Pies Place

Get the halibut. I've had many fish dishes from all over the world and it was actually one of the…read morebest dishes I've ever had. 10/10 easily. The short rib pasta was also great, good filling portion size. Service and the ambiance was also great. Highly recommend coming here.

the food, drinks, service, ambiance is beyond wonderful. Servers were beyond attentive. we live in…read moreNorth Jersey and will happily drive back to Ocean Gate for another meal. Totally worth it

View from inside

Crock of French Onion

See all

View from our table

Ocean Organics Juice Bar & Cafe

4.4(83 reviews)

3.6 mi

Great options! I Love to eat Organic and there are very few options. Thank you for your…read moreestablishment!

I walked in and it's a cute little café. They have a huge selection of vegan options and I believe…read morethey have non-vegan options as well. In the front, they have refrigerators that have fresh juice, yogurt parfaits, drinks, and more. The vegan options are well priced however I wish the burgers and sandwiches came with a side instead of adding a small fry for four dollars. I got the BLTA burger and added a small fry and it is fresh, tastes amazing, and I really enjoyed everything that I ate. The service was great. The guy that was working was polite and the food came out pretty fast. This is definitely a great place with a lot of options if you are vegetarian or vegan. I can't wait to come back and try something else!

The seating area

Veggie bagel and full loaded breakfast sandwich

See all

The main register

37 Eats Kitchen & Bar

3.8(30 reviews)

We have wanted to try this place for sometime and finally decided to do this on a Saturday…read moreafternoon, yesterday. I don't know how old the restaurant is, but I believe it's relatively new as it looks very clean, modern, has very high ceilings and a modern rustic type of feel. There are steel beams in the ceiling to the floor. The flooring is a warm laminate wood. They have booths, tables and a nice bar area. The dining room also has windows with natural lighting and also lights that come down to each table. We are greeted by our waiter and sat, he was friendly and attentive. The only thing that was odd, he didn't check to see if our main courses came ok. But overall, we really liked this restaurant. They have a very eclectic menu. We shared the Bavarian pretzel, the mustard and the beer cheese were excellent. I had the Tuscanwich with breaded eggplant. It also comes with broccoli rabe, roasted red peppers and house made mozzarella on Joe Leone's bread. It was awesome. It also comes with housemaid potato chips, which were excellent. My wife had the Smashburger with sweet potato fries. She said it was amazing. I had a Franzeskonner beer, which is very hard to find so I was very happy about that. My wife had a winter tequila cocktail, which looked beautiful and also tasted great. We passed on dessert, but we will definitely be back. They also have other really great entrées. They have a really good wine list and many awesome cocktails.

On a pretty busy Saturday night, other than taking a bit longer than it should have to get our…read moredrinks-service was great-food was amazing-everything everyone ordered was delicious! Drinks were fabulous!! This was our first visit, won't be our last! Seriously- must try the focaccia fagioli-omg!! I had the veggie burger which was so flavorful-clearly homemade and fresh-delicious! Others in our party enjoyed their meals as well! Great aesthetic-decor is on point! Lightning is great and it's not too loud! Some places are so loud you can't have a conversation-perfect noise level here!! All around it was a great night!

Smokey old fashioned

See all

Bar

Rue 561 Bistro

4.2(76 reviews)

3.6 mi

We had an anniversary reservation @chef Justin's sunset keys in Lavalette just to try some place…read moredifferent . Well, they couldn't seat us even though reservation 2 months in advance!?! (Don't waste ur time) Came back over the bridge to the mainland and luckily our absolutely favorite restaurant was able to seat us without a reservation. It was around 8pm. Always a great experience from food, to service, to calm ambiance . Everything we ordered was off the specials menu & as always nothing disappointed. Starters-AMAZING crab cakes as well as chicken liver mousse (definitely a 1st for us to try but was absolutely fantastic!) on grilled crostini with apricot habanero jam--yum! Entrees-Asian style filet mignon which hubby crushed & pan cooked halibut which was tender & delicious. Thanks for another great anniversary dinner Rue! BYOB is a nice bonus

