Italian sub. Yes. Strawberry Lemonade. Yes. Giant ahh ice cream. Yes. -------------------------------------------- read more

First time at Sauders and wow we were blown away! We started with lunch, always better to shop on a full belly. The food was incredibly fresh tasting and we got everything photographed (plus 2 drinks) for $36! We ended up buying some containers of the macaroni and potato salad for home. We ended lunch by shopping around the store and were impressed with all their goodies. We can't wait to come back when more local produce is in season. Everyone was very friendly, the building is clean and well maintained read more

Sauders - Reuben, fries, Mac salad, potato salad, Philly cheesesteak - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

So, I still love Sauders, always will. Fantastic store owned and operated by the mennonites. They some of the nicest people on the planet. They are so gracious and so helpful when in their store. I swear, I do not think I have ever encountered an employee at this store that was rude in any way. I absolutely LOVE how busy this store is. I will always smile when I see a local store that does great vs seeing the big box stores that do too much. Then throw in that this store is owned and operated by mennonites...that makes it even better. I was in here a few weeks ago with my mom when I was visiting her. PACKED! I couldn't believe it. So again, that makes me smile, makes me happy...to see this store continue to get even more popular with each passing day, passing year. They have everything a regular grocery store does, maybe not all the mainstream brands, but you seriously cannot go wrong here. One downside. OK so no matter what, you will save money of you shop here. HOWEVER!! like most places...the prices have increased here. That makes me sad. I get prices have gone up everywhere, but its little things like... ok....So if you are in any state where there are Amish and Mennonites.. you will always prefer their baked goods over the tired ass mainstream brands...whyyyy? because Mennonites and Amish just know how to bake and they make some of THEEEE BEST EVERRRR! That being said, I used to buy like a 10pk of Snickerdoodles at Sauders. First they were $1.99. Then they went up to $2.99. NOW!!! NOWWWW...they are $5.99!!! Thats BEYOND Wild to me. I did not buy them. I can't pay that much knowing what they were before. Yes, they are phenomenal, but I can go to an Amish baked goods stand or a store in like Penn Yan owned by Mennonites and get them much cheaper. Sorry, Sauders, I do not get the massive increase there. Again, yes, prices have increased on their items, but you will still save shopping here. That was just one tiny example. Im a wh__re for a snickerdoodle LOL. So I wanted to cry when I saw that bc I always got them when I. go home. Those days are over. Got some of the muffins tho. HUGE blueberry muffins and chocolate chocolate chip....$2 a piece. Worth every penny. Definitely check this place out. You absolutely will NOT be disappointed. From the amazing customer service, to everything they have in the store. Their produce section is fantastic as well. Thanks for reading, YelperSauderees! Cheers! read more

See all

This is a grocery store run by the Mennonites in upstate New York (Seneca Falls area). It's a large and beautiful store with farm fresh produce, hand crafted/ local cheeses, baked goods, and jarred preserved foods. In addition to foods that are made locally and grown locally, they have good such as toys and furniture and other items that are made locally as well! Beautiful hand crafted wood works from dining room furniture to smaller items for decor, to Amish made sheds! The folk running the store are kind people that are very friendly. They are people of the land, so they don't help with technology questions, but they're extremely knowledgeable about anything food or craftsman related! read more

Saunders is a big grocery store run by the menonites. There's lots of meats, fresh produce, baked goods, freshly ground peanut butter, a cheese counter with ample samples, and plenty of baking supplies. Specialties would be their jams and pickles- I have fun just looking at the names of them. Their candy selection is also good, especially if you like gummy candies. I can also find some unique sodas such as white birch beer, sassafras soda, and cheerwine to name a few. There is a little gift shop/religious books section near the front, which can be nice to browse through. Saunders sells outdoor furniture and decor, and there is a furniture store proper attached. I've been especially tempted by their swiveling and gliding rocking chairs. I've had some good food at the cafe, the Reuben in particular being super tasty. You do have to enter the cafe through the store and park your cart before you go into the cafe. You order at the counter and then the staff gives you a number and will bring you your meal. Car parking is ample here but there are speed bumps, so watch it! I haven't noticed any bike racks, so cyclists likely need to get creative. The store is closed on Sundays and can be busy with campers during the summer months. read more

