The best pizza in Appleton! I been going there since I moved to Appleton in 2004 from Feedom. The hospitality and customer service has always been great, just today I went in to have a bite to eat and felt very uncomfortable. When an employee makes you feel uneasy its time to find a new place pizza place, sorry Sal. Maybe well go to ordering out and picking up. So sad. read more

Yay! Just stopped at Sal's, my old stomping ground pizzeria from party nights in Appleton. Awesome slices and great service, nothing has changed. Tried the new lasagna pizza, awesome... My wife got the chicken, bacon, ranch slice and said it was the best she ever had! That is saying something, since she is quite picky about her favorite type of pizza everyone... Take note Sal's rocks. Always has. Ooooooooh yeahhhhhh! read more

Margarita pizza, but no basil! Veggie pizza all tasted like cardboard. The Cannolis was not edible.

Got in late from work and the crew was hungry. It was Saturday night and all the bars and pubs were crowded and loud, A quick jaunt from the hotel down the street and we found Sal's. Friendly folks and delicious food. The price is right. Small lobby with only about five tables, made it quaint and not too noisy. A great find when you don't want anything too crazy. read more

Sal's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

this pizza is amazing. customer service couldn't be better, everyone is so nice! I love the employees they need a raise!! Best pizza in all of Appleton. Giermo is my favorite person ever!!!! read more

Sal's has earned a loyal customer in me. I always enjoy their food, New York style pizza is my favorite. Recently I had two different issues that were not the fault of Sal's but were with a third party online ordering company. In both instances, Sal's stepped up and resolved the issues. I appreciate that. So, excellent food and excellent service = **** from me! read more

Yes. Yes. Yes. If u love New York style pizza, this is the place to go. The knot garlic bread was very good too. We do not recommend the pasta dishes. But their pizza is Slices are huge. Cost per slice is good. Expect a huge pizza if u order the xl. Enjoy Lmk what you think, if u choose sals. read more

Great spot for a quick slice of New York style pizza. They sell the giant slices and throw them in the oven while you wait. Quick and friendly service with a nice selection of pizzas available. read more

This pizza restaurant went above and beyond to save our company meeting! We had a company even catered from a catering company and they ran out of food. So we have more than 40 employees that did not eat. We called up Sals and they had 7 pizzas there ASAP! The woman was so so so so kind and empathetic to our situation. read more

I have always wanted to try cells, but was Hesitant because of the reviews. Today we stopped and got the meat lovers pizza it was hot, and delicious. They also serve a garlic roll along with the slice of pizza. I think this pizza is close to a New York slice. Some reviews complained about the price, $4.25 is not a bad price for the size. the place was clean and the staff was friendly. I definitely will be back. read more

best thing in this town the rolls are incredible and cheap quick service, nice workers and nice place read more

We ordered delivery from Sal's. It unfortunately took longer than our expected 45 minutes, but it was worth the wait! The pepperoni pizza was great and the garlic rolls were delicious. read more

We were too hungry to snap a shot of our slices before enjoying them. As a New York girl visiting Wisconsin I was very concerned about the pizza possibilities but I was not disappointed. They are open late with a variety of slices to choose from. We tried pepperoni mushroom, Buffalo chicken, bbq chicken and regular old cheese and to be honest - I would have enjoyed these even in New York! We will definitely be stopping in here whenever we are traveling through. read more

$4.25 plus 4% surcharge to pay with credit card for a buffalo chick slice with only 2 small pieces of chicken???!! R u serious??!!! read more

Sal's Pizza - This is crazy!!! Sooo cheap on the ingredients!!!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Unfamiliar with the area, Sal's didn't disappoint with their pizza. Picking it up to take back to our hotel after a baseball game, it was hot & ready at the time promised & delicious. read more

Great prices, good food, excellent service. Definitely coming back for more stuffed pizza!

It's been a second since I've had Sal's but holy cow--when this place came to the little college town of Appleton, WI, it took the Fox Cities by storm. I even had it on my recent trip back to Outagamie county for my boy and LU's leading receiver in school history, Zach M's wedding. The pizza still tasted dope, the white pizza was especially legit, and they still had a pluthera of choice for slices. Authentic as hell as Sal himself opened this place up back when I worked at was the real deal. An ex mafioso who gave a crap about his Za! I even worked for Sal's as a delivery guy in my fifth year (I slacked a bit). I used to take the pizza home at night. Shot up about 25 pounds in a trimester but it was worth it. I just had to give pizza away instead of buy drinks for chicks to work game. You'd be surprised what a bowl and some pizza can get you. read more

