I'm so happy I finally tried this place! I had the mac daddy pizza, and unlike every other mac & cheese pizza I've had, it was an alfredo sauce base instead of cheese sauce.. and it WORKED! It was way better this way. The cheese curds were delicious too, and the cinna nugs were one of the best desserts I've ever had. read more

See all

Went in to pick up a pizza and noticed a special: $4 cheesy bread with a pizza purchase. I asked if I could add it to my order, and the guy flatly said no. I wasn't asking for anything crazy, just to add a $4 item that was advertised in store (it wasn't even listed on their website, so I didn't know about it beforehand). No offer to help, no coupon, nothing, just a hard no, delivered like I'd asked for something unreasonable. On top of that, the total came to over $40 for one large and one small pizza, which already felt steep. Combined with the unhelpful service, it just wasn't worth it. read more

It was OK. I think I like thinner crust better. It reminded me of Little Caesars Pizza. What surprises you about my review? I am from Chicago where they have the best pizza! read more

Service was incredibly slow. They forgot what we ordered multiple times. Dont try to get the actual drink u order - just settle for whatever makes it to the table (be happy anything made it to the table). Food orders were completely worng too. Took over 30 minutes for chicken strips- and then had the wrong side and dip anyway. Servers - they dont even talk to each other or know their tables. They come to take an order - when a different person already took the order...that never came. Want a bill? Plan to wait...and then you wont get the right one anyway. Definitely wouldnt go back. read more

Great place to get some food if you're staying at the hotel right next door. The pizza is good but not the best. They also forgot to add my jalapeños onto the pizza. But they did offer to give me a side of jalapeños. Not the same when it's baked all together :( I wouldn't recommend the cheese curds here. I feel like the cheese curds lacked flavor. Overall, the place is decent if you're looking for something quick and nearby. Food is okay and customer service wasn't the best. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

After our experience with the terrible delivery driver the GM swiftly called to learn what happened. She was attentive, compassionate and understanding. I greatly appreciate her how she handled our situation. read more

Got a large BYO pie and an order of spinach cheese bread. Full of delicious flavor. Got it to go and it was piping hot when I got home. We don't eat out much cuz of cost but always willing to drop a dime here, never dissapoints. Always a smiling staff, thanks to all. read more

I'm not sure what changed, the pizza used to be just fine. This time both large pizzas were sloppy, inedible garbage read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

We ordered a large pizza with extra cheese to be delivered. There was hardly any cheese let alone extra cheese. We ordered delivery rather pick up so it would be piping hot.It was the opposite! It was cold. The garlic butter sauce ordered with the fried ravioli was solid and ice cold. It was not possible to dip. I contacted them direct with no response. read more

Just got off the phone with Trisha and she was amazing! Extremely helpful and any questions she didn't know she was timely in asking her manager! Such a good experience! Pizza is THE best too! Will continue to support this business! read more

Great food. Absolutely horrible service. The bus boy/ host was great. The waitress that checked aa on us and helped was good. The waiter assign to our table was slow, apathetic and distracted. Our drink sat on the bar for 15 minutes while he ignored the situation and did very little. When the manager arrived she was very apologetics for read more

Consistently good pizza. Service can be touch and go, but overall the staff is helpful and kind. Love eating in because of the music and atmosphere. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - Large Buffalo Nickel Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

The pizza and service is usually good, yet last night they lost my business! After waiting 35 to 40 minutes and a couple of update request, my waiter came back to our table (without saying sorry) to tell us that they gave our pizza order to another table. Though my waiter said they started a new one, I wasn't about to stick around. No sorry and no manager coming around to compensate us in any way. Very disappointed experience! Tony B. read more

