Rowdy Hall is the best! Their burgers are really good and you should definitely try them, but we really love them for their wings. So many buffalo wings can be subpar, but not here. They are crispy and delicious and you can order extra sauce with them if you like. They moved from their spot in East Hampton to Amagansett, which is actually closer for us and ideal. We won't be going anywhere else for wings. Also, try the artichoke! read more

My group hung out here for the first Friday afternoon of March Madness and had a great time. They had all the games on when we got there. The staff was very friendly and didn't mind us yapping about our brackets. The happy hour had some great deals and our bartender took the time to help me find the right beer. The food was good too, as the fries had the perfect amount of salty goodness. I would definitely return next time I'm in the area! read more

See all

The food was terrible. We ordered steak and Fritz. The menu stated strip steak, it wasn't a strip steak. We ordered the steak cooked medium and it came out raw and tough to chew. Acoustics very poor making it a loud place for dinner. We will never go back. read more

Service is friendly but slow and that is with a lot of wait and barstaff working the joint. We came before it was too packed and still had about a 35 min wait for a burger to come out. Asked for medium rare it came out medium well. Burger was so so nothing to write home about either.inside is your typical pub sports bar feel. Tvs up front showing the games. Overall when in area a decent place to have a pint and watch the game read more

See all

Great pub to catch a break from all the big scene restaurants. Our server welcomed us with a cheerful smile and friendly attitude. The menu has typical pub food perhaps elevated a bit for a nice take on things. The food we had was quite delicious! Definitely recommend if you find yourself walking through town. read more

See all

This place was perfect it's exactly the kind of pub you hope to stumble into on a night out--cozy, welcoming, and just the right amount of background music. The food was delicious. Ed's meatloaf was the clear winner for me! In fact, I stole my friend's meal right off her plate. The staff was amazing, really made the experience chill and fun. Highly recommend if you're just looking for a great meal with the unnecessary pomp and circumstance. Just good food. read more

Female bartender during Happy Hour, not Happy at all, Vodka on rocks filled about 1/4 of a glass?!! (This was September '25) can't go back... read more

I used to go here a lot when in east Hampton and have gone a few times to the new spot, last time had the French onion soup which was good but the fish and chips were a little disappointing, I know the dish well from here but the fish was a little chewy, it's fairly small pieces which I assume are frozen and maybe a little old, you get a lot of chips but the fish is really lacking read more

I saw some negative reviews so I was a little hesitant to go but as we were going to Stephen Talkhouse a few doors down to see GE Smith perform I figured we would give it a try. We had the special shrimp scampi it was a 10/10 . Generous portion of shrimp, jasmine rice and spinach .. I had a $6 Corona light my wife had wine also very fairly priced for the Hamptons. Our waitress Katryna could not have been better. All in all I would 5 stars. Got to say hello to GE Smith as he was walking by Rowdy Hall as I was leaving. Will definitely come back read more

Well... old location was one of our faves for past million years. This Rowdy Hall leaves much to be desired! Jeffrey our waiter deserves a 5! But... they're adding tax onto your bill when you tip so a 20% tip of our $85.00 dinner was $18.47 not $17.00. It's very noisy, mussels are fair whereas before they were amazing, and a house vodka martini was $15.00. After 3 visits this summer we will find another "fave". Randi read more

As someone who has worked in the service industry for 8+ years, I always try to be patient and understanding when dining out. But this experience was disappointing across the board. From the start, our server was dismissive and had an attitude that set the tone for the rest of the meal. The sequence of service was completely off--we ordered fries early on, and nearly 10 minutes later, while placing our entrées, she asked if we still wanted them. At that point, we honestly weren't even sure she fired them in the first place. We then waited over an hour for our entrées (salmon and steak), watching the same dishes go out to tables seated long after us. If it had been a timing-sensitive course, I might have been more understanding--but this was clearly a service issue. I wasn't sure she even the second course after the entrees were fired. And during that entire time, she rarely checked in, refilled drinks, or gave any sort of update. No communication, no accountability. My entrée finally arrived cold, which only made the situation worse. A blonde woman who I assumed was the manager came by to drop the entrees comped our appetizers and my meal, which we appreciated, but by that point the experience had already soured. We left feeling incredibly underwhelmed-- we were completely overlooked. Unfortunately, I won't be returning. When basic service standards and hospitality are missing, no amount of comped food makes up for the experience. read more

