I love their pizza. The crust is my favorite part but when it's burnt it's not so good. Little disappointed in the customer service. read more

Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Our other favourite for pizza in Appleton. Just a well run solid place with atmosphere and good vibe. We love it!

Nice place, larger inside than it looks outside. There is a patio for dining al fresco. It's dark and cozy inside. The booths have a very private feel. I enjoyed the ambiance. Service was friendly and fast. I think there only two servers working the floor. They were flying! We ordered eggplant fries for an appetizer and they were delicious. Our pizza was the Wiseguy Loaded Extra, and was great. Hand tossed crust was cooked perfectly, not soggy or doughy in the middle at all. Toppings were good, the cheese was very good. The onions were sweet and tasty. We'll be back for more of the pizza. The only false note was the "pint" of Guinness. The wee glass would get you laughed out of the place in Ireland! It looked like a 12 ounce glass, not 16 for sure. Even on the tab it said "pint". But otherwise a fine place and we will come back for sure. Edit: I see our server's name is Zachary. Nice job, man! read more

See all

Deep dish pizza is pretty close to Chicago style. Sauce is good. Crust was a little under done. read more

Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub - Deep dish pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

The pizza was OK however, the price was too high. I'm not saying don't try it. I think you should check it out for yourself and see what you think. read more

First time trying their Pizza, compares to the best pizza I've had in Milwaukee. I will be back again.

One of the best pizza places in the valley. You'll never leave hungry, or disappointed with the pizza

Been 3 years since we had Wise Guys food..sigh. We ordered takeout. A calzone for my spouse and a babyface pizza for me with added chicken, thin crust. (I also ordered a side salad.) We picked up the order when they told us and my pizza box felt COLD. It was a Wednesday night, 530 pm with only two patrons at the bar. When I bit into the babyface pizza, I knew why the box was not hot. The crust was very soggy and udercooked. I noticed there was maybe a handful of chicken on it (they must be cutting back) and the pizza itself tasted weird, like it was missing something. Yep..the key ingrediant of balsamic glaze was no where on the pizza at all!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Just disappointed. Havent eaten the food for years and go on a slow night to get takeout and it is not even prepared correctly. I did email the place to tell them what happened with our order and received no response. I guess they dont care about giving quality food out. And, our bill was $53 just for the items we ordered to go. read more

Our favorite place for pizza. Love the zesty sauce and spicy sausage. But if that's not your style, they have lots of crust and sauce options. read more

Atmosphere: Located in a strip mall off of Oneida next to a little game shop. There is a good amount of parking and the inside is quite large despite the outside appearance. They have a few patio seats outdoors for the warmer months. The inside is quite dark. There is a long bar area right when you walk in and then there is a dining area with booths and tables. Some of the booths against one wall have curtains, which is nice if it is loud (which it was VERY loud) and you want some privacy on your night out. Service: They seemed a bit understaffed, but the servers did a great job trying to make sure we had everything we needed. Our server was extremely personable and we were grateful for a wonderful evening out. Food: First off, we came here because we were looking for good onion rings, and the image on yelp looked amazing, but don't be fooled, they don't have onion rings on there menu (insert frown here). Despite that glitch, HOLY. MENU. I seriously don't know where to begin, this menu is huge. It took us forever to decide what we wanted. My fiance ended up selecting their Donny burger (sausage patty and beef patty with marinara and cheese) with fries, and I chose the Coco Calzone. Both of us were beyond pleased with the selections we made, and it will be hard to order other items off the menu in the future. Their french fries are so finger licking good, whatever seasoning they use packs flavor and they are crispy as all get out. I can't wait to come back here-I'm hoping it is sooner than later. read more

The best deep dish pizza around. Order ahead to avoid the wait. Great environment and always good beer.

Fantastic pizzas!! This place clearly stands out for the pizza that they serve. Our orders - Calpone pizza Fried fish Spinach and Artichoke dip Sangria and beers. Capone pizza - One with the Alfredo sauce and the other zesty.Both were immensely great especially the thin crust. Toppings well spread and delicious. The large serves 3 people and the small was good for 2. Excellent portions. The fish was served with baby potatoes and was a good addition to the menu. However, I have had better Friday fish fry. The surprise on the menu was the Spinach and Artichoke dip. Definitely a must have dish. It was mouth watering. The only Con was the waiting time. It was a busy night so we had to wait for 30 minutes. Great service, good food and how can i forget - Sangria was epic too! read more

See all

We went here the first time about a week ago and for the first time in a long time we found a place where servers actually pay attention to customers. The stuffed crust pizza was SO good and was way bigger than expected, the mozzarella sticks not the best I would not pay $10 for them again. Will definitely be there again maybe in a week or two cause I seen several things on the menu I wanted to try. read more

I love this Pizza. They lay it on like it should be. Their cheese is different than most. It tastes more high-end than the normal commercial mozz. It's buttery, heavy. The sauce is just right and plenty of it. Homemade crust starts it off. The oven looks like something special. The manager-owner-bossman takes pride in his pies. Have to say I love their big bag fries. Give them a try.1 more thing. Tastes great cold or nuked the next day. read more

