Side note: New to this location is a Shrimp Taco (or rather camarones) with shrimp, cabbage, and salsa macha for $6.45. You can find an IG post here- https://www.instagram.com/p/DQKJrI6kdDV/. Tacos range from $5.45 (most veggie to $6.95 (steak trompo.)
Originally home to the bustling and slightly dimly lit Tortaria, this is the 2nd location of this fancier Mexican taco joint, with them making the lighting much brighter, getting rid of a lot of the seats, and in general just making it much more modern-looking. Opened by the same folks behind Cosme, which I'm not that big a fan of, this was a pricey but tasty taco, with the size also being a bit larger, so I didn't really mind the price as much. The guys working here are friendly. They have a couple of fun/more unique extra things to top the tacos compared to other places, including chicharron, pickled onions, and a variety of salsas. The salsas included a morita salsa, which was medium heat and tasted fine, and a solid habanero one, which is listed as hot (I didn't see a mild option, but apparently there is a jalapeno one at least in the other location.) Said habanero salsa is dark, and judging from the black color and flavor, I presume it's well roasted, but it was not that hot for a habanero base (then again, I have a very high spice tolerance,) but was easily my preference due to the smokiness.
I went with two tacos, their steak and carnitas, along with their agua santa to drink. The Santi's Steak Trompo is their signature and their most expensive at $6.95 and is topped with strip and sirloin, and avocado salsa. The steak was cut thin and exceptionally juicy, with a bit of char and a bit of saltiness, and the avocado salsa was mildly spiced. It felt a bit rich, but adding the freebee pickled onions helped with the richness. I also liked the habanero salsa with it, with the slight smokiness and a bit of spice helping as well. This taco was well worth it for the price point, and I definitely would get it again.
The Pork Carnitas for $5.95 with pork belly & ribs, avocado salsa, and tomato martajada salsa was alright. I have had better carnitas with other spots adding a bit more texture, but the pork belly was pretty flavorful. The avocado salsa felt less necessary here, but I was a fan of the tomato-based one, which was chunky with some good spices. This was alright, but as said, I prefer the carnitas from some other places.
The Agua Santa for $6.00 with kiwi, cucumber, lime, and palo santo was unique. I would compare this mostly to an agua de pepino, a cucumber agua fresca, which isn't as common here compared to the usual horchata, tamarindo, or jamaica. I found it primarily refreshing, presumably from the cucumber. There was also a bit of lemon and a mix of nice citrus flavors, which was presumably from the mixture of kiwi, lime, and the palo santo wood. It was nice to have, especially with the richer steak taco, and even at the price point, I would go here, especially in the summer or something, and get one of these.
A person might look at the menu here and scoff at the prices, but for the portion size and for the changing NYC taco landscape, I didn't mind. This is especially the case with other spots like Los Tacos, costing more and more (and my favorite al pastor spot, Al Pastor Taqueria,) also being pricier. If the steak taco was not so good, I'd probably give this place a 4, but I'll give her the benefit of the doubt based on the general quality to bump it up a bit. read more