Great value for the sandwiches! Lots of cool stuff, check them out . Friendly service and clean place

Great googly moogly... wish I lived closer to Sauders. Hepped to this joint by a blue route fanaticist, my former co-worker Marcia K. who only drives on blue routes... no two lane roads for her (makes her nervous). Stunning array of jams, jellies, grocery items not seen elsewhere. GREAT deli if you're hankering for a fresh sub. Tremendous selection of baked goods... the lemon bars here are a must buy. Bottom line: if you are anywhere near Sauder's it is a must visit! Unless, of course, it is Sunday. read more

Amazing selection of gourmet foods baked goods! This is the store to go to (over & over) when visiting this area.

Decent prices and good selection, if you don't mind lax health/safety standards. I am a longtime customer at Sauder's and have always loved it. But my opinion has changed drastically since the start of the Covid pandemic. Along with my own observations of their absurd approaches to "masking" (lace face coverings or tiny plastic shields in front of their lips), Sauder's was also written up for multiple health/safety violations by the Dept. of Health. Now, I know a lot of "rebels" out there don't care about masks or even their own (and others') health. But if a food provider is blatantly cutting corners when it comes to health and safety, then there's good reason to worry about what's going on behind the scenes, too. In short, be aware that you might be risking your and your family's health by shopping here, whether during the pandemic or after. Personally, I'll be double-masking in the store, and I won't be buying any prepared foods, only produce and bulk items that I will wash and cook myself. Low prices are great and all, but they often come at a cost. In a profit-driven society, our principles and decisions as consumers can make a difference. read more

Okay, so I came and saw what the fuss is about. Large aisles with plenty of items, ranging from spices to mixes to candy, nuts, cereals and more. A bakery, meat market, produce and cheese place. In the end, I did buy some cheese and macaroni (for dinner that night). It is a supermarket, designed for people who cook and can and enjoy Amish baked goods. I bought an Apple pie, too, but the filling seemed to have come from a jar. It was mushy. Meh. read more

What's not to love! The cafe/deli is absolutely delicious. It really doesn't matter what you order here, you know it's going to be fresh and tasty. I love their daily soups. I highly recommend the regular sub, where you pick all the ingredients just like in Subway but 100 times better. I also tried their pizza slice - which was probably my least favorite, but I didn't care much for the crust. The toppings were delicious Their hot dogs are yummy as well. On a hot day, try their hard or soft serve ice cream and for a small upcharge they will serve it with a slice of pie as well. The grocery is incredible as well - especially the fresh produce, the meat section, the dairy and the cheese section. They also have everything you ever dreamed of canned, pickled or in a jam or jelly form. If you planning a picnic, this place has a freshly pre-made cold salads, fruit salads, bread and the variety of sodas and other dry products is unreal. Everyone who works here is also very nice and helpful read more

Extremely nice bulk food store with tons of selection. They also have a large cafe, a fresh meat counter, a deli, lots of produce and a huge selection of bulk foods, refrigerated & frozen products. Not to mention, a great owner. Better prices than other grocery stores around. If you have the option, support this store over your average chain. Its worth it! read more

Excellent place to go for reasonable prices on items you use a lot (semolina flour, yeast, spices, pectin, canning wax, etc). Only weird thing is there is no bratwurst. In fact no German sausages at all. I mean these folks are of German parentage, yes? I asked the girl behind the counter for bratwurst. She looked at me like I had two heads. I tried again with my high school German taught by a Austrian: "Hast du eine Bratwurst?" heavy on the "braaht-voorsht". She called the head butcher with my question. His reply "What is that?" So they have Italian sausage for days...but not a single one of the 1500 types of German sausage. Weird. read more

Love this local store! Mennonite owned and everything is delicious and pretty unique too! You can get hot food, product, snacks, mixed, spices, birdhouses.. a wide array of wonderful goods! Love coming here when I'm in Seneca falls! read more

Love this store! Produce and meats are fresh and delicious. Sandwiches from the deli are the best! Their baking supplies are amazing! Also, the girls who work there are very sweet and helpful. read more

Sauders Store is an genuine Mennonite country store that is packed with fresh produce, bulk packaged goods, Pennsylvania German meats and cheeses along with specialty products for the Mennonite community. The baking and spice sections of the store are extensive and inexpensive from a spectrum of sanding sugars, bags of dried cherries, apricots and mangos, to gummy candy anythings (fried eggs and chicken feet notwithstanding) to cookies to make ice cream sandwiches with . Their deli is not to be missed. Lots of John Martin cold cuts and smoked pork chops and ham hocks (for soups) not to mention local sausages from Hoffmanns. And the prices are unbeatable (really). Quality, excellence, great prices and friendly people gives Sauders a top ranking from me. I know that regular pilgrimages to Seneca Falls and Sauders will be filling my spring. read more

