Chef's kiss! What a great little place. Pleasant but nondescript interior, mix of booths and tables. We stopped late on a sunny Saturday afternoon, and it was not busy at all. Ordered breadsticks as an appetizer and a 14" Luigi's Special, which I'm told is the most popular choice. It should be. Wow! After our breadsticks, which came quickly, were piping hot, crusty on the outside and soft on the inside, the pizza arrived - and it was superb. Very tasty, great quality toppings (which I won't list, leaving to you to look up on the menu), very nice thin crust, and lovely sauce. I packed away a little more than I should've, because it was so good. Eating for pleasure, right? So yes, highly recommended, and we will be back. read more

I have been a customer of Luigi's since day one. They have very tasty food and it is affordable. I never tried the Cannelloni until today. Wow. It is fantastic. Too often the beef is a bit dry or runny with sauce. Not at Luigi's it was perfect. read more

The toppings are delicious and plentiful, but the crust is another thing. Mine which was traditional/thin tasted and had the texture of a frozen commercial grocery store pizza. If I give it another go, maybe I'll check out the pan or stuffed. read more

Great place. Amazing food. Wonderful owners. Great Italian vibe. Definitely recommend this place!

The food is great and reasonably priced. Our waitress was top-notch. The environment was very welcoming.

Great family owned and operated pizza place. Not only is the pizza great but so are the salads and apps. The meatball side is about 2 pounds and is amazing! read more

Great little family pizza place. Reminds me of the pizza places when I was a kid. I recommend.

Prices are different on the handout menu than what they charge, to the tune of 25% higher when checking out. The loud TV in the dining area that was there more for the staff than anything else as if people were there to watch game shows loudly instead of eat. Food was bland and close to what I would envision someone who knows what Italian looks like, but without knowing how to season it. The waitress was kind, so at least there was that. But after being bait and switched prices at the register I won't return. Do everyone a favor and don't hand out menus if they're not right. I would have thought it was a one time thing had I not seen the other review. Can only imagine how many people fall for this without noticing. If this is a small business, have more pride in what you do and more respect for those you serve. Shameful business practice. read more

My experience at Luigi's was exceptional. Outstanding customer service! The owner/manager goes above and beyond to get things right. We ordered the chicken bacon ranch pizza which was phenomenal. The ingredients are very fresh and the crust was a buttery flaky sensation. I will definitely be back! #supportlocal read more

Luigi's Pizza of Appleton - 16 inch Chicken Bacon Ranch - Italian Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Way to much cheese on pizza. Sauce a bit to sweet for my taste but if you like xcheese and sweet sauce you would probably love it. Just not fir me read more

Food was very reasonable and excellent. Service is spot on. We will definitely be back.

Ive eaten in at this location before and the family is amazing! Very friendly and goes out of their way to be social with each of their customers. I called an order in for delivery on 7/3. They always have great service and come through on what they say. My office was outside of their normal delivery area, but because of my order they made an exception. Everyone in the office was happy with their selection and pleasantly full! Nick, the owner, personally delivered my order and he remembered me! What outstanding service they have on all levels! Amazing taste, great portion sizes and very reasonable on their price! If you want quality Italian good, go to Luigi's across from Appleton North High School! Go hungry and leave full! Thank you for your awesome service!! read more

Luigi's Pizza of Appleton - a piece of bread in a box - Italian Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

This is the epitome of family-owned perfection. The love and care they put into all their menu items is so evident. By far the best pizza in town and they are always friendly and willing to chat. Their Big BBQ Chicken pizza is the thing dreams are made of. It is by far my favorite thing to order. But their calzones, French bread, pasta... oh the pasta... everything is so good. And you absolutely have to get a piece of their homemade tiramisu!! I promise you won't be disappointed with anything you order!! read more

Perfect Family Ran business! I can see the years of practice by both the daughter and mother. The employees are all bright kids who I have personally chatted with and all seem to help the owners in more aspects that just food industry life. I would advice anyone to go here and promise you'll enjoy the pizza or anything you get. read more

Not great pizza at all. Cheese was rubber and overall pizza was underdone Sorry Luigi's-we won't be back read more

3 or 4 stars. 3 or 4 stars. Decisions Decisions. I decided on 4 stars because of the taste of the food and the prompt service. Why did I want to give 3 stars? We came in on 3/27 and it was FREEZING inside. Like I was ready to leave after 10 minutes,it felt like there was not an ounce of heat pumping through there. Just because it's spring, people, doesn't mean you turn the heat off. The other reason ....and this was the part that bothered me the most. One of the employees warmed up a slice of pizza in the oven and ate it, right in the kitchen in full view of everyone inside the dining area, eating. He stood up, while other employees were cooking and preparing food ... and ate pizza and drank his soda. Directly after that. He said goodbye to everyone and left. There were tables OUTSIDE of the kitchen not even 5 feet from him. He could have sat at any one of those tables. It was not ok with me. It probably should not have bothered me as much as it did. But there I sat.. bothered ...AND COLD. read more

