Momberger's

Despite the demand and lines the service is exceptionally fast and friendly...extremely…read moreorganized...it's a well oiled machine! Of course the line is because the subs are SUPERIOR and downstate AUTHENTIC (without the attitude) ...fresh roll or Italian bread, tons of meat and all the fixings! Don't forget one of the old style deli pickles In the case....!!! Can't say enough about Casa...it reminds me of my old neighborhood grocery store...you'll feel like family too!

Tried their whit pizza for the first time and it is absolutely delicious. Top sub and pizza shop in…read morethe area.

Wow a lot of Italian Imports

Small Sub YUM THE REAL DEAL

See all

Dine Inn

Shortstop Deli

3.9(179 reviews)

38.3 mi

Locals told us: Get great sandwiches from the deli in this convenience store!…read more Shortstop Deli has been "hidden" in a convenience store in the "lower northside" of Ithaca NY since 1978! Great design-your-own sandwiches, and if you like, friendly suggestions from the staff. It was our first time in, and their helpful hints quickly showed they have every filling (savory seitan!) and every topping and a nice variety of breads. We got their "Italian mix" of cold cuts, which included Genoa salami, sweet tender thin-sliced baked ham, and meats that were either mortadella and capicola or at least richly-flavored alternates, provalone cheese, tomato, onions, a light amount of lettuce brightened with a splash of Italian dressing and a dash of fresh salad-oil, and a sprinkling of what we call "hots": lightly-spicy pickled peppers. All this on fresh French bread, which could have been with sesame, or could have been ciabatta or whole-wheat French or several others. We added a light scatter of our own crushed pistachios, which are in some mortadellas. Nobody said this couldn't be fun :-) The sandwich was a heavenly armful, shared amongst us on one of our woodsy picnics. Extra kudos again to their cheerful helpful (patient) staff!

Friendly fast fresh! I'll go again when I'm in town! Keep Ithaca fun!…read moreLove the fact that I could get a small-ish sub.

Order Counter

See all

In case you're curious about the order

The Downtown Deli

4.0(44 reviews)

8.8 mi

Take-out review only, but what a deli! Typical deli format…read more Walk down to the end to order and then work your way back towards to front to pay. This place gets busy, but they are working hard to take care of everyone. We ordered two specialty sandwiches to go yesterday and we were out the door in 10 minutes. Ma Bailey (grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, feta, tomatoes, red onion, mixed green w/ caesar dressing in a wrap). Red Hatter (smoked turkey, provolone, roasted red peppers and pesto on toasted focaccia bread). Both were very, very good, but that Red Hatter was the winner! Thanks for feeding us on such a hectic afternoon.

Fantastic New York deli with all you can think of and then some! Quick service too.Lots of soups…read moreand desserts.

The half sandwich, minus one bite.

See all

Bedford falls panini

Brownstein's Deli and Bakery

4.4(99 reviews)

34.9 mi

Outstanding! The bagels are perfect NY style. I tried the whitefish salad today & it was excellent!…read moreThe service was fast and friendly. This place is a true gem. Do yourself a favor and get a cookie. Worth every calorie!

Just had a fire on 9/9 and are unsure of damage. They aren't sure when/if they will be open again…read more Their website is up to date. So sad--they have the best bagels in town and are incredibly nice.

Corned Beef on Rye

Storefront

See all

Lots o bagels

The Olney Place

4.3(85 reviews)

23.7 mi

The guy that owns this place, Seth- what a gem!! Such a personable , hardworking guy…read more He makes great sandwiches My kids enjoy the egg and cheese and the bacon is fresh and delicious. Egg sandwiches are huge!!! Cozy spot to eat in the back or take it to go

Ok so we didn't eat here but my family did. They told us while the food and service was all good…read more It really is just a deli with a location. That said they were shocked at the cost of three deli sandwiches and some sides being the best part of $80. I reported that this was mentioned in other posts here and there seems to be no prices published. From that they concluded that the policy was to exploit tourists or non regulars. But charge the locals a more reasonable price. No proof but that definitely was the vibe. So drive few minutes further to the Switz. Unless you get the prices up front before placing an order.

A Rising Storm Hawaiian Punch Sour, Chicken Salad & Bacon sub, and potato chips. Good stuff.

See all

Holy Cow Meat Market & Deli

4.1(67 reviews)

35.3 mi

Great deli! Offering a wide assortment of sandwiches plus meats, fish, and cheeses to take home…read more Very neat and clean inside. They need umbrellas for outdoor dining.

The Reuben was packed full of meat and some very well. They have a relatively large deli menu for…read moredecent prices considering that this is such a touristy area. I would come back when in town.

Chicken wrap

See all

S & M Delicatessen

4.9(17 reviews)

71.6 mi

Rob does a great job he has the best pizza in town the subs are great City Chicken the mac salad is…read moreout of the world

I want to give this place a nice review because it's an old couple running the place for what seems…read morelike a million years, but the old woman behind the counter always seems miserable . Im giving you business for Pete's sake. Smile and be thankful. I really don't get the hype of the subs here. Mediocre at best. Both my husband and I got the Italian sub. I don't know , it was just average for me. ‍Sorry .

Latest M

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Em F.

11 years ago

Best subs in town !!! Always super fresh , And really quick too ! (On site , never tried delivery ) They have good salads as well . Friendly staff . read more

Joseph R.

3 years ago

Stopped here to pickup takeout before a bus trip we were taking. Subs were awesome! Everything made to order.

Kris S.

6 years ago

Found a piece of a latex glove in my sub. they Usually have great food and service.

James R.

Elite 26

189

968

12 years ago

I cant even imagine what the large sub is like...just a good hometown sub shop.