So, Glass Nickel Pizza isn't my favorite pizza in Appleton, but it is still good. Glass Nickel has a lot of specialty pizzas and we had great service for our group of 10. Our appetizer arrived hot from the oven, but a little overcooked. We had a BBQ Chicken pizza that had more BBQ sauce than it had cheese. Both the cheese bread and the pizza were good and we enjoyed them. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - Cheese & Spinach cheese bread! - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Tasty pizza. I wish they didn't leave so much plain crust without toppings, but it is still good pizza. It is very greasy, so eat fast before it gets soggy. The sausage is a big hit. Also, why cut a large pizza into only 6 slices? Delivery is always at least an hour (2.5 miles away). read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - Large pepperoni and half sausage, not sure why a large would be cut into only 6 slices. - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Mistakes happen, It's how you respond to mistakes is what separates a good establishment from a horrible establishment. My first pizza was completely wrong, as I said, mistakes happen. A second pizza was sent out, if was so undercooked that the crust had the consistency of wet toilet paper. This was showed their driver who was oblivious to what a pizza is. John, their general manager refused to be on the side of a good establishment and refused to correct their mistake. This was a large order of over $150.00 to feed a large family, the food that was sent correctly was sub par flavor at best. I requested they add a few plates and napkins because after placing a large, it seemed like a responsible request. They charge per paper plate. An extra $.60 for 12 pates after spending over $150.00. Just stay from this place. read more

Great pizza, even if a little on the pricier side. Their hand tossed pizza is probably the best crust. Fun spot!

Three stars. What's happened,Appleton? This place had killer Pizza, cold beer and fabulous service bar and table. Beer. Warm at best. Pizza. Good. Cant beat cracker crust and thus the reason for the three stars. Service. Great. Kind. I wouldn't say Fast... but the pizza arrived hot. Thai pie. Pretty good. We keep coming back because the PIZZA but it would be great if they got the refrigeration issue worked out for a COLD beer. So many Appleton spots getting a little run down during this COVID thing. Maybe if we keep supporting them they'll bounce back. I'm rooting for you Glass Nickel. read more

Great pizza! My son is dairy free and this is the first place we have found that he can enjoy pizza. We love love that. He gets DOWN on the pizza. We always order out so I'm not sure about the sit down part but we love this place! read more

I ordered delivery from here on Day 2 of the COVID-19 "Safer at Home" recommendation. I was charged $11.75, without tax, for the Mediterranean Lasagna. The portion size I received wouldn't be close to sufficient for a child's entree, let alone an adult. The other items on the order were clearly not prepared so that they all came out hot at the same time. The cheese sticks felt rubbery but warm, like microwaved leftover pizza. The bread nuggets were cold, too. I'm severely disappointed that the kitchen staff didn't even bother to try to make the items seem fresh. The photos included are of my Mediterranean dish. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - a person holding a pan of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

First, a disclaimer: we ordered on a day that it was snowing, so we knew going in that the pizza wouldn't be delivered super fast at all. We didn't expect, though, for it to take 2 hours. When the pizza arrived it was cold and--get this--burned. Almost seems like an oxymoron, doesn't it? We got a deal for a large pizza plus the Nickel Nuggets, which we hadn't tried before. I hated them, but that's on me. I should have guessed that from the description. Glass Nickel gets points on its pizza sauce, which isn't horridly sweet like what seems like every other pizza joint around Appleton. Still--a disappointing meal. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - Burnt, cold pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Yum yum! The (seasonal) Luau pizza is extraordinary! Some quotes from our small party "best pizza ever", "the crust taste like homemade bread", "wow; this is like sugar - deeelicious!" The pepperoni pizza was very very greasy for the carry out box, but tastes great and the hand tossed crust is thick, sweet, and amazing. Delivery to a hotel - arrived much more quickly than expected and incredibly hot and in great shape. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - The seasonal luau pizza - sweet, filled to the brim with toppings, and beyond delicious. A must have! - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Garbage pizza and staff, more than likely represents the team above them. I can't stand places like this. Have nice staff, that's not hard, but having tasty food is out of your hands, maybe better off closing. read more

There are many different and crazy specialty pizzas to choose from, or you can create your own. This was my first visit here, and it was hoppin busy for trivia night. Service from waitress Bridget was adequate and not overbearing; e were a large pesky group and she handled it with seeming ease. On Wednesdays for trivia night, happy hour pricing is on the whole time. I had a Titletown Dark Helmet on draft, and it was only 3 bucks. Spotted cow was 4 bucks for a pint. The draft beer selection was fairly modest, but you probably could find something to quench ypur personal tastes. There appeared to be a decent bottleselection, but i did not study the list extensively. With happy hour pricing, Nickel Nuggets were only $1.98...a steal. The doughy parmesan bites co.e with marinara sauce and are a huge serving. Cheap eats! For pizza, we had two selections at our table, the Buffalo Nickel (buffalo chicken style), and thr monthly special Chicken and Waffle. The chicken and waffle was tasty, just lightly sweetened with syrup, a sweet and salty mix. I also thought the buffalo chicken was great. In general, the pizza toppings may run a tad on the greasy-ish side, but what else would you expect? A solid pizza joint. We will be back on another trivia night to try our luck and use the team's 3rd place winnings. read more

See all

Tasty pizza with multiple varieties to order. The service is positive, quick and polite all in a great atmosphere.

