The meat lovers pizza was amazing!! Garlic knots were so good and the Alfredo was the best I ever had!! Definitely going back!!

Excellent Pizza. The garlic knots are out of this world. You can't go wrong at this fantastic pizzeria.

This isn't just "five stars for a family pizzeria." This is "five stars for any place on earth." Introduced by a local friend, I've been here four times and every single thing I have eaten has been above and beyond delicious. Start w/ the complimentary garlic knots - fresh, warm, not over-spiced or too oily. The pizzas are solid and homemade. But the specialty items are TO DIE FOR. One of the best penne vodka sauces I have ever had; melt-in-your-mouth arrencini; and gnocchi the texture of marshmallows (the ideal texture, often not achieved in places where the dish costs 4x as much). Sal's is a place I would take out-of-towners. The staff is super friendly, the atmosphere clean and respectable, but the food is truly among the best I have ever had. Come for the pizza - but order other stuff and be prepared to have your taste buds bedazzled. read more

My husband and I have been going to sal's for over 3 years now, and I'm so glad that i found this place! The pizza is always good. We've had the take-out and it's just as good. The food is amazing! You have to try it! My husband is a plain cheese kinda guy, and I usually miss the toppings on pizza, but not here. The cheese, crust and sauce are all so flavorful! I usually order the small house salad with ranch, and i love love love how many veggies they have on it! The place is family owned and operated, which makes it nice! They service is always quick. Even on a crowded day you can still get a table in less than 30 minutes! They recently remodeled, which makes the place look really neat, and clean! By far, this is our favorite pizza place! read more

This is my favorite place to go for authentic NY pizza. It's so good I drive from north west Mesa all the time. Any negative reviews about the pizza and crust can only be from those who have either gotten use to bad pizza or have never had pizza from NY. read more

Friend introduces me to Sal's and what a treat. Loved the garlic knots, pasta and service was awesome. Went back the next week, since it was so good. read more

This place was great. Few places leave wanting to try lots of items in their menu, but this one was just awesome. I can't wait to go back. The service was great. We waited for a little for a table, but nothing out of the ordinary. I definitely will be giving them my business over and over. read more

I think this place is a great Gilbert Restaurant it is so good and tastes like everything is homemade, we came in right before closing, and instead of being told we couldn't have this or that, the server encouraged us to get what we wanted even with 10min until closing.We have been back several times since. read more

It's been at least a couple of years since we've last have eaten food from Sal's. This changes NOW!! I ordered through Door Dash the other day- I was SO pleasantly surprised with the portions. I also forgot their entrees come with salads AND garlic knots!!! I also really LOVED how the people at Sal's packaged my food- it was placed in a cardboard box. My two entrees clearly visible, salads, garlic knots, and dressing. As the delivery guy was approaching my door I could clearly see all the items I ordered. My linguini marinara and meatballs and linguini Alfredo with broccoli were delicious. Enough to feed my three year son and I one night, and lunch for my husband and I the next. We are DEFINITELY adding Sal's back to our takeout options. read more

This place is bomb.com. My son and I loved it!! His fave ways the garlic knots, which by the way have tons of garlic, yum!! I got a slice, I don't remember which one. It was square and it was topped with basil and provolone. When I go back, I want to try the ziti slice! read more

Not awful, but not outstanding either. My favorite part of the meal was the very large Caesar salad..it was very fresh and reasonably priced. Our "Desert Heat" thin crust pizza was merely okay. I probably won't have their pizza again. I am from the east coast so the style of pizza was great, I just didn't think it tasted good. Oh, and I don't know why everyone goes cray cray over the garlic knots. Gross...you'll be sweating garlic for WEEKS! read more

We just moved to the area a few days ago, from New York! I had remembered trying Sal's when I was out there and loving it! Everything was great and the garlic knots were AWESOME!! read more

Yes it is busy...but that's because it's the best pizza and service you're going to get in the East Valley. Grace and Sal are the best! If it's too busy, go to the bar and grab a drink while you wait. The pizza is outstanding, the garlic knots could be $20/dozen and they would be worth it (they're free when you eat in!). The pasta is great. You can tell the owners care because you'll see them there EVERY DAY. read more

