Pies Place

Ordered their pizza, pasta and meatballs, and everything was great. The pizza had a nice, thin and…read morecrispy crunch with a perfect balance of sauce and cheese while not being greasy. We also attended an event here and they did a fantastic job. The fish was moist and fresh. Sauces were very flavorful. All the servers and employees were extremely friendly and helpful. Will definitely come back for the great food and fantastic service.

Unfortunately there was a guy pounding meat in the kitchen most of the time we were eating lunch in…read morethe dining room. It was extremely loud and annoying, even though the dining room is pretty and rustic. It truly put a damper on our meal. The food was great! We started with white garlic clams which were excellent! The sauce, full of slices of garlic, was worth dipping the bread in!!! I had the chicken balsamic which was excellent, with a slight sweetness with the tang of the balsamic. My husband had a veal dish with red peppers, melted mozzarella over a pasta in a pesto sauce. Also excellent. The service was really good. I would have given this place a five but the banging didn't stop!

Quaint dining room...separate banquet room available

Fiochetti Bascaiola

See all

Cappuccino

Biagio's Trattoria

4.2(123 reviews)

3.9 mi

Amazing food and service every time! Chicken francese is awesome. Specialty dishes are fantastic…read more Never a bad meal. BYOB is a plus! **The waitress always remembers my BF is GLUTEN free.

Food was excellent! Service was great. Carrie was our server and she couldn't have been more…read moreaccommodating. It was a very good experience. Would highly recommend!

Entrance with outdoor dining to the right

Fly close up

See all

Shrimp fra diavolo

Il Giardinello Ristorante

4.1(264 reviews)

6.0 mi

•$$$

I was there years ago and wasn't posting on Yelp but when I was there, the food was fantastic. The…read moreambience was fantastic and the service was fantastic. It used to be really good when they gave coupons away for two for one, but like I say I haven't been there in a while. Definitely gonna go back and try it out again and bring my friends with me.

I used to come here with my mom and dad, and I loved it so much. I haven't had a chance to come…read moreback until now and I remember now why I loved it so much! We had the most wonderful meal. I had the paccheri with peas prosciutto and mushrooms. The pasta was cooked perfectly. The flavor was fantastic. It was creamy and cheesy. And the serving size was incredibly generous. My salad was fresh and the Caesar dressing was nice. Service was on point. The restaurant is pretty and we sat next to the fountain with a view of the rest of the dining room. Honestly this restaurant is worth the drive. Next time we are down the shore, we are coming here.

Inside

Salad

See all

Bread

Tardis Ristorante Italiano

4.4(275 reviews)

4.8 mi

Just Wonderful!! Service was excellent. Food as always…read moresuperb!! Space is small and seating is limited so suggest planning ahead especially during the summer season

Came here last night. This is one incredible Italian bistro,…read moreAmazing food quality. The ambiance totally outstanding Great attention to detail. Amazing place for family gatherings.

Cozy and romantic dining room

Veal Milanese with fresh Mozzerella

See all

Patricia's Downtown

3.5(25 reviews)

2.9 mi

Came here for a birthday dinner and unfortunately left very disappointed…read more Bullet points: - BYOB - fees - not quiet! - food is oily and mediocre - service rushes It is BYOB, but we weren't given an ice bucket to keep our white wine cold. Not that we needed it (explained later.) There is a 3.29% service fee on the receipt. They will charge it for debit cards, too, which I was under the impression that's illegal. There is nothing in there to absorb all the noise, so if you have sensory issues this is not the place. Both of us are constantly at concerts and this was overwhelming. We couldn't talk to each other comfortably. The bolognese ($24) looked more of a vodka sauce than tomato and had way too much oil in it. His gnocchi ($24) was a good sauce, but the gnocchi itself tasted like it came from a box. The real star was the bread and dip they brought out. Had a bunch of garlic and crushed red pepper in it. I ate more of that than my pasta. From the moment we sat down we were rushed. The server was kind, but we barely had time to look over the menu. Once the check was brought she hovered. My bf barely got his signature finished before she collected the receipt and tried to take all the glasses off the table (she did put the water back down.) It was very crowded so I'm sure they want to turn tables, but back off. We felt unwelcome, and it certainly wasn't a dinner we needed to rush through. Safe to say we won't be back.