Sauders - Traffic Jam in the jelly aisle! - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

What a beautiful store! So much beautiful produce and a wonderful bakery. Where're in Seneca Falls on vacation, otherwise this would be my regular store!! read more

This is my new favorite market! Fresh meals, healthy food and ingredients for purchase, and fresh fruits and vegetables. The desserts are on another level! Service is great and patient employees. read more

See all

I was meeting a friend for lunch and she suggested this spot. What a great place! This is a Mennonite grocery store that has a cafe inside. The food is basic but tasty and incredibly cheap! I got a grilled cheese that was absolutely oozing (a little greasy, but yummy) and soup, as well as cheese fries. I love cheese fries! The cafe is clean and there are a good amount of tables. The furniture is plain but there are windows and a cozy little fireplace. The store is massive - I've heard it started small and then expanded. It has an extensive grocery stocked with local goods. I got pickled okra and smoked gouda pretzels to bring home and everything was delicious. There are also random general supply stores and knick knacks. Very cool place, and one of the only spots in Seneca Falls that's open during lunch time as far as I can tell. read more

See all

Our niece who used to live in the area sent us there and we loved the deli. The pepper relish is the best I've ever had and I want to go back to the area just to buy that. read more

The BEST shopping experience in and around Rochester, NY. Yes a little bit of a drive, but, in nice weather driving Highway 5/20 over is a beautiful and you can avoid the Thruway. The produce selection is amazing, and most from NY and PA or near by locations. The small cafe is fantastic. The bakery goods are so VERY good and the in-house butcher shop is the best. Their sausages are wonderfully flavored and very tasty, as is the ham, chicken and other goods, many cut and prepared right there. GREAT place to get baking supplies and locally prepared fermented foods. I can not sing my praises loud enough. Don't wait.. go now. read more

If you've never been to an Amish grocery store this is the one you need to go to. It used to be like a little mom and pop store. And then they expanded and boy am I glad they did they have fresh cold cuts fresh in-house butchered meat. Little knick knacks kitchenware and it's all in bulk. Every aisle you go down is amazing just the things to look at fresh bakery baked goods a cheese department they even have a little restaurant which there's always a line from the minute they open probably till closing people buying subs Pizza you name it breakfast sandwiches. Everything's delicious. I love their meat selection great prices always fresh and their produce oh my gosh their produce is amazing it's always top quality the freshest as fresh can be. They also sell sheds and outdoor furniture. If you go next door in the old grocery store part they have furniture everything from beds and dressers to sofas and chairs and kitchen tables. Find quality craftsmanship. About 20 years ago I bought a coffee table and end table and it still looks like brand new. If you're traveling through Seneca falls you need to stop at Sauders. read more

AWESOME!!!!! Pickled eggs the mustard ones ...tried and looooooved!!!!! Everything we got is great there...PB, jelly, meat sticks,Chicken, cubed steaks, bacon just everything!!!! Going back this weekend for the 2nd time. More poultry and pork and beef and definitely more pickled eggs read more

5 stars for the store, 5 stars for the fruit and baking supplies and 5 stars for the diner inside! Definitely one of the best places to eat in town, good portions, good people, good ingredients, my kids love it (especially the ice cream and sandwiches). My inlaws like it (soups and sandwiches) and I find it always delicious and I leave very full without a broken bank. Can't recommend enough! read more

So many things to try and see. A wonderful place to shop! I really wish I lived closer, I would definitely shop here more often. But it's always a treat to stop on my way to visiting my daughter. read more

