess what pal. Your sh*t does stink read more

I love it here. I could honestly stop there and be content with this review. HOWEVER, I know that would not get you out of the house and over to this divine destination which we humbly refer to as La Slice. Let's start with the employees. The staff are always attentive, friendly, efficient with their time management, and ready to give a recommendation if you're stuck. Their energy and enthusiasm is infectious. Now, on to THE FOOD. I've yet to be disappointed. The pizza always has a necessary crisp to its crust and base which my heart appreciates. The ever so slight hint of sweetness in the sauce will brighten your day and the generosity of the cheese ... a blessing. The garlic knots are also dependable and delectable - with or without marinara. Get you some ASAP. read more

My son and his friends had a great time today at La Slice. We celebrated his bday there and Dave, the manager, was more than accommodating. Highly recommend. Great service and the best pizza I've had in a long time. read more

La Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Islandia, New York

See all

Best pizza great service. Clean place . Very fresh pizza and pasta. Friendly service . I recommend this to all the pizza lover . They also serve ethnic Spanish food . read more

Great food, reasonable price, fast service! It was also conveniently located in a shopping area, so it was a great experience!

Got vodka rigatoni, my boyfriend got vodka angel hair. Both came with a side salad, bread and desert. The pasta was very good, saucy, and worth the money. The salad was also delicious and had a very good Italian dressing. The bread was bland- was hoping it was garlic bread but it was just regular bread, but my boyfriend enjoyed it with his pasta. Now to the desert.... I chose a cannoli and let's say... i don't think you could call it that. The filling is pasty, chalky, not good flavor, and runny. The crust itself is fine but I think something went wrong while making it. The cheesecake was fine though. For 12.00 it's a good deal, just the cannoli needs improvement. The delivery driver went the extra mile to come to my apartment door which I appreciate because I put in the instructions they could call and I would go outside since it was 9:00pm and my apartment complex is confusing. read more

La Slice Pizzeria - Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Islandia, New York

See all

Stopped by this pizzeria for a quick bite to eat after my boyfriend got an MRI next door. They offer a nice selection of pizza pie flavors but the taste just wasn't there. I ordered a buffalo chicken slice and a regular slice. The buffalo chicken was too heavy on the cheese and there wasn't even enough sauce on it. I did enjoy the taste of the chicken but it left a lot to be desired overall. The regular slice was simply meh, I could barely get any flavor out of it at all. The place itself is cute, they have a small counter and a good amount of tables inside where you can sit and eat. Nice staff as well! read more

See all

I was craving Cesar salad and desserts because it's Sunday and I wanted to treat myself! I found this pizzeria and called them to see if they could deliver to me since I'm in Sayville I wasn't sure if it would be too far considering they're in islandia. I had spoken to another pizza place in islandia and they said it was too far. The guy I spoke to on the phone here said it was no problem ! He was super sweet and nice and funny and took my order. Very accommodating! Their Cesar salad dressing is also homemade! A lot of places use store bought dressing so that is a major plus. Highly recommend this pizzeria they made my day by taking my order. Whoever took my order and if you see this you are awesome! Thank you!!!! **UPDATE*** Delivery driver was so friendly! I tipped him extra for coming to Sayville. Cesar salad is DELICIOUS. I also order zeppoles omg amazing. Same kind you get when you go to the fair! Cheesecake is delicious as well. My new go to. I work in islandia and we order pizza every Friday... this is going to be our new go to place! read more

Here's the Scoop: Stopped in for a quick bite while shipping out some orders and got a regular slice. Sat in a booth. Lighting for the afternoon was low. The service was friendly. The slice was tasty and a nice size. There were several choices in the display case but I felt like a regular. Crust perfect crunch and sauce not too acidy. I enjoyed my slice and it hit the spot. Menu had a lot to offer in sandwiches, entrees and specialty pizzas. Next time I will try one of their specials. Look for my update. read more

See all

the best mac and cheese slice on the island is HERE! they have a nice selection of specialty slices but mac& cheese is my absolute favorite. the location is so convenient, the store is always clean, the staff is super polite and professional. read more

La Slice Pizzeria - Mac & Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Islandia, New York

Food is good. Lots to choose from. Place is clean and very inviting. At times its pretty busy, but there is a good reason. Worth the wait. read more

La Slice Pizzeria - Food display - Pizza Near Me - Islandia, New York

Friendly environment.. clean locations always delicious no matter what we order and always on time. Thanks La Slice read more

The grandma slice was large and delicious! The plain slice was bland and boring with a nice crisp crust. All in all I'm not going out of my way, but I'd stop in for the grandma slice if I needed to hit the nearby Walmart on an empty stomach or something. read more

La Slice Pizzeria - Bad plain, great grandma - Pizza Near Me - Islandia, New York

Wow! Nice job ruining the pie delivery driver And I tipped him for this? So disappointed read more

La Slice Pizzeria - Half BBQ Chicken and Half Mushroom/Ham Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Islandia, New York

Hands Down, They Have The Best Sausage, Pepper & Onion Rollup.. It Truly Is Perfect..

