Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Schaffer's

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed 11:00 am - 2:00 pm

    Schaffer's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Schaffer's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Kim K.
    0
    10
    2

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Up Cellar - Up Cellar Steak

    Up Cellar

    4.2(61 reviews)
    15.8 mi

    Thursday Special is half price cocktails!…read more Chelsea provides great service. A cute patio. Comfortable and chic interior.

    New Chef. New Menu. New Concept. Time to update. We went to Up Cellar last night after an…read moreexhausting couple of days. We had a spectacular dinner at the hands of the new chef, Nicholas Murray. His concept is that starters and salads are meant to be shared. With the proteins, maybe not, although each was ample and could have been shared. We started with the Ahi Tuna Toast, Ahi Tuna on toast with heirloom tomatoes and fennel on a piece of sourdough toast. That was an excellent start to our dinner. Our other starter was a Stracciatella, orange supreme, candied pistachios, basil and olive oil panino. This, we thought, was an outstanding dish. Neither filled us so that we could not go on. We then moved to a caprese salad - unlike any caprese we had ever had. Again, heirloom tomatoes, pieces of mozzarella, pangrattato (a traditional Italian condiment made from breadcrumbs toasted in olive oil with garlic and herbs) basil and mixture of balsamic and soy. So delicious. From here, my spouse and I diverged. She ordered the half chicken. Chef Thomas Keller (famous for The French Laundry) believes that a properly roasted bird is a definitive benchmark for professional capability. The reason is because there is no place to hide. Achieving crispy golden skin with completely succulent, non-dry meat requires precise control over heat and timing. Chicken easily dries out and turns bland. My spouse's chicken WAS PERFECT! The skin was crispy but the meat was succulent, even the breast! Clearly, Chef Nick has mastered this deceptively simple dish. It was likely the best chicken we have had in a restaurant (or home). I ordered the trout (a butterflied rainbow trout) served over a white bean puree, butter beans and with an optional salsa verde. I opted against the salsa verde because the trout did not need it. Finally, a word about the desserts. I ordered something called "Liquid Nutella" served with a hazelnut crisp and an in-house vanilla gelato. Oh my. This dish was decadent and resembled most a molten lava chocolate cake. I am not ashamed to say that except for tastes I graciously gave my spouse, I at the whole thing! Chef Nick also urged that we try his key lime pie. We did, but given my predilection to hazelnuts and chocolate, the Liquid Nutella was my winner. Chef Nick has spent the last 20 or so years away from Indianapolis and its environs honing his skills at Beaker & Gray in Miami and Eleven Madison Park in NYC among other places. We are glad he has decided to come back home.

    Photos
    Up Cellar - Discover Up Cellar's stylish decor. Cozy, inviting, and thoughtfully designed for a relaxed yet upscale dining and cocktail experience.

    Discover Up Cellar's stylish decor. Cozy, inviting, and thoughtfully designed for a relaxed yet upscale dining and cocktail experience.

    Up Cellar - Enjoy award-winning cocktails at Up Cellar. Expertly crafted, bold, and unique drinks perfect for casual gatherings or upscale nights out.

    Enjoy award-winning cocktails at Up Cellar. Expertly crafted, bold, and unique drinks perfect for casual gatherings or upscale nights out.

    Up Cellar - Salmon sliders at Up Cellar. Fresh salmon with bold flavor, beautifully plated and perfect for easy, casual dining with wine or cocktail

    See all

    Salmon sliders at Up Cellar. Fresh salmon with bold flavor, beautifully plated and perfect for easy, casual dining with wine or cocktail

    Simmons Winery - Wine flight

    Simmons Winery

    3.6(35 reviews)
    9.3 mi
    $$

    Pleasantly surprised by this winery. It'd been quite a few years since my last visit and I was…read moreshocked by the growth. There is now a restaurant, distillery, brewery in addition to the winery. We ended up having lunch before doing a wine tasting. We liked all of the wine that we tried and even ended up taking some home. The winery, restaurant & brewery are all housed in a redone barn. The place was beautiful and the service was excellent. Would absolutely stop by here again.