Sal's Pizza - the white spinach - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Service is amazing.... Super anabolic pizza party with my bros after the gym ‍‍ anabolic and affordable read more

Sal's Pizza - Bbq chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

I have walked 500 miles and I would walk 500 more for SAL'S Pizza. Great service, great prices and awesome portions. Usually I buy 5 or 6 Za's and have them for breakfast lunch and dinner in the middle of the week to help me get over that wedensday hump. Every bite of their mac's cheese pizza literally sends shivers down my spine. read more

Sal's Pizza - The clean and robust pizza selection! - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

One of the workers came out at us yelling because we were enjoying another bars food on their outside patio (mind its not marked with their brand or restaurant it also looked like the cities own chairs and tables) and a worker came put and yelled to my group of people and threatened one of my friends (a minor) physically and followed us. overall not friendly or a good place read more

Wife and I have had 10 delivered pies from Sals in the last year. The consistency has really plummeted in the last 3 months, especially the crust. Mgmnt may want to review their quality control, just a suggestion. We'll find a new place to drop our $30, too bad cuz we like to shop local. read more

I walked into Sal's Pizza and after perusing the menu on the wall decided to order 12 buffalo wings for $9.99. After waiting for 25 minutes --which I thought was a long time since there weren't many orders coming out of the kitchen -- the matriarch of the place rang up the wings and told me my total was $26 and change! When I pointed out that the menu price was $9.99 another employee told me that since inflation, prices have gone up and it's too expensive to update the menu which is just a poster. It should be easy enough to afford when you're charging $5 per slice and $25 for a dozen wings. They were, however, able to print out and tape to the wall updated prices for pizza slices and soda. It seems to me that they should be able to do the same for the rest of their menu items. I decided to not take the wings, and they didn't seem upset or anything, so I will give them credit for that, but to raise prices 150% without any notification is wrong. read more

I'm loving their Italian flavors. But who the hell charges $4.50 for 1 pepperoni slice! Even NYC don't charge that much! Geez, I might as well throw in another ten bucks and order a whole pie instead. Smh... I've ordered from this place 3 times and now I have 10 thousand pizza boxes all over the place. Save tree use plastic! Jk... read more

See all

Average pizza. Overpriced to be honest. Decent staff, quick enough. Pizza is between good or dry, tasteless and terrible. read more

Best pizza place in Appleton . Authentic New York style pizza , all the ingredients tasted fresh and homemade . Definitely going back here again. read more

I have always been a loyal Sal's patron. I drove all the way downtown and they never made my food! The kitchen never heard the order. So I'm left with no food and they ask me to wait while they make it. The place had 3 staff members and some people already eating. I saw that there were only 2 tickets, one was my unfulfilled one, so slow night. Went to Luigis instead.. Don't trust Sal's to make your food! read more

I thought carefully about what rating to give this place. As a restaurant on its own the rating would probably be lower due to a limited menu. But for what it is it has to be 5 stars. It's on the strip in downtown Appleton. Its open late for the bar crowd and they serve amazing, giant slices of pizza for a reasonable price. Exactly what you want on a night out. The place can be pretty darn busy but I've always admired how friendly the staff is. The menu is light, but a warm slice of pizza (they warm it up for you right before serving) and something to drink is all I ever need. Highly recommend, especially if you are out on the town for the night. This is GOOD pizza! read more

Great selection of unique pizzas - buffalo chicken, macaroni & cheese, chicken & sundried tomato - as well as the standard sausage, pepperoni, deluxe, and cheese. I've tried several different combinations, and they are all great. Order by the slice. The pizzas are par-baked, so they can quickly get your slice ready. And, each slice is served with a garlic knot. Delicious addition. Grab a quick bite and enjoy the deliciousness. read more

Sal's Pizza - Chicken, sundried tomato, and basil - with a knot! - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

Came late night before the drunken crowd arrived. Line traffic moved smoothly and service was quick. Food was okay but not great. I wouldn't mind going back and trying a few more different slices. read more

Sal's Pizza - Deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

This is possibly the worst pizza place I've been to. Our group of 9 came in around 12:30 Sunday afternoon sept.9 Employee ( female possibly owner) Asked if we we're getting pizza by slice.. We. Asked for menu received mumbling and angry look..then told pizza only rest of menu not available. Pizza was average tasting and large. Service poor to pathetic. Paint pealing was the only form of decor..very tiny place,horrible booths.. Not worth the time to go back..service was a joke at best read more

it was a cruise the ave event, me and my girlfrien sat at one of the tables outside eating food from elsewhere. there were no markings on these tables to make it obvious the seats belonged to sals pizza. one of the employees took it upon themselves to come out cursing at us asking us wtf we were doing. we proceeded to leave and he followed us threatening me. he told me to meet him outside even though I'm a minor just trying to enjoy dinner. he appeared Mexican with black hair kind of swished to the side. read more

