If you haven't been to this pizza shop in Silverton since the new ownership took over a little over a year ago, do yourself a favor and check it out, you'll be glad you did! With so many pizza places in the area, it says a lot that this has become my go-to. The quality, flavor, and service have all been elevated, and you can tell they really care about putting out great food. One standout that absolutely deserves a mention is their Birria Pizza. It's unique, insanely delicious, and something you won't find anywhere else around here. If you're in the mood for something different that really hits the mark, this is it. Consistently great pies, friendly service, and creative menu options...this place has earned its spot at the top for me. read more

Unfortunately Verace is under new ownership. They didn't let me know when I ordered over the phone and the pizza was not good. I wish the new owners well however pizza should not be dry and overcooked. No sauce - small pie and very little mozzarella. Will not go back read more

Best pizza in this hands down. Wonderful customer service. Verace's never disappoints!

Always the best came back for a visit was happy to see nothing had changed . Best pizza still in town and the owners are just delightful. Order is always ready fresh and hot and prices are very reasonable it's the best in the area by far! Love this place service is always spot on and the ambiance inside is always super clean always! read more

Best Italian food and variety of pizza to choose. Place by Silverton Pharmacy strip and Jersey Mike's. Pleasant family owned and friendly atmosphere. Take out or eat in area . Definitely recommended by us if you like good Italian menu read more

I went to my go-to sushi place to pick up some lunch, disappointed to find out they've closed until further notice due to COVID-19. Still hungry, I saw that the new pizza shop in the plaza was still open. I was happy to see that they were doing pick up and delivery, so I decided to support them. At the time, I appreciated everyone wearing masks and taking precautionary measures by wearing new gloves when taking credit cards. Ordered two slices of pizza: one white slice with added broccoli and one cheese slice. $3/slice is super reasonable when the slices are pretty big! I took it home to share with my mom, and I wish I got more than just two slices. The pizza was deliciously warmed in their oven, and they added extra cheese to the white slice so that the broccoli stayed on the slice. The cheese slice almost reminded me of dollar slice from NYC, and it made me miss where I was currently located before the situation got worse. I made sure to tip them 75% since I know these are hard times, but I want to make sure they'll still open after the pandemic! I'll definitely be back to try out more local Italian food when I get the chance and the craving. read more

Verace’s Pizza - White Slice with Broccoli; Plain cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I believe there are new owners. My last review did not fare so well for this place. I stopped in this week for an update and I'm glad I did. The pizza is on another level. The dough is the star of the show. Crispy and reminiscent of good Italian bread from up north. I couldn't stop eating it. A follow-up will tell but I may have just found Silverton's new king. Very impressed. read more

My first pizza here was a meat lovers and was terrific than my second one was not so good but my third one was outstanding so everyone can get a one off but this is the place to go, the crust was excellent nice and crispy sauce also excellent as well as the toppings if you're looking for great pizza try them out you won't be disappointed!!! Thank you Verace's!! read more

Must try their off menu pies, very good considering how many pizzarias they have in the area

All I can add is "Birria Pizza, Wow!". Best pizza I've ever had. Will be my pizza of choice from now on.

There are many pizza places all right by each other in the Silverton area. Decided to try Versaces for the first time. First impressions were not great, called in the order for pick up the girl who answered was rushing the order didn't even give a chance to ask for how long or how much before she hung up. But once I went in to pick up the order inside they were very friendly. The pizza was good, definitely preferred the slices with toppings vs plain slices, as the plain was just okay and I've had better in the area. It's nice you can order online as well for convenience but the price is different than calling it in, like most places. They did get a lot of mozzarella sticks with the order (10) but they weren't amazing. We would be back to try other items to give them a chance. Recommend getting sausage on the pie! read more

Verace’s Pizza - Half plain half sausage and peppers - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

The food is good, staff is friendly. A reliable place to order pick up or delivery, or eat in. We're blessed in NJ with good pizza and veraces is one of the good ones! read more

I ordered two trays of chicken parm and chicken francese and both were excellent! You could cut the chicken with a fork and the sauce and seasonings were just right! Super friendly staff and I highly recommend if you are considering catering an event. read more

Best pizza and food in town we use them to cater parties the also made an extremely generous food donation to our Church St. Justin's and everyone raved about the food read more

Great pizza & garlic knots. They are quick but still making it fresh when you order. Inside it's clean & always nice selection of pie slices ready to go. Very friendly too! read more

Pizza is blah. Not anything great. We ordered a spinach stramboli and the literally put the whole spinach plant it it. Very little leaves and all stems. They just cut the root off and put the whole plant in and wrapped it up. Pretty stupid. This place won't survive. Much better pizza places around here like Brooklyn or Denino's. I tried it for the reviews but think it was family and friends that wrote them. read more

See all

I have to say I'm hard to please... I like their pizza, I love love their dinners !! Order for a friend the chicken parmesan and she called to tell me it was the best she had ever had. Decided to try their dinners. Ordered the Chicken Castelli, love love love!!! read more