Ok, this is a pretty yummy pizza chain... they can be rough around the edges, like forgetting one of our pizzas, or the extra cheese,.... BUT, we would recommend. Their specialty pizzas are fun, and their dairy free/ gluten free options saves me from the consequences of my wife having dairy ;D we've only done delivery and carry out, but the staff has always been very friendly. read more

Great food! Busy nightlife (when covid is over) and really good pizza mmmm! My favorite is the thai pie, although they never put even close to enough sauce on it at this location, even when I pay for extra. read more

Another great pizza tonight! With great delivery service. So many area restaurant's could learn from this place. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - Look at those toppings! - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

This was based on a delivery. Ordering/Website: Their website has everything listed out easily and is simple to navigate. Descriptions are good and the layout is well put together. Time: Took less than 35 minutes for this to get delivered to our house which is what they had said. Food: My boyfriend enjoyed his pizza, but the one I had was not cooked all the way. You literally could not pick up the inner portion of the pizza because it was a congealed mess. The walnuts on the pizza were burnt, but at least they gave texture to this gooey pizza. Thin crust lovers want crispy crust, not a soggy undercooked dough. There are other pizza companies in the area that deliver better quality at a similar or better price. read more

Painfully slow service. Came on trivia night, which they host weekly so youd think they could plan accordingly. No bartender, so wait staff had to make their own drinks. Took us 5 min to get seated while it was still empty (we showed up an hour and a half before trivia started so we could eat and be done before the trivia began... That was the plan anyway). After we were seated it took about 15 to 20 minutes before our waitress even acknowledged our existence. at least by that time we knew what appetizer we wanted what main dish and what first round of drinks. We ordered and got our drinks within maybe 10 minutes. And then the wait began. 45 min later still no food, no drink refill, no acknowledgement. Somebody at my table brought empty glasses to the bar to get a refill and one of the waiters filling drinks for his order said he was too busy to help her out, so he came back and sat. I guess that jogged the memory of our waitress and she came with a glass of wine for one of our table members and I was finally able to order my second drink. 55 minutes after getting there, our main dish arrives at the table. Mind you all we ordered were two salads and spaghetti and marinara sauce which literally take 12 minutes to make at the most. When the main dish arrived I asked about the appetizer that never came before the meal and she brought that over, and I did mention that completely defeats the point of an appetizer. no apology whatsoever and she just curtly responded well do you still want it? When we made the order we also ordered extra marinara sauce which did not show up. My meatless pasta had lots of cheese on top which nowhere in the menu was that mentioned, and I'm lactose intolerant so I had to send that back and get one redone with no cheese. Funny thing it only took about 6 minutes to get the replacement, how about that. The place was not more busy than usual but it just seems that every time I come to trivia the service is way too slow. Why they do not plan ahead better for these nights to add an extra wait staff or just put on a Flippin bartender would make a huge difference. so in the end, we got there an hour and a half before trivia started, and all still finishing eating while trivia started. An hour and a half from getting there to finishing food it's not acceptable for a pizza joint. read more

I have loved Glass Nickel Pizza for a long time, but here it is late July 2021 and they're still only doing delivery and carry-out due to...COVID! Time to open back up like the rest of America and get back to business. Will consider changing my review if they get back to work. Meanwhile, I'm having pizza at Christiano's! read more

I met my sister here for trivia. They had some good happy hour/trivia time specials. Drinks were well made. And my order of Nickel Nuggets (garlic) were delicious. Service was lacking and orders took quite a while. We were also left to find our own cutlery once our food was actually brought to us. read more

My family and I have visited this location on several occasions. We always start with the Nickel Nuggets....cuz YUM! Their menu is extensive. But, we always go for the pizza...cuz (again) YUM! The restaurant has a booth seating area as well as a bar. There is also an area in the restaurant perfect for groups....bench seating, semi private area. During the summer, we love to sit outside in their covered patio area. My only complaint is that their tap beer selection is always pretty standard. I'd love for them to carry more local craft beers. They do have a large bottled beer selection. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - Pizza, beer, and garlic nots... - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Thank you . Pizza was exactly what I was hoping for. And great desert.

