I have been to Slice House Toms River several times. I really like it. This pizzeria on 37 has enough room for casual eat in after counter ordering. SH does a large takeout and delivery business as well as the store ordering. Parking is easy out front. The place is clean and service is good. It is a bustling place at times with young people running the front. The pizzeria boasts many, many selections of by the slice as well as a menu of pies to order whole. Lots of add ins and drinks both bottled and fountain style. The pizza is tasty. It is served hot. I especially like a cheese pie but found their specialty pies like the cheesesteak & chicken parm pizza delicious also. The cheesesteak in particular tastes like a breakfast pizza due to its cheese, cheesesteak that is seasoned like sausage and it's white cheese sans sauce. It would be over the top great with sautéed onions, mushrooms and green peppers on it. The chicken parm with red sauce and chunks of chicken with yummy cheese is also tasty. They have salads, Stromboli, sandwiches, garlic knots etc to add on. I really like the entree Caesar salad. The dressing is good and the lettuce is fresh. It comes with toasty bread. I will continue to frequent this quintessential Toms River pizzeria as it checks all the boxes read more

See all

Friendly service, I think this is my new favorite spot when I am in the area! They have a to go menu with coupons you have to ask for if you don't get it. The eggplant parm is made fresh and delicious! they have an assortment of pizzas too. Garlic knots are also my favorite from them one of the things I definitely judge a pizza place on. Stop by get a slice! read more

Get real pepperoni. disappointed with the pepperoni used. Picked them all off to eat pizza which wasn't that good as well.

Finally a place to grab a good slice while you wait, and wait for your loved one to be discharged from Community Medical. Plain slice is meh BUT the Sicilian is delicious and the hot honey pepperoni is no joke, deliciously hot! Staff is friendly and knowledgeable about their wide selection of slices. So take the short drive and grab a slice while you wait for that discharge order! read more

See all

Heard great things about the Slice House. Decided to give them a shot on our way into town. Despite being only 30min till closing time, they had a good selection of pizza slices. We tried the Grandma Thin Square with pepperoni cups, fresh basil, and hot honey. Also did the burrata cheese, hot honey, and vodka sauce with sesame seed crust. Not sure how long these slices were hanging around but they heated up moist and delicious. Place is cute, clean and very functional for dining in. Service at the counter was polite and friendly. Can't wait to come back and try a fresh pie. read more

Slice House - Grandma Thin Square - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Bright, clean and busy describes this plaza-bound pizzeria with a small dining area. The staff clearly is busy (Saturday afternoon)). As noted elsewhere, there are lots of slice options for those walking in. We ordered the "Gold Pesto" pie and a side salad. Opening the box was a delight! This pizza looks and smells awesome!! The first bite verified what we were looking at and smelling. This is one very good pizza!! Now, the menu says the side salad comes with Ranch dressing suggested so we assumed it would come with Ranch but not comes with Italian. Some menu clarification is needed but definitely a nice mix of greens that were cool and crisp. Very happy with tonight's decision. read more

See all

I heard about this place from someone and I've been passing it since I moved here 2 months ago. Yesterday I had a doctors appointment close by and on my way to the gym I was looking for it and sure enough it was on my way. I pulled in and there was no parking. Apparently a bunch of law-enforcement decided to eat there right at the time I was going there. Thanks for your service! The young woman at the counter was very nice and very helpful. I was looking at all the specialty pies, but I wanted to keep it light. I've been trying to sample different pizzerias around the area to test their plain Neapolitan slice in comparison. I ordered a slice and ate it standing up while admiring all the delicious looking specialty pies that look like works of art. I'm sorry, but I can't recall what they were called, but I will definitely be back. The place has a very friendly atmosphere, I believe the owner was describing some of the pies to me. The plane slice itself was OK. The crust, taste and texture were all good. It was a little runny and a little loose towards the point otherwise though it would stack up to most plain slices anywhere, but I will definitely be back. read more

See all

I don't know why I asked for a thin crust. Well done pizza pie and the cheese still slid off this greasy mass

This place has awesome NY pizza and friendly service! Pizza crust is thin and everything tastes very fresh! There is a full lunch and dinner menu or you can order pizza by the slice. Plain slices are about $2 each and specialty slices are $4.15. I had both the plain cheese and diablo (pepperoni with hot honey) and they are delicious! Their Diablo has converted me to hot honey pizza! I want hot honey on all my pizza now! Slice House is a great spot to grab a quick bite! Wish I had come back to try their other pizzas before I left town. read more

Slice House - Specials Menu - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Pizza was a delicious thing crust. The staff was friendly and efficient. Pizza was ready quick!

Great pizza options and extremely friendly staff. Take out was complete fast and hot. Will definitely be back.

Good food. Caesar salad was yummy. Love the garlic knots. Subs are delicious. Easy ordering and ready on time.

