Everybody in our party really enjoyed the food, from the 2 pasta dishes, to the Cubano sandwich (BTW, mustard is the standard, not mayo as the menu lists, to the chicken MARSALA.. The portions were generous without being overwhelming. We didn't order the pizza, but looking around the room, it seemed to be a popular choice. There were only a couple of mis-cues. Two of us ordered the crab soup. It was not delivered until the entrees were brought to the table, and the temp was not as hot as it should have been. The flavor was good, but neither of us cold find any crab in the bowl. One of ordered a salad, and the wrong dressing was served. But that's a minor point. For the size of the restaurant, the menu was extensive. We will be back read more

Ordered a supreme pizza for takeout - really yummy, and good size for the price. Got a house salad to share, and that was terrible. 99% flavorless romaine with 1 tomato and cucumber and some onion pieces, and flavorless Italian dressing. We ended up throwing that away. But, would come back for pizza! read more

We found our new pizza & sub spot! Food was amazing! Friendly & helpful staff when I picked up my online carryout order. Their website is easy to navigate, too. So far we've had the pleasure of enjoying their pizza, cheesesteak sub, bacon cheeseburger, tailgate appetizer, sprinkle cake, Italian lemon cake, carrot cake & chocolate peanut butter cake and we've not been disappointed. Portions are great, too. read more

Food was great. Service and atmosphere too. Would go again and again. The prices are decent.

Every time we come in for dinner, we prefer the high tops in the bar area. The servers always seem to remember what we like to drink. We like watching CAPS games here cause they'll put the sound on, sometimes gotta ask. read more

The food has consistently been excellent. Portion sizes are large, especially their lunch sandwiches; I had to cut a club sandwich into pieces, it was so tall I couldn't bite into it! Service has also been good even when they're crowded. My only complaint is it's often loud in the restaurant so not a great place if you want to chat. read more

Came here for an early dinner and our server was great! She was super friendly and very attentive. I had the shrimp salad wrap with onion rings, and they were both really yummy, and the onion rings were big and fresh. We also had the mushroom and Swiss burger with a big side of fries, the mushrooms were raw which was interesting but the burger was great. read more

The food was absolutely delicious. Get serious and atmosphere. I would recommend this place to everyone. The seafood and pasta is amazing and look forward to eating here again. read more

Sergio’s - Pizza Near Me - Westminster, Maryland

The pizza was great! The staff were friendly, and the ambiance was nice, it was like a little bar and it was clean. read more

Sergio’s - Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westminster, Maryland

Hubs and I on our typical Saturday running of errands decided to try this spot. Neither of us had been here before; so, it was good to try something new. We were greeted by a friendly young lady whom stood behind what appeared to be a "to go" counter and she asked if we were dining in or carryout. We were advised to have a seat wherever we liked. The atmosphere was restaurant style, however, had a bar area with televisions located all over the restaurant. Our drink orders were taken by another kind young woman who seemed to be managing all the tables alone. I was impressed that she did this with ease and maintained a pleasant demeanor. We both had an alcoholic beverage; he a spicy margarita and I caramel Appletini. He enjoyed his drink, mine was fine I'm just not a fan of Tito's in a martini. We were given menus and had questions, and our server graciously answered everything. As seen in the pictures, the food was awesome, the menu extensive, something for all pallets. We will likely go again as with tip, we landed under $60 for both of us. From the dessert case, the cake slices appeared fresh. Although we didn't try any, we may next time. The only thing I forgot to do was get my points from the visit. The restaurant has a rewards program which I signed up for prior to arriving. read more

See all

Food is great and the old fashioned pizza is one of the best pizzas in Westminster. My only gripe is at times, when I order online, they give me the wrong type of bread. I've ordered their buffalo chicken sub multiple times and I'd say 2/5 times they give me a wrap instead of a sub roll. They also give me toppings I didn't select. It's not enough to not go there, but it is frustrating. read more

The meatballs are so good I get them on my pizza every time!! I love the onion rings, they are huge and have whole onions in them, the batter is spot on with crispness and a touch of sweetness they are so good! This place is my favorite for dine in or carry out and can be found on DoorDash which is very convenient!! read more