    We stopped by on our drive from Bloomington to Indy to break up the drive and try a winery we…read morehadn't been to before. I generally have low expectations for Indiana wines, and this was pretty much what I expected. Of the four wines in my flight, I couldn't even finish two of them. (A shame since they charge more for a flight than any other IN winery I've been to -- $14 for 4 wines!) The Cab/Zin blend was not too bad -- better than I had expected, actually, so the tasting was off to a good start. But the dry Riesling was awful. It had a distinct funk to it. As a wine specialist, I feel like I should be able to describe it better than that, but I didn't want to keep sipping to identify the "funk" more precisely. The semi-dry Riesling was drinkable (but way sweeter than semi-dry). The "semi-sweet" Traminette was full-on, dessert wine level super-sweet and lacking any acidity to balance out the sweetness. I couldn't finish that one either because I was actually starting to feel a little sick from the intense sweetness. My husband liked the Zin in his flight, and I thought it was okay. I also tasted his blackberry wine. I usually like blackberry wines because they have acidity & tartness to balance the sweetness, but this one did not. It was just all sweet. The service was fine, and the atmosphere was nice. I enjoyed the classic rock music. The winery shares space with 450 North. I can't say anything about the 450 North stuff or the restaurant because I don't like beer and we didn't get food, so the two stars is based on wine quality alone. I'm glad we stopped by so I know what it is, but we definitely won't go out of our way to visit again.

    Photos
    Simmons Winery - Banquet Hall gardens

    Banquet Hall gardens

    Simmons Winery - Winery options

    Winery options

    Simmons Winery

    See all

    Iozzo’s On Jefferson - Rigatoni alla Vodka

    Iozzo’s On Jefferson

    4.3(42 reviews)
    9.8 mi

    My husband took me here for my birthday, and I absolutely loved it! The food was SO good probably…read moreone of the best Italian places in Franklin. We loved everything we ordered, and my husband's favorite was the Toasted Ravioli! The restaurant is super cute, cozy, and has such a nice atmosphere. Our waitress was also very sweet and friendly. The only tricky part was parking since there aren't many spots, so we ended up parking nearby by the Mexican restaurant. Other than that, we had such a great experience and will definitely be back!

    My spouse and I chose this restaurant for a date night based on its positive reviews, but…read moreunfortunately, our experience was extremely disappointing. I ordered the Ricotta Gnocchi and the 4oz filet. After taking a couple of bites of the filet, I realized something was very wrong. Not only was it undercooked, but it also smelled spoiled. The odor was so strong that I became nauseated. To confirm my concerns, I asked our server to smell a piece that had been cut onto a separate plate. He did and immediately agreed that something was not right, even stating that the dish should never have left the kitchen. I want to give credit where it's due--the server was kind, professional, and genuinely apologetic throughout the entire situation. He removed the filet from our bill and offered complimentary dessert. When I declined a replacement meal, he encouraged me to order something else and he would have it boxed to go. I ended up ordering alfredo fettuccini noodles. What was frustrating was that I was still charged $27 for the replacement pasta. Considering my original meal was inedible due to a serious kitchen error, I was surprised to see that charge remain on the bill. By that point, I was exhausted by the experience and simply paid so we could leave. The server handled the situation as well as he could. My concern is with the kitchen and the lack of quality control that allowed spoiled meat to be served to a customer. I wish I had asked to speak with a manager before leaving. The seating arrangement is very close quarters to the patrons next to you and I did not want to appear like I was causing a scene or demanding a free meal. In hindsight, I should have made management aware of what had happened to help ensure that no other customer was served food in that condition. What was supposed to be an enjoyable date night ended with shock, disappointment, and concern about food safety.

    Photos
    Iozzo’s On Jefferson
    Iozzo’s On Jefferson - Lasagna

    Lasagna

    Iozzo’s On Jefferson - Lasagna Bolognese

    See all

    Lasagna Bolognese

    Solely Wine - Veggie Plate with Gluten Free Crackers - Amazing to share with friends!

    Solely Wine

    4.8(55 reviews)
    31.4 miOld Northside
    $$

    Solely Sober We…read morestopped in with some friends after dinner down the street and I'm really glad we did! As a sober person, I'm always on the lookout for fun NA options. The woman at the bar who helped us had amazing energy and was extremely friendly and helpful. She recommended two NA wines I could try and described them both in detail. They also had an Athletic Beer available. The space is super clean and chill. There's lots of space inside to hang out and play games. They also have a cute little patio where you can sit and watch the Monon. I really enjoyed my first visit and will definitely be back!

    This is my second time stopping into Solely Wine (first time was for a Yelp event) and both times…read morehave been great! When I had first visited and found out that they do wine bingo, I knew I had to come back. My bestie and I used to love going to Wine Market & Table for wine bingo, but after they closed a few years ago we never found anyone else who did it. Solely Wine has solved that! They have a nice selection of wines available by the glass, but they also have a much larger selection of wines, separated by type, that you can buy by the bottle (you can't grab them yourself off the shelf, a staff member has to do that) to open and drink there or take home. My friends and I each started out with just a glass of wine and then ended up buying some bottles to share while playing bingo since we were staying for a few hours and it was a better price point to share bottles. It can get expensive buying by the glass. They also have some snacks/appetizers available for purchase if you get hungry. The inside has lots of different seating options: cozy arm chairs and couches, large family-dinner-style tables, and smaller tables along the windows. They also have a beautiful patio! Towards the back they also have an art gallery and additional seating, although I don't think that space is always open. The bathroom is kept very clean and the staff are helpful and attentive. Can't wait to come back for another girls night.