Sauders is LOVELY. My mother visited for the first time recently and told me later that same day that she wanted me to go back with her so I could check it out too. I didn't realize how large the place would be, let alone what a delightful selection of produce, meats, bakery items, jarred jams/jellies, or pickled items would be available. It's definitely one of those locations where you wander around to find unique selections, but you can also get great quality basics like prepared pizzas, salads, and so on. One of the things my mother wanted to grab during this most recent trip was one of the cherry pies from the bakery area... and while she got a large cherry pie, I picked up one of their mini-strawberry/rhubarb pies. So cute! On top of that, there's a nice little café where you can grab a bite to eat during your shopping experience. They also have a very nice selection of beautiful plants for sale outside, and even have items like gazebos for sale outside / in the back of the building. Of course, there's a Mennonite/Amish feel to the store, and spaces like the book nook area contain puzzles, books, and gifts that are more religiously-focused. Even if that's not necessarily your thing, it doesn't take over the environment of the store. If anything, there's honestly just a strong sense of pride in what's available at the store - and the workers clearly take pride in providing a lovely experience. TL;DR While it's a bit far away to be a regular grocery stop, Sauders is a fun experience - and provides some great offerings. Would be fun to check out during different seasons. read more

See all

Located in Seneca Falls is this unique country store. Great selection of fresh produce, meats, baked goods, deli and cheese shop. There is also a cafe where you can purchase sandwiches, hot entrees, soups, ice cream and fountain drinks. In the summer time there are flower baskets and Amish made planters. Service is fast and friendly. Very clean and neat read more

See all

Fantastic food and prices! Clean environment with food and groceries organized very well with a good variety. The cafeteria area has delicious subs and drinks, but I highly recommend the pretzel with cheese. WORTH EVERY PENNY!!!!! Service was a little slow but that was because so many people had ordered food. Yes, it's that good! I love going there! read more

Sauders - Pretzel with cheese dip - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

My husband called it "Amish Costco". Never didn't think I'd enjoy walking through a supermarket on vacation! The cafe was packed and for good reason, good coffee, good sandwiches, and friendly service. All the other departments had interesting food for sale and the people working here are helpful and friendly. There was even a relatively affordable souvenir area. If I'm back in the area, I will definitely come back with a better plan than I had on this visit, walking around aimlessly for two hours. If you're traveling, make sure to bring a cooler bag to bring home all of the smoked meats and cheeses. read more

Sauders - Cafe sign - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

Great selection of produce and specialty items. Full service grocery store. Prices range from really reasonable to questionable depending on the item. Always enjoyable to shop here. read more

I love stores like this one! Clean and just simple to get around. Beautiful mums and pumpkins were outside along with huge tomatoes and peppers. Inside is a full grocery store and small cafe. There's also a small book shop with puzzles and gifts. They do offer some prepared food. My friends and I came in to buy some things for a picnic. We picked up two large subs/sandwiches. There is also a large section with jams,pickles etc. read more

I had not been to Sauders since before Covid and they have really expanded since my last visit. Tons of interesting, packaged foods and fresh produce. I found the prices to be excessively high hence the three star rating we did not purchase anything so I can't comment on friendliness or helpfulness of staff. Decent selection, but be warned of high prices. read more

See all

The mums were beautiful! They were a great price for big, full pots.... with a nice selection of both flowers blooming and many pots with buds starting to open. An amazing variety of colors. Pumpkins, gourds, squash, decorations and everything you want for fall. They have an enormous meat section with cold cuts, cheeses and butchered meats. They have smoked pork chops and house made sausage in many varieties. Too many choices to list. I bought dried green lentils and smoked pork hocks to make a tasty soup. I got their jarred sauerkraut and pickled eggs. Their lunch sandwiches are delicious and loaded with fillings! I had roast beef and provolone and my friend had a BLT. They come with chips and pickles.my macaroni salad was very good, a little on the sweet side. My friend's potato salad had nice small cut pieces of potatoes, cooked well and a nice taste of dill in the dressing. read more

