2 cons and one is only personal preference: delivery was over an hour (peak hours on a Thursday, there's only so much they can do,) and no garlic crust. The sauce is sweet. The pizza is thin. The garlic bread is fluffy and the sauce that comes with it is also a fresh tomatoey delight. It is not overly oily! (Look at the pizza box in my pictures!) Throw some hot honey on this pie, it is perfect. Almost perfect... just a bit of garlic crust would make this unstoppable. :) Will absolutely be ordering again! Well worth the delivery wait, or go pick it up. Either way, you will be happy. read more

Pacidough's Pizza Joint - 16" plain pie - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

One of the most delicious pizzas I've ever had, loved it! Rich, flavorful sauce and that cheese.. WOW!..Absolutely amazing taste. Great price, too. read more

Pacidough's Pizza Joint - Half Hawaiian half margherita - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

The food is amazing ! You can taste the quality of the ingredients ! And John the pizza guy is the best !!!! I'll be back with friends !

I've yet to have a bad experience here. I'm turning into a weekly regular! Pizza is always cooked to perfection and in a timely manner. Owner makes the best pizzas but his staff is getting better at making them as well. Reasonable prices ($17) for a large plain. Don't walk, run here!! read more

See all

The pizza had a thin crispy crust. The sauce reminded me of that perfect caramelized sweet tangy glaze on top of a meatloaf. Flavor was legit. Crust and undercarriage perfect. Had to call on and off for 20 minutes to get through, and when they answered, it took about 35 minutes to pick up. My favorite pizza in ocean county so far! read more

Pacidough's Pizza Joint - Receipt - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Food is awesome. My pizza and meat ball sandwich was delicious. I came in to pick up my order and the young lady Tatum was so sweet and friendly , and Thank you to John for a perfect pizza. Pacidough's is amazing .I have been ordering from them since they opened. read more

Get figgy with it pie was very tasty! Good quality ingredients and a crispy crust. They offer personal size pie for every one on their menu when most places will only make those as a large. read more

Absolutely magnificent pizza. My wife and I have been going to pacidoughs for nearly a year now. We have yet to have a bad order, pizza is magnificently flavored, and the miss piggy got drunk sandwich is AMAZING. Cannot say enough good things about this place. read more

A great family owned business with delicious pizza, friendly staff and quick service every time!

Hello fellow yelpers! I'm happy to be the first (of many) to review Pacidough's especially after the Barstool's review and high score! This is a small pizzeria with only (2) two seat tables. So they are catering to small "walk in" business and slices but mostly takeout or delivery. The restaurant is theamed in 90's movie memorabilia and music but only to keep you busy while you wait. The menu has lots of choices the wings and pizza are great (exceptional on an Ocean county standard) definitely worth a visit! Be patient, their recently fame has drawn a lot of attention. read more

See all

Just plan pie was amazing really good pizza it well worth going again for the pizza I would try the dinners and desserts read more

Pacidough's Pizza Joint - Just cheese plan pie to go - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

It brings me great shame to have to write this review. I think that the pizza is quite good, worthy of at least 4 stars. But I just cant, in good faith, recommend that anyone support this business. They are very shady. 1 month ago the price for a plain pie on DoorDash was 19.00. To add pepperoni was an additional $3, which is fine, sure. Additional toppings are an extra $3 each, not so fine, but sure. 1 week later, they updated their prices... $10 per topping. So, to put this into perspective, if you wanted to get a pizza with 2 toppings, you're paying $39. Now that is insane. I called to ask them their prices, and to also let them know that the prices on DoorDash may have been messed up/typo. They said that the prices were wrong and it was a mistake. Surely it must be a mistake! Please fix. Another week passed, they updated the prices. Now, each topping is $11.50! Nice work, good fix! 3 topping pizza for $45? Sign me up! Yet, once again, another week passes. Instead of fixing what may have been a typo, they have gone unpunished for this disgusting greed and thievery. Now, the plain pie has gone from $19.00 to $21.85. Perhaps this pizza restaurant in the mini-mall by the Peek A View pornography store might hold the world record for the most price adjustments in a single month in the history of restaurants. Perhaps it is time to leave the ego in the parking lot, and put the pizza in the box. I will not be supporting this kind of blatant money hungry behavior all because of some instagram pizza review influencer's 8/10 rating. Stick to your local pizza and italian cuisine, don't bother with this place. Glorified bar pie with Michelin star pricing. read more

We ordered this for delivery the other night. Everything was delicious, some of the best around. The delivery was a little late but can't complain on the food quality read more

See all

This is the best pizza I've ever had. Top notch ingredients and inexpensive for the quality. read more

Pacidough's Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Best pizza place in the area food was quick, tasty, and reasonable. Great dough, favorable sauce glad to see the pizza wasn't swimming in cheese. read more

Well heard the hipe about this place and all I'll say is if you like burnt pizza with funky sauce this is the place for you. Not me way better places in the area. Don't waste your money read more

Got caught up in the busyness of a Friday. Ordered a plain pie. First time here. Wanted to check out the post portnoy buzz. I was sort of aware that the norm is a charred pizza. Mine was just straight up burned in some spots. Didn't feel like getting it redone. Haven't decided if I'd try it again. read more

Had to try the pizza with all the hype. The crust was crunchy, perfect and delicious. The meatballs were very tasty!! I did not like the sauce on the pizza. The sauce had an awful taste. read more

Very disappointed considering all the hype I've heard. I ordered online around noon for a 5:00 pickup. Arrived just before 5 and had to wait 20 minutes. At least 6 employees all of which seemed like they had nothing to do. Perhaps some were training, hard to tell. But I've tried to order online and by phone in the past and was told it would be an hour or more. Just doesn't add up. They were not pumping out pizzas like I've seen at all the other pizza places in town on a Friday night. The crust was anything but thin. Very thick and dry. Ordered the Trenton, half plain half meatball and a onion and steak special. The steak one was good. Lots of leftovers because no one liked it. Wish I hadn't tried it and stuck to the several other Italian spots around town. read more

Great staff Awesome pizza nice crust with a sweet sauce Incredible meatballs A great experience overall! read more

Great meatballs and everything else I have tried place is clean very good customer service

Absolutely the best pizza we've had in our area! Our go to place. And very nice people too!

Amazing Pizza! Loved every bite! Very friendly and attentive staff. I will be going back for more!

What is pictured is the same my family recently bought-a large sub for $15. 4 meatballs and approx. 8 inches. A little light on cheese and sauce also. I didn't like the meatballs . Too much pork in the blend. My step daughter didn't like the meatballs or the sauce. The pizza is Ok. The sauce was a bit sweet. $3 a slice and it's not a larger "slice pie" slice. More like a medium pizza slice. $15 for a half a sub anywhere else is vastly overpriced. read more

See all

Pizza was delicious! Perfect crunchy crust and sauce is very sweet as opposed to bitter tomato sauce it really elevated the flavor of the pie. read more

Great crust. Delivery and pickup slow. Place is small limited seating. Location is a little tough to get in abd out of

Great pizza, very good, chewy yet crispy crust. 4/5. Long wait time, order in advance.

I saw a review on Facebook, so I tried it. My opinion is it will be my go to pizza place from now on. Great sauce little sweet not tart asked for thin well done and it was perfect. Good luck to them. They will definitely need a bigger place soon. read more

My neighbor ordered them and said they were great. I didn't believe him, but tried it a week later, and there is no better pizza in the area and hasn't been for a long time. The people are nice, the food is amazing. This reminds me so much of 90's Jersey Shore pizza before is started losing quality. 90's ambiance to look at while you wait. read more