very nice server and amazing food, french onion soup was soooo good. the entire experience here is so nostalgic and wonderful, as it has a very cozy feel to it. would recommend to anyone read more

See all

Ordered spaghetti and meatballs. Only had 2 small meatballs and almost no sauce. Called to complain and was told to come back anytime for sauce. We will never go back again. We stopped by wegmans to get a small jar of spaghetti sauce so we can eat. We do not recommend this place to anybody. They do not take care of customers. read more

Best mom and pop pizzeria spot in Geneva . If you want quality pan pizza this is your spot. Great service that welcomes you like famiglia, with a down home and home style decor that says authentic‼ read more

We eat here regularly. Always great. Best pizza! Don't forget a dozen of their delicious chocolate chip cookies. Great service. Always consistent. read more

We were here last year and the food and service were spot on. We decided to go here for dinner with friends tonight. What a disappointment, we only had short wait and were seated quickly. Server came over and took our drink order,our drinks came out in a timely manner. We ordered appetizers and our dinners, and told our server we wanted separate checks. I ordered the "best chicken soup" according to the menu. After about 25 minutes or so the server came out and told us they were out of soup and offered a substitution. A while later our food finally came out and was just alright, red sauce was spicy. After we finished our server brought one check and informed us we had to go to the counter to have it split. Unfortunately we probably won't be back......probably the short wait to be seated had something to do with service going down hill. read more

We only ordered the wings for takeout but they were crispy and tasted great ! We ordered hot and the flavor was spot on

This was my first time here, my mom Had been here many times and loves it so we met here for lunch and I can see why she wants to keep coming back:) The service was prompt, friendly, and accommodating. The ambiance was traditional Italian decor and cozy family like, with booths and separate tables as well. Their menu has many options and the food came out pretty quick and was delicious. I definitely would come again:) read more

See all

Last night I called in an order at 4pm, told them I will pick it up at 5:30, got there 5:25, they started to put it together at 5:40. I got out of there at 5:48pm. read more

Outstanding place. The atmosphere is cozy, and very lively on a Friday evening. We were a big group but the service was excellent and friendly. The food was very good all around. And the prices are reasonable. read more

I brought my family here and though they were a bit leery do to the location in the end we were all satisfied#! We at cheese ravioli, ziti and ceaser salad. We drank a strawberry wine. Martini! I would recommend going here.... read more

Uncle Joe's Pizzeria - Order the wong wine. But they waitess was kind enough to bring a new one - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

Finger licking good ! Came all the way from Indiana to Geneva, NY for important matters and very great things here ! Well recommended to people that just one a last minute grab! read more

Uncle Joe's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza!" - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, New York

First off, the facade and the interior decor really have that cute small town feel. So I really wanted it to be good. That plus some of the older reviews of this place gave me high hopes for it. I saw a few comments saying it was good prior to 2020, but I guess things have gone downhill since then. We ordered two pizzas, and they were both really inedible. One of them was GF, which can be a gamble but they were both pretty bad.They weren't fully cooked, tasted unsalted, and seemed to have no spices in the marinara. It was disappointing. read more

My girlfriend has wanted to come here for quite some time so I decided to try it out. It was a nice change from the same pizza we usually have. This was a unique experience for us that started with complimentary Italian bread, which was delicious! The butter was cold and so I ended using the spread, even though I know it would have tasted better with real butter. We got a side of sauce to enjoy the crust after eating the main part of the pizza. While we enjoyed the pizza, there is one request...more toppings! The pizza we got was sparse on pepperoni and sausage (see photo). The third photo is the one we saw in someone else's review and made us want to order that exact pizza. Ours had much less toppings. I'm hoping next time to get one closer to that pizza. If so we'll go 5 stars! read more

See all

Monday is NOT an open day. I called to place an order and no one wants to pick up the phone.

Not sure if this was just a bad day or what but the waitress was so burnt out that she gave us the wrong checks. Food is so so and had to wait for silverware after being served. She seemed annoyed at anyone who was taking their time ordering and joked with the table next door that the "kitchen was closed" when they requested more time. read more

Best pizza in town. You ca actually eat a couple slices without having a grease belly ache, Adequate toppings cooked just right. House salad is nothing fancy but perfect for a pizza meal. Don't forget a chocolate chip cookie for dessert! read more

1. Had a very nice server. 2. Three of us ordered the Lasagna. It was very good and extremely hearty serving! each of us took half of our servings home for another meal. The bread was very good as well. 3. One person had greens and beans with gnocchi. It was not as good as in the past. The gnocchi was average. 4. It was a Saturday night and busy, but that did not affect our service or the food overall. 5. Two of us purchased a quart of sauce each to take home. It was very good. Unfortunately, I had to dispose of the whole container as there was HAIR in it! I wish restaurants would go back to requiring hair nets. This keeps happening to me. Ugh. read more

