Just ordered mozzarella sticks and a chicken parm sub ... mozzarella sticks are over cooked, and the sub is cold. I walked into the place to order and i live less than 2 mins away. NO reason for the food to be cold. First time trying the place and will be my last. Ill stick with Capri read more

My first time trying this pizza and honestly it's one of the best slices I've had in a long time being that the tomato sauce is homemade you can tell that has a light sweet taste the tomato sauce absolutely absolutely 100% recommend to anybody read more

Great pizza. One of my favorite places. I miss the wonderful food since I moved nothing compares.

Had a craving for pizza and this place did not disappoint. Small storefront but plenty of seating even if you want to stop in to enjoy a quick slice. Friendly staff and very quick service! Ordered a variety of slices including the cheesesteak, taco, Buffalo chicken and the margherita. All very good. Each slice had great dough and texture and the toppings on each slice were abundant! I'm not much of a French fry person but I gotta admit they were great! If you love a thicker boardwalk-style fry that has some delicious seasoning on it, it's a must! Will most certainly be coming in again! read more

See all

Quality has definitely gotten worse. Pie topping on barely any slices and peppers weren't event cooked. It's like they threw them on after the pizza was done because they forgot. read more

I like thin pizza and a sweeter sauce.this one hit the spot.next time I will ask for it to be well done.

Called three times just to get the price of a single slice. Young girl answered the first time and hung up in my face when I asked. A young man answered the second time and did the same so I called a third and finally someone answered my question. Very rude for no reason. Completely steered me away from even wanting my slice from there. Terrible customer service. If I could vote negative stars I would. Hope they have the day the deserve. read more

We showed up after closing because the maps had a different time! The owner still served my kid pizza to go and my very tired softball player was very grateful! read more

Pies On Nine - Pizza Near Me - Beachwood, New Jersey

Grandma Pie delicious! Mozzarella sticks delicious...wings delicious and scrumptious too lol all was great, and delivered within expected time and still hot. Thank you And when orders are done in store, staff is hustling and knowledgeable! Thanks again read more

We've ordered out from here a couple times & it's usually ok. Tried their Lucia panini today & after a few bites I just couldn't continue. The portion is huge-enough for 2. Flavor wise it's very bland, greasy & soggy. The bread is too thin & airy therefore it ended up being very soggy & not NOT crisp as a panini should be. The eggplant is fried, rather than grilled (which is a better option for the bread they use) flavorless with balsamic glaze & pesto that made it inedible and just a soft, soggy mess. Fries were good but undercooked & soggy due to the wet pickle being placed right on top Mozzarella sticks were pale in color & also undercooked. Fried mushrooms with the horseradish are always good. Wings & their special cheesesteak were just ok. Lunch for 3 was $90 - not cheap for such disappointment. read more

Nothing more to say....their post says it all. Once the original owners left it went downhill they never made it back. read more

Pies On Nine - This is what happens when you hire drug addicts.....lol - Pizza Near Me - Beachwood, New Jersey

I've had a few things from them before they were so so ,but good for the price just got a Stromboli ugh horrible can't even eat it It's definitely not a Stromboli Filled with mostly cheese, somehow cold !also the dough isnt cooked through still doughy .you can see in the pics the cheese is all clumped together not melted and the pepperoni is all on one place.just poorly put together and not thought out cooking .fairly simple to roll cheese and pepperoni in dough not make a pocket like a calzone. Totally can't eat it Waste of money And you know you can't ask people for your money back so here you go read more

Pies On Nine - Pepperoni & Cheese Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Beachwood, New Jersey

See all

Food is great been ordering since I've moved to Bayville and always ordered $50-$60 or more. Called to order food and girl on phone could be nicer. I had to call and cancel order right after placing it. Won't be ordering from there anymore. read more

Most delicious chicken ceasar wrap ! Not dry like other places around town. Outstanding cauliflower crust pizza. Just wow!!