First off the pizza and the food quality is second to none. Second the staff is amazing and very friendly. when you put those together i would give this Gilbert staple a 7 star rating if i could. Having good food as a restaurant/bar is one this following it up with a great owner and staff is what keeps this place packed day in and out. read more

Had the lasagna and the wife had the ravioli. Both were great! The meal came with both salad and knots. The location is in a cute area. Staff is friendly. We'll be back! read more

Great sauce, garlic knots and cheesecake. An all around great local Italian restaurant. Family owned and it shows. Try a glass of the house wine, relax and enjoy the excellent service. read more

I've ordered pizza from this place plenty of times. The first 3-5 times were excellent. Crispy crust with perfectly cooked cheese and toppings. The last 3 times though, not so much. If we got what we actually ordered, the crust was not crispy and the cheese and toppings was barely hot. It's like they cooked the crust first then waited until they got an order and then applied the toppings and heated it enough to melt the cheese. The result was bottom of the barrel.....,,even for pizza. There's plenty of pizza places in the area, do yourself a favor and try them first. read more

Love this place!! 1. Food is always amazing. 2. They are all so sweet. I could go on and on. Hands down the best Italian place. It is busy but well worth the wait! Tonight we had the lasagna pizza it was delish. Great jobs sals pizza. read more

Again we wanted to try a new pizza place after spending an hour on yelp searching for one around us we landed on this one. We got seated fast and our waitress brought us twisted garlic nots which was so good. We went through two plates of them. We order our pizza and it looked good but it was flimsy and the crust was flavorless. read more

THIS PIZZA PLACE IS AMAZING! They were very polite and kind. This would be a great place to have a b day party at.

Good pizza...although nothing to knock your socks off. The staff here is very friendly as well, and the Italian beer on tap is very good! Expect this place to be packed with families and kids. read more

Deliciousness! I really felt like I was back home at this place. Amazing pizza huge portions, and amazing garlic knots. Wow!! I am glad I moved up the Street from this place as I imagine I'll be a frequent visitor here. read more

So far, not impressed. When I came in, the guy at the counter didn't seem to understand English. I said this is my first time here. How does this work? Due to there being pizzas in this glass cabinet. He just looks at me so I see a menu and say I'll just look at the menu. Then a lady comes up and says, this is your first time here? I say, yes. As that happening, this lady asks for garlic knots. The woman heats them up in a microwave in a styrofoam container. They do have Pepsi, which is nice! I had the calzone. It was really pretty good. The tea is a little weak, but drinkable. read more

This place will win you over on smell alone. The white pizza was amazing and they have some great specials. My Gal Pals like the pasta special on Tuesdays, they end up with dinner from the left overs. I honestly cant wait to try everything on the menu! The staff has been really great each time too. One last thing...GARLIC KNOTS. =) read more

We found Sal's just last year... but we keep coming back. The garlic knots are a great way to start. The salads are tasty with their Italian dressing. We rarely stray from the supreme pizza but can also recommend the desert heat. The service is friendly and outstanding. Domenic makes the round when customers to ensure that all is well. Looking forward to our next trip. read more

Really good Pizza, but Expensive. Got the Traditionalist (Extra Pepperoni, Extra Cheese $19.00) It looked like a regular pie you'd get back East. It didn't even have a normal amount of Pepperoni let alone Extra. The waiter was Great, but when we got there nobody greeted you and no tables were available. Girl at the counter took our name after she got off the phone.... I'd get the pizza again if I was in the area....... read more

Awesome owner, great food, excellent variety, good for kids... best neighborhood pizza in Gilbert! The price point ain't bad either.