Split a pie w two other people. General census, not tasty or flavorful. Very bland, thick heavy pizza. My recommendation, put some spices in the gravy and use less cheese. However if I were to score the sub and fries I would haven given those better review. Italian sub was damn near perfect and fries were amazing. Customer service was very nice too. Pizza was a flop, but sub, fries and service were amazing. Definitely excited to order meals, subs, and wraps from here tho. I would give everything overall an 8.2/10 But the pizza was a flop. I look forward to ordering wraps and subs later in the week. read more

Verace’s Pizza - Plain pie - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

So glad Naples got a pizza place in Silverton! Not that going to Naples on Fischer Boulevard was far but it was about a 15 minute drive for us, and this location helps keep the food hot. Pizza and sandwiches all the way! read more

This is a great little treasure I found. I'm from northern NJ, recently bought a home in Toms River. I wanted pizza, however super reluctant because nothing will ever compare to food up North. Tried this pizza place called Versace's Pizza! I must say, I love love love this pizza!!! It was delicious! This is a must try for everyone! read more

One of our favorite pizza places. The chicken parm pizza and Buffalo chicken pizza are particularly tasty. We recently ordered some pasta dishes from them (chicken parm, manicotti) and they were also really good, with generous portions. read more

Wow! Just had a fabulous grandma 's pizza with sausage!! Fantastic!! Delicious! Highly recommended!! Great job Jury!!!!

Honestly, such a good find. My parents always are going to the same restaurants and I like to try something different. So we took a shot and ordered from here. I have to say, it was AMAZING. So happy we tried this place! First, the prices are so cheap and you get SO MUCH food. Second, the food tastes amazing. They are not scarce on the ingredients. They really put their all into making the food taste good. Third, the little restaurant is so cute and the staff is very nice. Come here! read more

Took me 1.5 years to finally find EXCELLENT entrees at the local pizzeria. I've tried every one in Silverton and unfortunately found this one last. Wish I started here. Ordered chicken francaise to be delivered, arrived hot, and was sooooo good. Giant portion. Have yet to try their pizza but looking forward to it!! read more

Great food! So happy Naples opened a closer location to me. Pizza is amazing. The sauce is excellent! Love this place!

Best pizza in the area! La pizza siciliana era saporita. Calamari with tentacles.... My favorite! My wife loved the penne vodka pie so much she wants to try the pasta dish next. Grazie! Ciao! read more

SILVERTON, NJ STORE IS well managed. grandma's pizza was delivered piping hot. really tasty, well cooked. can't believe we ate the whole pie. it was too good to resist. read more

Found this place that just opened on Hooper Ave. Nice deco and the pepperoni pizza I had was quite tasty, not greasy and had a nice crispy crust. Real friendly staff also... highly recommend! read more

Our new favorite! The crust is delicious and that's always a plus. Haven't had a pie we didn't love here but our absolute favorite is one we made up: garlic and basil, so delicious! read more

Delicious, fast slices. Drove by and stopped was not disappointed. Cheesesteak pizza was on point!

Absolutely the best pizza in toms river no one can compete. Their chicken Parm slice and their grandma style pizza is second to none are used to go over on Fisher Boulevard to Naples but recently they just moved the new place over here in Silverton on Hooper Avenue and I am honestly thrilled same taste they put a lot of love into their food I would recommend this to anyone traveling nearby or any locals if you want some of the best pizza you've ever had read more

garlic knots are basically a dinner roll. unseasoned, not a drop of garlic or even garlic powder, dry as a bone in no oil/garlic mixture like most pizza spots. sauce tasted like straight tomato paste and was bland as anything. onions ring nice and crispy BUT the rings and knots both came with no lid, uncovered in a folder over brown paper bag. unsanitary 100%, like hello? ...covid? pizza was over done with torched cheese spots that were nasty, crust was so over done it turned to crumbs once bitten. didn't even taste good cold the next day. would never order from again. read more

Be eating these guys pizza for many many years from his family's other location, ordered this then grandma pie a few times always bake perfect anything we've had there has been excellent they are the best in an area where there are at least pizzerias within 1 mile read more

Usually when you're drunk any food will taste lovely. Shockingly to my surprise I was quite displeased about how this pizza turned out. Once I took my first bite I realized I just wasted my money and time. Would rather have gotten dominoes which is always a last resort. Pizza was very minimally seasoned, bland and super oily. Super disappointed and can't believe people would willingly eat at this establishment. read more

When you order the same meal 2 nights in a row you know you have a new favorite place. So glad we decided to try Versace's when we were in the mood for cheese steaks. Great food great service. read more

First time I tried this place. I saw it had a five star rating so I gave it a try. We only ordered Italian heroes, but they were excellent. Chicken was tender, bread was fresh. I will definitely order again trying their entrees next time. Delivery was excellent, prompt and courteous. Give them a try. read more

I give this pizza place a 10. The inside is so clean and everyone is very friendly. The food is excellent! You will Not be sorry. Enjoy! I will be going back. Donna and Don. read more

So t understand how this place has such high ratings ! I ordered 2 plain pies and it was gross .

The owners of this establishment were extremely unprofessional. Not only did they give ME a hard time about THEM getting my order wrong, but none of the staff were wearing masks when I went on 9/3.... this place will not last long. Rude, unprofessional, and immature. read more

Amazing!!!!! The eggplant parm- is so good! It's thin- not greasy! Customer service is wonderful! Highly recommend this place.