As in the name, Sammy's under square is under square in Walworth. Only negative part of this review is the parking as it's very limited or you'll be walking a little bit. At some point, they expanded the restaurant so it can easily handle over 150 people and I'm guessing anywhere is up to 180 people. Was very clean inside and appears that it had been painted not too long ago. Our waitress was Alaina. Hope I spelled, her name right. Very good waitress and made sure she took care of us. I had a few questions about the food on the menu and she had all the answers. I got what I think was called the sweet potato brisket skillet. My girlfriend had just eggs, toast, hashbrowns with bacon. She said the coffee was OK. She's a little fussy with the coffee so we've had a few places where it's been great. She says it's drinkable and she liked it. Good enough! They give you generous portions of food. The bacon was cooked crispy the way she likes it and the eggs were done perfectly. Hashbrowns taste fresh and good and never cooked perfectly. They under utilize salt, but there's probably a good reason for it and that's why you have salt at the table. The skillet I had, however, was real good! Generous portions of brisket and the sweet potatoes were cut strips and grilled and tender. It had chunks of green peppers which were grilled and you could tell they were fresh. Fresh grilled onions and chunks of tomatoes inside. It was loaded with cheese too. My eggs were done to perfection and I had the sourdough toast. Their sourdough toast is Home made style bread. I don't believe it's baked in the restaurant, but it was very good. Once again, very generous portions. The place is huge inside with plenty of elbow room. As for the price, their prices were average and in line with other places we've eaten breakfast in the area. The whole staff that is there greeted you at one point or the other. Very friendly staff. They are also open for lunch and dinner. The place is busy for breakfast so I'm guessing that they're Friday night fish fries probably pretty packed. I highly recommend Sammy's on the square. read more

Sammy's on the Square - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

See all

Pros: avocado was fresh, there was a lot of great options on the menu to choose from, place looked clean overall Cons: steak cooked so fast it turned out tough, food was good but not super warm, the blueberry Swedish pancakes were watery so I'm assuming the blueberries were frozen It's nice to have a breakfast spot in the area with a variety of options on the menu. This is good if you're looking for a traditional breakfast, but not a place where you'd have a memorable meal. Staff members were friendly. read more

Sammy's on the Square - Ribeye, blueberry Swedish Pancakes, avocado Benedict - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

Great classic diner vibes. Prices I think are very reasonable and plenty of people at tables which I think is a great sign of a great diner. I wanted to order the special of the day which was the fried chicken but my waitress made me feel she didnt want me to order them by saying "This would be an additional 20 minute wait. Are you sure that you want to make your table wait for your food?" So I decided on the sampler since I knew this would be my one time at the diner since we were visiting. BBQ sauce was a little too hot for my liking but loved their ranch and their cheese curds were very good! Thought the breading on my onion rings were good and complimented the onion well. The chicken tenders were just okay. Just regular chicken tenders. read more

See all

Lovely place! Great service that was friendly. Typical dinner food and went with a breakfast option. Very classic dinner menu but some funky options. Super good would enjoy again. read more

Sammy's on the Square - Sweet potato brisket skillet - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

Always great food and service. Casual diner type atmosphere with extensive menu at reasonable prices. read more

Sammy's on the Square - Ribeye dinner - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

Great breakfast. Food. Service. All good. Good reviews are well deserved. Coffee good. Everybody happy and full.

The service is classic small town friendly and efficient. There are many options and they all taste good. The value is good and one often takes home leftovers. The room is fairly quiet and relaxing. read more

Great great spot. You might have to wait but well worth it! Staff was on their game. Some great selections. I had the Irish Benedict and would order again read more

Sammy's on the Square - "Irish" Benedict - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

Always good . Great hours of operation. A good choice for Breakfast or Lunch. I enjoyed my best meal ever there today . Gyro and Eggs over easy w hash browns . The servers here are amazing. read more

The food here is delish! I've been here for breakfast and for dinner before. I loved that the menu is expansive but the food is really no frills. It's so good too. My fish was super yummy! I also had the clam chowder with it which was delicious. The restaurant is close to my grandparents home and it was nice that the staff knows them and treats them like royalty. It meant the world to us. It's the best diner nearby and we will return! read more

Sammy's on the Square - Friday Fish Fry Baked Cod - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

Excellent service and food. Eggs Benedict is the best. It's a must stop if you're in the area. read more

Was in town for a baseball tournament and needed a place to go for lunch. Came across this cute diner and the food was delicious. Ordered the 2 eggs with meat and had the chicken sausage. By far the best chicken sausage I have ever eaten. Prices are reasonable. Good came out hot and fresh. Pancakes are well sized. Definitely worth the stop. Thank you for the excellent service. Praying your business be blessed! read more

Food was bad and old. Rice was obviously not kept in right conditions. It was obviously old rice and the food is just bad.

