Absolutely the BEST local pizzeria! They always have a great selection of fresh pizza slices ready to go -- the Big Mac slice is hands-down my favorite. The chopped salad is also incredible, especially with their homemade vinaigrette, which is packed with flavor. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. There's a small amount of high-top seating inside if you want to dine in, but it's also perfect for a quick takeout stop. Highly recommend giving them a try! read more

Ridiculously good pizza and garlic knots! Stopped here to pick up pies for a family gathering. Staff was super friendly on the phone during ordering and in person for pickup. Super attentive too. They have a parking lot and a cute outdoor setup as well. The pizza is delicious, sauce is perfectly sweet and savory. The crust was delectable. Nice amount of cheese. Really no complaints. I regret not getting more garlic knots, they're fried and garlicky and perfect. Don't skip the garlic knots if you come here! read more

Great pizza every time, they have so many options for slices every day. Also love their chicken Marsala

Best pizza in this area! Staff is not very friendly, but the pizza is worth it. There's not a lot of seating.

We live in Whiting and just want it to be recognized that everyone from the person that took my wife's order on the phone to the gentleman that delivered our order and the pros that prepared our order were outstanding. I couldn't believe how huge and delicious everything was. This was our 1st order and I guarantee it won't be our last. Thank you all for your excellence. read more

Ordered food tonight, I talked to Ben on the phone he was great!! Even gave me dressing, i loved it!! Thanks ben!!

Service was great. Friendly staff. Inviting atmosphere. A lot of slice choices. Got a pepperoni with mike's hot honey pie. The pie was alright. Am I upset I drove 45 mins to try here? No. Will I go back again? Also no. Worth a try read more

Pies Place - Cupping pepperoni & mike's hot honey - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

Awful, just awful service and the pizza we had was not even close to what we were expecting

Amazing pizzeria! I'm from north Jersey and this pizza is so close to home, I was blown away! The staff was super friendly! We tried the Cavatelli & Broccoli, mozzarella sticks, and a chicken francaise slice. Everything was really good. This is quickly becoming our go-to place! read more

Nice addition to bayville. Not the best pizza I've had but it's one of the better pies I've had in south Jersey. I ordered a pie with peppers and onions. Well cooked and great taste. Also ordered mozzarella sticks and boneless Buffalo chicken. They were excellent! Definitely would try them again read more

Food is good, portions are not. Whole Sandwhich for $20 is half the size of sandwhich ordered a week ago. So small I called to ask if they mistakenly made 1/2 Sandwiches yet charged for whole. Way to expensive for this size of Sandwhich. read more

Order from here often so many Italian food options. I love the Stromboli and manicotti. They also have great Salads to choose from. read more

Pies Place - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New Jersey

See all

The most amazing pies you could eat to the end. The best pizza I have ever had. Once you have tried it you will know.

Delicious and vast menu of pizza variations and other goodies ! Pizza ensalata was HUGE! Delicious food in my neighborhood!

The ensalada pizza is our absolute favorite! We really enjoy all the food and the service is always great. Kind, friendly people

Had pizza here several time. It has been alright but a bit pricey. I purchased a grandpa's pie and it was disappointing. The crust was hard and tasteless. I ordered online with a credit card and was charged a credit card fee which I feel is abusive. Increase your price and don't charge me for a convenience both you and I enjoy. I won't be back, there are some good choices around. read more

Everything from ordering to service was on point! The subs are where it's at and the pizza and salads are awesome too! Thank you for taking care of us! read more

I ordered a Sicilian pie with sausage. The crust was fantastic but sauce was non existent. There were a couple of pieces of sausage. Wasn't worth paying extra for the sausage. read more

Just wanted to share a wonderful act of kindness.. so Pies Place in Bayville not only has awesome food and pizza, but a wonderful owner!! I received a phone call from Jess (owner)telling me that when she was going through receipts she noticed I probably made a mistake and added an extra zero on my bill when I picked up takeout over the weekend. It ended up being a $200 mistake I made!! She not only called me but offered to drop off the money AND was so nice! Please patronize this wonderful small business and people like Jess who not only makes awesome pizza but is a great person as well!! read more