Sauders - Photo by Greg Cotterell - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

Visiting wine country from New England.....A MUST VISIT...Prices were LOW.The selection of jam, salsa,pickles left nothing to the imagination..XL coffee and big sticky bun Less than $4..we sat in the cafe. My only regret is that we are still 3 days from home and therefore only purchasing non perishable goods! read more

Sauders - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

Phenomenal store. We have nothing like it in my Area, that's for sure! Tip: Don't put jams or peanut butter in carry on luggage if flying! TSA confiscated my peanut butter- said spreads aren't allowed on carry on. Thank God I packed the jam in suitcase that was checked in. They said I can call and order and they will ship so I may try that. Only thing missing is online ordering. Maybe someday.... Loved this place! So many interesting home decorating items, handbags, candy, baked goods. I could go on and on! read more

This is the best place ever! If you are staying in the area it is a must visit for groceries! It's an Amish market and all the meat, vegetables, baked goods, etc are extremely tasty and fresh! You will not be disappointed!! read more

My family loves shopping here. Fresh produce, awesome meats and deli items, make this top notch. On Saturday they have samples throughout and I like to taste everything to discover new foods. Love this place!! read more

The thing that struck me was how clean this store is! Nice selection of meat, bulk goods, and baked items. Just about every variety of cheddar (yancy's) you could imagine. A fun place to check out if you are at the outlets or Seneca Falls. read more

This place is a nice alternative to the big chain stores. They don't carry as much of a variety as the chain stores but you can still find what you need. There is a nice selection of canned items. Jellies, jams, pickled veggies. The deli is huge. There is even a place to get subs/sandwiches. Right next to it you can get fine made Amish furniture. read more

Great lunches, great groceries. Some items are one-of-a-kind. Everyone in the family will have their own favorite item here. Best jams around. read more

If you are looking for snack foods and things to spread on them, both in nearly infinite varieties, this is definitely the mothership calling you home. The place is also made for people running a catering business and as well as those like looking to keep the local birds fed all year long. The Amish staff are quiet but friendly as you would expect. It was actually the other customers who made the experience less enjoyable by rushing through the store without much regard for anyone else. We picked up baked goods for the most part, but you will definitely find a wide variety of products either made in Pennsylvania or enjoyed by Pennsylvanians. Amish paradise indeed! read more

Sauders - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

Sauders is a nice large grocery type store. Might be called the Wegmans of the Amish/Mennonite communities. It has a big variety of jarred and canned goods as well as a plethora of bakery items and fresh meats and produce. There's even an area of Household decorations and Knick Knacks. It fairly easy to maneuver. We went on an early Fall day and the pumpkins and mums were beautiful. read more

The employees don't wear masks, even the one's serving food. An employee got snippy with me when I asked if the employees were vaccinated. Mennonites don't get vaccinated. read more

I love Sauders, but be aware they are no longer wearing face masks. I did a quick turn around as soon as I realized and left. It will be awhile before I go back. read more

I am a disabled Veteran, 76 years old with many health problems. I stopped into Sauders with my service dog. i went to the cafe for a sub and drink. I was going to sit for a while and rest while I ate lunch. My small service dog was contained in a dog stroller with a "lid" with netting for vision and air flow especially designed for dogs. After I paid for my meal I was told I had to leave. Dogs were not allowed in the store. I told them there are no tables or any area to eat outside. I was still coldly turned away. Amish and Mennonite people refuse to serve our country - they will not serve or contribute to the military. This vast group of people live here safely yet won't serve and protect. But at least they could respect those brave Americans who have, especially those that are war veterans. read more

Love Sauders! Had been wanting to get here for a few years- especially after hearing reviews from many of my friends. Stopped in the morning on the way through town and was not disappointed to say the least. Much larger inside than I had anticipated. Very spacious- great selection- and helpful workers around every corner. Many locally grown and produced items. Many samples of mustards and dips to try. Prices seemed pretty good and the meats that we bought were delicious. They also have a huge deli counter and a sit down area for eating. Next door you will find handcrafted Amish furniture, toys, bird houses, etc. looking forward to a return trip to Sauders! read more

Sauders - Handcrafted bird feeder at Sauders - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

Went to this place for the first last week, why did I wait so long? Unbelievable place. Cannot find one negative thing (except for one whiney reviewer that was upset they didn't have zucchini bars? I'm sure they keep them stocked just for you, spoiled millennial! ) Prices great, selection great, quality great, what more can you say? Def 5 star (even if they run out of thing late in day! Duh, can you say fresh?) read more