Was a cute place in a small town. We were greeted right away and sat at a table up top. Our server was fantastic she was attentive and easygoing. We have 5 people. We ordered country fried steak and omelets and sprinkle pancakes. The steak was fantastic gravy was just ok. So I was glad I did not get the biscuits and gravy. The pancake looked fabulous and was enjoyed by the child every one had a great meal and was great price. Worth the trip read more

See all

Great food, quick service, pleasant atmosphere and parking was easy. The service requires special mention because it was spot on. Every time something was needed , there Laura our waitress was and she came back moments after serving to see if we needed anything else. She could not have been more attentive. read more

Sammy's on the Square - Front of restaurant - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

I like that the standard side dish is soup, not fries. Friendly service, very clean talbes.

Diners are always special places, but Sammy's exceeds expectations. Really excellent breakfasts -- and those pumpkin pancake, hot damn! Friendly folks serving, as well. So glad we stopped on our way back to Chicago. Will definitely return when next in the area. read more

A small diner located in a small town. Predictably packed with locals. Seemed like a good place to grab a bite as we were passing through town. Ambience was nice and service attentive. But oh my, the quality of the food. I had a greek omlette, and it contained small waxy cubes of something masquerading as feta cheese. It tasted vaguely of feta cheese I suppose. My friend had soft scrambled eggs, which showed up as a rubbery omlette like material. Neither of us finished our plates. So if you are passing through, my advice is to keep passing through. read more

I've eaten here a number of times and the service and food is very good. I've only come here for breakfast or lunch - not dinner. Those folks looking for a more reasonably priced meal than Lake Geneva restaurants or the nearby Abbey Resort offer would be happy they made the short drive. The breakfast and lunch food here is every bit as good or better and the service is outgoing and friendly. read more

See all

Went to eat there today. Food was amazing especially the Alaskan Waffle. Definitely recommend coming here. Good service and very fast.

Trash trash trash. I left a Google review but of course it isn't there so yes here I am. First off this place is near The Abbey Resort so common sense should tell you that you may have many out of towners come check you out. Anyway my sister and I wanted to order food and bring it back to our family at the resort. We were told that we couldn't order kids meals because we didn't have kids with us. I didn't know you had to have kids with you to order a to go kids meal. I'm wondering why McDonald's doesn't question people when you go to a drive thru and order kids meals. The waitress was downright rude and nasty ass attitude. Talking to people as if you hate your job means you need to do better. You work at a restaurant where you greet people and tone is important. I would hope that the restaurant learns how to teach their staff how to greet customers. I would never ever step foot in there again! And while you're at it take a look on google, they have so many nasty reviews. They're down right nasty people. read more

Great food and awesome prices! Good music and great staff. Went two days in a row. Parking is plentiful.

We loved this place! Service was great and the menu options pleased everyone. We ended up getting two orders of the Denver omelette and two of the choc chip pancakes for the kids. The pancakes were huge and we easily could have gotten away with just one order. This is def a local place, not touristy and not overpriced. Only thing is the lady who sat us (not our waitress) wouldn't let us get away with just waters, and somehow we ended up with chocolate milks for the kids. But that is really my fault not hers :) read more

Sammy's on the Square - Kids already tucked in on the choc chip pancakes. Great portion for $5.99 - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

See all

We had two meals here in the two days while visiting from out of town. I had ordered take out for both orders - two breakfast sandwiches were big and very good, and two dinners were also delicious! The cream of chicken rice soup is fantastic! read more

Awesome food and somewhat good service, they just don't know how to refill waters lmao

the breakfast we had here was delicious , i had strawberry nutella french toast and my husband had country fried steak . we thoroughly enjoyed our food. the service was very nice and food came out fast. we love breakfast places and will definitely be back. prices good for delicious food. read more