Great quality!! I live right around the corner and this is the best authentic italian food around…read more Portions (both apps and meals) are large and reasonably priced. Will definitely be back again.

Special: Crabmeat Pasta

Bread and dip

See all

Anchor Inn

3.9(103 reviews)

1.5 mi

Delmonico steak is delicious every time. Service is great…read more It's a 45 minute ride but wee worth it.

10/10 food, service, atmosphere, pricing. I came with a…read moreparty if 10 and our waiter, Frankie demonstrated exactly what GREAT service is. He was extremely pleasant, patient, etc. I got the broiled seafood platter and it was delicious! Would absolutely recommend this restaurant.

Fluke franchiase

See all

Broiled seafood platter

Piccolino Italian kitchen

4.5(82 reviews)

5.6 mi

We love this place. The food is fantastic and the service is excellent. Nice and small so you feel…read morespecial and can actually talk with your guests. Ashley and the rest of the staff are the BEST.

I honestly don't write reviews, good or bad, but I just am confused. Ordered for pick up Caesar…read moresalad and meatballs. Meatballs were fine. but the Caesar salad was so bad it was inedible. I honestly don't know how you screw up a Caesar salad, but it was swimming in dressing. I tried to eat it, and even threw some of my own lettuce in to soak up some of the dressing. I gave up and threw the rest in the garbage.

Small but Nicely appointed space

Swordfish with Clams and Mussels over linguine

See all

Front entrance

House of Pizza

4.8(4 reviews)

0.5 mi

Being Italian, grew up on good cheese and gravy. I find that the first Gen Italians make the best…read more Pascual and Emily owner/operator make the best Pizzas. They are also able to make 2 types of Fradiablo sauce pizza with while being the cheapest around at $12.00 on Wednesdays for a large Pie. Before the pandmeic the special used to be $7.00. The curst is good too. I order double cut and well done.

In town visiting family and with so many pizza places in the bayville area I always try to find the…read morenext best one when I'm in town and trying this place for the first time I went with their garlic pizza and talk about fresh garlic..wow....for me it was just the right amount of cheese and the crust & sauce were really good.....a very solid choice for pizza.

Batman loves House of Pizza

Sicilian

See all

Linda's Pizza

3.9(42 reviews)

1.5 mi

I've been going to Linda's every Summer for the past 20 years. It has always had great food and…read morefast service. The past few years I have become a resident and Linda's is my go to for the nights I don't feel like cooking or need something quick. Their BBQ Chicken Pizza is AMAZING. Their Eggplant rollatini is excellent. Their Chicken Parm is the best in immediate area. The prices are reasonable and they have a good Italian menu. I recommend them if you are in the mood for a good pizza or a Italian dinner entree to go.

First time trying Linda's- I called to make sure they delivery to my area and the owner (I believe…read morefrom how it sounded) was super nice & helpful. We ordered on a Sunday evening, super late so I'm not going to totally blame them but the pizza came looking/tasting super dry. I threw it in the oven for 10 min and it was SO good!!! Antipasto was deceiving - looked mediocre but tasted amazing! The garlic knots were crispy, fluffy & the sauce was awesome. Definitely ordering again!

Pepperoni pizza - Large

Antipasto - medium

See all

My antipasto all dressed up

Rosie’s Ocean Gate

4.2(135 reviews)

1.8 mi

•$$$

Get the halibut. I've had many fish dishes from all over the world and it was actually one of the…read morebest dishes I've ever had. 10/10 easily. The short rib pasta was also great, good filling portion size. Service and the ambiance was also great. Highly recommend coming here.

the food, drinks, service, ambiance is beyond wonderful. Servers were beyond attentive. we live in…read moreNorth Jersey and will happily drive back to Ocean Gate for another meal. Totally worth it

View from inside

Crock of French Onion

See all

View from our table

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Nelson M.