Is this place ever open?? I called…read moreOnce To make a reservation and they wanted a credit card and would charge if you didnt show up but I pass it all the time and noone is ever there if you had to cancel in advance so I never went. Heard its just Ok. I cant Give any stars because I dont know. I do live in the area. Maybe i see cars once a week. But i have to, so here is 1. This is the response from the owner. Very professional. Who wants to make a reservation with a narcissist? I live in the area. You must be a moron for your response! Why would i lie? I leave my credit card for La Mondina. Charlies never tells our party when to get out. Last place I would Dine! See health code violations attached Michelle, you need an attitude adjustment but I guess according to your other responses, You need To know only while you are in The restaurant. That will never happen. Sadly, you will fail in no time. Love, Troll

See all

Book your special occasion with us. Customized menus to fit your special celebration.

Pika’s Restaurant

5.0(6 reviews)

Stop by to try out the plantain heard about the chicken empanadas. Had to try the rice on top of it…read moreall. A wonderful experience, a small homemade style kitchen a must stop by in Toms River.

Good stuff. We ordered take out from Pika last week. We ordered ceviche and a 1/2 chicken w fries,…read morerice and beans. Everything was really good and tasty. The beans were some of the best I've had. The next day I put leftover beans on my eggs for breakfast. The food was ready and waiting when we arrived. The restaurant is a little small with o oh a few tables. Although when we walked in it was packed.

Plantain w cheese

See all

Ecuadorian flag

Dina's Bistro

4.3(179 reviews)

Wow, dinner date night was a big success at Dina's! Fantastic food and hospitality. Richie went…read moreabove and beyond making us feel welcomed, it was super fun chatting with him after our meal. We got the calamari which was gluten-free, the Bolognese, and the scallops . The portions are HUGE We were starving, and we barely finished 25% of it. Very authentic "family" type feel, and they actually care here. We will be back again soon!

Dina and staff have a hidden gem. The food is always delicious. The specials we had were…read moreoutstanding. Veal short rib with veggie risotto was mouth watering. The 20 ounce lobster tail cooked to perfection, sweet juicy and tender with butter for dipping. Lamb shank huge and savory. The staff is amazing and ready to offer info about specials, honest, authentic and professional. The atmosphere is cozy and feels like home. The owners are always there and available to say hello and check in. Our place for a great meal with friends and family.

Table setting

See all

The Charming Dining Room!

Della Cucina Italian Market & Catering

4.4(28 reviews)

Della Cucina is the best! We have hosted two parties recently and the food was amazing! So many…read morecompliments from our guests and there wasn't much leftover afterwards. The staff is so helpful and friendly. We won't go anywhere else in the future.

Finally tried their new dining room experience for dinner. Party of 8. Very nice, modern & clean…read moreinside (including bathroom). Only 2 ladies serving who were very good but seemed a little overwhelmed by the time the small dining area filled up (they could use an extra runner for busy nights to help). The risotto balls and caprese salad appetizers were out of this world. Filet mignon was cooked perfectly, the pasta dish with sausage & bell peppers was very good. My end of the table : 2 ordered linguini (1 subbed penne) w/clams & 1 ordered of chicken Sorrentino. The chicken dish was very tasty, clams were very good too-tender & no grit. However, the "sauces" that each dish came with were literally just bland broth, no flavor, like the just poured low sodium broth on top of pasta. Hopefully their chef beefs up the sauces a little bit, they shouldn't be watery & tasteless. Everything else was delicious so not much to complain about, but they definitely need to fix the sauce situation (although the tomato sauce with risotto balls was out of this world).

THE BEST Macaroni Salad

Chicken Salad (8")

See all

Filet mignon

Mia's Pizza 37

4.0(32 reviews)

2.9 mi

Mia's in Tom's River is located right on Route 27 in a small strip lot. There's parking in the lot…read moreand along the side street that connects to 37. I got some takeout on a Friday night at prime time and was told my order would be ready in 30 minutes. It was. The staff inside are very friendly and pickup was a breeze. Prices here are quite affordable. If you're staying along the island strip for a vacation, I highly recommend driving across the bridge and getting your pizza here. You'll have a more reasonable wait time. The fried calamari considered of large pieces, which I liked, but others may not. No tentacles either. The breading wasn't crisp, but I got takeout so I can't hold that against them. My kids enjoyed their traditional pie, which I got with half pepperoni. Good pizza indeed. The real standout for me was the Grandma's Sicilian! It had the crispiest crust I've ever had on a pizza. The topping was delicious, balanced and I really loved it!!! I could order this every time, but unfortunately I don't live in the area. No credit card fee here either. Highly recommended!

