I stopped in to grab something small to hold me over while we shopped. Pros: It was clean and bright. There are a kiosks in the center when you walk in if you want to order but I decided to go to the register and order. There was no line and the cashier was friendly. There are a few tvs and lots of seating inside. Cons: I was going to order regular fries but saw they had a promotional on these Parmesan Garlic Fries and opted for that instead. There was no price on display.......there was my mistake.....it cost me $5.98 for some seasoned fries!! They were good but not $5.98 good. This was my fault but I have learned my lesson. read more

See all

This is typically a stop when we go to the Fashion Mall. Over the years, I've never tried the burger. Since they had a gluten free bun, I finally decided to try. I'm going to break down the pros/cons of the visit and venture down an area I don't usually have to. Cons: While waiting on our food, I felt every germ social media post quickly cross my mind. A girl with curly hair was flipping her head/hair multiple times while standing at the counter where they grab food to bring to the counter. She also had her face through the window area to the kitchen just inches away from several boats of fries and other food. Almost all employees were wearing gloves, but almost every single employee would touch their face or other areas without replacing the gloves. Due to everything I witnessed while clearly visible, I can't imagine what goes on behind customer view. Price - I was a bit shocked at the price. $30 for 2 burgers, 2 sodas and one fry at a fast food joint. Pros: The burger was good (but fairly expensive). read more

This is a pick up/delivery location only with limited parking for pick up. We had food delivered to us at a hotel a few blocks away. The Thai tea milkshake was packed in with the hot food, so it was melted. They also forgot to put a straw and napkins in the bag so that was frustrating as heck. The Thai tea shake flavor itself was mid. It had a very light Thai tea flavor, so I wouldn't order that again. The burgers and fries were delicious and warm. Just really perplexed as to how a place that does nothing but pick up and delivery orders doesn't know how to pack them correctly. read more

Recently walked over from a work meeting to grab some food at the Fashion Mall. Didn't have much time so quickly selected Shake Shack. Had a chicken sandwich, fries and a drink. (Apologies, no pic this time) Pros: Kiosk ordering was relatively easy, allowed great customization of your order, and payment was easy via Apple Pay. Text received when order was ready. There were several order kiosks available. Food was as expected, well executed, tasty and hot. Cons: Pricing while probably in line with this location (Fashion Mall) , was high for what was received. No combos available that I could see. It was all individual item ordering and no price break for a combo. Lots of choices in this price range that would likely be more memorable. If not for price to value aspect this review would have been 5 stars. read more

I was back in the area and wanted to try the mew Korean BBQ burger and well the fries too. Wow the price has creeped up all in burger fries and deink $18.00 so was hoping it was as good as it looked. Well not sure what a Korean BBQ burger and fries should taste like. There was brown sauce in a cup to put on the burger that had a strong umami taste to it and was good but kind of overwhelmed the burger. The fries had a dusting of a red spice and also had cheese on them. Overall it was enjoyable still kind of expensive and probably decided the new burger isnt my favorite, but was good to try. read more

See all

Ok burger. Good quality meat, kinda small, tasty toppings ok variety. I need to try the chicken sandwich I've heard so much about .... fries are about a 2.5 /5. All far too expensive. Culver's Shake Shack read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Greasy, horrible tasting, and the most expensive burger joint I've ever taken my family. Kids didn't even finish their lunch. Wife and I tolerated it because of the cost. What does that say about the food. read more