I was in Geneva and called a friend to ask where to get the best subs. She recommended Uncle Joe's and she was spot on right. One of the bet subs I've had in years. It just tasted right (I know that's not very specific), like I hoped it would taste (think of the best sub you've ever had). Bread was just the right amount of soft. Tuna tasted great, just like I wish I could make at home. I will be going back just about every time I'm in Geneva. read more

See all

Uncle Joe's is a quaint step back in time. It has a nice old time pizza parlor/Italian restaurant feel. The photos and items on the wall are fun to peruse. The staff is friendly . The food is good down home Italian fare. (We really like the sauces.)There's a varied menu. There's a good children's menu so it's a fine place for families. The beer and wine list is a good accompaniment and should appeal to most. This visit was for fish sandwiches on a Friday. Very good with an ample side of pasta! read more

Uncle Joe's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

My friend recommended me this great local pizza joint in Geneva. The place is so cute with its knick knacks and memorabilia. I had the $2.50 slice of pepperoni pizza and my husband had the Pizza and Wing lunch special. I wasn't much of a fan of their pizza, as it was kind of too airy and fluffy for me, but, I did love their wings! We got them well done with the Hot sauce (more of a tangy Buffalo type of sauce, but mild) - it was perfectly fried and sauced up with a nice container of Bleu cheese. My husband also enjoyed their freshly - made clam chowder very much that he ordered 2 cups! Friendly service and great wings and soup, it was a nice experience! +wings +clam dhowder read more

See all

If your going sell pizza cut it all the way through and place the non stick sheet in the box properly. Ordered a small turkey sub and small pizza. Bread was dry on the sub and barely any meat. Pizza sauce is flavorless. Many other places to choose from in the area. A sure letdown. read more

See all

I had the beans and greens over spaghetti and I loved it. Wish it had a few more greens in it but it was delicious. The waitress walked by with someone's lasagna and I'll definitely be back to try it. read more

These people do not care for delivery because this isn't the first time my order has been terrible, I asked for provolone and my bun to be toasted with my steak sub and I get it and the bun was soggy I got American cheese instead of provolone and the meat tasted like they boiled it, very bland absolutely no seasoning. They some how removed my review on Google when I infact just bought the sub with picture. read more

Food and service was fantastic, The chicken tenders almost melted in your mouth they were so tender. You have to try the cream of broccoli soup - best I ever had. The atmosphere was homey and welcoming. read more

Incredible chocolate chip cookies!! Good food. Space can feel crowded at times. Clean atmosphere. Love the boneless wings and the garlic bread read more

One of us ordered Lasagne and the other Ziti w meatballs. The meatballs accompanying the zitis were excellent. The red sauce was indigenous to this area of upstate NY. IF you're from elsewhere bring your own sauce! TheBread was also a local favorite, served and a preference for many years. We ordered Beans n Greens for takeout to take home for tomorrows supper. We were VERY satisfied with our local pasta dinners. Service was excellent, prompt and friendly. This is a great local family restaurant, very clean and cozy!!! read more

I liked the pizza. My girlfriend on the other hand thought it was disgusting. For me, I enjoyed the sauce and dough of the pizza which I thought tasted good, she thought it tasted like pizza hut pizza, which I can understand because it had a similar texture. So if you are looking for a traditional NY/NJ Za, this ain't your place cause it's a pan style pizza... But, like I said, I liked it... We both loved the mozzarella sticks, but you can't really rate a place on it's mozzarella sticks (unless they F' them up, cause that's pretty hard to do) The people who worked there seemed nice enough. Definitely a ma & pop style place. It's a very cute place, which looks like a real pizzeria, so it has that going for it. But we did se this creepy WWII poster talking about dead soldiers and trying to recruit women into the Women's Army Corps... I'll post the picture, it's bizarre, it took a while for me to figure out what exactly the poster was trying to say... Anyways, if I come back here, it will definitely be by myself since my girlfriend probably won't come back with me... I really want to try the calazones! read more

Uncle Joe's Pizzeria - Weird WWII propaganda poster... - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, New York

We got a meatball sub today 8-25 and it was delicious! Great sauce, friendly staff and customers....2pm on a Wednesday and dining room was packed but everyone looked happy! Very filling sub ... only downside is I had timo share it with my lovely wife! Bwahahaha read more

Good pizzeria food, and a pretty cool atmosphere. We've eaten in the restaurant and also had carry out. After drinking our way through the Seneca wine trail all day, it's nice to have some carbs in the evening. The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is that the last time we were here getting carry out pizza, the entire staff in the kitchen is yelling and fighting with each other. They were busy, and I'm sure tensions were high, but that's not professional to do in front of your customers. The positives definitely outweighs the negatives, so I'll be back. read more