Had a NY style pan pie with pepperoni (I love that they give you a choice between "regular" pepperoni and the cup-style; there is obviously only one right answer to that...) Just an excellent pizza. The flavors were just right on point, both for the sauce, cheese, and crust. It seems like they might sprinkle some parmesan on the edges and brush with butter before baking? If that's the case, it works great... Overall a 9/10 pizza; they only thing that could've brought it to a perfect 10/10 was if the crust in the center of the pizza had just a bit more crisp. read more

Slice House - NY style pan pie with pepperoni (cupping style) - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

We are big fans of this place. This is the best and freshest slice counter I've experienced in the whole area. The smash burger can be easily missed on the menu.. do not make that mistake. This burger is right up there with Burger 25 for my locals! Super fresh, great portion nestled between a toasted potato bun. Make sure you try the home made honey mustard as well! read more

Slice House - Double Smashburger with side salad - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

We had the burrata slice. Oh my God! Literally THE best pizza I've ever had in about 40 years. I talked to the owner and told him that the pizza blew me away. Got a few other slices to go to try them out. We also got some zeppole's to go. Those were so freaking fresh and so delicious. We are only going to this place for pizza for now on. read more

Amazing pizza with lots of topping! The service and staff are excellent. Best to eat in so you get optimum crust crunch! And, the stuffed zepoles were insane! Pricey but very good! read more

Since moving to South Jersey, we have found so many great restaurants overall as well as no complaints on pizza till now.............. What a waste of $$, as sometimes you just want to stick to what you know and not take the risk of disappointment, but we decided to try a different pizzeria each month for our first year here. We are on #8 but maybe after this experience it`s time to stop. Bottom line and best part, were the girls on the phone were lovely. We ordered "A Special" (Pepperoni, Sausage, Red Onion, Peppers & Mushroom) we usually love that, although normally we would rather Kalamata Olives than the Mushrooms, but we didn`t want to ask for anything different, let's not take the chance. We also ordered a Cold Antipasto & 6 Zeppolis, but let's just talk Pizza & move on. We knew opening the box it wasn`t going to be good, as the crust had that undercooked look. There was no ( and I hate using the word) BURNT spots, let alone any of the beautiful bubbles to be found. What we found was a undercooked loaded pizza, that once we attempted to pick up, all the toppings fell right off, and our finger went right through the crust, SERIOUSLY. Normally after we order we eat a slice or 2 each and wrap the rest, 2 slices for the fridge (makes a great breakfast the next day) and the rest in the freezer. This one was sadly thrown out!!!! read more

They have such a great selection of pizza and I love that you can get it by the slice! My favorite was the white pizza! We also got the drunken Sicilian which was good too, very cheesy! I wish the buffalo chicken had a bit more saucyness to it, but the flavor was good. I do have to give a shoutout to their boneless wings because they were the best I've had in a while! read more

See all

Glad I came across them. Wasn't sure what I was in the mood for so got a variety. Glad I did. Fresh out the oven, the vodka sauce one was so good. Buffalo is always high on my lists. The one with tomato was amazing then and the best one the day after. read more

Slice House - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Moved to Toms River in the Fall 2024 & Slice House became my "Go To" place for consistently delicious pizza. I have tried others in the area and none have come close. When eating in at their shop, the service da been great! Highly Recommend! read more

2nd time here and the food is so good. Tonight felt like a salad night and the Cobb with added grilled chicken hit the spot! The staff is also so nice read more

Slice House - Cobb salad with grilled chicken, red onions and honey mustard on the side. - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

We love the drunken grandma pie! It's a Vodka sauce pie that's to die for! So glad we found this place!

I had this place on my radar for almost a year. It's about 45 minutes away and was well worth the ride! Their NY Style Pan Pie with added pepperoni cups was outstanding. I also really wanted to try their Diablo Pan Pie. The owner actually heard me talking about it and gave me a fresh slice on the house - it was without a doubt one of the best slices I've ever had - and I consider myself a pizza snob. Everything about it was absolutely delicious... their bone in wings are also top notch. I would probably drive back just for those. I can't wait to go back and try some more of their pies. They have a really vast array. The staff was also very friendly. You should run to try this place! read more

Slice House - NY Style Pan Pie with Pepperoni Cups - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

We asked if they could do a tomato pie lol I think the girl was a little confused as to what a tomato pie was , but the pizza was still very very good. Will definitely be back. read more

Slice House - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Just had the Diablo pizza and it was excellent - spicy for sure but super tasty. We've never tried hot honey before, and oh boy it is definitely a treat. Who knew? We also ordered the rice balls, which were perfectly crunchy on the outside and proper consistency on inside. My only small critique is that it was a little heavy handed on the basil, but if you're a fan of pesto, you'll love them. Picked up our order, which was ready exactly on time and appreciated. We will absolutely return, especially to try other variations as their crust is fantastic. We are picky about pizza and these people know what they're doing. read more

