I dined last night at Rosey's with 3 other people. Everything we ordered was great but I have to recommend HIGHLY the eggplant Parmesan and their meatballs! Both are FANTASTIC. I don't always like eggplant parm - but theirs is thin and crispy and very flavorful. Even my husband LOVED it - and he used to say he doesn't eat eggplant. Whenever I am at a place that has meatballs I always order one for the table to share - and am admittedly hard to impress. Rosey's meatballs are INCREDIBLE. When I was leaving I was telling someone (maybe the owner) that the meatball was wonderful and she told me they are homemade. That was one hundred percent how they tasted and honestly, had they not been already closed when we were leaving, I would have ordered some to take home. If you haven't been and you love a good Parmesan or meatball dish - GO! Also - our server, Mia, was incredibly kind and did a fabulous job of making us feel welcome and helping us order. Thank you, Rosey! read more

Rosie's is a delightful little restaurant in a little plaza that you migh miss if you're not looking. The dinning room is not elegant but rather homey... Very comfortable if a little loud. Pleasant and efficient service. While the food isn't particularly unique or special it is a perfect fit if you're looking for basic and delicious Italian. We will definitely be visiting again soon. read more

See all

Ordered the eggplant parm and this is what it looked like. A total of 1.5 slices of cheese! Kind of felt like eating Italian diner food. read more

Rosey's Italian Cafe - Italian Near Me - Penfield, New York

Some pretty good items, know others who enjoy coming here. The shrimp french was fantastic. The haddock french was good. Unfortunately the pasta wasn't drained long enough or perhaps another factor in the takeout packing process led to just lemony water in the dish, as opposed to butter, oil or 'sauce'. Pasta was well-cooked al dente but as a result of all the water, had no flavor to it. Really was surprised as a pasta-focused restaurant. Service was friendly and efficient. There's a 3% additional charge to pay by credit card, referred to by staff as a 'cash discount'. Both prices are listed clearly on the bill before you pay, so that you can choose knowingly. read more

See all

Food and service are always outstanding! I like giving our business to a small locally owned business and Rosey's always delivers a great experience! read more

Ordered the parm/lasagna special - all three of us did - a hearty portion of lasagna with either chicken Parmesan or eggplant Parmesan - sooo good! Both had the perfect crispy crust paired with a meaty , cheesy lasagna with a generous red sauce - one of the best sauces I've had anywhere! The wait staff were hospitable, attentive and gracious. read more

Rosey's Italian Cafe - Chicken parm/lasagna combo - Italian Near Me - Penfield, New York

Delicious classic meal - my husband said it tasted homemade. He had the veal/chicken combo parm. My son had chicken parm and I had the pasta sampler. We also had calamari and arcinni. All delicious. Def make reservations as almost everyone had them - we went on a Friday night. Service was great read more

I had the opportunity to stop into Rosey's with my family during a recent weekend zip trip to Rochester and was so impressed: + They got 6 of us in on a fairly busy evening with no issues, even though it's a smaller spot. They were super welcoming and accommodating go to the kiddos, and made sure we were all comfortable and had what we needed. + The prices here are great. We had a bottle of Chianti for $19 and the entrees won't set you back too far either. They do a mean takeout game as well it seems and keep up with the volume with no issues. + The food is quite good! I went the eggplant and chicken parm combo with gnocchi on the side. Not the best gnocchi I've had in my life but very serviceable, I just tend to go for a more pillowy soft vibe as opposed to what is served here - a more sturdy style dumpling with ridges. The sauce is not quite as flavorfully robust as I prefer and with a thinner consistency, but that's totally personal preference. I don't know what bread they serve but it is soft and the perfect dipper for your leftover sauce. If you're looking for a good family option in Penfield this should be on your list! read more

Rosey's Italian Cafe - Chicken & Eggplant Parmesan Combo - Italian Near Me - Penfield, New York

We were in for dinner the other evening. The service was excellent attentive knowledgeable server. Food was great. They have restored my faith in humanity as I had dropped a considerable amount of $. When I discovered & called they had it & kept it for me. Big thank you to the staff. We will definitely return just finished leftovers for dinner read more

Food was good but overpriced three people was $73. The service was really bad- one person for majority of restaurant. Took 15 minutes after we sat down to get bread, and we had to ask a busser for it. Ambiance is nice and homey. read more

I just recently tried this place the service was great and the food was amazing I would definitely recommend this place

Chicken cacciatore was subpar. Sauce was like they just opened a can of tomato sauce and put onions and peppers in it. Chicken was little chunks and few and far to be found. Will not be coming back, but have to admit the place was busy with takeouts and people at tables. Fish fry was "ok" per other diner. French fry's cold. For $90 for 3 people, one soda and one glass of wine, I will stay home and cook. read more

Very delicious! I enjoyed this fancy pasta from Uber eats and it's served with garlic bread. The sauce is really nice and I look forward to sampling more. They are also doing a Bogo special on their Caesar salad on Uber Eats and it was excellent as well! read more

