Our first time here, one of the best pizzas I've had. The flavor of all the ingredients used is top notch, fresh and a ton of flavor. We will be going back, a must stop for pizza connoisseurs. read more

The food is extremely delicious. The server knew what soda I usually drink. The restaurant may be small but it looks nice.

HIGHLY RECOMMEND. This pizza is absolutely amazing! It is similar to Chicago pizzas. I could drink the sauce! I like the Sicilian crust best; both bready/chewy but also with crispness. We drive from Green Bay to get it. The owner is also fantastic. He constantly donates to organizations for the community, sponsors teams, and even has donated free pizzas to low income kids during tge summer. read more

Best darn wings around. I love them so much, my wife even surprised me with them for my birthday dinner. I was VERY happy and hungry read more

The ambiance was nice the woman at the counter was very friendly and accommodating. I had a calzone which was fine but nothing to write about. My friend had the buffet that looked dried out and lukewarm when I arrived at noon. We stayed an hour, there were maybe five other patrons, and no one else ate from the buffet. Zero fresh food was replaced, it just became drier, colder and nastier. read more

See all

The best compliment I can offer is this: the pizza is so good it doesn't lose any quality in reheating as leftovers. It is that good. Thin, pan or deep dish... they have it covered. Excellent staff! read more

Holy Cow! Now this is some good pizza! Buttery crust and my husband loves the sauce. We got the Mama's Kitchen Sink and it was fantastic! They do deliver, but I picked it up this time. This is some really good pizza!! read more

Came in for pizza and a salad. Had the Sicilian pan style pizza. It was wonderful, and the side salads were artfully crafted and carefully presented. Servers were very attentive, great beer list. Had my first ever Italian Pilsner Not Italian style, but beer imported from Italy.. and really tasty. Older woman sitting next to us was waiting for a to-go order.. out comes this huge pizza and a even huger order of wings. She's on beer number two at this point, she sits for a bit has a couple wings and a slice of pizza, finishes her beer then asks for her check. Picks it all up and heads out. Guessing grandma had a house of full company and was having a little "me time" before bringing home dinner, good for grandma! Don't let the location fool you, this is not a typical strip mall pizza place! If they were in a nicer building, they would have to charge you more :). Be generous with the tipping, the prices are low and so is the Wisconsin minimum wage and they deserve it. read more

We came for the lunch buffet. Drinks and salad is included $15. They have 4 pizza options but did mention of there is a particular one let them know and they will make it. They have 2 pastas, breadsticks and cheese bread. Marinara sauce is on the sweeter side but very good. Pizza is thin crust and delicious. Friendly customer service. Great place to try. read more

I always love the food from Pagoni's. It is delicious and the service is great. This time I ordered the deep dish pizza directly from the free "Order Online" link on their upgraded webpage (pagonispizza.com)--it is so convenient! I much prefer the customization available here rather than using the Slice app (which charges me $1 per transaction). The web order interface also lets me schedule my pickup for convenience, along with additions and substitutions desired for my order. The deep dish pizza was sausage, tomato, garlic, mushroom, and spinach goodness. The crust was just like I would get down in Chicago. When I picked up my order, everything was ready. I had a brief chat with the cashier who is so friendly, and even Ernesto Morales the owner took the time to make sure everything was to my liking. If you love wonderful Italian food and great customer service, Pagoni's is the venue for you. read more

I've lived in Kaukauna since 2016, and never had Pagoni's pizza, until tonight. My mistake...for waiting so long. Delicious pizza and incredibly fast delivery. Highly recommend; will absolutely order again...very soon!!! read more

Pagoni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kaukauna, Wisconsin

See all

My wife and I received a free pizza coupon in the mail as a welcoming to the neighborhood. We ordered a family size, half pepperoni, half sausage, with extra sauce. The service was professional and friendly. Our pizza was portioned as stated. The sauce was a sweeter sauce with incredible flavor and seasoning. The crust was thin with a medium crisp and classic flavor. The cheese was plentiful and oozing with goodness. The toppings tasted fresh and the seasoning on the pizza was the perfect touch. The owner of the store stopped over to our table to make sure our experience was satisfactory. He enlightened us on the story of his family owned business and the passed down family recipe still used today. A great local pizza parlor that guarantees quality and the home feel You're looking for. I'll be stopping again. read more