Absolutely delicious calzones and pizza! I went here with a few members of my family as I'd heard good things about their fish fry, but when I saw the menu, I knew I had to go with a calzone. I asked them to drown me in garlic, and they most certainly did not hold back! The calzone's crust was very flakey and soft, and was absolutely delicious and buttery. It was filled to the brim with cheese and meats, and it was so large I could barely finish a third! It would definitely be large enough to share with a friend or partner! My family on the other hand, decided to order pizzas, and all confirmed that the thin crust was light and crispy and wasn't soggy--a huge bonus! The cheese was piled on top generously and there were tons of mushrooms as well. They certainly aren't miserly with their toppings here, which is certainly an added bonus. We ordered two pizzas for four adults, (not including myself) and all together we still ended up taking about a third of a pizza home in the end. Great value for the price, and the mozzarella had a splendid flavor and texture--nice and gooey. Wait staff was attentive and no ones glasses went empty even once. Our server was polite and friendly, and food came out at a reasonable pace. (About 30 minutes, as could be expected). Overall, I'm glad we stopped in here on a whim. It was a bit difficult to find, but it was well worth the hassle! We will certainly be coming back. read more

Was craving pizza one night and decided to check this place out. I wish I had not waited so long! This is one of the best pizza places in the area! Food- We got the Bar-B-Que Chicken pizza and a cheese pizza with garlic and tomatoes. The pizzas were awesome! The Bar-B-Que pizza was delicious! The sauce was just the right amount of sweet and tangy. Chicken was cooked perfectly. The cheese pizza was awesome as well. I got it with zesty sauce and it was packed with flavor. The crust on both pizzas was the right amount of crisp and chewy. It also had good flavor. Drinks- There are a large amount of drinks to choose from. They have a full bar and many custom cocktails and martinis. They also have beer on tap and have bottled beer. Service- Service is great. Pizza takes a little bit of time to cook but it wasn't long enough to make it annoying. We were checked on regularly and our drinks were filled whenever they got low. The server also had recommendations for us when we asked. This is a great place to grab a pizza for either dine in or to go. The price is also comparable to other fresh pizza places in the area. read more

One of the best pizza places in Appleton. Currently following guidelines with regard to COVID (social distancing, masks) which was greatly appreciated. Hand tossed is my favorite with deep dish a close 2nd. Warm cozy atmosphere as well. read more

Stopped in to Wise Guys for a pizza in between games at a softball tournament. Had the thin crust with spicy sausage and pepperoni it was fantastic highly recommend. The cheesy garlic bread was also very yummy! Service was excellent as well. read more

First of all, the food for this type of establishment is a 5. If you're not in a hurry you will love it. Great atmosphere and decent decor. The service is absolutely atrocious. And it's not the people - they are great. There just aren't enough of them. The owners put a sign on the door apologizing in advance for their soon-to-be shitty service because they can't hire anybody. Waaa-waaaa. Who does that? It doesn't make anything better! 4 people applying for jobs since February (it is now the end of October) is either a flat out lie, you need to actually try to recruit people other than help wanted flyers in the pisser, or you pay for shit. Figure those things out, get the excuse note off the door, stop killing your 3 employees on a Friday night and leverage this great product and be more successful. read more

One word sums up this place. Atmosphere! The restaurant is great inside, thanks to the decorating details, and they were playing some great music the day we were there to continue our pizza challenge. We got a table in this little nook area next to the front window and it was an enjoyable dining experience. The menu has a large selection of pizza to try and I was almost tempted to try one that isn't our standard!. But we ordered the standard and the pizza was delicious. One downfall was too much cornmeal on the bottom of the crust. Next time I want to try the chica. Oh another plus is they have zesty or mild sauce red sauce and a few others to pick from if you build your own pizza. It is in a strip mall and can be easy to drive past but worth looking for. read more

This place has a great ambiance and the best old fashions. It does get pricey after a few drinks but we love this place and the outdoor seating is a bonus. read more

Great atmosphere and fantastic pizza. From the outside of building, does not look like much. Get inside and be amazed. read more

Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub - a man holding a sign - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

One of the best pizzas in the Fox Valley! Pizza is always cooked perfectly, and the service is consistently fast and friendly. Prices are very reasonable for the pizza quality. Highly recommend the thin crust; so crispy with great flavor. read more

The service is excellent. The atmosphere is casual and very welcoming. The pizza and pasta is very good. And to top it off the beer selection is good along with very good martinis. A favorite of ours. read more