Rosey's Italian Cafe - Mussels marinara - Italian Near Me - Penfield, New York

I've been to Rosie's in the past (prepandemic) and really enjoyed it. Today, I had a hankering for some old school Italian and decided to go there. I ordered Lasagna, Broccoli Cheese Soup and a side of meatballs. Oh gosh- won't be back!! Firstly, I would not consider myself to be a low salt cook. I'm pretty liberal with my salt shaker. Everything was sooo salty that I took refuge in my bread and butter and glass of water! Aside from the salt, the quality of the lasagna and the meatballs was ok, but nothing to write home about. The lasagna had oil/grease pooling in it. The soup was horrendous. I know, broccoli cheese isn't exactly Italian, but I do expect Italians to know how to cook. No joke, I think they used powdered cheese, or some kind of instant soup. Again, ridiculously salty. When I concluded I could not eat anything else of my entree due to overwhelming salt and/or grease, I decided to open my little package of saltines that came with the soup. I spat them out because they were soft and stale! It's too bad about this place. It used to be quite good. read more

Old school, Rochester style Italian, on steroids. Home cooking in a little re-purposed house, with the owners on premises as hostess and chef. The beans and greens are the best I've ever had, and the red sauce is award-winning. Service is friendly, and although the restaurant is small, they move the patrons through, so there is little wait, although I recommend a reservation. Great value too. Just sublime. read more

See all

This review is for take-out; physical restaurant and/or staff not included!! To start, this is one of the places that actually gets your order right when you do takeout! I've noticed that many places mess it up-Rosey's did not. We had a pretty big order too. Thank you! Food wise, it was good! Portions are huge. In all honesty, my aunt and I were not super impressed though. Don't get me wrong, it was not bad in the slightest, I just didn't think it was anything special. I had rigatoni with vodka sauce. After a few bites, I thought that maybe adding shake parm would make it a bit more "wow"? It didn't do too much though. I am happy to come back, but think I will order something else besides the vodka sauce. It's always hit or miss for me! But.. we got FREE BREAD! A lot of it. And it tasted absolutely wonderful. Thank you! I had leftovers for breakfast the next day. Only reason I'm not giving 5/5 was simply because my aunt and I both agreed we weren't blown away by our dishes. Perhaps dining in would change my mind? I'll give it a try for sure... read more

See all

I sampled a catering spread. I liked the chicken parm over the chicken french. I think there should have been some Parmesean shake cheese available. The sauce was good, and the chicken parm chicken was crisp but not dry. read more

See all

Yum!! We picked up a wonderful Saturday night dinner from Rosey's, heroically still open during this quarantine. We placed our order through Yelp for later evening pick up, and they made it so easy. The staff wear masks and gloves and bring your order to your car, os they make sure everyone is protected while also able to support their establishment. Our food was delicious. We had their chicken French (full of lemony taste!) and veal Parmesan. The portions are large and the taste very good. We started with garlic bread and side salads. The homemade Italian dressing is light and lovely, but the garlic bread with cheese doesn't hold up great after a drive home - we'll need to try it when we can dine in again. We have leftovers that I can't wait to break into tomorrow, and I'm grateful that a family restaurant like this is still open. Stay safe, support local! #yelpnightin read more

Rosey's Italian Cafe - a table of food - Italian Near Me - Penfield, New York

Food- We had the arancini as an app, which were decent. But both me and my husband were blown away by the taste of our meals!! He got the stuffed pasta meal and said it was all cooked perfectly and tasted amazing, I got an eggplant parm sandwich and I am not exaggerating when I say it was the BEST eggplant parm that I have EVER had- it was so thin and crispy.. Atmosphere- small and casual decor.. Service- Very friendly and attentive server.. read more

Made reservations for 6 pm. We arrived a 5:55 and waited a good 10 minutes before being seated. Sat for another 10 minutes with no water, bread or drink order being taken. Finally came to take drink order & edited another 10 minutes before that arrived. And on it goes. It was almost 6:45 before our order was taken. Finally got our good at about 7:05. I ordered Fra Diavlo. It was Horrible! It included small frozen shrimp, slices of frozen fake crab and frozen fish. The only thing fresh and good was the angel hair pasta on the bottom. It was $24.00. The other 3 guests with me weren't impressed with their meals either. I doubly I'll return. read more

Love this place! Never disappoints. Staff is always very friendly and super attentive. The restaurant is pretty small but very clean and cozy. I love their Italian Wedding soup - but unfortunately they hardly ever have it as an offering. Delicious Haddock or shrimp French, my partner enjoys their rose sauce with the sampler plate (on special often), when it's available. read more

We walked in on a Friday night, no reservation but thought it would be ok as it wasn't even 5:30 yet ... wow, we were not correct! It is a small place and was already packed. It didn't matter though as the hostess quickly found us a spot to sit. The food was amazing - I had sausage Cacciatori, my wife had the chicken Pizzaiola and my daughter had the manicotti. Their sauce is incredible and I would highly recommend Rosey's - get anything that comes with their house made red sauce! The staff is friendly and attentive. We will certainly be coming back. read more

Excellent food and take great care with take-out! I have eaten in and had food delivered. The ambiance is friendly and homey. Delivery was very quick and the food was still hot! Love this place. read more

The tripe is something. Love it! The place Was empty but the reservations where full. read more

Went in last night with my little sister. We were sat right away, even though it was kind of busy. Food came out in less than 10 minutes and was so good! The two girls up front (Sofia and Grace) were so sweet!! I'll definitely be back :)) read more

Always tasty food! Only ever had take out so I'm not sure about the service. But the food is delicious.