A hidden gem in a smaller community. Delicious pizza. Crust is perfect. Nice choice of toppings.

me and my bf are here from st. louis and this was the best pizza i've ever had. we got the cheese breadsticks and the ulti-meat pizza. the place was a good atmosphere as well, i don't see how this place isn't full all of the time. also the girl who served us was so sweet. read more

Pagoni's Pizza - cheese bread! - Pizza Near Me - Kaukauna, Wisconsin

See all

When I walk through the door of Pagoni's Pizza I am always greeted by a friendly employee. Their customer service exceeds my expectations. The food is excellent... their pizzas are on the top of my list. read more

Always delicious food and service. I love how many different deals they run throughout the week! Ernesto has always been so kind when he's in. The workers really care for the customers!! read more

We love Pagoni's pizza. Favorites include the stromboli, deep dish, and salads. We haven't tried Sicilian yet. Maybe that will be next.

Had a great snack on our way back to DePere tonight at Pagoni's in Kaukauna! It always smells amazing in here! The pizza is always great and will always return! read more

See all

Pagoni's is never disappointing! The food is fabulous and the service is 2nd to none. Can't wait to go back!

Employees are very friendly food comes out as a reasonable speed and everything we've had has always been good. We love the mozzarella sticks my entire family agrees they are the best we have ever had. We usually get the deep dish pizza (ask for it to be cooked longer) the first time we tried it it was a little undercooked but requested to be cooked longer because it was so thick it was a little undercooked they cooked it for about 10 min longer and was perfect. read more

Good Sicilian style pizza and sauce. Thin crust is great. Lots of pizzas moving out the door so a good sign there! read more

See all

Ordered pizza and cheese stuffed bread sticks. Pizza: ordered pepperoni and half sausage. The amount of cheese was serious lacking. The sauce was good. The crust didn't complement the pizza, it was missing something. The overall look was great but looks were deceiving. Bread Sticks: looked really good.. but failed to deliver any flavor. 3 stars out of 5 because.. ingredients were fresh for the most part and the sauce was pretty good. read more

Pagoni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kaukauna, Wisconsin

See all

Great service. Very reasonable prices. Quaint little joint. Not skimpy on portions. Would go again to try a different dish! read more

Pagoni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kaukauna, Wisconsin

(Based only on one delivery I decided I couldn't yet give Pagoni's a 5-star rating.) Many years ago I had the best pizza of my life in Amsterdam. I was afraid I'd never again find a pizza so delicious. You know what's coming next: I think I just stumbled upon a pie that rates right up there with the one of my dreams. Right next to the Piggly Wiggly! Shrimp Scampi Thin Crust I'm in love with you! The slight sweetness of the dough is what reminds me of the pizza I had that day in the country of my ancestors. The crust was brushed with garlic butter which didn't overpower the delicate sweetness of the dough. Yum! This was a delivery order so I need to go to Pagoni's again, of course. But will I dare order anything other than the Shrimp Scampi Thin Crust? Oh my, is it my duty to try the Sicilian & the Deep Dish? And the other flavor combos? Will the interior of the restaurant & the service then rate them a 5 star review? Hmm..... And BTW, I have had pizza in Italy, New York & Chicago. And Kaukauna, Wisconsin! read more

Pagoni's Pizza - Shrimp scampi pizza. Best I've ever had. - Pizza Near Me - Kaukauna, Wisconsin

The order process was quick and easy. The staff was helpful and friendly. While the pizza was hot and good it was not my favorite. The crust seemed too much like bread. The flavor was not great. I would not go back. The pizza was fine but for my personal taste I like other places better. read more

Great pizza! I've been to Pagoni's multiple times for their lunch buffet. The buffet is a great price with a good selection of pizza, noodles, bread sticks and dessert pizza. The buffet also comes with a drink. The staff are also very friendly! read more