The Nickel Nuggets were great! The nugget appetizer seems to be a great compliment to the main dish - the pizza! This is the first time I've been here and I have heard great reviews from friends. We tried the Nickel Nuggets and definitely no complaint. Our server was very courteous and she brought everything in a timely manner. The pizza was great. It was not over-baked nor having uncooked toppings. The pizza came out perfect. From the outside, Glass Nickel Pizza looks small. I thought when we went, we have to get our orders to go. I was amazed on how big the inside, plenty of room for everybody, and the place is clean. This place is better than most pizza places I've been. The only knock about Glass Nickel Pizza is the location. The place would be hard to see coming down the bridge. From the top, you would be looking ahead towards the freeway or mall - not knowing Glass Nickel Pizza is on the right hand side. It would definitely benefit them if they relocate to downtown Appleton. Either than that, Glass Nickel Pizza is a great place to take your family for great pizza - and Nickel Nugget appetizer! read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - The Nickel Nugget appetizer. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Whoa! Ordered the 14" Deluxe, Regular Crust. No changes. The order was easy to manage and process online. 35-40 min from order to delivery. Pizza was fresh, toppings were well distributed. The pizza dough was chewy and tasty. We will definitely order out again soon! This was our first time doing delivery. The first time we had eaten here was at the Madison location, and we had dined in. I remembered it was great then. Glad to know the Appleton location rocks too! read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

The 6 piece chicken strip basket is actually the best chicken strips ive ever had my life, these chicken strips I'm eating right now actually changed my life, thank you whoever cooked this, this is the best chicken i've ever eaten in my entire life. read more

We order delivery frequently from glass nickel and it's always delicious! The chicken alfredo pizza is especially good and their salads are great as well-if you like Greek, try the acropolis. Would definitely recommend glass nickel and they usually have some sort of coupons/deals via their online site. read more

We order delivery from them on a regular basis, but because of family issues, it's been awhile and we put in our usual $80.00 order the other night. We get the 'build your own' pasta with side salads, some chicken wings and a 14" 'build your own' pizza. Enough for the 2 of us for a few days. The pasta was tasteless; hardly any alfredo sauce - just pasta, a few pieces of chicken and about 3 mushrooms, in each order. The side salads were as usual, however they sent wrong dressings. The pizza, which was always the best we've ever had, was lacking in flavor in spite of our usual order of extra toppings. We sent them an email explaining what we received and expected an answer from them, but nothing. We don't know what's changed since the last time we ordered from them, but we won't be ordering again. For our money, we expected the quality and flavor we've received in the past. We'll go elsewhere. read more

Ordered delivery from the Glass Nickel on 6/18/18. I ordered a fish sandwich and the "bacon blue" salad. Delivery was within the 30 minute time frame which I was quoted, and the food arrived very hot (sandwich) and cold (the salad). They definitely kept the two temperature foods separated. The Fish sandwich was excellent. Two fried fish patties, cheese, lettuce, tomato, on a toasted long roll with a side of tartar. The fish was light with a crispy batter and not at all greasy. The bread was not soggy and had a bit of chew to it. The tartar sauce was nice and tangy. All told, an excellent sandwich. On to the salad. What can I say? When they say it's a "bacon and blue" salad, they mean "BACON AND BLUE". There was a good deal of fresh, tender spinach but the amount of bacon and blue cheese crumbles was amazing. The star of this salad was the the bacon and blue cheese. The spinach was there as a vehicle to help bring these two to your mouth. The salad includes walnuts, BUT they're plain. The salad would be so much better if these were candied walnuts, to bring a bit of sweetness to the salad, and if they included some cranberries or some other tart fruit, it would help cut through some of the richness/cloying of the bacon and blue cheese. These additions would have made for a bit of a more well-rounded flavor profile for the salad (hope someone from the restaurant reads this). I made the mistake of going with blue-cheese dressing with this salad. If you were to order this salad, I would say go with something like a vinaigrette, again, to help cut through some of the richness of the salad. I can't speak to the dining room, but I can say that you will not be disappointed by the food. read more