Manager/ owner was not the nicest, but after he calmed down, made a good pizza. Probably wouldn't go back. read more

Pizza here is fantastic. Try the Wisconsin Phiily cheasteak pizza. I have to make this review 85 read more

Good sandwiches, VERY nice workers, the place was cool, not too crowded. I liked it a lol!

Best take and bake pizza in Oshkosh! Fresh, great ingredients and the staff is quick to make your order with a smile. Anytime we don't feel like cooking we pick up a pizza from here. Very small interior, but they have coolers of ready to go food options, drinks and shelves of other local goods and snacks. Great prices and great options! read more

Such a cute local place! Beyond having terrific take and bake pizzas they support local products by selling them in the store. It's cool to see a local business supporting other local places. You can do some shopping while you wait for your pizza or sub. The pricing is reasonable - a 16" and 12" pizza for $25. The ingredients are very fresh. The crust was thin and crispy but didn't have a ton of flavor. Toppings were fantastic! The service was very good and friendly. It took around 7 minutes to get my pizzas. I really liked this local chain and wished they had locations in Milwaukee! read more

Very unhappy. We order here frequently. I will say that the pizza is always delicious and we love the Rewards program! Yesterday, 2/22/24 I called to place an order. I asked the woman who answered what the special was. She told me the Veggie pizza 16 inch for $15.99. I said, "We'll take that!" I told her that we would prefer green olives instead of green peppers and on only one side. No Problem. My BF Ted went to pick up and when he got home he told me it was $19.10. I called the store right away and the same woman told me that we didn't get the $15.99 special because we ordered one the the halves with no peppers. To get the special we would have had to order another topping on the half I requested no green olives on. Now, this sounds crazy, right? If I would have ordered a different veggie on my side and picked it off, my price would have been $4 less. This woman turned rude and said that's the way it goes! Now, why didn't she tell me as I already said we wanted the special! I just couldn't believe it!! If the owner wants to contact me and make this right I will consider ordering from there again. It's the principle and I will put this out there for all my friends and family. Make sure you check your order and the price before you leave the store! And the woman with all the tattoos needs to not deal with the customers! She was awful. read more

On behalf of the subs we got they were good everything was done to what we asked. I don't know if it's common, but I feel the sauce should go on after being toasted. To the service the one who was in charge I feel needs some guidance to customer service skills and possibly not walking around a food establishment with their hands in their pocket and rubbing their face most of the time being there. To me this makes me question the sanitation process. read more

Love Eatons pizza! freshly made and they don't skimp on the toppings! They were patient with me when I had to change my order and when finding a card to work after learning they don't take personal checks anymore. thank you! read more

Horrible customer service. This sealed the deal for me. I use Firehouse subs now a block north of this location. read more

we ordered the Mexican pizza and were super disappointed to find it piled with lettuce before cooking. I called to confirm this is how it was supposed to be cooked because every other Mexican or taco pizza I have had at other establishments- it was on the side. I was assured that it was correct. It was the worst pizza we ever ate! the lettuce was slimy once cooked (which i pretty much assumed would happen). it's too bad because if they just left it off and offered it along with the chips on the side it would have been great. if you order this pizza- definitely ask for the chips and lettuce on the side and add them after you cook it along with some taco sauce, lettuce and fresh tomatoes. read more

I give Eatons 2 stars because they do have good food. However, every time I go there they get slower and slower. I just stood there for 30 minutes waiting for 4 subs! But hey at least THIS time they didn't screw up our order. Cant blame it on covid, it was like this before. They used the excuse they were short staffed. Well guess what buttercup? This means you have to move faster! I have worked in the food industry before so your excuses don't mean anything to me. I don't think I have ever seen a staff work so slow before. Needless to say I wont be returning and just ordering from Jimmy Johns because they are FREAKY FAST! read more

Excellent pizza subs and hot food . out of my way but I'll travel the extra 45 minutes to stock up on there products. Especially delicious Pizzas they make. read more

Such a great sandwich shop!! Recommended by locals and would send anyone there over Subway!

Little storefront. To go pizzas and deli sandwiches. Stop in for the sandwiches. Very fresh and quite a selection. Take home a pizza or pasta for later. Reasonable prices and good sandwiches. Will stop in again. read more

Eaton's Pizza & Subs - Eaton's deli classic sub. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Oshkosh, Wisconsin

Exceptionally friendly service, very good and fresh sub sandwich. I would definitely eat here again. Very convenient location for pilots parked in the north 40! read more

Eaton's Pizza & Subs - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Oshkosh, Wisconsin

We placed an order here as we were attending the EAA night airshow and wanted to pick up something quick. I had one of our guys pick up the pizza and we were surprised it wasn't cooked. We are not from around here and had no idea they did that. We were able to bake the pizza in the RV and it was great tasting. Great selection of pizzas. read more

My fiancé and I love a good sub and but this Eaton's trip was a bust. I am still giving it 3 stars because this is the ONLY trip that has been unpleasant. We walked in to fill out our sandwich slip picking out what we wanted, and while doing so I made eye contact with the woman behind the counter a couple times. When my fiancé finished filling out his slip He went to the counter and waited a good 3-4 minutes before the woman asked him what he wanted. I was a little disappointed that she knew we were there but she acted like we weren't when he walked up to the counter. I wasn't expecting her to drop everything she was doing but I did expect a greeting and maybe say we will be right with you.... anyway He handed her the two sandwich orders and then we waited. I should say we were the only people in the store so waiting 10 minutes for the subs was a little long but like I said this trip was the only trip I've had like this so maybe they were having an off day. But what really made upset was the fact that she got both of our orders wrong, like I said earlier Eaton's has pre-made slips that you just circle what you want. So how did they both get made wrong? So with the less than satisfactory service and the incorrect orders I will have to try the other store out and maybe the workers there will be friendly. read more