Wow, huge disappointment! I have been a loyal fan for many years and finally made it to the new location in Amagansett. I ordered a burger medium but it was served rare with lukewarm fries. Terrible, the old Rowdy was super reliable. Our bartender was ... let's just say not welcoming. Anyone who knows the vibe at the bar previously can understand what a huge disappointment this experience was. I sent the burger back with an apology because I hate to be one of those.... Anyway, my burger came back medium but the fries were obviously thrown back in and refried then over dosed with salt. They were literally inedible. Our bartender returned and ask how the food was with an I don't give a sh..attitude. I again apologized and said I'm sorry but the fries are inedible. She made a face and I said I'll keep em. Thanks. Bill comes ... with zero reduction for anything... not even to $5 club soda. Really? Wtf. All good. I will never come back. Big loss. The restaurant seems busy enough that they won't miss my business I'm sure but there are much better choices out East. read more

Luke Murphy was amazing! He was slammed with a ton of tables but went above and beyond for us all night. Will definitely be back.

The food was outstanding. Great burger and the park truffle fries were some of the best I've ever had. Our server was very nice as well. Great experience and highly recommend this place! read more

Pros : Service here is on point. The atmosphere is clean and nice. Cons : The food is nothing special - for starters they changed their burger style, before they relocated from EH they had a legit sesame seed bun, now the bun is a basic generic one you find at a cheap rushed backyard BBQ. I ordered my burger medium, it was totally well done, I couldn't even finish it. Burnt vibes. The fries were overly salty and borderline not edible. I got a chili & cornbread special,l - the chili was fine, but it there was 3x more cornbread than chili, so it was a bad proportion. End of the day forty-five bucks before tip for a burger with fries and a chili with cornbread appetizer is pretty excessive for how unimpressive it all was. One and done for me personally. read more

We were on our way back from Montauk and someone in town said stop at Rowdy Hall in Amagansett. we did and what a Great late lunch. for when you walked in the hostess is great - when she sat the 4 of us she explained the menu - from the beer selection to cocktails . our server Jeffery is great - burgers were cooked to perfection . Overall i will be back to have more fun and Great food. read more

Burger undercooked. Ordered medium, received rare. Ordered pretzel. No dipping cheese. That is criminal. Never seen that at any establishment in my life where a pretzel was on the menu. They also forgot our wife's so had to wait longer for that. Fries were good. Overall I would not return. read more

Staff is welcoming and attentive. Food, dessert and coffee is excellent. One of our favorite places.

Lunch 2/3/24. Ordered three onion soups, two burgers and wings. Asked that all be delivered at same time. Soups arrive-very good, though $18. Wings came 15 minutes later. Burgers come another 15 minutes later-lukewarm, not hot. Were they sitting waiting to be delivered to the table? Seems that way. Fries were overcooked. Waitress was very pleasant but the timing and delivery of the food was poor. Very surprised and disappointed. Renovations were well done. Rowdy Hall needs to up its game on the actual food preparation and delivery. read more

Very solid pub in the East End. We stumbled upon it and found excellent service and an extensive drink menu. They have a nice mix of cocktails, local brews, and some wines. Elevated ambiance. We didn't have food, but the food menu seems like standard pub fare. Would recommend. read more

WTF Rowdy Hall!!! Small portions and high price. Not good. $30 fish and chips and I get 4 small fish nuggets. Even the soda is mini sized. You need to do better. read more