I would give this place a 4 1/2 if possible, but it isn't. I rounded up because the staff was friendly and the place super clean which is important during COVID more than it normally is. My only complaint is that I didn't much like the consistency of the first. I'm what some would call a "pizza snob" and I guess this place didn't quite meet my expectations of Jersey pizza. Still, the pizza was not bad, it was actually pretty good. It must be a popular place because in the 20-30 minutes I was here I must have saw close to 50 orders go out. If you're looking for a good pizza spot in the area and you like friendly service, definitely check these guys out! read more

Pies On Nine - Outside seating is open, care to join me (from a respectable distance of 6 feet)? - Pizza Near Me - Beachwood, New Jersey

Ordered for take out two pies, one gluten free which was good, the other however was not the pie we ordered, only to notice when we arrived home. We called the store, and we were hassled by employee #1 whom informed us she would take off $7 because THEY got the order wrong, awful response! We live about 4-5 miles from the restaurant and they deliver, would it not have been a more proper response to simply have said, "Our mistake, we will get you out what you ordered right away"? That certainly did not happen and then it just escalated to speaking with a female whom identified herself as "The Manager". She offered absolutely ZERO help and was condescending to say the least so the conversation was relatively short due to her arrogance. We concluded that we'd just dispute the charge with the credit card company and dispose of the pizza that was 100% wrong, how do you wind up with Sausage and Green Peppers when the order was for Pepperoni, Sausage and extra cheese? We just dug the leftovers from the fridge and made due but I can't explain the attitudes we received from two different employees over what they eventually confessed to be an error on their part . . . No, No, No, NEVER again! read more

Pies On Nine - a price list for pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Beachwood, New Jersey

Great spot. Been here a couple times , the food is awesome. Good prices as well. Highly recommend the Veggie Wrap. You get a lot for what you pay for. read more

Pies On Nine - Paisano Salad - Pizza Near Me - Beachwood, New Jersey

See all

My friend got her graduation party food catered from here and when I tell you this was some of the best food I've had. Every single person at the party was saying how good the food was. We couldn't stop eating it all night. I highly highly recommend this place especially for catering!! read more

A very extensive menu with meal options that are all good. Their pies and salads are well prepared and pie toppings that are very generous. Salads are fresh and put together very well. Highly recommend. read more

First off I'm from north Jersey and I lived in Staten Island for awhile which we all know is where the AMAZING food is at! So when I moved down to the Jersey shore I was nervous on how good the pizza was going to be down here. Yet I think I have found a great local spot! The sauce is great! There regular pizza and specialty pies are bomb! Their hero's and wings are delicious! We get our food delivered most of the time and the service is great! Super friendly and pretty good with there estimated time frame! Highly recommend! read more

This place used to be my go to but they must've changed chefs. 2 weeks ago I ordered 2 subs . Small cold one large chicken parm. The chicken parm was small the bread wasn't toasted basically stopped a chicken cutlet on a cold roll which was lousy. Gave it one more chance ordered a baked ziti with sausage. There was no cheese on the ziti basically macaroni with some tomato sauce. This place has become a disaster. Do not order their food read more

By far, this is the best place I've come across to have Great pizza, Great desserts and Amazing people. Haven't been there in a minute but next road im gonna grab my favorite. CHEESESTEAK PIZZA MMM DELICIOUS EVERY TIME. read more

Authentic Italian sauce makes this pizza the best in ocean county! Huge selection of fresh pizza by the slice reasonably priced makes this place really stand out. My daughter loved her plain slice, I had an out of this world Buffalo chicken slice. 5 stars no doubt about it. read more

Love this place. Pizza is great and has the Perfect crust. Ordered with their app and always get a discount. Crazy. Always get a grilled chicken sub it's Bacon. It comes with a bunch of bacon and it's always perfect. Next time I'm trying the garlic bread option. Bacon at some places is often rare or raw and here's its plentiful and perfectly cooked. Will be back forever. read more