TL;DR Good smash burgers at the New York price. This location has self serve kiosks in the middle of the store. Only two of the four were working on this visit. We went in specifically for the Hot Ones menu and got a burger and chicken sandwich. The Hot Ones sauce was applied sparingly. The heat is very forward and then dies down. It's safe and good. The crinkle fries we got were plain, and delicious. The problem is the New York price point. $60 for the three of us to eat lunch. At this price point, Bru Burger is a much better burger (and fries) and sits outside the mall. They serve Coke products. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Hot Ones burger. It's not very hot. It's good though. What spice it has is up front and fades fast. - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I can tell that they're trying their darndest to make the best out of a chaotic situation. This Shake Shake is located in the food court of the Keystone Fashion Mall, so a) you know it's going to be busy because it's in a mall, and b) this is one of the only three Shake Shacks in central Indiana. Yes, it's very busy all the time. But they are also working very hard to get the orders out quickly, and they actually have a line set up with someone attending it to manage all the chaos. And there are touch screens where you can order, as well as the option to order from a person at the register, so once you get in line, it isn't as horrible as you think it will be (or as horrible as I thought it would be). Considering how many people were there ordering and dining in and whatnot, it probably only took me 15 minutes from the time I got in line until I got my to-go order. This time, I got the chicken sandwich, which is great. It was assembled a little slap-dash, but that didn't bother me too much. It still tasted great. The crinkle fries are always good. The restaurant is accessible from the mall proper. If you try to go in from their street entrance, you'll find out that you can't. The street entrance is where you can pick up online orders, apparently. read more

After a long work week, I decided I'd head over to the Fashion Mall to check out Central Indiana's latest Shake Shack, a New York-based chain that only entered our market this year with its first spot up in Fishers. This spot is located inside the Fashion Cafe in the spot that previously housed Tesla and directly next to a now vacant spot that was Shapiro's. While I think most people have heard of Shake Shack, for those not in the know this is basically considered one of the better burger joints. I'd probably call it fast food at fast casual pricing, though the food is probably just a notch above actual fast food. I will admit that I'd been a little underwhelmed at the Fishers spot and I was anxious to try this location. In my opinion, this location is warmer and a little more inviting. They had quite a few employees working and the hospitality was on high. As you enter, there's a set of kiosks where you can order if you're paying by credit card or you can go straight forward and order at a cash register. They had two registers and both were steady though not quite seeing the overwhelming crush that the Fishers spot saw in its opening days. I decided to order at a kiosk. The kiosk set-up is surprisingly wheelchair friendly and at a decent level. The menu is very logical and easy to use. I will admit I'm typically a service kind of guy, but I do like this convenience. They take your name and number and then they text you (and call your name) when the order is ready. I ordered a double burger with crinkle-cut fries and a large iced tea. I only had to wait a few minutes and I was also pleased that an employee offered to carry the tray. The layout is pretty relaxed. There's rows of tables on both sides of the dining room with the kiosks in the middle. I wouldn't say the tables are super wheelchair-friendly, though they're not bad and they are at a good height. You can get your condiments, napkins, and straws at a small area by the pick-up spot. I've still never figured out if they do refills on drinks and it does seem like the layout lends itself toward more of a quicker dining experience. This is more relaxing than Fishers, at least to me, because the spacing is better, there's also seating out in the mall, and the acoustics are considerably better here. It's still fairly loud, but it's much more tolerable. I enjoyed the meal. It came in at about $13 - the burger was delicious. The fries were tasty and the drink was solid. I'd say the burger is in the Steak n' Shake range, at least before the current owner completely tanked Steak n' Shake's quality. I would easily return here and because this is a mall there's ample accessible parking, automatic doors, and overall the wheelchair friendliness is very high here. They had a couple kiosks that weren't operational yet and you could tell that folks are still learning, but this was a solid experience and a better meal and better customer service than I experienced at Fishers. I'd say that Fashion mall easily has the best food court type setting in Central Indiana and the addition of Shake Shack is a definite home run for this mall. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Double Burger, Fries. - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

It was dark outside, I was making a quick return in The Fashion Mall, and I'd been craving a burger for weeks. When I walked by Shake Shack, I had to try it. I walked up to the counter and was the last customer of the day - yay! I ordered the ShackBurger and fries. The burger came with lettuce, tomato, and ShackSauce (similar to Thousand Island dressing). It was delicious! The fries were crinkle cut; nice and crispy. There were screens for customer ordering, as well as about ten booths for dine in. The only reason that I knocked off a star was because there were lots of crumbs and fries on the floor, but they were about to close, so I'll give 'em the benefit of the doubt. The manager was friendly and thanked me for coming in, which is always impressive! Thanks for a yummy, quick meal! read more

