Best restaurant! Food is great, varied menu , the staff is awesome! Never disappointed ever !

Outstanding service our waitress's were outstanding they checked on us and informed us that our order was going to be 15 minutes cause we had a special order added to the chicken wings. You have to try there blueberry mojitos bbq wings outstanding my wife and I also ordered the French onion prime rib sandwich really good flavor. The decor of the restaurant was dark but pub style decor which made it feel friendly and relaxed which allowed us to enjoy each other's company we also found out that they make everything from scratch including the dressing great job read more

For a celebratory dinner, four of us sat near the kitchen door. Servers was trying to move us along like it was a Friday night, inappropriately fast. The place was half seated. From the get-go small bugs flew around us all at the table. Possible fruit flies problem. I was able to kill one. I presented it on a napkin to the young man who was cleaning tables. I asked him to give this to the manager stating there was a bug problem that annoyed our dinner. Crickets! Spaghetti sauce is too thick like a paste. Not good. The stuffed mushrooms appetizer was drop dead delicious. I wouldn't be bothered writing this if not for the bug problem with no managerial comment. read more

This place fills up fast on a Friday night and for good reason. The food was delicious! We each got a different haddock- the French and the Cajun and they were both excellent. We also highly recommend the homemade crumble for dessert. All of the staff are personable and attentive. This place is a 10 out 10! read more

We had take out burgers! Everything was cooked properly packed so it didn't diminish flavor in the travel home! Highly recommended!

Best food around. The service and food quality is dynamite. The three cheese pasta bake always hits the spot!

I love the atmosphere and the flavors of the food, no matter what I order! The service is good and the entire experience was great!

Went out for a fish fry on a recent Friday night. Ambiance was pleasant. Service was excellent. New England Clam Chowder was delicious. The house salad was fresh and crisp. All great so far! Unfortunately the fish fry itself was on the bland side. It took a few good shakes of salt to bring out the flavor. The tartar sauce was a little too sweet for my taste. The mashed potatoes were smooth and creamy but also bland and lacking flavor. So, here we are with some positives and some negatives. I wouldn't even have bothered to write a review except for this - normally the mashed potatoes don't come with gravy so I asked for some. It wasn't the best gravy, but it was okay. I fully expected there to be an upcharge for it, probably $.75 or maybe $1.00 at most. The upcharge for the gravy (a tiny dish of 2 or 3 tablespoons) was $2.00!!! Unbelievable. Sometimes it's the little things that leave the biggest impression. I'm crossing the Arlington off my list. read more

Small portions compared to a few years ago. Ordered Shepards pie and Chicken pot pie. Both full size. Mostly puff pastry over a scattered few pieces of chicken and gravy Hardly any mashed potatoes in the Shepard pie. The potatoes appeared to be instant potatoes. I love comfort food but this left me disappointed. read more

Only one visit with me and my other half. We had bruschetta app, I had chicken parm w/ salad, she had gnocchi w/ salad (both with Italian dressing). Mozzarella was homemade, Italian dressing I think was house made, croutons even looked fresh made. Everything was VERY good. Service was pretty good, they did initially forget our salads but offered to bring them out or give us a free dessert for our trouble. We were checked on a bit throughout but not too much. I would've like to see drinks offered to be refilled at some point, but not a big deal. Dirty dishes were removed from the table quickly. Biggest downside to me is the atmosphere, we sat inside and it was very loud. They also have a "sport bar" type area and NFL ticket so I'm sure game days get crazy! Outside seating looked nice but we were worried about it getting cold. All in all a good experience and I would go back. Price for two with a app was around $55 but neither had drinks (just soda and water), price wasn't bad especially for really good, FRESH, food. Definitely would go again. read more

See all

Good diner food for lunch - never had dinner here We had a turkey club and fries Split the sandwich and fries we fresh and hot read more

Everything was good but the portions. I ordered two full shepherds pies and they were both smaller than I would have thought a full order would be. Maybe a dozen plastic fork fulls and it was gone. That means half an order would be six. Crazy. And expensive. I won't be going back. It used to be a great place. Not sure what's going on now! $60 for two tiny shepherd's pie and two glasses of Chardonnay. read more