Catered twice from here and have sat and ate inside more than a handful of times! Staff is very nice and they have GREAT food. Catering is so easy with them. The food is amazing. Had a party this past weekend and everyone raved about the food. Highly recommend here! read more

This place was recommended by the front desk at the hotel where we stayed in Islandia. She said they had a special on Monday nights where you get an entree, salad and dessert. We walked over and found it in the shopping center. At first glance, it doesn't look like much. Small dining area and looks like mostly take out pizza. The hot food bar looks a little scary, but we asked if they made food to order? They said they make everything on the menu to order. The folks working there were super friendly. We ordered the fettucine alfredo and baked ziti. They came with salads, cheesecake and hot bread. The portions were enormous and we could not eat all the food we got. Lots of people were coming in and getting pizza which looked good. We went back to the hotel and they asked how it was. We said too much food and she said that is why she goes there. She has enough food for multiple meals. Don't judge this place by your first impression. The food was good and the service was friendly. Next time, we know to share the dinners!!! read more

The entire staff was incredibly nice and friendly and the slice was great!!! This was a great accidental find read more

La Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Islandia, New York

Bro you're stupid if you don't come here. Cheap, friendly and delicious. Love it here

The food was outstanding and the service was great. Highly recommend this place if you want great pizza

I'd like To be able to give them a 4.5! This was a really pleasant experience! So, I used to go to a place that had a calzone they called the "Frank Sinatra". It was filled with baby clams, ricotta, mozzarella and garlic. I've been calling around and asking restaurants and pizzerias if they would make one on request. The answer over and over again is usually, NO. The answer took awhile, in fact the kind young gentleman that answered the phone had go go back and check.... In the process we were disconnected and I figured that that was that.... Nope. He called me back! And added that they'd be happy to give it a shot and throw together such a combination. About 20 minutes later, I drove over and they were just taking it out of the oven. Now they could have spread the ingredients around a little better before sealing this up; but, this was delicious! I consumed EVERY bite. Awesome job here! I especially liked their can do attitude! read more

Don't Bother, Walk Away!!! We ordered over 45 pizzas and sodas for a in-work luncheon The pizzas were delivered 30 minutes late, when we got them, they were barely warm. LaSlice didn't provide enough soda for all the employees -(delivered 3 bottles of soda for over 150 employees) after complaining they delivered the soda after the luncheon was over. Needless to say my boss wasn't impressed. No one enjoyed the pizza (probably because it was cold) and then to add insult to injury - they had nothing to wash it down. When I called to complain, I received a lame excuse - they said they were 'too busy' that was why the order was late This was a total disaster My advice - Pass on LaSlice! read more

So disappointed, the menu I was given states Sunday either Sicilian or grandma pizza $15.99. Went to pick it up, also sign in the window states the same. Price was more and when we asked why, the girl said, oh we didn't take the sign out of the window. Sounds like false advertising to me. read more

It was good when it first opened but after they had a fire it seems they went with a different crew, mostly kids that don't know what they are doing read more

The best pizzeria around! They always are fully stocked with speciality slices and the food never disappoints. Must try the chicken, bacon, ranch pie and the chipotle chicken! The slices are huge!Their pasta special on Monday's is also amazing and a great deal :) read more

La Slice Pizzeria - Chicken Bacon Chicken Ranch Pie Slice - Pizza Near Me - Islandia, New York

Been here a few times and they never disappoint. This time had chicken parm slice, pepperoni slice, regular slice, and garlic knots. Garlic knots are super garlicky. Fast and friendly service, ample seating and food is fresh. Takes cash and credit. Will definitely return. Plain slice is very very good read more

La Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Islandia, New York

Today I visited La Slice Pizzeria at 1826 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Islandia, NY 11749 while doing my Morning Show on i495 Radio. Julia saved the day with just a few simple words as I was walking out the door. She was not even helping me and was busy with another customer....yet she still took the time to make me feel like my business mattered. Congratulations Julia... you are an asset to La Slice!! read more

La Slice Pizzeria - www.i495RADIO.com - Pizza Near Me - Islandia, New York

I had pizza here while in L.I. It was very good, the sicilian slices were very tasty. The place had a big crowd and the service was prompt and friendly. read more