See all

The service was attentive and fast. The whole staff was on point and professional. Elijah, Jackson, and Jordan were the mvps of one of the best fried chicken sandwiches I've ever had. The place was crowded but not overwhelmingly so, as the staff effortlessly worked together to provide a great dining experience. Jackson, Jordan, and Elijah, or as I have dubbed them-J2E-all deserve raises. read more

I hadn't had Shake Shack since eating at one in Las Vegas several years ago, but the chain has made its way to Indianapolis so I thought I'd try the shakes this time! While they were very busy, things moved along pretty quickly and we had our shakes in no time. It was close to Christmas when we ate here, so each of us tried the three flavors of the holiday shakes on the menu and all agreed they were probably some of the best shakes we've had. My fries were good - I do wish they'd had more cheese on them, but the flavor was there and they stayed pretty crispy. I'll go back sometime to have a burger sometime! read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Shake Shake's Holiday Shakes and cheese fries - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We ordered classic burgers with fries. Exactly what you think you would get for a smash burger with all the fixings. Would not recommend the shake sauce, tasted like plain, extra thick mayo. The fries could use some more salt as well. The Tropical Kiwi Lemonade was the perfect refreshing drink. Nice seating area with roomy booths. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Tropical Kiwi Lemonade - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I wanted to like Shake Shack much more then I actually did. We were at Keystone at the Crossing and in a hurry, so we stopped in for a quick carryout order. I like the streamlined ordering system, which I used for our order, but you can still order from a human being. My husband and I both ordered chicken nuggets, fries, and chocolate/vanilla ice cream cups. The service left a lot to be desired. Every staff member seemed like they would be happier if everyone left. And little care was put into packing our order. One of the lids on the ice cream cups fell off when the guy was getting it out of the freezer and he just put it in the bag. Then, when we got to our car on the other side of the mall, we realized we had no spoons. Were we supposed to get those on the restaurant? I didn't see them. For a carryout order I would've expected them to be in the bag. The food was fine. It was hot. The breading fell off the chicken nuggets, so if you tried to take a bite instead of eating a whole nugget, you'd lose the breading from the second bite. But the flavor was fine. The fries were very salty, but also fine. The ice cream was decent. It wasn't the experience we were hoping for, that's for sure. I thought Shake Shack was supposed to be great, but it just wasn't awesome, and that was disappointing. There are many places to choose from in that food court, and we'll definitely dine at one of the other establishments next time. read more

This was my first time to shake shack. We were going to be in the area so we went to the fashion mall. We had to wait in line you either can order at the kiosk or a person we chose the person. But when you walk up you can't see the menu so you have to stand way back to read what you want. I seen the sign that said black truffle burger so that's what I got $8.79. My husband got the shake shack burger $8.49 and we both got fries because they don't come with the burger there an extra cost $2.99. Both got a drink our bill under $33.00. My burger was very good but the fries were just crinkle cut salty fries. My husband burger was supposed to have lettuce tomato and special sauce on it and it just came burger and cheese. I don't know if it was just this location but I don't think we're going back. read more

See all

They forgot my items and my food was very cold I'm disappointed. You might as well just hand me a wet potato than this excuse of a basket of fries. People who work here really need to pay attention to grabbing the sauces. read more

Half of the kiosks for ordering don't work and the others one that supposedly work kick you out at the end of the order. So after trying to put to an order for several people you have to wait on line to order with a disgruntled, unhappy, bored and rude employee. When you bring up the issue to her, her response was "What do you want me to do? I am only here to take orders!" BTW - if you like deep fried burgers, this is place for you. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Careless employee at the register. - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Nothing great about the burgers or fries BUT they offer a gluten free bun and that is a WIN for me. And the GF bun is only an extra one dollar. Lots of places it is is two dollars. Those dollars add up over the years. The fries here aren't guaranteed GF as they might have cross contamination in their production BUT that is better than most other fast food restaurants that coat the fries with gluten. So far I haven't had issues eating the fries here. One thing that really bothers me about Shake Shack - self ordering at a tablet. So detached. Can be more work than just talking to, well.... a human. Give me a human to assist me, please. read more