In my opinion there are two types of pizza places, the type where the plane pizza speaks for itself, and the second type is a pizza place that makes due by providing all types of gimmicky pies. Pies Place fall somewhere in the middle, but they actually pulled it off. First off their plane slices and Sicilians are above average, especially for the area where a good pizza is not as readily available as it is up in North Jersey. The pizzas got a nice crust crunch, and the ingredients are all pretty fresh and high-quality. They also have a large selection of specialty pies with everything ranging from the standby "Granma pie" to their twist on what's called a "Chick Fila slice" which pulls ahead of the crowd with tender chicken pieces and waffle fries on top of a sauceless pizza. They have enough variety in pizza to keep most families happy and the quality of their ingredients definitely stands out. I had a baked ziti which really wasn't worth writing home about, but their sauce was noted as being pretty decent. Overall this is one of the better pizza places in the area, definitely the best mom and Pop style place in the Bayville region. I recommend walking in and trying a variety of the different slices as opposed to just buying one single kind of pie. I'll definitely be back read more

Nothing disappoints here! Everything is super fresh! Even there shredded lettuce is amazing!! Huge variety of pizza!!!!! Every time I order a dinner or sandwich I always try a different slice of pizza. You cannot go wrong here! read more

Pizza not too good. Even if decent it's over priced

I ordered online today and mistakenly hit no salad for no salad dressing. I was reached out to immediately to get clarification and make sure the rest of my order was correct. That's the kind of customer service we need more of! Those people all need a raise! Thank you Pies Place read more

Hello fellow yelpers I'm new to the area, and struggling to find my go-to places. I tried a few places for pizza. Seems "chuck-E-cheese" style pizza is fairly common around here. That's almost a crime in New Jersey. I've been hearing good reviews about the Pies Place but the business wasn't listed on Yelp. How is that possible? So I'll gladly be the first! The pies place this is by far the best pizza in the area.. Thin crust, great selection of toppings, i tried a straight cheese pie and a bacon and tomato.. both outstanding! Similar to a good bar pie. If you are used to good pizza, and find yourself in this area, definitely make this one of your first stops. Happy yelping! read more

Ordered from pies place for the first time tonight. It was a large order with a few customizations. Everything was perfect with the exception of a small miscommunication with a salad. We called and received amazing customer service. No business likes to have a complaint but there was zero attitude over it and they couldn't have been more accommodating. Within 10 minutes they were at our door with a brand new salad at no charge and it was exactly the way we wanted it. All the food we ordered was AMAZING. Definitely have a new pizza place. We will return FOR SURE. read more

Absolutely the best pizza and other food around. Staff is always pleasant and food is always top notch. I highly recommend eating here. It's always a clean and inviting atmosphere. I personally order from here at least every other week if not more and always a top notch experience. read more

I genuinely don't know how this place does it. I am the PICKIEST eater, which is only amplified by the fact that I'm pregnant. Somehow, everything is delicious. The Chloe salad is a personal favorite- that dressing has something addictive in it, I can't get enough. I always request well done chicken in whatever I order, and every time, it's p.e.r.f.e.c.t. Super bowl Sunday? We were the heroes with the wings, people devoured them. Wanna know how I KNOW this place is the place for me? I live too far for delivery, and I'll literally pack the baby in the car to go pick up dinner because anywhere else will leave me wishing I'd gone to Pies Place. read more

Everything about Pies Place is super solid. The pizza dough has flavor, their sauces are distinct, and the staff always listens to any requests for modifications. read more

This place is amazing....I'm from North Jersey so I'm picky when it comes to pizza. But this place definitely destroys all local competition by far.....I wouldn't recommend any other place in Ocean County besides this one....let's also mention how this is the only pizzeria in the area that has a useful app that functions properly.... read more

Great food, staff, and owners. Tons of different pizza options and an amazing lunch and dinner menu. You won't be disappointed!

White pie 1/2sausage, and a full size "cali chs steak "all outrageously excellent;Will do again and again,

Foods ok. But good luck getting what you order. Have ordered here a number of times and they pretty much send whatever they want. Order a California chicken cheesesteak you'll probably get a regular cheesesteak. Order extra dressing? You won't get it. Don't bother saying no onion or tomato on something. It'll come with it anyway. read more

Order from this place once a week and it's always so good! Definitely recommend the grandma pie, but everything I've had there has been good. read more

Food was absolutely delicious. Specifications made on the order were done and done right. Highly recommend.