Phenomenal gluten free pizza! I love their pepperoni and mushroom. The sauce is a nice balanced it's not too sweet or too salty

Incredibly good tasting pizza. The stuffed crust is awesome, the flavors are rich, and the texture is crunchy but soft. Staff there was friendly as well. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Create Your Own Pizza 14" Deep Dish - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

We paid $2 for mozzarella. Where art thou? Check your cheese before you leave. This is WI after all. ​It could be there if you squint. Maybe dried out? The remnant of failed mozzarella dreams. It strived to be great but the universe took it's toll. RIP dried alfredo. Be one with the dessert that lacks moisture. You are free now. ​ read more

Rosati's Pizza - I will tell you what isn't in this photo. $2 of mozzarella. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

They always have amazing pizza. Staff is always friendly. I wish they would still have their homemade ranch.

We ordered a deep-dish pizza with bacon from Rosati's, and it did not disappoint! This thing was loaded with cheese--every bite was rich, gooey, and incredibly satisfying. Definitely a super filling meal! Service was great, and they were very respectful of the estimated pickup time, which we really appreciated. While they do have a nice little spot, this is more of a grab-and-go place, so calling ahead and picking up is the best way to go. If you're craving a deep dish that brings the cheese in a big way, Rosati's is absolutely worth it! read more

Rosati's Pizza - Deep dish with bacon - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

The meat lasagna that was to serve two to three people was a serving for one, there was no meat, the one piece of garlic bread was half a sub bread burned, the noodles were barely there, mostly cheese and red water. The order was 15.00 and was worse than a frozen dinner at the store. read more

Worst customer service I've had in a few years! We asked if we could have half Parmesan and half BBQ wings for the 6 piece wing appetizer. We requested this so my partner and I both could have our preferred wing sauce flavors. The cashier which whom was a middle aged male mocked my partner and said " no we can't do half Parmesan and half BBQ but we can do six Parmesan and six BBQ". Our modification request was not acknowledged but met with a rude response. I'm sorry but when did being sarcastic to a customer ever become acceptable? I grew up in the early 2010's in this neighborhood remembering countless days walking to Rosati's on Commercial Ave for a quick bite. Now I will remember how bad the customer service and food is in 2025. The chicken is dry, and the pizza has too much cheese and onions. I will NEVER give Rosati's my money. They need to work on a respectful atmosphere and being flexible with their food when a customers wants a modification's we shouldn't be talked down to. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Not good. We ordered two small pizzas and a 6 piece of wings and it was over $60. The pizza was extremely bland. While the cheese and toppings were decent, the sauce and crust left a lot to be desired. It almost tasted like paper - not very buttery or crispy, super doughy. Wings were alright - probably the only thing I've actually enjoyed. I also like their fried chicken but tbh they usually end up burning it and their French fries are almost always over cooked. I wanted to like this place but I just can't. read more

I don't know what happened to my dish. It was a lasagna, but my lasagna is much better. It seems like they cook the noodles and then put it together. The portion of noodles was small compared to any other restaurant. They were overcooked and the sauce was so watery that I had to dump it out after I reheated the serving. The flavor was bland. I won't be ordering it again. Italian sausage was fine, but the dish overall was not impressive. read more

My husband and I wanted to try a new pizza place, as we like a particular pizza that is found in very Italian-based areas. Rossetti's has a thin crust option and chicken wings so we decided to try that one. (We formerly lived in upstate New York, a bit away from Buffalo, so we are used to having pizza and wings their way.) Unfortunately, it didn't work out so well. I am a bit of a chicken wing snob PLUS, I hate the taste of leftovers. My husband said he did not like the wings and I asked him why... He didn't know the answer. He just didn't like them. I knew why I didn't like them, but I wanted to hear his answer. to me, they tasted like leftover meat. My guess is that they cook up the wings day(s) ahead of time and pop them in the fryer when you order them. They were hot and they were uncoated (which is my preference) but that is all I can say good about them. The bbq sauce was just okay. The order was on time and was hot. If they make some adjustments, we would go back. The crust was not my favorite. It was thin and crispy, which is what I like, but I didn't like the flavor. The rest of the pizza was OK. We will continue our search! read more

Bathroom review I don't think I need to go on about how disgusting the men using this bathroom are but pis stains on the and baseboards of the wall IVF that are ranking 2-10 The music isn't the best buttt it's Ight Smell is ok 7-10 Tp is 2 ply sooo heck ya Good lock 9/10 Helper handle on left side of the toilet is clean and in a good position 6-10 Urinals are very clean and have fresh urinal cakes 10-10 Overall at 6-10 bathroom experience read more

I had a Real bad experience with the delivery driver man . That delivers Most the time . Very very Rude man . To the point we were Literally arguing back and forth. I told him I was going to leave a review, he Stated SO, and that He didn't care . Unbelievable read more

I've heard they have great pizza. They're fairly close to my house. I was looking forward to trying them. Website says they close at 11pm. Google says they close at 11pm. Sign on the door says they close at 11pm. I showed up at 10.35pm, and was told "we're closed". I asked, what time do you close? The guy looks at his watch and says "Ummmmmmmm 10.30" Maybe I'll give them another try and update this review. read more

Hey it's really good pizza I can't say how good it is I don't like Chicago crust that's fancy pizza old school pizza.