Did takeout from shake shack and our food was ready pretty quick but it was a odd time. The fries were fresh and crispy! The burger was good but could of used more sauce. Was surprised how small the burgers were. Staff was friendly read more

See all

Not exactly what I was hoping for after all the hype. We went and waiting in line for about 15 minutes in a loud restaurant. That wouldn't have been so bad if the food was only 'meeeh'. I got a Shroom Burger and fries while the gf got a standard Shackburger, both were okay, nothing to write home about. This place has been hyped to the point it's not able to live up to it. read more

This Shake Shack is located where Shapiros Delicatessen was inside Keystone at the Crossing Mall. There was a little line and it went fast!! You can order on the app, on the tablets they have set up or at the counter. It tasted great and ask for the shake shack sauce it's good with the fries! They also have seasonal milkshakes for the holiday season. I like how they have nice to - go bags that have handles! It's so much easier to carry your food especially if you have a drink in the other hand. I'm still a big fan of Shake Shack! I can't wait until the one downtown opens! read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Nice to - go bags - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

First time visit and boy what a disappointment. I guess because they're located in the Fashion Mall they feel like they need to charge extra premium prices. The fries were stone cold. If they had been warm, they probably would've been pretty good. Ordered a chocolate shake and quite frankly was no different than a Wendy's frosty. The menu placement in the store is difficult to read when you're ordering at the counter. Seems like they would be better off eliminating the counter ordering option and go with their self-serve kiosk. The burgers were decent but certainly not so amazing that they couldn't be replicated at any number of higher end burger joints. I'm sure I'll stop by again and hopefully the next visit will be much better. Until now, only two stars and that's almost too generous. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Parmesan garlic fries - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I'm so happy to have a more convenient Shake Shack location near me! My wife and I tried the Chicken Bites with Shack Sauce, fries, and Chicken Shack. I ordered ahead just in case there was a line since it's still relatively new. The pick up was quick and easy without waiting in the line. As for the food, everything was fresh and hot when I opened it at home. The fries were crunchy and delicious, the chicken bites also have a good crunch, but lack a little flavor and are SUPER greasy. The Shack Sauce is also lacking as it tastes more like mayo than a flavorful aioli. The Chicken Shack was perfect and the garlic herb mayo is amazing! I wish there was a little more to it. Also, I normally dislike pickles, but they added a great texture and flavor to the sandwich. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Chicken Shack - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I have been a fan of the shake shack way before they came to Indy so I am happy now that we have 3 locations around the city. I'm a sucker for a good burger and I'm never disappointed when I get one from here. I just love the basic shack burger, fries, and chocolate milk shake. If you want to try something different they always have various specialty items on their menu from burgers to lemonades. The keystone location is the closest one to me and I would recommend ordering online just to cut down on the wait time. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - They have kiosks to place your order. Great last day of school meal for the kids. The line moves pretty quickly at 4:30. - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Excellent food. Fast service. This is just a burger review. The beef patty was grilled to perfection, with crisp edges to the patty and a retained inner moisture. The bun held up to the patty and had a buttery flavor with a decent chew. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Just a burger - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My little sister had never had Shake Shack and after a dentist appointment I took her for a treat. We because it's a Wednesday afternoon it was largely empty and we walked up and ordered with no wait. I love the order screens- making it easy to own the experience. The only time I had to interact with a person was when my name was called less than 4 minutes later! I got our tray and it was full of cheesy goodness. A single bacon and a double bacon cheeseburger one cheese fries, one bacon cheese fries. I still take issue with the cost, as a meal for two was $31 (not including drinks), so it's not a meal we frequent. But def a nice treat when possible. The restaurant was relatively clean with nice background music to vibe to. We quite enjoyed this little afternoon sister date. read more

