Cancel

Open app

Search

Simple Gyro

4.5 (42 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

Order Simple Gyro Takeout or Delivery

Simple Gyro Photos

Business Info

SIMPLE GYRO ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Outdoor seating
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

More like Simple Gyro

Recommended Reviews - Simple Gyro

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

NY style gyro with the sauce on the side.
Renee C.

I want to preface my review with the fact I no longer stay in Columbus. It's important because something might be subpar nationwide, but great locally. I'm glad to see more variety of food selections here since I've graduated (many years ago). That being said, I ordered to-go the bang bang shrimp, 2 NY style gyros for me and the hubby (He's from NY), side of rice and hummus. The food overall was OK. The gyro meat was OK. The hummus was OK. The rice was slightly better than average, probably my favorite thing. My husband was not impressed. He thought the food was very subpar and didn't understand the extremely high rating. I personally think he's being a little overly critical, but he's also a New Yorker. I think the food is decent, but only for the area. So why am I rating it 2 stars? Well for one, they forgot my bang bang shrimp, and almost forgot my rice had I not asked them to check. It left me pretty inconvenienced as that was for an elderly picky eater who will not eat beef, or hummus. And two, the pricing is inconsistent and doesn't make sense. It was advertised to order online to save 10%. I ordered online and paid the same price. I also find it weird I would pay 2 dollars for an extra patty, but $4+ dollars for extra rice? The prices for extra sauce is almost a dollar. And third, my food was not fast at all. I ordered online and was given a 10 minute ready time. I got there 20 minutes later, there were still working on my order. I feel I'm being nitpicky, but I had much higher expectations given the unusually high reviews. It's the only reason why I gave 2 stars and not 1, to give the benefit of the doubt. Everyone has an off day I guess.

Gyro meat over rice
Julia G.

Food was delicious and well seasoned. That's often hard to find in a fast food type restaurant. The service was a 4.5/5, one of our orders took a solid ten minutes to come out after the other but it was clear the employees were working as quickly as they could. They just got hit with a rush of orders when we arrived. Nice location and inside was clean and well kept.

Gyro and loaded fries
Lori C.

We tried the lamb/beef gyros and the loaded fries and both were delicious! The fries were battered and fried to perfection and then topped with generous amounts of Giro meat, feta cheese, red, onions, lettuce, and tomatoes, and topped with tzatziki sauce. These were delectable and an unexpected treat for us. The Gyro was traditional but done right. Would definitely recommend both! Can't wait to come back! The service was great too.

Crispy Chicken Burger W fries
Lexie R.

The beef Gyro was simply perfect. I would appreciate a bit more meat to balance with all the other toppings inside, but this gyro is undoubtedly the best I've ever tasted--truly perfection. From now on, it will be a regular stop just for that. The chicken Shawarma served over rice is well-portioned, though it leans a bit heavy on either the nutmeg or cinnamon for my liking, while my husband seemed to really enjoy it. The Smashburger was exceptional. Personally, I would prefer a little more cheese, but it was cooked to perfection. The loaded fries are absolutely fantastic, but considering the extra charge, they should have more meat on them. The beef is seasoned just right. The chicken burger is average--nothing special to rave about or order again, just a basic chicken filet that was overcooked. The fries on their own are well-seasoned and cooked perfectly; they hardly need anything else. The service was incredibly fast. They prepare your order right in front of you, behind the glass. The establishment is very clean, with bright colors that are really inviting. You have two options for ordering: either in person or through a large tablet, which I find very convenient as I can see pictures. A couple of downsides are the sides; there are only fries available, and it doesn't specify the differences between them. I was unaware of the variations, and there's also a price discrepancy between the hot wings listed on the tablet and those shown on the TV screen.

Dining area

First visit, very clean, great food, welcoming staff. We tried the chicken gyro and the NY gyro very delicious. They have different sauces that are made in house. White sauce and garlic sauce are very good. We will be coming back.

Chicken rice bowl

Yhe rice bowl is great. The rice is unusual and seasoning was a new experience for me. I wish I had some right now. The fountain drinks and teas all tasted off.

Smash burger and a few FF. Both combos had very little FF.

Well the smash burger was really good. The staff is friendly. But I was really disappointed in the amount of French fries that came with the meal. Especially $32 for 2 burgers with fries

Wayne P.

This place used to be Pita Mediterranean. Simple Gyro is night and day better than PM. Food is delicious. Could have used a little more meat on the Beef/Lamb gyro, but was delicious nonetheless. I will be back to try other dishes.

See all

Photo of T G.
0
7
0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

One of the best gyros I've ever had! Saucy fries are a must. Quick and friendly service.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Simple Gyro

You might also consider

Simple Gyro - halal - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...