Sammy's on the Square - my strawberry nutella french toast with extra nutella (don't judge me) - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

Stopped in yesterday while in town for an event with my family. Large, spacious diner. Very friendly staff and servers. Basic coffee but it was good and generous with refills. Couple of family members had the egg options which looked awesome but wife and I had yogurt parfait and Swedish pancakes and quality was excellent. Definitely recommend as a breakfast spot. read more

See all

I was heading to IL and I looked to see what breakfast places were near my route and this place was so I stopped. The place is on the town square with easy parking. The place is nice enough with a look of country charm with two levels and mostly tables/chairs. I loved the sweet pancakes aroma in the air which made the whole breakfast experience for me, your in the right breakfast place. The menu has all the usual breakfast fare and I was pondering an omelette but omelettes are hit or miss and I could get the the crappy food service liquid eggs, I'm taking a chance because of the great breakfast smell. I ordered the meat lovers omelette with fruit and sourdough toast. Service was slow for having about 9 people working the floor and a good 10 minutes before my order was taken. My breakfast looked good when it finally hit the table and jack pot, the thick omelette looked like real eggs. The fruit was mostly all Mellon with one grape. The sourdough toast was the real deal, not the kind that blends in to white bread with that dense texture and that nice chew. The meat lovers omelette was moist/thick and fluffy with plenty of meat and cheese, nicely done with that real egg flavor. Overall the service was slow which could be a small town thing but they do a real good breakfast. read more

See all

Nice clean restaurant. The service was so friendly and kind. Can be busy on the weekends for breakfast. Everything we had was very good. If your looking for a good breakfast place, I recommend. read more

Just as good the second time. Service was also excellent. Portions were generous for breakfast. I'll have to come back and try it for lunch or dinner read more

In one word awesome. I've never had a bad experience and the food is amazing, the atmosphere is great, and the service is kind and polite but also fast. read more

The breakfast here is really good. We were in Lake Geneva for a wedding and stopped by here for breakfast! The restaurant/dinner is extremely clean. The staff is friendly and accommodating. read more

See all

Great food!! Very friendly family and wait staff!! we have had breakfast lunch and dinner and have never been disappointed very clean and reasonable read more

Downtown Walworth mainstay. Cheap, delicious food. They also have a bar in the back which is a bonus. Waitresses are nice and attentive, bringing more napkins and refills without asking. So much cheaper and better food than any of the resorts. Stop by for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. I recommend the chocolate chip pancakes or french toast. read more

Sammy's on the Square - Tuesday breakfast specials - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

Stopped in for breakfast and what a great place. Staff was great and food was amazing. Place was clean and well staffed. Will definitely be back when I'm in the area. read more

We had a very nice lunch here. Great soup: cream of chicken with rice and vegetable beef. Good sandwiches and breakfast items too. Quick, friendly service. read more

We stopped at this place for a Sunday breakfast around 9am. It was raining outside, the place was packed. We waited about 10-15 min before we were buzzed in. The places is bigger than we expected. Nice selection of food. We ordered two different meals and split them. One was corned beef hash eggs Benedict with the sauce on a side. The reason we asked on a side is because we have noticed how much sauce comes with it. For us - it is a little too much. Eggs were cooked perfectly, we like them runny inside and that's exactly what we got! We were a little bummed that corned beef was from a can, not made in house. Overall corned beef hash eggs Benedict were good. As a second meal we had lingonberry crape. It comes with a lingonberry jam and lingonberry butter. Everything tasted good, plenty of coffee. read more

Sammy's on the Square - Lingonberry crepes- good - American Near Me - Walworth, Wisconsin

See all

Friendly service. Seated right away. Ordered unsweetened iced tea with lemon. Good tea. I had the omelette special and it was delicious. My husband had the biscuits and gravy. Will definitely be back! read more

Food: it was food. Bland. Tasteless. Eggs: Pale pale yellow. Rubbery. Gross. Skimpy grill flavored bacon. Swedish pancakes that seemed like they saw duty as tortillas not long before. Service: slightly better than average. Ambiance: harsh fluorescent lights. Not great. Many better offerings in Williams bay and LG. Honestly feeling a bit nauseated after eating this. Will never return. read more

Excellent place for lunch. I had the BBQ burger and it was amazing. Service was quick and the food was hot.