Prices went way up. Ordered a cheeseburger little pricey. The waitress asked me what kind of cheese I would like named them all Picked mozzarella. When we got the bill it was a 2.00 up charge. Also up charged my wife 2.00 for blue cheese on her salad. Ended up with a 62.00 bill for a cheeseburger and she had a salad and we had a a beer and a glass of wine. Then we had to tip on top of that. We will never go back not worth it. Was not even that good and we are not fussy read more

A classic Main St dining room indeed. Unpretentious, warm, and inviting. I have eaten in the dining area and yesterday settled in at the bar for drinks and a meal. Blair the bartender ... simply awesome. Attentive, conversational just the right amount, and pours a mean drink. Our party consumed the pasta special, pork cutlets, wings, stuffed mushrooms, and Sicilian calamari. Everybody happy. Next time ... the haddock french. Thanks Arlington. Worth the short drive. read more

Great food and awesome service. Everyone was friendly and a family atmosphere. Will definitely go back.

Went for a birthday dinner on a Saturday night. Loved the remodeling. Waitress was very friendly. Ordered the battered fish fry and steak tips. All was delicious. Rolls are amazing !! read more

Always good food, good people, and great service. The owner can often be found going table to table checking on customers. Love the small town feel. read more

Tasty cuisine, friendly staff and nice portions. My only complaint is the uncomfortable chairs outside. read more

Lovely small town restaurant in small town Hilton. Bought in a time warp but that's not always bad. The food is good , home made and plentiful They have a full bar The rolls were hot and served with butter The salads were fresh and tasty dressing The chicken French was one of the best I've had. It was perfectly cooked and juicy. There was plenty of flavorful sauce and the pasta was al' dente Veggies were fresh and not overdone The meatloaf is a masterpiece. It's huge! It's homemade with lots of mashed potatoes, gravy and fried onion rings. I'm getting that next time Desserts are homemade. The rubarb cobbler was wonderful Not at all fancy Very reasonable prices and lots of choices read more

See all

The food is excellent with fantastic waitresses. If you sit at the bar for drinks or food at the bar, the bartender on Friday nights is awful. No personality or extra attention. Spends a lot of time with "busy work" rather than taking care of patrons. read more

Satisfied every time I have been their...can't wait to go back!! Great food and beverages...pretty bathroom too.

Great food Great service. Highly recommend this restaurant for large families too. Very friendly Staff. The best prime rib and chicken French around !!! read more

The Arlington is a great place to eat. The lunch menu has a lot of options, and my group ordered a variety of meals and each one was very good. Their salads are a good way to start off, or order one as the main dish. The staff is attentive, and provides personal service. The next time I have visitors from out of town I am taking them there to eat. read more

This place is awesome! Never had a bad meal there. Tonight I had steak tips and noodles. Not sure what they call it, but was literally one of the best meals I've ever had! Super friendly staff and super clean. There is always a staff member washing down tables, chairs, and walls. The drinks are always full on and never watered down. This is literally the best restaurant in Hilton! read more

Worst service ever. HAD A VERY RUDE WAITRESS......Debi... She was too interested what was happening at the bar read more

One of my favorites for years, many great meals until recently. Our table of four had a 50% success at receiving a decent meal. My fish was over cooked this time and my sides were cold. Last time my whole meal was cold and my fish fry was oily and overcooked. I had the server take back most of my meal. Probably won't return. read more

Have gone passed this place numerous times, so finally stopped in. Friendly staff and comfortable atmosphere. Made a nice lunch for the end of the work week. read more

Arlington Restaurant - Baja Turkey Burger - Italian Near Me - Hilton, New York

See all

Best food in town. Consistently awesome! They do lots of home style options, but often with a unique twist. Really great establishment.

Came in (August 22, 2020 11pm) told the bar tender one minute please and she threw her hands in the air and made a scene and marched away they rolled her eye back at me and my friend older lady. Not going back read more

awesome food good people and a good vibe. always fun little shenanigans happening to keep the customer experience involved!