Rowdy Hall - 2 nuggs of fish. - Pubs Near Me - Amagansett, New York

Pretty good service. Waaaaay too noisy. (Please address acoustics) Food ok, but need vegan options. The vegetable burger was a frozen Praeger's. At least offer a homemade veggie burger. French fries heavily salted in kitchen. (Please don't.) I like to be able to have a conversation with my dinner mates, decide whether to salt my own food, and have more non-animal options. read more

Great place in East Hampton tucked away from the Main Street for casual pub fare. The portions are generous without being too much food. French onion soup was deliciously cheesy and the s'mores sundae is not to be missed. It might be one of the best things I've eaten anywhere in town! The homemade seasonal ice cream (peanut butter) was also delicious. On a weekday night after Labor Day it wasn't too crowded and we easily got a table for four. Only downside is that the chairs stick to the floor and it's difficult to move your chair in and out. But that wouldn't stop me at all from going back to or recommending this great place! read more

Rowdy Hall - French onion soup - Pubs Near Me - Amagansett, New York

See all

The food was excellent! Loved the escargot and the fluke. My bf got the burger he enjoyed it a lot and his grandma got the French onion soup which she loved! I love how it's sets back on the Main Street with indoor and outdoor dining. Would def go back! read more

See all

They have best cheeseburger I've had here. The bar is usually full and a lot of locals. I like the pub feel of this place. It's good for lunch and dinner. Service is always good. read more

Been here a few times Food was ok Had the moules And Andouille on garlic toast. Not bad! My friend decided to have the lobster roll! $42 for maybe 1/4 of lb of Lobster roll! On a Hot dog roll probably purchased at a now defunct FAIRWAY Lobster was at best caught within the last year! Over priced Under staffed Lame lobster roll Service slow- When does host or hostess not ask how was everything! Lame but open! read more

Rowdy Hall - Rowdy - Pubs Near Me - Amagansett, New York

We stayed in the Hamptons one weekend and we stopped here for dinner. I was blown away by their espresso martini, it was one if the best I have ever had! For dinner we shared a bunch of apps including the escargot, giant pretzel, and artichoke which were all amazing. My favorite however was the french onion soup, the veal broth was out of this world. It is a must order! read more

I've been coming to Rowdy Hall since I was at least 13 years old and am now about to turn 19 and overtime i've seen the place I once loved and would frequent turn into a place i'm not dying to go to anymore. After covid many of my favorite items were removed from the menu like the disco fries and buffalo chicken dip. I understand that menu changes had to be made but I feel as though there isn't much variety anymore. Tonight I went out with my dad and didn't have to wait more than 5 minutes, which was quite pleasant. After we were sat the waiter came over and we ordered our drinks, appetizers, and entres since we already knew what we wanted. We started off with the clams casino, which to me are always a hit. They were flavorful and delicious and overall incredibly enjoyable. I then had the meatloaf which was absolutely devine, it is possibly my favorite dish on the whole menu. The sauce and vegetables were great, and the meatloaf was cooked to perfection. My dad however had ordered the steak frites medium, but when it came out it looked a bit burnt and my dad said it was quite over cooked. The fries were tasty, but other then that the steak was just alright, and for $38 I would expect a bit more than just alright. Moving onto desert, we were really excited to try the bread pudding since it used to be our favorite desert pre-covid. However we were incredibly disappointed with tonight's desert. The bread pudding was drowned out by the sauce which was quite unpleasant. This resulted in us leaving the bread pudding more than half intact. I had also ordered a hot chocolate to warm up on this cold night, but felt as though I was drinking warm water with chocolate. Super disappointed by the desert portion of the meal. I wish I could have left with a better experience, but in all honesty I was a bit let down. I hope they are able to improve their menu and bring back some old classics. Since that was the Rowdy Hall that I loved and spent multiple birthdays at, this new one however is one that I would not want to celebrate at. read more

Solid comfort food, good drinks and lovely atmosphere! I won't take a position on the black exterior controversy!