Sergio’s - Onion rings - Pizza Near Me - Westminster, Maryland

See all

There are three pizza places within a short distance of each other and I found this one the easiest. The inside is divided between a bar and sit down tables and it was rather loud when I was there. I placed and order to go with the friendly staff. I had a short distance to drive back to where I was stopping and the pizza was still too hot to eat. It was loaded with toppings so much that the crust wasn't able to support them and kept dropping off. The pizza was excellent hot from the oven as well as the next morning eaten cold. Well worth a visit if you enjoy True hand tossed NY style pizza. read more

Sergio’s - Meat Lover Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westminster, Maryland

I have enjoyed everything I have gotten here. The staff is friendly and the service is great.

Very impressed with this restaurant. We went for lunch with another couple. Our server was very attentive. Our table ordered side salads, taco salad, meatballs, sausage and meatballs, and a shrimp salad sub. The food was all very good. Large portions for the price which we thought was quite reasonable. read more

Great family restaurant. The food is excellent. The staff is friendly amazing and attentive. Best restaurant in Westminster. read more

I had this pizza yesterday. I got the margherita pizza and one with peppers and onions. It was pretty good. The sauce had a good flavor and even had a little bit of spice to it which was unexpected, but tasty! However, I wasn't a huge fan of how they didn't spread it evenly since many of my bites were just cheese + bread. My friend picked it up to go so I can't speak to the service or ambiance. Overall, a pretty unique pizza. read more

First time here and very impressed! Calamari was outstanding, old bay wings cooked perfectly, steak n cheese was one of the best I've had in a long while l and the Naples pizza on point! Great bar area with all higher end liquor was very nice! 10 tv's and touch tunes!! Kelly was our server and did an excellent job! Definitely will be back! read more

Sergio’s - Pizza Near Me - Westminster, Maryland

Wife and I very much enjoy this restaurant. We have never recieved a poorly prepared meal here. Great subs, Denise's Special is our favorite, unique grilled Romain salad with grilled shrimp is very good. Great staff, great bar staff that can mix a fine drink. Friday and Sat can get a bit crowded, but that is because it is good. Take advantage of reserving a table on Fri and Sat available on there web site. Wife and I feel that they also serve the best pizza in Westminster. Very fairly priced, won't break the bank. read more

The food is always amazing. The staff are obviously super busy but are always attentive and really responsive. Food comes out quickly with huge portions. read more

Sergio's has very good food. We have tried several dishes but actually prefer their pizza. It is down perfectly and very tasteful

Great service, great food, atmosphere is welcoming and always a good time! Highly recommend grilled romaine with blackened chicken and old fashion pizza. Chefs kiss! Carry out or dine in always a great experience! read more

Sergio’s - 16" Old Fashioned Pan Pizza extra sauce and grilled romaine salad - Pizza Near Me - Westminster, Maryland

See all

Friendly staff. Always super sweet when I come in to order they are always ready with a smile & positive attitude

We have had multiple orders both pickup and delivery and we have always been pleased. The family is a big fan of the old fashioned pizza and the variety of the menu is good for the toddler life. Sometimes they have been slower but being able to weather the short staffing and unpredictability of supply chain issues, I think they do a good job. It's a nice local place that tries always to deliver a good product. read more

Worse pizza i have ever eaten. Ordered an Italian sub and it was literally a ham sandwich with no toppings. Will never return. read more

This was our first visit to Sergio's. We had a great meal last night! The lasagne and stromboli were delicious. My husband had a beer fight and I had a nice glass of pinto noir. We saw friends at bar and in the dining room. Sergio's is the perfect spot to spend a Friday evening. We'll be back. We hear the pizza is the best in town. read more

I LOVE their cheesesteak and fries with gravy along with their Maryland crab soup and shrimp salad sandwich!!!

