I have been to Slice House Toms River several times. I really like it. This pizzeria on 37 has…read moreenough room for casual eat in after counter ordering. SH does a large takeout and delivery business as well as the store ordering. Parking is easy out front. The place is clean and service is good. It is a bustling place at times with young people running the front. The pizzeria boasts many, many selections of by the slice as well as a menu of pies to order whole. Lots of add ins and drinks both bottled and fountain style. The pizza is tasty. It is served hot. I especially like a cheese pie but found their specialty pies like the cheesesteak & chicken parm pizza delicious also. The cheesesteak in particular tastes like a breakfast pizza due to its cheese, cheesesteak that is seasoned like sausage and it's white cheese sans sauce. It would be over the top great with sautéed onions, mushrooms and green peppers on it. The chicken parm with red sauce and chunks of chicken with yummy cheese is also tasty. They have salads, Stromboli, sandwiches, garlic knots etc to add on. I really like the entree Caesar salad. The dressing is good and the lettuce is fresh. It comes with toasty bread. I will continue to frequent this quintessential Toms River pizzeria as it checks all the boxes

Friendly service, I think this is my new favorite spot when I am in the area! They have a to go…read moremenu with coupons you have to ask for if you don't get it. The eggplant parm is made fresh and delicious! they have an assortment of pizzas too. Garlic knots are also my favorite from them one of the things I definitely judge a pizza place on. Stop by get a slice!

The pizza was delicious. Crust was crispy and so good. Toppings were plenty. Sauce was slightly…read moresweet. Wings were great, lots of flavor with subtle heat. The staff were friendly. The decor was fun.

Delivery has gotten significantly quicker, but the food has taken a bit of a dive. The garlic knots…read morethey just sent us are burnt BLACK (see photo.) Decent, sweet pizza still but might start trying other spots. Also who leaves food on top of a flower pot next to a dog poop trash can when there's perfectly sanitary chairs next to the door you just rang the bell at? Common sense, kids. If you're getting delivery I'd have them hand it to you.

Sals is our go-to place for pizza, Italian, & sandwiches. They did a great job catering a big party…read morelast summer as well. Good food, friendly service, & reasonable prices. This last time we ordered bbq chicken pizza via delivery. It came fast, was hot & looked perfect. The pizza is so large you can only eat one slice! It was a little salty for my taste, but still pretty good.

We stopped here after taking a quick trip to the shore while in Philly for week 18 of the Eagles!…read moreWe were excited to try as the reviews were great! Ordered an Italian hoagie and a calzone, the hoagie was perfection everything I could ask for, the calzone was terrible wasn't cooked through and the sauce was more like tomato soup then marinara we thought we ordered grilled cheese too! Wasn't the warmest environment, there was an older guy there talking smack underfed his breath because we ordered a calzone, which we regretted anyways! Maybe don't be rude to customers that are just passing through wanting to enjoy the best things of the area I grew up going to, maybe the freezing had everyone on edge idk!

Honestly, such a good find. My parents always are going to the same restaurants and I like to try…read moresomething different. So we took a shot and ordered from here. I have to say, it was AMAZING. So happy we tried this place! First, the prices are so cheap and you get SO MUCH food. Second, the food tastes amazing. They are not scarce on the ingredients. They really put their all into making the food taste good. Third, the little restaurant is so cute and the staff is very nice. Come here!

If you haven't been to this pizza shop in Silverton since the new ownership took over a little over…read morea year ago, do yourself a favor and check it out, you'll be glad you did! With so many pizza places in the area, it says a lot that this has become my go-to. The quality, flavor, and service have all been elevated, and you can tell they really care about putting out great food. One standout that absolutely deserves a mention is their Birria Pizza. It's unique, insanely delicious, and something you won't find anywhere else around here. If you're in the mood for something different that really hits the mark, this is it. Consistently great pies, friendly service, and creative menu options...this place has earned its spot at the top for me.

First of all the pizza is very cheesy and delicious, the tomato sauce is authentic and also the…read morecrust is delicious This was my first time trying this place and I would certainly recommend it, not only is the food delicious but the prices are amazing! I got 2 slices and a drink for 6.00 plus tax, and they have specials every Wednesday. Not only is the food and prices amazing but also the service is outstanding, the service is friendly and they make you feel welcomed. I arrived 2 minutes to closing and the guy made me a whole pie with a smile. You wouldn't get that anywhere. The ambience is updated and it's a very nice and comfy ambiance. I would definitely recommend it if you pass by Tom's River.

dude that's usually always there is weird as hell, asking my daughters weird questions about her…read morelove life even though she is 13??? the pizza there is alright but it is just that dude with a weird looking tired eyes and dark skin who keeps acting like a little pedo. not coming back again. and definitely not safe for younger girls who come to pick up or order food.