Five of us stopped for lunch on 12/22. It was very quiet, yet we were seated at a table meant for 4 that was very uncomfortable and too small for our party. The waitress seemed annoyed that we weren't ordering drinks. The food was very average. My son had the mussels that were very gritty. My omelette came 10 minutes after everyone else's entree was served .Poor coordination in the kitchen for sure. Overall a lackluster yet extremely overpriced lunch. Not going back to Rowdy Hall again. read more

Service was excellent! Food came out quickly and was nice and hot with good presentation! The mussels were delicious!

We went to the new Rowdy Hall recently relocated from E Hampton to Amagansett tonight for an early Sunday dinner. The place was pleasantly packed and vibrant. Seventies Classics and Eighties New Wave music played in the background. We were told by the friendly hostesses that we'd perhaps have a 45 minute wait and grabbed drinks at the bar. To our happy surprise just 15 minutes later we were seated. Service was spot on (thanks to our friendly and efficient server, Suri). The elevated pub fare was perfectly cooked, brought swiftly to the table. After a shared shrimp cocktail that would rival that of any seafood restaurant or high end steakhouse, we enjoyed a cheese burger and fish and chips both cooked perfectly and brought to the table piping hot. In essence, it was a perfect, casual Sunday night dinner. We will be back regularly for sure. read more

We stopped by on a Saturday in October for a couple beers before dinner. We had a great time sitting outside by the heaters. The atmosphere inside looked great as well. The beers are large which is always a bonus :) read more

Rowdy Hall - Pubs Near Me - Amagansett, New York

The fish and chips were way overcooked. You can tell just by looking how dark the batter became. Fish was dry. Didn't eat it all, left it. The burger is the way to go here, what Rowdy Hall does best. I sent the artichoke back because it was tough as leather, and they were nice about it. Let me substitute chicken wings, but before I ordered, I asked if it was a mixture of the drumsticks and the flat part because I didn't want it if it was all drumsticks. My appetizer only came with one flat part. read more

See all

Had a nice dinner here with my husband. Hard to see from the street, but still a good location on Main St. We didn't love the drinks, but the food was very yummy. I had the clams casino & moules frites and my husband had the Buffalo wings & a burger. Their fries are delicious and the service, although a little slow, was very polite. read more

See all

The best burger ever!! Every thing is great love the onion soup and fish and chips Don't walk run to this great neighborhood place with Great prices and quality read more

I came to amagansett to try the new rowdy hall location. it was always a casual favorite. I think we should all give them time to settle in to their new space. this evening, Rowdy Hall has the distinction of providing the worst service I have ever experienced in all my years of eating out. I sat there for a half hour waiting for my dinner while my companion was served. the waitress disappeared and was unable to produce my meal from the kitchen. it was only after we asked for the manager to come to our table that I eventually got my dinner. Best of luck Rowdy Hall but for now, what a mess. Linda Li read more

This is for the new Rowdy Hall in Amagansett. We went there Sunday night around 4:30 or so and it was packed just like the night before, but we did find a seat at the bar. Wasn't a good experience at the bar, felt ignored and waited 20 minutes for the guy to take our order, but again it was very busy. Went to a table for dinner, nice seating. We had the special prime rib and it was excellent! The staff are friendly and hard working. The room is a good size but very noisy due to the amount of people there I guess, it was fun! So glad they opened there, definately going back. read more

I had salmon Niçoise salad and it's delicious. I asked my salmon medium and it's perfectly cooked. Nice size of salmon. It has green beans, fingerling potato, a lot of olives. Highly recommend read more

Rowdy Hall - Salmon Nicoise* - Pubs Near Me - Amagansett, New York

See all

After all these years, it's nice for something local to still be there when you get a craving. Great place for a drink with friends or to grab a quick bite. The burgers and fries will never disappoint! The bonus is they are open all year round. read more