My wife and I were looking for Italian food, so we gave Wiseguys a try. It was our first time there, but won't be our last. We were greeted by Cassie, who was also our server for the evening. She was very friendly and attentive. We started out with the Bruschetta. It was delicious. We both order the lasagna. It comes with choice soup or salad, so we both had the garden salad. The vegetables were fresh and tasty and the lettuce was cool and crispy, just how I like my salads. Next came the entree. It too was delicious. The serving was large, so we have leftovers for lunch. We topped our meal off with a slice of cheesecake, which was a perfect way to finish our meal. We saw several people ordered their pizza. It looked and smelled good. We will be back to try their pizza. read more

Amazing pizza!!! Definitely get the zesty sauce and the garlic butter crust! You won't be disappointed!!!! read more

Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub - AMAZING pizza!!! Definitely get the zesty sauce and garlic butter crust!!!! Will be back!!! - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

This is the best gluten-free pizza I've had. It's the thin gluten free crust not fluffy. I had my reservations because it's in a strip mall but the ambiance was nice also (although a little too dark for my taste). I would have given them 5 stars except they use styrofoam. What's up with that??? It's 2018, there is no excuse for having any styrofoam anymore. It's got to go. read more

Ordered a stuffed pizza - quoted 45mins took over an hour ...asked for tomato's received sun dried tomatoes BIG difference! Large pizza was 30$ very salty and burnt crust . Too bad will never order again read more

If you like pizza, this is a must-try. Their Chicago-style deep dish is soaked in sauce and eats like a heavy lasagna. Absolutely awesome...this thing must've weighed 4-5 lbs. Also, as mentioned above, you could drive right by the place having never realized what you're missing out on. It was a pleasant surprise. Inside has a semi-private dining area and a well-kept bar; an easy place to relax with an after-work beverage while the impossibly backed-up construction traffic fizzles out. I'm going back for seconds; that goes without saying. But my next visit is dependent upon finishing the leftovers from my first monster pizza (which will take a bit of delicious effort to accomplish). read more

Went here with my husband for a quiet dinner. Walked inside and was ignored by the bartender for about 6 minutes despite standing at the bar (she was more interested in talking with the 5 or so drunk locals at the far end of the bar). Radio was super loud- to the point you can't talk to the person next to you. I could understand this on a game-day but this was ridiculous. The food we had was soaked in grease and seemed to not even be strained before being served. I would never eat at this place again. We have had success in ordering their pizza and having it been serviceable. read more

Pizza is my passion, and Wiseguys is my newest favorite place for pizza! The service was EXCELLENT, the atmosphere, EXCELLENT, food, EXCELLENT! Three thumbs up!! And such unique pizzas that you can't go wrong with what you get. I only suggest they get a wheel barrel to haul people out! read more

Excellent food, never had anything we didn't love here. But Brittany is terrible and has a bad attitude. We always consider going somewhere else when Brittany is working. read more

Found this place by accident when in Menasha for Seafood Fest. Nice place, staff was great, pizza was excellent, but really pricey. Pinching me $2.90 for a soda was ridiculous. Quality was good, value not so much. read more

We found this gem when we were in town for the Christmas Eve Packers game. It was snowy outside and nice and cozy inside. We were lucky enough to sit at the bar and get a taste of the friendly local culture. Brittany recommended the Pancho Villa pizza on thin crust, and she didn't steer us wrong. Best. Taco. Pizza. Ever. As a bonus, we received well wishes and game tips from Brittany and fellow diners at the bar. Another great Yelp pick! read more

The BEST thin crust pizza in the valley! Seriously, you're missing out if you have not at least tried this place. Plus, they always have some pretty decent beers on tap. The rub however, is the service. I've actually taken to calling ahead and getting our pizza to go because the service has been so consistently frustrating. The prices seem a tad high to me, but the pizza is worth it. It is with trepidation (the service) that I recommend giving Wiseguys a try if you're looking to expand your pizza horizons. read more

Very nice restaurant! Food was delish, service was fast and courteous. We ordered the onion rings (more like onion strings) and the coco thin crust pizza. We will be back with our friends. read more

Best pizza in town. Hands down. Sauce is amazing. We also had the eggplant appetizer... Which is also fantastic.

We had just moved to the neighborhood and wanted pizza so we thought we would try this. It's in a strip mall so we didn't expect what we walked into. The ambiance was very nice and the pizza was to die for. We were waited on by a very nice young man from Poland. He was very polite and a great server. The zesty sauce was spot on Italian tasting. Will definitely be going back. I highly recommend this establishment!! read more

Came here to meet with a buddy on a Sunday night at 7:30pm. I heard really good things about their pizza, but my dreams were crushed as the bartender immediately looked at us as a nuisance and was told they could only make appetizers. I hope there's some logical reason that I don't understand why they would decide that since they were open til 9. I'll admit they did let us stay a little longer as the Super Bowl was on. I did order some chili fries, which hit the spot for a late night snack. I will give this place another chance, because I really want to try their pizza. Plus they had decent craft beer on tap, and inside it's nice and clean inside. read more

Great menu and our favorite pizza. Hamburgers, Friday fish, Italian beef sandwiches -- you can't go wrong. Friendly, efficient staff in a nice setting. read more