2 days ago

Food is always good at this establishment quick courteous employees reasonable priced and fast deliveries

Alexandra A.

5 years ago

Slow service, rude custome service

Pies Place - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Restaurants near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Things to Do near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Desserts near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Coffee near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Burgers near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Dinner near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Breakfast near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Shopping near Pies Place

BEST of Bayville, New Jersey Arcade near Pies Place

Best of Bayville

Things to do in Bayville

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pies Place also viewed

Pies On Nine

3.8

(101 reviews)

Pies on 9 opened a month ago in Barnegat NJ! They are not yet delivery so we picked it up snd it…read morewas really great! We had baked ziti w meatballs really yummy! We also shared a chicken parm sub really delicious! Try it!!

Service was fine, when I got home the pie was over cooked, couldn't wait to have pizza that night,…read moreand we were all disappointed with it. The girl behind the counter was just OK. Can't recommend as someone else was complaining when I was in there.

Sal's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.3

(60 reviews)

My new favorite pizzeria down the shore!! I ordered over the weekend, and everything was delicious!…read moreThe penne vodka with angel hair, chicken Marsala, soup and mozzarella sticks were awesome! They even gave us free zeppolis!! (We did pick up before they closed) Can't wait to be back down to order again!

Sals is our go-to place for pizza, Italian, & sandwiches. They did a great job catering a big party…read morelast summer as well. Good food, friendly service, & reasonable prices. This last time we ordered bbq chicken pizza via delivery. It came fast, was hot & looked perfect. The pizza is so large you can only eat one slice! It was a little salty for my taste, but still pretty good.

Pop's Pizza

3.6

(18 reviews)

Excellent cheese pie and tremendous Sicilian We ordered…read moretwice so far, best thing crust in area. Great to have this local. ThanksPop

Delivery and customer service is terrible. I ordered delivery two times and both times they claimed…read morethat since they couldn't find my place that they just went back to the store. I never even received a call that they were lost or couldn't find it. I had to call them myself after hours of waiting and I was informed of this situation. After this I still nicely asked for them to try to find it again since I already paid. After even more time and then having to wait outside my house for the delivery driver to see, the food arrived cold, and was not even given an apology or any discount. Never again

LG's Pizza & Pasta

4.5

(83 reviews)

Best pizza north of Romeo's in Wildwood or Panzonis and DeNunzio's in Sea Isle. Every topping is…read morefresh. All the cheeses taste like they're supposed to. Crust is deliciously chewy and the right thickness. Absolutely holds up as leftovers the next day. Very nice people when we pick up. 10 stars.

My physical therapy office is very close to this place in the same plaza. I'm trying to visit every…read morepizza place I can. I just had a plain slice, a little over three dollars with tax. It was very good. Could've been a little bit hotter because I like it very hot otherwise it was quite good. The size was excellent. It was very cheesy with good sauce and good crust. He had some white pizza there in the display case that looked amazing so I will definitely be back. I took their menu.

Il Casereccio Family Pizzeria & Tavola Calda

3.3

(21 reviews)

•$$$

Hidden little gem in the area. A TON of pizza options in the general area but many are inconsistent…read moreyet this one is consistently right. Ask for it how you like it and they deliver. I've also found their crust to be the closest to a thin crust pie like up north. Garlic knots are average, nothing special but it's also hard to screw that up. Only suggestion would be on the Stromboli, fillings should go to the ends. Theirs (like many in the area) was empty the last two slices. All in all this is a good place to go for pizza, can't comment on the rest of their menu. I've heard good things about breakfast but can't speak to it myself.