Catering was fantastic! Did not bring enough sternos to keep food warm but it didn't matter because the food came piping hot. We ordered cavitelli with broccoli, chicken tenders, garden salad, and chicken franchese. I would definitely cater using Pies on Nine again! read more

Ordered for delivery . Food came quickly . Like the kid that delivered it . Opened my bag to find the burnt end piece of the bread that decided to throw in the bag and think that was ok ! After spending quite enough. Food was good outside of that read more

Looking for the best pizza look no further Pies On Nine has it all. Never disappoints. Pizzas, salads , sandwiches or dinners. Everything is fresh and delicious. Just yesterday I had a margarita pie grandma style, plain and the most delicious white pie with broccoli. Their Melania salad and their mussels are also excellent. I have never been disappointed What makes their food so good is the sauce. When your thinking of Italian food Think Pies on Nine.. Thanks Kathie Fortunato read more

I've been on the Keto Diet for 3 months. Found out they had Cauliflower pizza. The frozen stuff sucks. I gave it a try and man was it amazing. They have the best pizza around and now amazing cauliflower pizza for the Keto Diet people. It's a definite must try. Everytime we order from there I get that for me. Love it!!! read more

Pies On Nine - Cauliflower pizza with Mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Beachwood, New Jersey

Picked up a plain pie on way to friends house to enjoy some pool time. The staff were cheerful and the place looked clean. They even gave me plates and napkins. The pie was a HUGE hit. Sauce was good, crust was perfect and had a nice taste. Wasn't greasy at all. Really enjoyed it. Will definitely be back. Actually making me crave it as I'm writing this review. read more

My family & I have been vacationing in Bayville the past two summers & this is our pizza spot. There's plenty of pizzeria's to choose from in the Bayville area, but this establishment is the top one! I've never had a bad pie from this place & always enjoy whenever we order from here. I highly recommend the grandma's pie, as it has plenty of sauce & very cheesy as well. For people who are gluten free, they have plenty of gluten free pizza to choose from. They also give you a plastic cutting knife with the gluten free pizza so it is not cross contaminated at the place. Also, their buffalo wings are excellent & have a sweet tang to them. I recommend picking up from here as delivery can sometime be awhile, as they are rather busy, especially on the weekends. This is a must have if you're ever in Bayville. read more

Pies On Nine - Buffalo Wings: Pies on Nine, Beachwood Nj - Pizza Near Me - Beachwood, New Jersey

My go to ace whn im running late for dinner and its my turn to cook Pasta dishes are enough for two adults. The pies are literally running out the door. Or just stop in for a slice or 3! read more

They have great pizza but the place is dirty. If I can see dirt on the outside what's the kitchen like. read more

Excellent pizza, Caesar salad, sandwiches and more. Highly recommend. Not you average place. We were very very happy, full and will be back. read more

Their alway a good place to grab a slice of pizza along with other tasty food. The other good part is they are located close to our house that makes it easier to order and go to as well. read more

New ownership or something. Screwed up order twice . And then tried to tell me we got what we asked for. No we didn't ask for meat on the veggie stromboli. read more

If I could give this Grandma pie a - star I would! Still looking for a halfway deviant pizza in Lacey township!

I called at 5 to have my pizzas ready for 7 and they obviously didn't start them till I walked in the building. I was in a rush and expected it to be busy and I can't believe they didn't even start it. Now I get home and the cheese is everywhere on the one pizza with it sliding all over the place. It's not my first problem with them but it sure will be my last! read more

Great food,, good prices, great local delivery service. I have bought so many meals from Pies On Nine and they have never disappointed.

Pizza was above average. But I think you have to go here for speciality pizza. Also the sauce they put on the wings was TERRIBLE. I wanted mild but they named some other sort of sauce and it was like spicy cheesey but it was Gross read more

Pretty decent pizza restaurant. It has good pizza and some creative ideas for pizzas which can turn out good.