Momberger's - delis - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Geneva, New York Parking near Momberger's

BEST of Geneva, New York Restaurants near Momberger's

BEST of Geneva, New York Coffee near Momberger's

BEST of Geneva, New York Desserts near Momberger's

BEST of Geneva, New York Things to Do near Momberger's

BEST of Geneva, New York Pizza near Momberger's

BEST of Geneva, New York Sandwiches near Momberger's

BEST of Geneva, New York Shopping near Momberger's

BEST of Geneva, New York Lunch near Momberger's

BEST of Geneva, New York Thrift Stores near Momberger's

Best of Geneva

Things to do in Geneva

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Momberger's also viewed

Smoke N Dough’s BBQ and Pizza

4.5

(19 reviews)

We stopped here for a quick lunch amidst a weekend of wine tasting. This place is not fancy but…read morethe food was very good. I had the brisket sandwich and it was melt in your mouth good. The staff is super friendly and will make sure you are satisfied with your meal. There is an outside seating area as well and there is an ice cream store in the same building if you care for dessert. If you are looking for to satisfy your hunger when cruising along Seneca lake, this is a nice choice.

Just a small restaurant along the main thoroughfare as you drive from winery to winery. But, what…read moregreat bbq brisket - and Mac and cheese. Very reasonably priced. Friendly staff. Eat in or take out available. The restaurant shares their building with an ice cream shop if you're looking for dessert!

Club 86

3.5

(51 reviews)

Great gluten free options! Came here twice in one weekend, we loved it. Service was pretty quick…read moredespite being busy. There are fun board/card games to play while you're there. Seating was a bit hard to find during the busy morning rush.

Stopped in for breakfast on our way home and we enjoyed the experience. This place was wild on a…read moreSunday very busy but they made it work! I had the heuvos rancheros and hashbrown and my fiancé got the lox bagel with cream cheese. We also tried their famous strawberry cake which was awesome. Prices were pretty good overall and everything was tasty. The rancheros needs something flavor wise but otherwise was pretty good. Plenty of seating indoor and outdoor and lots of parking. Everybody was so friendly and nice here we enjoyed the experience!

Pisano's Deli & Pizza Kitchen

3.5

(17 reviews)

Staying in Canandaigua on business travel, I had the pleasure of having Pizano's delivered to my…read morehotel since I really didn't want to go out. I ordered the "Pizano's Special" calzone and and an order of hot wings. Both were absolutely delicious. I was really impressed with the sauce on the wings. I'll certainly be eating here again the next time I am in town. I just took off the one star because I thought that delivery was a tad bit slow.

Great food, friendly service- we visited here a year ago and were impressed. Not disappointed this…read moretime

Valentine’s Pizza & Delicatessen Skaneateles

3.9

(53 reviews)

Always amazing. Best wings around. Pizza is always hot and fresh and delivered quicklyread more

Great service and very friendly employees. You order at the counter and drinks are in a…read morerefrigerator case. They have sandwiches, subs, pizza, calzones, etc. I felt like plain cheese and it looked fresh in the case. There were at least 5 choices of pizza with different toppings. It was a decent size slice, I wouldn't say really large but I could see the pies were cut very unevenly. ( I was hoping I didn't get one of the smaller slices). The crust was perfect, I could taste a little sweetness in the dough and it had a nice chew. The sauce was so flavorful with spices and the cheese was nicely melted and a perfect amount.

Uncle Joe's Pizzeria

3.5

(75 reviews)

Tasha our server was great. Food was very good - French onion soup was great, chicken parmigiana…read moresandwich was ok (dry, need more sauce, which Tasha noticed), antipasto was very good, wings & pizza great, beers were great too. Great little hole in the wall, relax & chill kind of place.

Ordered a salad, ouln't find the ham or the pepperoni. The lettuce was supposed to be romaine but…read morewas clearly iceberg. Very disappointing, especially for the price.

Peppers

3.6

(64 reviews)

Have enjoyed Peppers several times. The menu is amazing with many options although a little pricey…read more I've always enjoyed the food I've ordered. On a previous visit we were seated in a quiet booth and the waiter Mark was awesome in helping my partner negotiate a food allergy for cilantro. On my most recent visit, we had to request bring reseated as the woman in the next booth was having a loud, obnoxious phone call for everyone in the neighborhood to overhear. The ambiance is upscale diner- comfort depends on where you may be seated. Will definitely go again- I hope I can find the quiet & enjoyable spot to have my dinner.

After just arriving from our trip we found Peppers located not far from our hotel by the lake. Our…read morewaitress took good care of us. All of our dishes had good sized portions. Two of us had the pot roast which was very good along with mashed potatoes. The meat was tender and reminded us of a home cooked meal.

Otis & Reds Pizza

4.7

(9 reviews)

Brand new pizza joint in Phelps. I just had a slice of pepperoni for lunch and it was delicious…read more They sport a thin New York style crust. Service ran smoothly for a new place that was pretty busy for lunch. They have indoor and outdoor seating as well as a separate arcade room with several different games.

In town and had to stop by. I am so glad we did. I was in the mood from some good wings and boy…read moredid this place deliver. These wings are life changing.

Redman's Chicken n' Ribs

4.4

(114 reviews)

A great local, family-owned establishment. Don't pass it up!…read more Just the kind of local, family-owned establishment I enjoy stopping at when traveling. I got the 6-piece fried chicken, which is prepared fresh, and it was wonderful. A great place to check out along your route.

4.5 stars! $33 for 8…read morepieces of huge delicious fried chicken, 1 large macaroni and cheese which was amazing, and 3 corn breads. 20 minutes wait for the chicken was definitely worth it. Huge portion! We also ordered the fried green tomatoes, which were just okay. Overall, this was a great meal with excellent value. We'd definitely come back for the fried chicken and mac and cheese!

Talk of the Town Cafe II

4.7

(37 reviews)