    Photos
    Solely Wine - Wine Flight

    Wine Flight

    Solely Wine - Glass of Wine

    Glass of Wine

    Solely Wine - Bacon wrapped dates

    See all

    Bacon wrapped dates

    Antilogy - Brunch Waffle Fries

    Antilogy

    4.4(229 reviews)
    17.5 mi
    $$

    My wife and I decided to stop in here for a breakfast date and we're so happy we did!…read more When you walk into this place you're immediately struck by the ambiance. It's a hybrid between a breakfast spot and a cigar lounge vibe. We digged it! After sitting down our very friendly waitress came over and took our order. We ordered the orange sunrise mocktail, a quinoa bowl, gluten free pancakes and the California club omelette. Everything was AMAZING. Not one thing was bad. The omelette was one of the best if not the best I've ever had. Stuffed FULL of all the mix ins and cheese with yummy breakfast potatoes. The star of the show was the gluten free pancakes. They were stellar!! Would highly recommend. This place is one of the easiest 5/5 I've ever given. 100% would recommend!!

    Antilogy nailed brunch from the first sip to the last bite…read more We started with Bloody Marys. Our server asked if we wanted them spicy. We said yes, and she delivered. The cocktail actually had some heat, and the glass was rimmed with Everything Bagel Seasoning. I'd never had that before. It was a tasty touch. The candied bacon garnish was divine. We ended up ordering a second round. The Jalapeño Deviled Eggs are outstanding. Smooth and creamy, topped with jalapeño and candied bacon. Every bite was a pleasure. For entrees, I got the Bourbon Jalapeño Shrimp. It had a light kick and tasted incredible. My husband ordered the Rise & Shine Chicken Biscuit. It was all tasty, but that biscuit was fluffy and salty, exactly how a good biscuit should be. Our server made the whole meal. She was friendly and patient with me even though I was having more trouble than usual deciding what to order. She also mixed our Bloody Marys, so she was working double duty and doing it well. The space strikes a balance between sophisticated and casual, so you can dress up or keep it relaxed and feel comfortable either way. We'll definitely be back!

    Photos
    Antilogy - Interior

    Interior

    Antilogy - Shrimp and grits

    Shrimp and grits

    Antilogy - Espresso Martini Affogato & Ex-presso No-Tini (nonalcoholic)

    See all

    Espresso Martini Affogato & Ex-presso No-Tini (nonalcoholic)

    Depot Tavern - Depot Tavern

    Depot Tavern

    4.5(4 reviews)
    54.4 mi

    This is a very subjective five stars. Here's why:…read more 1. It's the only bar in Orleans. 2. They have Not You Father's Root Beer 3. The NYFRB and a PBR was $5.25. Like, total. Not each. 4. It's the ultimate dive. It's filled with all the dive bar regalia: Miller Lite mirror, Coors neon sign, Bud Light neon sign, Busch Light neon sign, pool table. They've got one TV. It's set to NASCAR. Smoking allowed inside, a true relic. When you only have 1 option, it's truly your best bet.

    This place is the true definition of hole in the wall dive bar, in the best way possible. Depot…read moreTavern is in the middle of nowhere Indiana but it was hopping on Friday night. There was a live band (the reason we sought out this place) and they charge a $5/pp cover charge. Their menu is basic bar food - mozzarella sticks, burgers, poppers, fries, etc. (no wings). The burgers looked REALLY good and everyone was ordering them but we weren't hungry enough to get one. We arrived around 7:15PM and stayed until last call. We each had 4-5 beers in that time (since we had to drive out of there on back country roads) and we split an order of mozzarella sticks and our total bill was only $30! Amazing! Note: they do allow smoking, almost everyone in there was smoking, and the ventilation system didn't do much to help the air flow. At one point my eyes were burning pretty bad - but it's a dive bar and I was not expecting it to be non-smoking. It's a cool little joint and I'm glad we went!

    Photos
    Depot Tavern - Friday Bike Nights and Saturday Charity Ride Stops

    Friday Bike Nights and Saturday Charity Ride Stops

    Depot Tavern - Right by the train tracks

    Right by the train tracks

    Depot Tavern - Saturday Steak Night! Ribeye, baked potato and salad $13

    See all

    Saturday Steak Night! Ribeye, baked potato and salad $13

    Schaffer's - wine_bars - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...