I grew up in Geneva and whenever we return to visit family my 12 year old daughter asks for Uncle Joe's! Consistently delicious Italian food. My daughter loves the spaghetti and meatballs w chocolate chip cookies for dessert. I got the chicken parm sub, my dad the open faced meatball parm sub. Everyone was happy! Win-win-win. read more

Not a happy experience. My husband ordered crispy wings and I ordered a small pizza. His wings arrived hot, but not at all crispy. He was done eating before I even got my pizza. He could have waited, but after 20 min the wing would have been stone cold. Not once after delivering our drinks did the waitress check to see if we needed anything (even when she delivered the wings) and since I had no food, my drink was long gone. When my pizza finally did come, I had her box it up to take it home. When we checked out, we mentioned it to the cashier. We got a, "sorry". Won't be returning anytime soon. read more

The only thing edible was the salad and soup. Used to love the fried dough with coffee, but it was simply awful this time.

First time. We got pizza and wings to go based on other reviews but ordered our food then read the reviews. Noticed one review mentioned the garlic parm wing sauce and they thought it was overdressed and tasted like Italian dressing. At first I disagreed but after eating a few i agreed; the pizza was good. We will try again. read more

I went to Uncle Joe's on 8/20/15 while visiting the wineries in the area. The food at Uncle Joe's would be average to below average when compared to places in the Washington, DC metro area. However for the area it is in the food is above average. Uncle Joe's offers a good selection of deep dish pizzas and subs (had the eggplant parmesan). I don't have any complaints about my sub just that it was satisfying after a couple of hours of wine tasting. I also liked the campiness of the ambiance of the restaurant with replicas of old signs and Italian symbols. In a nutshell, a solid choice for a satisfying meal if you happen to be in the area. read more

This place has gone downhill. We used to love it here. Our dinner last night was terrible. My husband's eggplant parm sub was inedible. We complained and the waitress did nothing. My calzone looked like something that was mass produced pulled out of the freezer. We won't ever go back. read more

I have to chime in here. Sorry Uncle Joe, I am not a fan. Yes, your pizza is decent, your pan pizza is a notch above decent I will give you that. Where you fail is with everything else, in my opinion. I have nothing against older people but this place is gray hair central. You will find this place busy at 4:30 on any given weekday. The last time we went we were the only table under 70 and I am dead serious. Your weakest menu item is your salad. Yup I am going to say it Geneva and I am going to say it loudly; Uncle Joe's iceberg lettuce salad blows. This wet, over dressed item (I cannot even call it a salad anymore) is so disgusting I cannot believe they serve it. Gnocchi? Gross. Beans and greens, average. Come on Uncle Joe your menu needs some updating, this is not 1989 anymore. If you find yourself in Geneva and you want Italian I will say it one more time, go the The Deluxe. If you want good pizza...you are out of luck in Geneva, sorry. read more

Ordered 3 calzones, double order of boneless buffalo wings, and mozzarella sticks. It was 60 dollars and the food wasn't great. They charge extra for anything you add to the calzones and they came out soooo tiny. I'm used to getting a nice thick calzone that takes me 3 meals to eat, this was the size of my hand or a small plate. Disappointing. Also the garlic parm boneless wings tasted like they added Italian dressing to them or something besides garlic and parm. read more

I'm with Heather. I was in the Army and stationed near Geneva in the late 70's and early 80's and lived on N. Genessee St. just down the street from Uncle Joe's. Back then Joe and the family were all involved in the business and it sort of became a staple in my life. The pizza's were always great as well as the meatball subs. My wife still talks about the subs as being the greatest she has ever had in her life. I must agree although I am a pizza guy. I have been back to the area twice, most recently was last August (2010) and I do not understand why I didn't pay homage to Joe and the crew on Yelp before this. I saw somebody on Facebook from Geneva and it triggered my salivary glands but out here in Vancouver, Washington there is nothing close to Uncle Joe's. In fact Joe has expanded to a newer, fancier Italian restaruant near the tracks in downtown Geneva but I just couldn't try it when I had an opportunity to eat at the original. I highly recommend it. read more

Order took longer than expected and I had to leave a tip on my credit card BEFORE I got my food. The escarole and white bean is amazing!! Very garlicky. I should have ordered 2. The big Al sandwich was tasty too. The mayo was light and the cold cuts tasted fresh. Feeds at least 3 people as a small. Mom says the grilled cheese was good. Props for giving us plates, silverware and napkins. They delivered. If you're in need of food- give them a shot! read more

Uncle Joe's is high school pimple cafeteria pizza. Simply put, that's exactly what it is. Sauce was literally just plopped onto the thick crust. Sauce taste was sour and bland. Joe's is very cheap on the toppings as well, a few pepperoni on each slice. 2 stars for excellent wings, they were very good. We had ordered mild which were done very nicely and tasted very good. I would never return here. read more