Food was really good. Love the breadsticks served with marinara sauce given when you sit down. Veal…read moreand chicken entrees were very good. The restaurant has a small dining room, perfect to enjoy a quiet meal. Service was good, friendly and competent.

Fried calamari

See all

Outside

Sal's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.3(60 reviews)

3.1 mi

My new favorite pizzeria down the shore!! I ordered over the weekend, and everything was delicious!…read moreThe penne vodka with angel hair, chicken Marsala, soup and mozzarella sticks were awesome! They even gave us free zeppolis!! (We did pick up before they closed) Can't wait to be back down to order again!

Sals is our go-to place for pizza, Italian, & sandwiches. They did a great job catering a big party…read morelast summer as well. Good food, friendly service, & reasonable prices. This last time we ordered bbq chicken pizza via delivery. It came fast, was hot & looked perfect. The pizza is so large you can only eat one slice! It was a little salty for my taste, but still pretty good.

Italian hoagie

Pepperoni and sausage calzone ( cold inside )

See all

BBQ chicken pizza

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Alexandra A.

5 years ago

Slow service, rude custome service

Pies Place - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Restaurants near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Things to Do near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Desserts near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Coffee near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Burgers near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Dinner near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Breakfast near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Shopping near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Arcade near Pies Place

Best of Bayville

Things to do in Bayville

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pies Place also viewed

Pies On Nine

3.8

(101 reviews)

Pies on 9 opened a month ago in Barnegat NJ! They are not yet delivery so we picked it up snd it…read morewas really great! We had baked ziti w meatballs really yummy! We also shared a chicken parm sub really delicious! Try it!!

Service was fine, when I got home the pie was over cooked, couldn't wait to have pizza that night,…read moreand we were all disappointed with it. The girl behind the counter was just OK. Can't recommend as someone else was complaining when I was in there.

Sal's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.3

(60 reviews)

Pop's Pizza

3.6

(18 reviews)

Excellent cheese pie and tremendous Sicilian We ordered…read moretwice so far, best thing crust in area. Great to have this local. ThanksPop

Delivery and customer service is terrible. I ordered delivery two times and both times they claimed…read morethat since they couldn't find my place that they just went back to the store. I never even received a call that they were lost or couldn't find it. I had to call them myself after hours of waiting and I was informed of this situation. After this I still nicely asked for them to try to find it again since I already paid. After even more time and then having to wait outside my house for the delivery driver to see, the food arrived cold, and was not even given an apology or any discount. Never again

LG's Pizza & Pasta

4.5

(83 reviews)

Best pizza north of Romeo's in Wildwood or Panzonis and DeNunzio's in Sea Isle. Every topping is…read morefresh. All the cheeses taste like they're supposed to. Crust is deliciously chewy and the right thickness. Absolutely holds up as leftovers the next day. Very nice people when we pick up. 10 stars.

My physical therapy office is very close to this place in the same plaza. I'm trying to visit every…read morepizza place I can. I just had a plain slice, a little over three dollars with tax. It was very good. Could've been a little bit hotter because I like it very hot otherwise it was quite good. The size was excellent. It was very cheesy with good sauce and good crust. He had some white pizza there in the display case that looked amazing so I will definitely be back. I took their menu.

Il Casereccio Family Pizzeria & Tavola Calda

3.3

(21 reviews)

Hidden little gem in the area. A TON of pizza options in the general area but many are inconsistent…read moreyet this one is consistently right. Ask for it how you like it and they deliver. I've also found their crust to be the closest to a thin crust pie like up north. Garlic knots are average, nothing special but it's also hard to screw that up. Only suggestion would be on the Stromboli, fillings should go to the ends. Theirs (like many in the area) was empty the last two slices. All in all this is a good place to go for pizza, can't comment on the rest of their menu. I've heard good things about breakfast but can't speak to it myself.