This has been our go to for pizza. If you like cheese, and I mean fresh, real mozzarella cheese oozing off the slice...this place is for you. Excellent, homemade sauce. Sandwiches are good too. Family friendly and family owned and operated. You won't be disappointed. read more

Wow amazing delicious yummy food Taste is Italy seasoning are a secret Service is good ,,,,drinks also The pride of Luigi is Pizza!! read more

A true Italian runed restaurant, Calzones have Ricotta and Mozzarella. We are from CT and was hard to find a great Italian Pizza place, well we found it. Owner is friendly, great friendly atmosphere. Cant wait to go back and try the Manicotti. The sausage on the pizza was actual sausage chunks and not small shredded sausage. Please go and give this a try. I think you will enjoy. read more

I'm always on the lookout for a new go-to pizza spot in Appleton. Presently, Glass Nickel is pretty much the end-all, be-all in town (unless you have time to go to Neenah's superb Broken Tree Pizza). Luigi's is a dud. Maybe it's their doughy, flavorless crust. Maybe it's their lack of variety of toppings. Maybe it's just the fact that their pizza isn't very good. Who can really tell? read more

The pizza was really good! So was the garlic bread! Everything was amazing! I will be honest though, I have had better, but i've had waaaayy worse then this. So I really do recommend it! read more

I love Luigi's! The staff is very nice and they do a great job. The service is quick and the food is delicious! We enjoyed a yummy dinner last night with cheesy garlic bread and a sausage pizza. My daughter loves that they have pink lemonade! The pizza is outstanding! read more

I drove by this place a few times and skipped it over. Good pizza in a strip mall looking spot? My friend Phil swore by it. Our family ordered the football. It was delicious. The crust was just right and the sausage was good. The canolis were spot on. She even included one extra tho round it out for our group. I enjoyed our server Gio's sense of humor. She kept us laughing and the drinks full. I would definitely recommend this spot. My family will return when we are in the area. I guess they also have some Facebook coupons available. read more

It has been awhile since we have been here!! Still one of the best pies in Appleton!! Always a happy place.

Ordered several 30" pizzas for a team dinner. Pizzas were delicious, ready on time & customer service was top notch! Highly recommend

Great authentic (just listen to the accent of your hostess) Italian restaurant. Took the family there for pizza after work and were pleasantly surprised by the quality of food. Can't say you should go for the ambience, but the food is great. read more

We love Luigi's pizza. Easy red sauce with incredible cheese. No need to get extra cheese. We always carry out because pretty small location on Ballard Rd read more

Great pizza and pasta. Love it for carry out. The restaurant itself has a bit of cafeteria feel, but the food more than makes up for it.

Great pizza. a little out of the way but worth the short drive, it is one of the top two pizza joints around. My only suggestion is to add delivery as an option. read more

Love this place. The staff is super friendly. The food is good and the place is clean. I have had the pizza a couple times and it is excellent. I have only had the thin crust so far, but have heard good things about the others. My wife tried the calzone. It was huge and she loved it. She was only able to eat half. The wine selection is limited to Cavit and Surtter Home. Overall, one of our favorite pizza places in Appleton. read more

Take my review with a grain of salt...I was late picking up and they graciously waited 10 minutes after close for me to get there. Amazing. Crust was good, decent amount of toppings but a little inconsistently placed. Not a lot of sauce. This is probably really good if you aren't the last order of the night. I didn't know they close at 9 on Fridays. I want to love it based on their kindness alone. read more

Very good food and super friendly staff!! We had a large party and the waitress and amazing to accommodate us and joked around and made the overall experience a great one. I would definitely recommend it to anyone! read more

Had couple of pasta dishes and have to say was very surprised. Was really really good..would definitely go back. Next to try the pizza.

Deserves 6 stars, but only 5 available!! Great pizza!!! Very nice people! Definitely one of my favorite small businesses. Please support, they deserve the business!! read more

Pizza here is amazing! Service is ok. Wish the hours were different. Its kindof hard to eat here.

I just had the worse cheese steak sandwhich ever!!! If anyone has ever had a cheese steak sandwhich you right away think of tender, juicy, thin slices of steak piled on a bun with sautéed green pepper and onion topped with melted cheese. Well what I just had didnt even resemble meat. It was completly dry and crumbled with absolutely no flavor at all. I should note that we were not charged for it... Seriously cannot believe they would sell that crap. Obviously outdated meat. Kind of sick to my stomach thinking that I was actually hungry enough to eat it - my bad!!! Lost a customer for sure! Too bad too because we always enjoy talking to Jo. read more

What a wonderful place. Great atmosphere and wonderful people. The food is excellent. Highly recommend!

We come to Appleton 4 times a year, and this is the place to go! Very friendly staff and tremendous pizza!