I just LOVED this store! I didn't realize how close it was off the thruway, exit #41, only 5 miles after you get off the thruway! I needed to load up on bulk baking supplies and this was definitely the place to do it! They have everything you need from fresh fruits, to beautiful flowers to all your baking supplies! I replenished my stock for wheat flour, sugars, oats, spices and sprinkles!! The employees are very friendly and will help you find what you need too! If you haven't been, you need to go!! Best prices for bulk items too!! read more

This store (which was recently upgraded in size and offerings) is a top list stop in the heart of the Finger Lakes Region. If you are looking for great deals on bulk foods (especially spices and baking items) this is your spot. The poultry and baked goods make it into my cart each time I go. Quality service and ingredients. If you are looking to get the best of baked goods and other key items try earlier in the week. Best time to go to beat the crowd is later in the day or Friday nights. (You have to try the zucchini bars, that's if I haven't bought them all) read more

A fun grocery store and cafe hosted by Mennonites. There's a mix of home bottled fruits, jams, pickles, and even homemade cheese. We arrived late in the evening so the grill was closed but we enjoyed a sandwich and salad at the cafe. read more

This is an excellent Mennonite grocery store. But be warned, on the weekends it gets busy and you will have a hard time navigating your little cart through the little aisles. This is THE place for deli meats, chicken, cage free eggs, butter, vanilla bean, bread, buffalo turkey breast, smoked pork chops, potatoes, spices and CANDY. The packaged from bulk candy selection is crazy. If you love gummy anything you will appreciate the selection here. Cash or credit, friendly, efficient check out process. Tops Markets could learn some lessons at this store. Bravo!! read more

Sauders is an Mennonite Fresh Market. It's a great place to shop inexpensively for groceries and they also have the best cold deli in town. read more

Sauders - My Favorite Store - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

I have been going to Sauders for 20 plus years- well before their recent expansion- which is impressive. It is a Mennonite run store with all sorts of great items. I particularly go to Sauders for the bulk spices. Every imaginable spice is available in a plastic container in small, reasonably priced quantities. Bulk candy! Where do I begin? Probably with the bag of spearmint leaves or perhaps the sour gummies. Maybe the chocolate covered peanuts or licorice. Let's just say they have plenty of bulk candy for everyone. They have a large selection of canned items like pepper relish (yum), pickled beets (yuck) and loads of salsas. Great store with great selections. read more

This place is such a treat! We were in the area visiting some spots in our church's history and I had put Sauders on our "nice to see" lost. At our last stop of the day one of the guides asked me, "have you been to Sauders get? You have to go!" So we did and I am so glad! The selection of bottled/preserved goods is enough to blow your mind. Then add the biggest assortment of sprinkles, pie fillings, and flavoring extracts I have ever seen . . . so much entertainment! My friend told me about their amazing dip mixes and I picked up a bunch to bring home to friends. The homemade peanut butter and bread made for delicious snacks during our road trip. We had hoped to get sandwiches but did not realize they closed at 6pm. We lost track of time while shopping / exploring the aisles and then had to quickly checkout so they could close. read more

See all

We do all our deli shopping here everything is fresh. Usually free samples throughout the store. I would recommend stopping by the sandwich shop and ordering a mega sub there worth the money for the meat. read more

Sauders - Buffalo turkey mega sub - Grocery Near Me - Seneca Falls, New York

They're close to finishing the expansion on their building! I've been trying to stop here for months, I would always pass by on a Sunday on my way to church and they aren't open on Sunday so I finally made a special trip to the store today and I was not disappointed. Prices are good, lots of local items, household goods. They have a large canning section, large book section. I stopped and checked out a book on the community full of old pictures and information. Tons of dry goods in the store from spices to baking items, meats, dairy items. I went in not needing anything but felt compelled to buy and try a lot of things. read more

Oh my goodness!!! It was beyond my expectations I could go on forever about all the amazing things... I mean isles and isles folks!! You have to go for yourself and check it out! read more

I was told by a co-worker to go try this place out and its very interesting, They have a large selection on unique things like dried fruit, spices, flour and dried powder soup which I think is interesting. I went and got a couple of items including deli meat which I felt was real tasty and cheap. I am sad that sauders is so far away but the next time I head towards waterloo I will make a stop their to stock up on goods. Overall, This place is Unique, Large Selection of selective items, Reasonably priced! read more

Amazing homemade products...from furniture to jams to body lotions and baked goods. The quality of all of the groceries and goods here are excellent. read more

Love it, love it, love it especially their selection of sugar free pies and low sugar products. Something for everyone from produce to baked goods to packaged goods and beyond. read more

This was such a neat stop and some really neat finds. The kids loved it too! Fresh soups.... the gift shop is very nice too!

We saw this store multiple times and finally got a chance to check it out. I'm so happy we did! The grocery store was amazing with so many specialty items for a great price. My family is being quite cautious due to the COVID-19 pandemic and this store had the best level of mask wearing we have seen so far. We will definitely be returning! read more