One of the best pizza places in the area (tied with Stuc's & Wise guys). We get the Sicilian style crust and it's DELICIOUS. Flavorful & perfect thickness. The sauce is one of the best in the area and toppings are plentiful. I also like that you can order online, but wish it wasn't through Slice which charges service fees. We'll be back again & again. read more

Amazing pizza. Wish I would have remembered to take a picture of our Deep Dish pizza but, honestly, it didn't last long enough. My family ate it way too fast. Chicken tenders were great, too. Delivered to us out in Sherwood, which was a very pleasant surprise. Will definitely order from here again! read more

Great pizza and don't sleep on the pasta dishes. The wait staff was knowledgeable and friendly.

Have had Pagonis in both Neenah and Kaukauna. Not the cheapest pizza, but most certainly worth the extra money over the large pizza chains. The sauce they utilize is fantastic. I prefer to take advantage of their lunch buffet. Salad, bread-sticks, pasta, pizza, and a drink for a fair price. We also frequently receive a buy one get one 1/2 off lunch buffet (found in the color mailer). Cannot comment on delivery. Have yet to utilize it. read more

If you like grease, you'll like Pagoni's. I got a cheese stromboli and my dad got a pizza. Both of them were so greasy that even after wiping my hands, the grease still showed up on the next clean napkin I picked up. It was OK, but I've had much better strombolis. The service is decent and worth a star alone but the food is unremarkable. You get what you pay for, I guess. read more

Great pizza and service but we hit them at an off time in the afternoon would definitely go back read more

Pagoni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kaukauna, Wisconsin

See all

I love Pagoni's! We have their food all the time (Kaukauna location). Everything on the menu is delicious. Everything. It's so nice to have a local restaurant that is not just another chain with the same old food. Additionally, the service is stellar and there is hardly ever a wait time - whether you are dining in, picking up, or getting a delivery. The staff is always friendly. Writing this review... I know what I am getting for dinner tonight! If you are not sure what to have, I would recommend trying your own custom made Stromboli. My fave - ham, pineapple, green pepper, and because it's WI... extra cheese!! :) read more

We had wanted to try Pagoni's for a while but regret our choice. We ordered 2 pizzas and were not impressed. We ordered thin crust but it was more thick. The sauce was more like tomatoes mashed up and not seasoned. The pizza was mushy and watery and very greasy. Oh another thing the service was extremely slow. The people in the kitchen appeared to be either chatting with each other texting on their phones. We tried so now we know and won't go back. read more

Yeah! They are the best. The always get my order right and even have donated free pizzas to my non-profit. My only recommendation is they add a vegan cheese and some more gluten/dairy free options. read more

Got carryout from here for the first time. We got a thin and deep dish pizza. Both were amazing. The sauce is perfect. Got some boob action later from the wife, Thanx guys read more

OMG, awesome deep dish pizza and way better than the Uno's chain. Best I've had in WI, definitely plan to return again.

I have lived in Door County, Green Bay, Manitowoc, Appleton, and Kaukauna, and I can tell you...this is by far the best pizza in Northeast Wisconsin. The only place that comes close is almost 2 hours away (northern Door). Every pizza I've sampled is delicious, the gluten free crust is decent, the cherry bomb is seriously the bomb, and the Italian beef sandwich...damn. Just...yum. Service is meh...great if they're slow, not so great if it's busy, but the delivery guys always call if/when they are running late, which is a nice touch, and the manager (Lorenzo, maybe?) is attentive. I once waited about 20 min for a pick up order that I was told would be ready when I arrived, and he offered me free wine, beer, or soda while I waited. Also a nice touch. The delicious food more than makes up for the ok service. It's worth it. read more

The best pizzeria in the area. By far. After moving from Jersey a few months ago, I sampled pizza from 10 or so pizzerias. Pagoni's is the best quality and most authentic anywhere near Kaukauna. Thank you. read more

The food is excellent. The service....not so much. I wouldn't say horrible service, but good would be a stretch. Maybe 'average'? But the good news is, that the food is good enough to compensate for that. Exellent pizza and calzones!! If someone asked me, "Where will I get the best pizza?" I'd send them here. read more