Rusty P's is really good! Seafood baskets, salads and crab cakes. Cold beer and nice servers! Thumbs up!

Always tasty! My favorite is the crab cakes as an entree with potato salad. The debris burger is amazing with roast beef gravy topping it. Yum! Good family environment! Service to good too. read more

I've got to say this is one of the best hamburgers I've ever had! If you're anywhere near this place come and get it! The review speak for themselves! I have it hijack burger and it was amazing! read more

Rusty Pelican - Sandwiches Near Me - Mandeville, Louisiana

I am so excited that we found this gem. The Handy Mandy is one of the best things I've eaten in a long while, and even though I like to mix things up when I return to a restaurant, I won't be able to pass up an opportunity to enjoy another Handy Mandy. I was also shocked at how quickly this high quality food was served. A+ for service. And we sat at a sidewalk table that allowed us to enjoy the charm of the area. Excellent experience. read more

Every tv big was delicious! And the service was great! The Gumbo and the hijacked burger were both a 10/10 ! I also loved all the signs and decor in the restaurant! read more

Wonderful food and great service. Atmosphere is casual and comfortable. We can't wait to eat there again read more

Wanted to grab a quick bite before our flight so our family suggested this place for burgers. It absolutely did not disappoint! I got the Pontchartrain pickle burger and it was cooked to perfection. Service was great and the atmosphere was very comfortable. read more

The Brickhouse Chicken sandwich and Blackened Shrimp tacos were outstanding. Onion rings were some of the best I've ever had. Ice cold draft beer, gotta hand 'em 5 stars. Doing it right. read more

Great place with great food! We will be back soon got firecracker shrimp sandwich and catfish basket and both are amazing read more

Rusty Pelican - Firecracker shrimp sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Mandeville, Louisiana

This a great spot for some Louisiana grub. Twice I've had the Holland Sandwich which is perfection. Great staff. Everyone is hustling and working here. No slackers. I'm impressed. Full bar too. read more

Rusty Pelican - Shrimp w/Swiss & bacon - Sandwiches Near Me - Mandeville, Louisiana

See all

Great restaurant with an awesome atmosphere. We had the shrimp po-boy and the Mahi sandwich, both were wonderful. The staff was super friendly. read more

Excellent restaurant. The food is always predictable. Never had a problem there. The food is quick, prices are appropriate and the staff is always proficient and courteous. What more could you ask for? Good food at a nice place with nice people at good prices. The inside of the location is really nice as well. The amenities are traditional/homestyle. Give it a try I'm sure you will like it. read more

I really like the Rusty Pelican. This casual restaurant is located in Old Mandeville, but is a new building. This is a plus compared to some of the other restaurants in old buildings which aren't as comfortable. Rusty Pelican has a fairly broad menu, but the burgers and sandwiches are the stars. My favorite burger is the hotsy totsy burger with fried jalapenos and pepperjack. The burgers are cooked to order and are always juicy and flavorful. On my most recent trip I had the jive bird (buffalo chicken). It was a whole fried chicken breast topped with their buffalo sauce on a bun. It was perfectly cooked and mildly spicy. The chicken breast was so large it had to be folded over to fit the bun. This was a very good sandwich. Service is always very good. You order at the counter, get a number and your food is brought out to you. The other thing I really like is their beer selection. They have standard brews like pabst and high life, but they also have Shiner and some more fancy brews. If you're in Mandeville and want a casual, good meal, give Rusty Pelican a try. read more

See all

Decided to try this local spot, and was not disappointed! I had the Pelican burger with fries, and it was perfectly cooked and delicious. My daughter had the roast beef po boy, and we shared the fried jalapenos, which were very spicy and delicious. Sat at the bar and chatted with Tony, the owner. Everyone was very friendly and our food was delivered quickly. We will be back! read more

Rusty Pelican - Pelican burger with cheddar - Sandwiches Near Me - Mandeville, Louisiana

This may be my worst post-covid19 take out experience I have had. Let's start with the food, I was told 45min, showed up in 40 to ICE COLD FOOD that had obviously been ready for quite some time. The crispy bacon was undercooked and flabby. The fries inedibly cold to the point of being hard and inedible, and yes know fries are never as good to go. This however was extreme. Now to the service, NO easy pick up or curbside. One was expected to enter the PACKED (I mean wall to wall people, even at the patio tables) past a line of people placing orders, 8 out of 12 with no masks, to a packed corner to pick up the order right next to people wearing no masks. If you care about good food or your health avoid this place at ALL costs. Ok, other than the bacon the burger was good, increasing to two stars. read more

Excellent seafood restaurant---sandwiches and plates come out hot with an abundance of food and service is more than adequate.