Seriously some amazing pizza. With all the pizza places in Appleton, what makes this one so awesome? First, the cheese. A great pizza needs some seriously amazing cheese. This place hands down has the best cheese for a pizza. Second, the crust is great. Not too thick, or too thin. It is the perfect crust to fold in half and eat New York Style. Personally, I like to call ahead and order my pizza to take home. They are always piping hot and I am usually famished by the time I get home. And did I mention the rolls? Delicious! A family favorite that comes with all pizza orders. If you are not quite hungry for the whole pizza, you can order by the slice. Trust me, you at least have to try Sal's once! You will love it! read more

Best pizza in town- hands down!! We always order for delivery, and its always hot and fresh. The spinach and ricotta pie is definately a fav in this house! Ive had a canoli from sals, but I wasnt impressed. Doesnt change my rating though!! Oh and their garlic knots- to die for!!! Pasta Bolognase-- Yummy!!! read more

Food was good. Three workers were not wearing masks at all and one was wearing it under their nose. Irresponsible.

Pizza has really declined over the years. The owners are nasty, too. If your downtown and need a bite, it's still pizza. It's not worth picking up an order though. read more

Stopped at Sal's for a slice on our way back to our hotel room. The first thing the person behind the counter was very helpful and had excellent customer service. The second thing is not only do you get huge slices of pizza but you also get free garlic knots with each slice. So the last thing is the pizza. I have eaten a lot of pizza being Italian and also coming from just a couple hours away from Chicago. This pizza was a top ten in my book. I will definitely stop and grab a slice if I'm ever in the area again. Also it was very reasonably priced too. read more

Let me first say my pizza rating for this place is 10 stars! I still LOVE their pizza, best in the valley hands-down, despite it being re-heated! Dare I say it's the best I've had in Wisconsin, 2nd best to Lombardi's Pizza in NYC IMHO... My review of the staff, is 2 stars, maybe 2.5 if that were an option. You truly get "just okay" service. Occasionally I see them happy looking or smiling, but not often. Definitely a little cold. The owner, who I'm assuming is the older lady with an accent, really needs to brush-up on her customer service. She always looks angry, barely talks to you, and when she does, I sometimes feel like I'm bothering her by requesting a slice of pizza. You make the best pizza in the area, and in a cool historic section of town, please try to like what you're doing. Or at least pretend to. A smile goes a long way, but so does a frown... read more

Mediocre, overpriced pizza, and rude staff. The pizza was ok but definitely not worth the price, and one of the workers was extremely rude.

First time giving Sal's a try, and I really wasn't all that impressed. I ordered the Philly Cheese steak and Chicken Parm sub sandwich for delivery. Delivery took almost two hours on a Tuesday night, and I only live a few blocks away. Both of the subs lacked any real flavor or quality. The Philly Cheese was watery and drippy, had very little ingredients or cheese on it, and both subs had burnt bread. The Chicken parm was better than the Philly Cheese, but again lacked any real flavor, and I'm pretty sure the chicken was processed. Overall not a good experience, I will not order from here again. (Update 4/6/17) Both my wife and I became sick after eating the Chicken Parmesan sub sandwich, and have now been sick for almost two days. Where I first thought the chicken was processed, I now believe the chicken to have been spoiled. read more

Guys: After living in NYC many years ago, there are two things I miss most: Central Park jogging and Ray's Pizza. Ray's Pizza is simple but great tasting pizza by the slice meant to be eaten plain with cheese, maybe one ingredient. It's just a really satisfying meal. Sal's is a flashback to authentic New York style pizza and it's a Wisconsin oasis for me when I want great pizza. I usually go for two cheese slices, maybe one with sausage only. The lovely Maureen always gets a cheese slice. The teens like the pepperoni and we always have to bring slices home if it's just Maureen and me. I heard there's a really good Mac and Cheese pizza. I don't get it but I go simple here. Preparation hint: Unless it's straight out of the oven, they throw the pizza slices into the pizza ovens to warm them up. They bring it out piping hot. Maureen likes it piping hot. I have burnt my mouth too many times on piping hot pizza so I tell them to just warm it up and "not too hot." The staff is kinda quirky. They don't add to the place. The pizza is the hero. Bottom line: If you like or miss New York Style Pizza, you've found the place. Don't walk. Run. It's a once a month great meal for Maureen and me. read more