Another great Sicilian Pie from these place. This time with meatballs also their subs are off the chain. If you haven't been there you don't know what you're missing. read more

Slice House - Slice house Meatball Sicilian. - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Stopped in while in the area after reading the great reviews & SO GLAD I did. Had a thin square slice with pepperoni cups and hot honey that was AMAZING!!!!!!!! Also had The Chop salad with grilled chicken (add on) and it was HUGE!!!! I also liked that they give you more than enough dressing but its on the side (without asking) as you can add as much of it as you want. Will DEFINITELY come back when local again for sure!!! read more

Amazing thin crust pizza! Very good vodka sauce as well! Everyone at the restaurant was very friendly and welcoming. read more

Slice House - Vodka chicken parm pie with pesto - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

This might be our new pizza place! Went today for lunch. We got a Diablo slice, Buffalo Chicken, and Sweet Chili.. all 3 were amazing but the stand out was the Diablo slice with the hot honey. We also ordered Teriyaki Garlic wings and a Buffalo Chicken wrap which were amazing as well. The only thing better than the food was the service. We talked in and were greeted by everyone. Its refreshing going into a place and you feel like everyone wants to be there. My wife has a severe allergy and they were beyond accommodating and extremely nice about it. Love this place!! Cannot wait to go back!! read more

Food is good I ordered eggplant parm it was bitter.which I have gotten there before with no complaints. I called the restaurant made it right with no hassles the redelivered the food quickly I have eaten there before would recommend them anytime read more

first customer service is horrible. They have an attitude after I asked if they had anchovies and they said no and for a slice of pepperoni have any ready and wanna wait you know you don't wanna pizzeria are you just shut your door read more

Had the Mikes Square. Was good but the pepperoni n mushrooms were just slung on top like was rushed process. Seems like they could save money by taking a few seconds to properly place toppings. read more

Omg! omg! omg! You have to try the diablo pizza with pepperoni and hot honey. You will thank me. read more

I am obsessed with this place hands down they have the best wings in town. I love the classics and the new trendy slices they make very delicious! I just don't know how they make everything so affordable? Service is always on point and the ambiance is always welcoming and clean. Wether it's game day wings or pie you can't go wrong try them out today! read more

This is become our new favorite place. The Diablo pizza is out of sight very friendly staff. We always get it to go but the place looks very clean. I like the way they make the pizzas. Well done you don't have to coach him highly recommended. read more

Super Bowl Sunday and they let me order in advance. I ordered a large pie two dozen wings and a Cobb salad. I've never ever had a problem here and after today it seems I never will. Whatever the Slice House is doing they're doing it right. From the girl who answers the phone to the guy who delivers the food everyone is top-notch on time polite, respectful. And we have since visited, since our first review and the food, and service was just as good indoors as it has been out read more

Welcome to Slice House! This pizzeria has only been open for four months, but I can see that it will last a long time. First of all, I am a sauce girl. If your pizza sauce isn't good, I don't care what else you put on it. However, this sauce was excellent. I'm pretty sure I could eat it with a spoon if the opportunity was presented. This place is owned by two brothers and they are rocking the pizza world. They use crumbled sausage, which is the only way sausage should be on a pizza in my opinion. But can we please talk about the Burrata slice? Possibly one of the best slices I have ever had. It has tomato sauce, burrata, cherry, tomatoes & sweet roasted garlic. We asked them to drizzle balsamic glaze on top, and it was delicious! They had Zeppole filled with cannoli cream and with Nutella. We had already picked up dessert before going there so I didn't get to try them, but I would be willing to drive an hour back there so that I can get another burrata slice and try those zepolle. Now let's talk about the people. The staff was incredibly friendly, helpful and accommodating. They had some unique slice combinations and they were happy to explain them all. They had a spacious dining area, and it was immaculately clean. I had to make sure it really passed the cleanliness test, so I used their bathroom. Even there, no complaints. We took our food to go, but I definitely would have no problem eating there. Come, give this place a try! read more

See all

Just tried this place got a thin crust pie 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 Broccoli rabe it was loaded No skimping here! so delicious We moved here 7 years ago and the only thing we missed about up north was the pizza! Not anymore! read more

Good Pizza w sausage on time pickup. That's simple but often doesnt happen. I would try other items. read more

People are nice and helpful & it is clean as well. Which that being said the pizza has good taste just needs more crunch on bottom had to put each slice on a pan at home to crisp bottom (lived in nyc & Philly so had great pizza) Now Stromboli was a no for me because it's definitely not like a Philly one, the dough is too soft on outside I'm used to a crunch/ crispy outside way too much cheese & they put sauce on side? Maybe that's a jersey thing idk. Steak wasn't a Philly type cut or flavor. Overall better than other places in NJ but ehh. Very expensive & then all the negatives. read more