Food was really great! Small but good beer selection. Employees were were awesome! Grilled Shrimp & Avocado Salad read more

The best burgers in Mandeville hands down! Everything else on the menu is great as well; crab cakes, fish tacos, salads, etc. All so delicious and most importantly, the food is always consistent. I like my burgers cooked medium rare, my husband likes his medium well, and they nail the temperatures perfectly every single time. The staff is always friendly and the atmosphere is always nice and laid back. Just an all around great place! read more

Rusty Pelican - Hijacked Burger - Crisp bacon paired with Cheddar, Pepper Jack & Fried Pepper Jack and all tied together with Chipolte mayo. - Sandwiches Near Me - Mandeville, Louisiana

See all

Met a group of eight friends for 5:00pm on a Saturday. Everyone was served their individual meal by 5:15pm. Outstanding quality food. We shall return! read more

Im from Cali, no veggie burger option. Ordered a grilled cheese. Sad it was in an inside out bun. No slices of wheat bread for my compromise grilled cheese. Inside was comfy, fries and service were good. How about a veg option, chef salad with a hard boiled egg/avocado, no meat? read more

We had lunch there for the first time. I ordered the mahi mahi sandwich. It was by far the best fish sandwich I have had in years. Love the outdoor seating and atmosphere. A great place to go after biking on the trace or lakefront! read more

The food is really good. Love the outdoor dining option. Quick service. Good for families.

Good service and good food here. They do a great job of getting the food out and it's delicious. Burgers, fried seafood, and salads are top notch. read more

Update: I brought two friends this time. We ordered oyster po-boys and a soft shell crab po-boy. Everything was excellent, and everything was devoured. I appreciated being able to upgrade my side of french fries to cheese fries and they were top-notch. Personally, I would rank the oyster po-boy in 3rd place in the Metro New Orleans area and number 1 on the Northshore. Speedy service and everything was hot!!! read more

Rusty Pelican - Soft shell crab po-boy. Excellent. - Sandwiches Near Me - Mandeville, Louisiana

See all

Only been here a handful of times and we love the food. However, the order takers are always rude or have a bad attitude. Also, it always takes forever to get our food. There are people who ordered after us getting their food. Idk if we are bad luck or what but why is it taking 45+ min for a simple order? Doesn't make sense. Took our food home to go once we got it because our friends were already done with their food....come to find out our food was also given away to the wrong person...ridiculous read more

Great blackened fish sandwich and great seafood platters! Love their club sandwich h too! Great outdoor seating and on the go service

Food and service is fabulous. Air conditioning and fans are evidently set for the comfort of the kitchen staff. So cold and windy that you have to eat fast before everything gets as cold as ice. Love the place but I cannot go back because of the discomfort. 5 stars for food and 1 star for comfort. Not just the fans. Huge ac vent down middle of ceiling with ports to push ac to the walls. Seems to never turn off. People with jackets and sweaters everywhere. Fans being on is ludicrous. read more

Good food. Love the crab cakes it's all crab meat not just stuffing. Good service ! You

Mediocre food that takes an hour and a half to make. And kitchen was fully staffed so it wasn't an issue of a labor shortage.

Ambiance was great. Loved the outdoor seating. Service was good. Very friendly. My entree was ok. Serving size was great. I would go back maybe try something else though than what I ordered. My kid loved her meal. read more

The food is delicious! I recommend their Caesar Salad to go with anything! I also love the stacked BLT. My friend thoroughly enjoyed her seafood. We topped it off with their spectacular Bloody Mary's! Fabulous! read more

Food was delicious! Service was great! Nice atmosphere. Highly recommend! Will visit again.

Stopped in for lunch to try the place out. Since we were in the area doing some shopping. The name is catchy enough to draw you in. Interior is a mix between hole in the wall and trying to be trendy? Glad we came early, its obvious this place is a popular lunch spot. The line went out the door before I food came. This is basically a self serve Cafe. You order at the counter, get your own drink and they bring the food to your table. Its basically a basket and burger joint. She got the pickle burger, its actually fried pickles (alot of them) on a hamburger. I got the chicken parm sandwich. I did try her burger. I say both sandwiches lacked any flavor. My parm sandwich, I think was trying to be poboy. The tomato sauce tasted straight out of a can. The chicken may have been better, by itself. Fries were your basic bagged frozen fries. While, the food is what I expected, it doesn't really reflect the cost. The quality could of been better. read more

See all

Good food, questionable service. I've had bad service experiences there but I love be the salad so I pick it up. I doubt I'll ever sit down and eat there again and if I could find a better buffalo chicken salad they would not get another cent of my money. read more

Awesome sandwiches at a great price. Have been there multiple times and I'm never let down. A great place for the family, kids too.

Great service and good burgers. If your looking for anything other than hamburgers, your choices are limited.

cold beer, frosty hurricanes, fried seafood, this place has it all. Stopped by for lunch and had no problem getting a table inside with aircon. Outside tables looked fun too. This place is popular and in cute lakeshore Mandeville. Great for some quick grub. read more

We stopped by for lunch after surfing through reviews. I had the shrimp avocado salad. My husband ordered crab cake salad. We shared buffalo shrimp. My salad was good. The shrimp were grilled to perfection. The buffalo shrimp were amazing. My husband enjoyed the crab cake salad. I tasted the crab cake and it was very good. The restaurant is small and located in a good location. After looking over the menu, i noticed several other great options if one would like to pig out. read more

Rusty Pelican - Shrimp and avocado salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Mandeville, Louisiana

See all

Great burgers and fries sit at the bar or a family dinner in dining room or outdoors on those nice days. Always great food.

We were visiting the area for a week. We were looking for sea food. I had gumbo and 1/2 of a fried oyster Poboy My partner had a shrimp salad at the Covington location. Both were excellent. While eating, we observed soft shell crab being served at the next table. Two days later we visited the Mandeville location. The crab was superior. Informal service format and friendly staff rounded out a great experience. read more