Been going here since just before Sal took it over. I'm born and raised in New York. I'm so serious about NY Italian food it's borders on being OCD. This place is amazing. It's a mile from my house. It's a dream come true for a Gilbert resident raised on family owned Italian pizzeria fare. read more

I had not been to Sal's in a few month; went back last night with a few friends and WOW was it good! We started with a caprese salad which was quite nice with fresh mozzarella. Next we had fried calamari which nice an d crunchy on the outside an d not over cooked on the inside. Out came two pizzas...one sausage and one meatball and boy were they yummy. I'm originally from the Bronx and these two pizzas were awfully close to the real thing. My only issue I think, is they put too much cheese on it. But really it's hard to complain about too much of anything! Lastly, we ended with cannollis, the shells were perfectly crunching an d the filling just sweet enough. I must mention too that the wait staff was great....we came in very late and they did not at all try to rush us out and I'm sure they had a long day there. read more

Our first time dining at Sals and we were quite impressed. We ordered a kids cheese pizza, chicken Marcella and mussels appetizer. The salad that came with the dinner was fresh and crisp and served right away. However, we waited far too long for our mussels to arrive. Also, the kids pizza took a long time along with the chicken Marcella. The food is good but the service was slow. P.S. I saw my neighbors pizza arrive a lot faster then our appetizer did... read more

I live in Gilbert and wanted to give this place a try since my brother had brought me a slice and I loved it so I called in an order ( A cheese slice and an order of garlic knots) and went to pick it up shortly after. I got there went to the counter and politely asked about my order and the lady was VERY rude, I wish I would have looked at her name tag. She snatched the money out of my hand and walked away, sometime after another younger girl asked me if I had been help and all I could reply was " I don't know" .I explained how the other lady took my money and walked away. She asked for my name and gave me my food, I left happy to be getting out of there. The pizza was good but the garlic knots not so much, even though the slices were good I don't see myself going back for the simple fact that if i'm spending money in an establishment I would like to be treated with respect. read more

phenomenal pizza!!! I loved the food the wings were some of the best I've ever had! And Kelli our server was so friendly and sweet! This place is a great hole in the wall treasure! Definitely a keeper on the speed dial too! read more

Update: This place has really gone downhill! They screwed up my order, which is understandable (it happens). The main problem was I had two pizzas, both were under-cooked. The dough was like playdough right underneath the cheese. The garlic knots had almost no taste to them. Unfortunate that things have gotten this bad, I felt like Chef Gordon Ramsay because everything I tasted was bland or cooked wrong...I hate to give out low ratings, but this place deserved it. read more

Second visit this afternoon. Just as good as the first! Love the baked ziti pizza! If you haven't been here, you definitely need to add it to your list to visit. read more

Absolutely amazing food, the service was even better and the complimentary garlic knots just tops off the entire experience. This was our first time going and we will definitely be back when we want anything Italian! Good job Sal's. read more

I was introduced to Gilbert Pizza 3 years ago by another New Yorker. When I had my first slice of their cheese pizza I felt like I was back in New York. Sal and Grace (the owners) made our family feel at home. We visit regularly and have never been disappointed with anything we have ordered off their menu. read more

Very good pizza. Thin crust was tender but had a nice crispiness to it. We got a Desert Heat (sausage, jalapeños, green chiles & double cheese). They can make it anywhere from mild to very spicy by dialing up the jalapeños. Medium was a flavorful heat without being too spicy, at least for our taste. Chicken parmigiana was also very tasty. And, yeah, garlic knots are free but would be worth paying for even if they weren't. read more

In town visiting family and this is their new favorite pizza place. We got a large round pizza and a large rectangle pan pizza with a side of garlic knots. Got it home, opened up the boxes and... Nothing special. read more

Great Pizza " a great NY Pizza . Try the all white pizza for me it's the best :) going there for years still great service and food *****

It took me almost three years to find Sal's, and good NY Pizza, in the east valley. I am not sure why it took me so long to try Sal's, as it is a staple and was on DDD. Cool, casual spot to eat and very family friendly. Also had takeout that was just as good. The baked ziti pizza is incredible. Pasta, pizza, the best of both worlds. I would say specialty pies are the way to go, although the basics are solid too. I still need to try the chicken marsala pizza, another one of their best supposedly. Good reason to go back this weekend! Wings are decent and garlic knots are a huge bonus. Thanks for coming through with great NY Pizza Cuffaros! read more