My pasta dish was great and my daughter loved her spaghetti and meatballs. Service was quick and friendly. I will be back soon. Thank you. Stop in for local charm. read more

Food is good prices are inline with other restaurants. Only thing is the menu is dated. It has not changed in a long long time. Would like to see then menu updated with new items. read more

Shepherd's Pie was delicious. Fish fry was about average. Excellent IPA on tap. Service was good. Prices are reasonable. A friendly, small-town place that fills up with regulars with conversations jumping across tables. Like their customers, the place is slightly dated, but I like that. read more

Mediocre food, mediocre service, disrespectful management. Okay, so we went on Ash Wednesday, so we couldn't order from the full menu, but the options weren't good. We wanted just spaghetti and marinara but were told we had to have the meatballs. So we got them on the side but were charged 3.50 EXTRA when we didn't even want them. When asked about the charge we were told we ordered it wrong. $16.99 for spaghetti and and a small amount of flavorless marinara? Never again read more

I have been here several times with my fiancee and her family. This place is situated in the small town of Hilton, NY. We don't frequent Hilton very often but when we do, we usually end up here for food. The outside is quaint and simple. It is a standalone building amidst several others surrounding a parking area, which can become quite crowded especially on Friday and Saturday nights. Upon entering, you will see the coat area and a few tables for those who are waiting. A dart board is to the right and the full bar is straight ahead. You go slightly to the left and the dining room approaches. The decor is simple with a rustic farm country type of style. The menu is not a typical family restaurant where you have pages and pages of everything. There is a soup and salad section, a specials section, a burger section, and an entree section. The clam chowder is quite good. I also got the beer battered fish fry with fries and coleslaw. It was very nicely done with a crisp outer layer surrounding the moist fish. The fries are very crispy and the coleslaw went well with the whole ensemble. I have also had the chicken pot pie, which is decent, and the shepherd's pie, which is decent. Their dinner rolls (when they remember) are delicious. Bready and yeasty, the crust gives a touch of crunch, yet gives easily to expose the warm, soft, and chewy interior. The service is decent. Nothing really spectacular. The waitresses do a good basic job. Overall, a nice change of pace from a typical family restaurant. 3.5 stars. read more

Until tonight, it'd been more than 5 years since I'd been to the Arlington. It was my uncle's favorite restaurant, and we'd go at least once when my parents and I were here visiting. Sometime within the past 5 years they got new owners-something my aunt told us. I don't really care for it now that they have new owners and a new menu. My uncle (RIP) would be quite sad to learn they don't have his favorite Steak Diane anymore. It was pretty delicious. Anyway, on to the present. I ordered a Caesar salad. It was okay, but I was really glad that I ordered the dressing on the side, because as it turned out- it was actually a mix of oil, vinegar, and spices. It wasn't a traditional caesar at all, and with my intestinal probs and the fact that oil has 14g of fat/tablespoon, it was a darn good thing I didn't add any. It was totally annoying to not have a real caesar dressing, but I ate the salad anyway. The rest of the fam seemed to like their food, so that was good at least, but I wasn't really impressed. I'd take the way they were 5 years ago over the way they are now any day. read more

Terrible service. Waitress took other tables when we were here first. Waited 30 minutes just for a drink. Would not recommend

This is my favorite local restaurant, and for good reason! The food is fresh, scratch made, homestyle cooking in an intimate setting perfect for families or for sharing laughs with friends. You can't beat the quality or the prices, and you certainly won't find a place with more heart. This is a jewel in Hilton and we are lucky to have it! Chicken French is a Rochester staple and you won't find a better version anywhere. We also love the meatloaf (and it isn't easy to get excited about meatloaf, haha!), the crispy pork cutlets with country gravy, the fish fry, and the burger. We've also never had a miss with the soup special, their award winning chili, or the creative gourmet specials they surprise us with nightly. If you're on the West side, I can't recommend the Arlington enough. Give yourself a break from the dishes and let them do your home cooking tonight. read more

Tuesday night is Pasta night! Good local restaurant with good food. Recommend Tuesday nights for the Pasta night, but food is good all nights. I also recommend the Friday fish fry and the Shepard's Pie. read more

Excellent service every time! Food is delicious and always consistent! Best restaurant in Hilton!