I feel like I'm the last to know about Woodshed Pizza. My family members have been raving about it…read morefor what feels like ages, and my first bite was last night. We ordered takeout and had three different pizzas. We asked them to cut each one into eight slices so each of us could try several bites of each pizza. * Soppressata, Calabrian chili oil, and hot honey * Semplice (plain) * Margherita with fresh mozzarella, basil, and EVOO I can safely say that every single solitary bite of every single pizza was superb and absolutely excellent. We also loved the Limoncello wings. They were even more enhanced with some of the hot honey. Needless to say, I finally understand what all the excitement has been about. I understand that their salads are equally delicious. I'll add that into the mix next time... And there will be a next time. Like I'm thinking today! (I almost hesitate to submit this review because the restaurant is already jampacked with people trying to get back to this amazing pizza)

My favorite pizzeria!…read more All great vibes! Friendly staff! Delicious pizza and salad! Enjoyed the dessert! Lemon mousse Freshening and light! Awesome way to celebrate the Fourth of July! Server Carissa was awesome! Appreciate her recommendations and letting us know we got a free pizza with their reward program!

We ordered on the way from a long day and drive to good ol south jersey. The chicken francese was…read moregood my husband was pleased. I had a salad and grilled chicken and the chicken was yummy. I would order again. But try something else iff the menus

Grandma pizza with pesto = $22.30 (online order)…read more Probably the best pizza in Toms River, our family has been regularly getting pizzas over the years here! Workers super friendly, pizza always taste the same every time, which means they have consistency of items being made. Crust is nice and thin, and the sauce they put is excellent, it has a slight sweet taste, perfect with pesto!

I was very happily surprised! I made the mistake of going to JOEY TOMATOES nearby last week. It…read morewas terribly expensive for what we got. The crust was overbaked and very hard to eat. The tomato sauce was from a can, I could tell. And, despite the fact I asked and paid for extra cheese, we didn't get it. Now to the good. Rosie's pizza reminded me of pizzas back in the day! They put on extra toppings, and tons of cheese! Loved their cheese. I could tell it was good quality! It was melted all over the pizza, and it truly was one of the best pizzas I've had in N.J. They kept our sodas filled, and were very nice to us. I recommend only this pizzeria, to be honest. Great food, great service, and reasonable prices. WE WILL BE BACK. Oh, and they are child friendly, unlike JOEY TOMATOES.

Another incredible dinner at Rosie's! Their pizza is the best I've ever had in New Jersey by far…read more The sourdough crust, fresh basil, and garlicky sauce all come together to create the perfect piece of pizza! Calling to order and picking up was quick and easy, and we were able to enjoy sitting outside at one of their tables. We love Rosie's!!!!

We come for the pizza hot out of the oven. BYOB and usually get a salad to start. The grand ceqsar…read morewith chicken. Service is friendly. It is not a separate dining room from the counter but it a fun NJ pizza place. Just a nice place to get a pizza.

Recently moved to Toms River! Told Brooklyn Square Pizza was…read morethe best in the area! We ordered the Brooklyn Square Pie! It was pretty amazing!!! Crispy thick crust! Flavorful sauce! Just the right amount of cheese!! Highly recommend!

Atmosphere is good. The man working behind the counter was friendly. This review is a little late…read more It was a few weeks ago. I am trying to get to every single pizzeria I can find and judge their plain Neapolitan slice. This one was fairly priced, texture of course was good, cheese and sauce ratio good. I would definitely eat here again.

I was in Manahawkin, NJ for a wedding and desperate for a vegan meal the night before the event…read more There are few options on Uber Eats for late night meals in Manahawkin and even fewer options for vegan food. I was amazed to stumble upon Attilio's Pizzeria with a well labeled vegan menu and so many meals to choose from. My husband and I splurged and had delivered: mixed salad with BBQ tofu, garlic knots, and a vegan grandma's pizza with mushroom and buffalo tofu. Every item was INCREDIBLE! The mixed salad of course was a pretty standard salad, and I was impressed with how well marinated the BBQ tofu was and how many veggies were included. The olives and red peppers were such a treat! The garlic knots were of course delicious. How do you ruin those? But it is so rare to find them vegan and really special to be able to order that. The pizza was filling, and we had leftovers all weekend! The buffalo tofu as a topping is so unique and also a treat to be able to have vegan protein on a pizza. The crust and sauce were both fantastic. There was so much flavor in each bite and just the right amount of vegan cheese to keep all the toppings on right. If I am ever in this part of NJ again of course I am ordering from Atillio's Pizzeria. What a gem for vegan options and I really thank them for such an inclusive menu.