The pizzas are fresh and the cannoli here is delicious. The owner clearly doesn't trust his staff…read morethough and so does everything, making the dining experience hectic. This place needs waitresses, preferably locals and not illegals

Mimmo's

3.7

(57 reviews)

Mimmos is hands down my husband and I go to spot! We have had everything from their cauliflower…read morecrust pizza, Greek salad, grilled vegetables, and various wraps. All of these were beyond delicious and always with the freshest ingredients. Last night Mimmos catered a party at our house and was beyond accommodating. There was a pasta that was not originally on his catering menu but Mimmo went above and beyond to make this pasta for us and ALL of our guests said it was the best Pasta Carbonara they have ever had. The eggplant rollatini was hands down the best we have ever had and the sauce was superb! We also ordered the Chicken Contadina which my husband said was his new favorite chicken and would go back to Mimmos especially for this dinner. In addition, Mimmo supplied us with the absolute best focaccia bread and three grilled mini pizzas! Every one of our guests asked where we had gotten the food from and for their information. Not a person at the party didn't compliment the food ... repeatedly! Thank you Mimmo for EVERYTHING! We couldn't have asked for better food, service, and accommodations. We will certainly be in soon for dinner!

New owners are very friendly! A few weeks ago I ordered pizza and it was a lot better last time. I…read moredon't want to mention what went wrong. The salad was good. I think they should probably make it brighter without blocking the windows with signs. Very big menu! Give new businesses a chance

Nonna's Place Ristorante Italiano

3.5

(179 reviews)

•$$

NONNA's GENUINE ITALIAN RED SAUCE is the VERY BEST; Servers are all friendly, knowledgeable,…read moreprofessional & helpful.. For us, the sausages are frequently over-cooked & the meatballs plain-tasting.. But all the Entrees are still delicious ~ & we always need a take-home bag because of the generous & plentiful portions. The sandwiches (both hot & cold) are enormous/generous.. However, lately the pizza is not as it used to be ~ since the crust is now too thick & tough & lacks its past-usual crispness (& we have heard others have same comments about the negative change in the pizza).. So, we never hesitate to return often ~ but are selective when ordering ~ & thus, always enjoy our meals, etc..

The food is consistently good. I have tried a few different things on their menu and it's always…read morebeen very good. Everyone there is super friendly and the atmosphere is very welcoming. It's definitely worth the trip if you're not local to the area.

Inzillo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.8

(113 reviews)

•$$

Catered an entire party for a fair price, food was absolutely amazing and everything we could have…read moreasked for, also great for just a regular lazy night where we don't want to cook dinner. Very good food all around. Can't forget the extensive gluten free menu as my wife has a gluten allergy, it's all great. Eat here.

Highly recommend! I just moved to Jackson right down the street I walk there it's so convenient for…read moreme. Im vegan and I saw vegan options and let me tell you DELICIOUS!!! They are so kind and friendly in there and that's all it takes I am a repeat customer now and will continue to be ! Get over there it's worth it sooooo good! The Buffalo chicken pizza though ‍YUMMY!!

Tita's Pizzeria & Restaurant

5.0

(2 reviews)

Went here today with my parents on a Lent Friday. So traditionally it's pizza night. Lol. We wanted…read moreto try this place and glad we did. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. The restaurant was very clean inside as were the bathrooms. Might be the new go to spot for pizza. We just had pizza and mussels. And both. Were delicious. Mussels were very tender and not sandy at all. Cleaned well. the mussels very good. And the sauce was flavorful. Rating the pizza: tomato pie with the red tomatoes on top was so good. Love how they dress the pie all the way to the end of the crust. The dough was very crispy and crunchy and the cheese had a good bite and wasn't chewy. The New York pie was just as good same great taste. Crispy crunchy crust. I prefer the tomato bc it looks nicer and the fresh basil was a nice touch. Definitely a great place for pizza. I'll have to try the dinners next time.

Pizza is thin and crispy! Garlic knots were very good! Pricing is really good for the wraps and…read moresubs!!

Naples Pizza & Restaurant

3.9

(117 reviews)