The pizzas are fresh and the cannoli here is delicious. The owner clearly doesn't trust his staff…read morethough and so does everything, making the dining experience hectic. This place needs waitresses, preferably locals and not illegals

Mimmo's

3.7

(57 reviews)

Mimmos is hands down my husband and I go to spot! We have had everything from their cauliflower…read morecrust pizza, Greek salad, grilled vegetables, and various wraps. All of these were beyond delicious and always with the freshest ingredients. Last night Mimmos catered a party at our house and was beyond accommodating. There was a pasta that was not originally on his catering menu but Mimmo went above and beyond to make this pasta for us and ALL of our guests said it was the best Pasta Carbonara they have ever had. The eggplant rollatini was hands down the best we have ever had and the sauce was superb! We also ordered the Chicken Contadina which my husband said was his new favorite chicken and would go back to Mimmos especially for this dinner. In addition, Mimmo supplied us with the absolute best focaccia bread and three grilled mini pizzas! Every one of our guests asked where we had gotten the food from and for their information. Not a person at the party didn't compliment the food ... repeatedly! Thank you Mimmo for EVERYTHING! We couldn't have asked for better food, service, and accommodations. We will certainly be in soon for dinner!

New owners are very friendly! A few weeks ago I ordered pizza and it was a lot better last time. I…read moredon't want to mention what went wrong. The salad was good. I think they should probably make it brighter without blocking the windows with signs. Very big menu! Give new businesses a chance

Nonna's Place Ristorante Italiano

3.5

(180 reviews)

NONNA's GENUINE ITALIAN RED SAUCE is the VERY BEST; Servers are all friendly, knowledgeable,…read moreprofessional & helpful.. For us, the sausages are frequently over-cooked & the meatballs plain-tasting.. But all the Entrees are still delicious ~ & we always need a take-home bag because of the generous & plentiful portions. The sandwiches (both hot & cold) are enormous/generous.. However, lately the pizza is not as it used to be ~ since the crust is now too thick & tough & lacks its past-usual crispness (& we have heard others have same comments about the negative change in the pizza).. So, we never hesitate to return often ~ but are selective when ordering ~ & thus, always enjoy our meals, etc..

The food is consistently good. I have tried a few different things on their menu and it's always…read morebeen very good. Everyone there is super friendly and the atmosphere is very welcoming. It's definitely worth the trip if you're not local to the area.

Inzillo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.8

(113 reviews)

Catered an entire party for a fair price, food was absolutely amazing and everything we could have…read moreasked for, also great for just a regular lazy night where we don't want to cook dinner. Very good food all around. Can't forget the extensive gluten free menu as my wife has a gluten allergy, it's all great. Eat here.

Highly recommend! I just moved to Jackson right down the street I walk there it's so convenient for…read moreme. Im vegan and I saw vegan options and let me tell you DELICIOUS!!! They are so kind and friendly in there and that's all it takes I am a repeat customer now and will continue to be ! Get over there it's worth it sooooo good! The Buffalo chicken pizza though ‍YUMMY!!

Tita's Pizzeria & Restaurant

5.0

(2 reviews)

Went here today with my parents on a Lent Friday. So traditionally it's pizza night. Lol. We wanted…read moreto try this place and glad we did. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. The restaurant was very clean inside as were the bathrooms. Might be the new go to spot for pizza. We just had pizza and mussels. And both. Were delicious. Mussels were very tender and not sandy at all. Cleaned well. the mussels very good. And the sauce was flavorful. Rating the pizza: tomato pie with the red tomatoes on top was so good. Love how they dress the pie all the way to the end of the crust. The dough was very crispy and crunchy and the cheese had a good bite and wasn't chewy. The New York pie was just as good same great taste. Crispy crunchy crust. I prefer the tomato bc it looks nicer and the fresh basil was a nice touch. Definitely a great place for pizza. I'll have to try the dinners next time.

Pizza is thin and crispy! Garlic knots were very good! Pricing is really good for the wraps and…read moresubs!!

Naples Pizza & Restaurant

3.9

(117 reviews)