Updated to add: under new ownership and the pizza is totally different and not in a good way. Very disappointed. Haven't tried the subs yet. My tastebuds are thrilled that the pizza and subs here are so delicious. My wallet isn't mad about it either...my waistline, on the other hand... seriously though, the bread is perfection: crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, the subs are jam packed and priced right. The pizza is NY style, just the way I like it! Try the spicy square slice, just the right amount of kick in the sauce! read more

Very happy we found this place. We got a carry out pizza and found it very good. So after that we went for a sit down dinner in the resturant. The cheese steak subs were very good. Service was good. My only issue is that they provide Lays chips with the subs. There are so many small local chip options in this area, should have UTZ and support local. read more

Sergios was a different experience and want to try something new with the wife. We got seated right away and gotten our menu but there were no silverware on the table. The host tells us that our waiter (was a dude) will be here in a few minutes. We never saw him and i had to wave down somebody else to take our order. It seem that our orginal waiter (dude) was more helpful to the table that had 6 people and was expecting a bigger tip then to wait on us of two. Well i hope he got a tip that was less than 10%. The waitress that i had to wave down gotten a bigger tip because she took us right away without making an excuse that she will get somebody else. The food was good when we did get it and the wine was great with our meal. Go early b4 dinner or later if there is just two of you. Other than that still had a nice dinner. read more

Just had my second meal at Sergio's. The first, there were 8 of us and we all ordered something different. The food was all brought to the table at the same time - correctly! Today there were 10 of us, and it was a repeat of the first visit. The food was great! The menu - vast! They also have a huge number of draft beers. Sergio's is on our rotation list of good restaurants. read more

I'm old school who believes 3 strikes you're out!!! I will never order carry-out from Sergio's again. On 3 different occasions I have ordered a whole steak sub(no cheese or hots) with lettuce, tomatoes, RAW onions & extra Mayo. 1st time, sub had cheese, fried onions & rest of condiments. 2nd time, sub had fried onions & rest of condiments. This last time, sub had fried onions & no other condiments. How hard can it be to make a steak sub the way I order it? read more

Grew up in Jersey I know good Italian been to Sergios twice now was shocked at how good the food was meatballs excellent the sauce excellent had the baked ziti last night most places don't know how to do it but it was tremendous best Italian I have had since I moved here do yourself a favor try it you'll like it!!!!!!..... read more

The bread on the cheese is to soft and light. Need good Italian bread. The bread makes the sandwich fall apart and soggy. The pizza is great. EJ read more

Nice, friendly staff and clean, quaint restaurant with the best cheesesteaks and pizza in Westminster!!! Very good bang for your buck!

Their pizzas have changed. Don't know if there are different hands doing pizza, I understand Sergio is still cooking, but pizza dough was thick and mushy, burnt on almost a full half. It's been my go to for pizza since they opened and reopened but that may be changing if we get too many more like that. Happened twice now. read more

I went in there about 2pm on a Thursday after lunchtime it was pretty slow. I ordered carry out from the counter and was glad I did order from there, and not from the bar. I have been in the restaurant industry for over 30 years mostly behind the bar and management. Anyway, the girl at the carry out was extremely helpful and pleasant, I placed my order left a tip and waited at the bar. Here's where my problem begins, it was a very hot day and I would have ordered a drink at the bar had I been offered anything. I sat there for over 15 minutes waiting for my carry out and the bartender (who wasn't very busy 3 bar customers and 1 table) didn't bother to ask me anything at all or engage in any polite conversation. No big deal , I had a water in the car but it could have been a few more bucks in the register and being a bartender all my life a few more bucks in her pocket. Also, while I was waiting she was making a drink at the service bar and opened a canned beverage and sprayed it on me with no regard. No acknowledgement, no apology whatsoever. This broad would have been better suited for a job at Social Security or the MVA certainly not any type of customer service. Anyhow, long story short the food is good and it's hard to find a decent place in Westminster anymore. If you go I would recommend sitting in the dining room or order carry out. I certainly wouldn't pay for that kind of treatment from that miserable #*@×! and that's coming from a bartender ! read more

We ate here for the first time last night and absolutely LOVED it!! My husband had a steak and cheese sub that was by far the best we've had in Westminster. I asked for my pizza well done and it was cooked to perfection! Will definitely be going back often! read more

Great pizza ate here a while ago and again just recently very polite staff and very helpful. They helped me pick out what I wanted by letting me know what was the most popular and helped me to decide. The reason for 4 stars is because I wasnt the happiest with the wait time but that is it. It is a great place to sit down with friends for a while and enjoy great food read more

First time. Food, atmosphere and service was great. Had French onion soup and pizza. Not overpriced.