See all

I absolutely love this place. Not cheap but great place. They should lower prices to make it a true Amish Market! They will benefit greatly! read more

Love this place! Bulk candy, cereals, canned goods, fresh food and fruit, pies, meats. It's great! The cafe is great! They use real plates and utensils. It's a little gem in the Finger Lakes! read more

Sauders is a unique grocery and goods store. The Mennonite/Amish influence is strong. You can tell the workers take pride in their jobs as it seems that every product is perfectly placed and everything is so clean. The produce is typically fresh and you can't go wrong with any of their baked goods. They have some sugar free options for those watching your sugar intake. I am a huge fan of jams and jellies and if you are as well, you have to check out their aisles of such! The kids go crazy over the extensive candy selections. Most products are competitively priced, although their meat prices are on the higher end. I fan over the quilts they have for sale and furniture, most of which are out of my price range! This is a one of a kind store, I highly recommend visiting if you are in the area! read more

Sauders - Produce Area - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

See all

Love this place! So cheerful and open inside for shopping for everything from soup to nuts. For fall they have quite a display of pumpkins of every size and stunning mums. The prices are reasonable also. Not my first time at the store but my first time having lunch. This is a busy place at lunch but they are very organized and keep the line moving. I ordered a BLT on honey oatmeal bread and I side of potato salad. The price was just $7.77 for sandwich and $2.69 for side. The sandwich was generous and came with chips. Bacon was cooked perfectly and bread was toasted perfectly. The potato salad had small diced potatoes that were cooked perfectly with a dressing and dill. I did miss the eggs in the salad but it was a good variation. My girlfriend got a sub sandwich and it was huge!!!! I could spend many hours here just looking around it's a very cool place. I will get back before winter hits. read more

See all

So good. Subs are a win. Super friendly service. Everyone was full and satisfied. If we lived here, we would totally come all the time read more

This place is phenomenal. Come just to browse their aisles, even if you don't need anything! You're most likely to not leave empty-handed. They have bulk everything and it all looks high-quality. They have all kinds of gifts for the home too. read more

See all

A super location and a very niche business. An Amish supermarket that has rows upon rows of unique items. They had a plethora of jams, jellies, relishes, salsas and so much more. The variety of items such as the picked vegetables was amazing as was the vast variety of cheeses. Definitely something for everyone. read more

We have been coming here for years. Product and service has been outstanding. Not so much today. I prefer to buy my produce here because it is always fresh. I wanted to buy broccoli and cauliflower and Brussels sprouts but they were all clearly old and had started browning. So sad. We made our way to the food court and I ordered a BLT. Their bacon is outstanding so was so Looking forward to it. Mistake. Could you have been less skimpy on the ingredients? Thin thin slices of bread. One leaf of lettuce and the tomato was sliced so Thin it was like mush on the sandwich. The bacon was all in little bits. And to top it off I got about 5 chips to go with it. Awful awful. So disappointed in this trip. 2 because my husbands chicken sandwich was up to par read more

Very nice, polite, people and good products. I always enjoy going there and looking at all the array of items they have for sale

I loved this Amish market! They had a fabulous selection of fresh jams, pickled everything, sauces, produce, baked items and all the cheese! I got some house made pumpkin peanut butter (they had about 20 flavors). They have all the spices and candies as well as other gift and local made items! I'll be back. read more

Sauder's is a local treasure. Quality local products- great options for candy, preserves, cheese, deli, gluten free, fresh seasonal produce. I love coming by in the for for all the unusual pumpkins. Their frosted carrot cake is the best anywhere. For my family this is a stop we make every month or so. If you are looking for regional food gifts this is the place to come- coffee, jellies, jams, pickles, popcorn- everything you need for a nice package. There is an adjacent store that sells furniture and we purchased 5 chairs made from recycled milk jugs for our fire pit. They are a great selection of indoor furniture as well. There is an eat in deli- although I have never been I know it is popular. read more