See all

Food is always on point. Hot and fresh. What makes a good burger are the fries that are served with it: I love a good crinkle cut fry. We came in on a Tuesday evening. We ordered our food on a kiosk and it was ready within 7minutes. I love when the managers come out and check on the Customers while eating. Just to do a check to make sure food is to your liking. It was really refreshing to see the manager running trays out to customers and actually wiping off tables and tidying up. It wasn't busy at all and he still came out to do that: I've visited this location several times, some busy and some slow. All times food has been good, hot, and fresh. Clean inside so it makes dining inside a plus. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Shake burgers and fries with bacon and cheese with a root beer float - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I ordered the Shack cheese burger with pickles and tomatoes, and it was delicious. The cheese fries were horrible. I couldn't believe the fries tasted like they were fried twice and the cheese tasted like it's been fighting with glue. The cheese is so thick and it won't move. The ice tea and lemonade taste super water down. I would have taken this food right back but they closed shortly after I ordered. I know to order the burger ONLY. I tipped and everything and I'm so disappointed :( inflation is ridiculous and this was a waste of almost $20 read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Cheese fries. These were suppose to be nice and fresh :( - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Order a promotion shake like the picture, and didn't get the topping, they gave me the shake and didn't say anything, when i asked, they just told me that they are out of the topping. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Choco Salty caramel shake with no topping Min - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

the food was amazing! the service was not very hard to do since it was a kiosk, but the time it took to cook was Slow. food and the shakes were great! the ambiance was crowded and loud so it was very busy! read more

Food just ok Service - indifferent Restaurant was horrid, no one cleans up trash or cleans tables. 9 employees and no one cares about the dining area. Prices are outrageous. 1 chicken sandwich, 1 single cheeseburger, 2 shakes - $34 read more

Paid $33 for two sad burgers and old fries. This is mass produced fast food and its not great. Table was DIRTY when we sat down and when burgers came (ordered kiosk) the buns where already flat (not puffy and fresh like the pictures everywhere) Not worth the hype. Skip it. read more

Having been to Shake Shack in California, I was really excited for them to come to Indy. I love their fries! But unfortunately, both times I've visited, everything I've ordered has been cold.... except for the milkshake?! Twice, I received cold fries, a runny, not super cold milkshake, and a lukewarm shroom burger (and I wish they just had a veggie burger or a black bean burger!). I'm giving this 3 stars because I want to believe Maybe Shake Shack just isn't all that, though? read more

It was ok, the burger was great but not worth 6 buck for just a single burger with no cheese. Fries are just like white castles and we got a large drink. Burger, fries and drink 11.00. Not my style. Burger was great. You be the judge. read more

See all

meat smelled bad + was see through (picture below). overrated. very busy area. it was dirty. read more

Shake Shack The Fashion Mall at Keystone - Burgers Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Everything was great. Stopped inside the mall to find something to eat. I'm a sucker for shake shack, so when I saw there was one inside the mall, I knew what I was going to get. The chocolate shake is very chocolatey, which lead me to the conclusion that I'll never order that again. The food came out slow, and when I got the message that my food was ready, I had to wait an additional 5 minutes. Not horrible, but just don't understand. Overall, would go back. read more

I ordered to go so I can't say much about the ambiance, but this shake shack was fast and flavorful! It's really convenient for them to have a separate walk up window for pre-orders. I had the smoke shack and cheese fries. Both were delicious and service was fast! read more

World's slowest Shake Shack. Over 30 minutes and still waiting for a simple cheeseburger and fries.

Really enjoyed the hot ones chicken sandwich. It's in the Fashion Mall and as a result, is very busy and loud but that's not a fault of the restaurant. I'd give them five stars if the pricing was more reasonable. When Danny Meyer started the restaurant I recall he wanted shakes like those from midwestern restaurants and I'd say he's surpassed them. My kids loved them! read more