Omg this is our 3rd and never last...Tonight I had to ba bang shrimp And I'm still raving about it and on top of that I had their lasagna and their sauce is definitely second to none it is phenomenal. We both had a glass of wine it was like a half a bottle each. LOL My fiancé had a side salad that was huge and then she had a egg plant Appetizer Which was like five beautiful thin pieces just exactly like she likes it, It look like a meal to me.. And she had rigatoni's with oil. I missed the lemon ice last time as I've never had it before and I asked the waitress right away when we got served to make sure that they save some lemon ice. And she did and it was delicious very refreshing. Our waitress was Natalie and she was very sweet and a lot of fun..:) I really like to recommend this place but I'm scared at the same time because so many people are going to try it I'm not gonna be able to get in there on Saturday nights. LOL read more

See all

You simply cannot go wrong with Rosey's. They are so good, I have never had a bad dish! The order is always ready before the time says, and they never forget items. I just wish they had butternut ravioli, it's hard to find around here & it is my favorite. The portions are large, which includes takeout too! They give you bread with your order. Thanks for the awesome food read more

Best Italian food in Penfield! Our table had the chicken parm with gnocchi, lasagna, and rosanello. Everything was delicious!! Our server, Megan, went above and beyond to give us excellent service and to ensure we were having a great meal. The cannolis were also incredible. I can't wait to come back! read more

This is a little restaurant tucked into a tiny strip mall that s absolutely wonderful. Their food tastes like your Italian grandmother made it back home in her kitchen. I highly recommend stopping by (you'll need a reservation so that they can ensure C19 mandates are upheld) or grabbing takeout with curbside service. read more

Amazing Food for a great price. Staff were very welcoming and friendly. Rosey introduced herself as we walked in the door which added to the homey environment. We got the Chicken Alfredo, Lasagna, Veal & Egg Plant Parm combo and the chicken parm. Outstanding meals! Will definitely be coming back! read more

We love Roseys - dine in or carry out is always great! Staff are always super friendly and kind! I love that it's a family owned business and food is fresh and homemade! The only down fall to Roseys is choosing between Chicken Parm and Chicken French- both hands down the very best! And I can't say enough about their fish fry! The only place I will have a fish fry now!!! It's a MUST TRY!!! Recommend to Many friends! read more

They have done many events for us and always deliver great food at fair price. Thanks for the hot, delicious Italian goodies!

This was our first visit to Rosey's, but won't be the last. The service was prompt, friendly and attentive without being instrusive. The homemade sauce and meatballs were excellent, the portion sizes were large and were served quickly. Will recommend to friends and we'll definitely be back. read more

IMHO, their red sauce couldn't be more bland. We've tried eating there several times at the behest of others. Disappointed every time.

Love the food and hard working staff here. Rosey's is a gem on the east side of the city!

With all that's going in the world. We decided to order take out from a restaurant we had never eaten from before. We weren't disappointed here. The food was awesome and enough to feed an army. I was craving chicken french and this was truely delicious.( I normally very picky about it) They give you lots of the juice which I love, the pasta doesnt get dry. And it's so big it's a meal fit for 2. My husband loved his chicken alfredo and also has some for tomorrow. Dont let that garlic bread foul ya! It was awesome! I dont think I could get food here again without that bread. And finally the Arancini. Not what I was expecting, but they were still good. There are veggies in the which I wasnt expecting. When all said and done I would order from here a million times more. Thank you! For working through hard times and pushing out great food!... read more

See all

Discovered this little gem in Penfield. I've only had pasta and veal parmigiana and both were delicious!

Local business. Had been there a couple of years ago. Got carry out last week because tired of driving out to victor to go to the chain pseudo Italian restaurant the kids like. Service was quick and easy. Called order in. Pulled up, someone came out, got my name, then came out. They had mask, gloves, etc... and apologized for making me wait a whopping 2 min... Sauce was good. I liked it a lot... and ate a lot because the kids unfortunately did not - they have gotten used to that sweet fake sauce from that restaurant with unlimited fillers like salad and breadstick. Portion size was excellent ie big, on par with competitors like the 2 Italian restaurants across the street from each other in ER. For the cost though, a much better bargain as it is less expensive at Rosey's. I will order again. And pretend to buy orders for the kids, so I have "leftovers". read more

Had table of 10 and service was great. Atmosphere is mello Italian and menu is awesome. Wine and mixed drinks were good. Salad and table bread were very good. read more

See all