We've been going to this store for years and they have an amazing selection of food, outdoor furniture (beautifully made), plants and home furnishings. There is a large variety of different meats, cheeses, breads, and produce but also have a HUGE dessert and bulk candy section. Sometimes I'll go just for that! Everyone working are so helpful and friendly there. read more

Sauders - Buttercup Squash Selection - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

See all

Gotta love the cafeteria with food taste, quality and price. All done with cheerful and helpful Mennonite girls and women. Store has an amazing variety including fresh fruit and vegetables.. Hand ground peanut butter is the best ever, made in front of you. "Home made" jams are the best (made by Mennonites or Amish). A destination store. Don't miss it if you're in or near Seneca Falls. Also a quality hand made furniture store abuts. Rest rooms are super clean. read more

My family lives in the area, so I stop in often. I love their baked goods, they are always great - my favorites are the whoopie pies and oatmeal cookie sandwiches. The veggies/fruits are hit and miss as sometimes much higher prices than other shopping locations in the area. They have some excellent low sugar jams/jellies and pickled everything. The Deli has a large selection and excellent prices. They carry all Yancey's cheese flavors with great prices. Their house made nut butters are a must buy - Honey Roasted PB is a favorite in our home. They also carry a nice variety of flavored coffee beans. Where Sauder's shines is the huge variety of baking items - tons of flours, seasonings, extracts available. They have a nice café which gets quite busy at lunch time. They offer burgers, pizza, soups, subs but my favorite are the excellent house made fries. They have a small seating area and makes for a cute lunch experience. They offer a wide variety of outdoor furniture, but I really haven't had much experience with it. Staff are very friendly and helpful. Stop in if you're in the area. Sauder's is about 10 minutes from Del Lago Casino. read more

I stopped by the cafe at Sauders for a mega sub, Italian with provolone, and all the fixings. Let me tell you , this place serves the best subs in the area. The cold cuts were piled high. The veggies were fresh and crispy. The roll was soft and tasted really good. I would recommend this cafe for your lunch if you want a good sub sandwich. read more

Sauders - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

Do you need jam? Pickled ingredients? Bulk items? Amish baked goods? Produce in abundance? Sauders was this store my mom always talked about and I was like sure-- that sounds like a small touristy story that sells jam. Ya, mom, we have seen that before. Then, she took me there. And holy shirt, it has so much there. Honestly, it was overwhelming. Just look at the pictures of the jam shelves! They had FROG (fig, raspberry, orange, ginger), traffic jam (lots of fruit, full of puns), and on and on and on. I think if I was putting together holiday/gift baskets for people - this would be the place that I go to. So many unique - but also tried and true - flavors and delicious treats. It is totally worth the stop if you are in the area. Plus Seneca Lake is quite beautiful. read more

See all

Wow! Locals get to call this their regular grocery store. They are lucky. When you think Amish grocer you probably think quaint. This place is not quaint. It is a power house. Everything you would expect from a regular grocery store and many things that are special. The summer offerings were awesome. Fresh from the farm. I grabbed green beans, tomatoes, watermelon, cantaloupe. All were outstanding. My real reason for stopping. Peaches! They had pecks of peaches at very reasonable prices from Amish country in Pennsylvania. After about three days they were peach perfection. If only they were that good year round. I also observed a very impressive display of smoked meats, an awesome deli and a cafe. Jars of homemade pickles, relishes, spreads etc. They had homemade bread in the bakery. Want an Amish quilt? They had those too. Don't worry about that whole no electricity thing. They accepted credit cards too. Sauders is worth the stop off the NYS thruway. It will take you a little out of your way but it will be part of my summer plans from this day forward! read more

Sauders - Peaches from Pennsylvania. Outstanding! - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

First timeout like this place it has a little bit of everything you can sample cheeses and they have a lot of local farm food they have samples of lots of items to try and you can get some things in different sizes like baked items to soups love this place and prices are not to high Love this place still great deals always clean and service food read more

Sauders - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York