My go to pizza spot in Madison! Thin crust is crispy and delicious, ingredients fresh and satisfying. The staff remembers and appreciates their regulars...give them a try, you will become one! read more

Best pizza ever. It's the first place I tried in Madison. The sauce and the crust were just right. The tiramisu was delicious! I had the thin crust and my friend had their stuffed pizza. read more

Before I moved away from Madison, I used to order the Italian beef from Rosati's on a regular basis. It was great. Italian bread with a crusty outside and soft interior, thinly sliced and flavorful roast beef in good proportion, and mozzarella cheese. I would also order the hot peppers (giardinara) and au jus on the side. However, I was recently in town and ordered an Italian beef and was sadly disappointed with the amount of meat on the sandwich. With all the ingredients, it barely filled the bread. That's not how it used to be. Although the flavor and quality of the sandwich was good, given the price of the sandwich and my expectations for what an Italian beef should be, this last experience was extremely disappointing. I just cannot justify giving the review anything more than two stars. I hope they will employ better quality control to assure customers that they will receive the sandwich they pay for. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Italian Beef: a paltry amount of beef, with all ingredients it barely fills half the bread :( - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

The people here are always very nice and the food is great! Best pizza in Madison. Everything I have gotten from sandwiches to salads to pizza is outstanding. read more

So after waiting an hour and a half for our food to be delivered, they got our order wrong. And when I called to complain they offered me a free coke and then told me, and I quote, "fuck you." Never again. Update: They responded to my review claiming that I was vulgar and used racist slurs against them. I will fully admit that I was cussing at them after 2 phone calls and nearly 2 hours of terrible customer service, but I did not use any racial slurs. For them to claim that I did, in a political climate where people face actual racism and racial slurs on a daily basis is completely disgusting. Racism is alive and well in this country, but I am 100% anti-racist and would not have done that no matter how hangry I was. They are also saying that they didn't say 'fuck you' which they did, it was clear as a bell. My guess is that someone is trying to protect their job and cover their ass by saying I was being racist, but that simply wasn't the case. Maybe if you spent more time making and delivering pizzas, and less time arguing with everyone that leaves a bad review on Yelp you would have fewer bad review to start with. Just a thought. If you want your pizza with a side of defensiveness and a false accusation of racism then this is definitely the pizza place for you. read more

In a word..."meh". Ordered a pizza from here on a Saturday evening - the online ordering process was easy and they have a tracker so you can estimate what time your food will arrive - for us, it ended up being about an hour wait. We ordered the "Valentino" with regular pizza sauce rather than BBQ. It wasn't that hot when it got to us, and was super, super greasy. For $30, I expected more. read more

Epic pizza (if you dont like it your taste buds game ended their selves).Also their cannolis are awesome and you know go high or go home so buy everything on the menu read more

Boy oh Boy, if you like bland pizza, dis is dah place. Ordered small thin crust, cheese and sausage. No flavor in the sausage or the sauce. In a word, horrible. Today the pizza market is saturated, competition is fierce. You gotta try really hard to compete. Throw some oregano or something in it. Make it taste like pizza. You suck. read more

First time visit. Just came back. I was really hungry. When u are really hungry bad food also taste good. But here I ordered personal cheese pizza. How wrong can U make that. Below is the list: 1.cheese so hard it takes a bit to chew 2.you ask for fresh dough and what they give u is 7/11 ready made dough The above two ingredients are enough to make a shitty pizza. I wish I just went to dominoes. I asked u was the base fresh made u said yes. U probably meant the base was made last night. read more

Very disappointing. Ordered a thin crust and specifically asked for a thin crust, well done and crispy pizza. The crust could not be more soggy. The response from the location was atrocious when I called to even just ask for a credit or refund. I am stunned. I used to order from this location for years and was back in town visiting. I will never order from them again. I was willing to pay the steep price as I had remembered high quality pizza. The prices have gone up while quality and service have gone down. Done. (Update) Yes, I was in Madison. I had it delivered to a location on Jenifer street. As I said, I was back visiting. Amazing how one can travel from one part of the country to another. read more

Why one star? Well, we've been to the Rosati's location in Oconomowoc for years, excellent food and even better service. We were hoping for a similar experience in Madison, unfortunately, we didn't get it. This was our second time at this location and will be our last. We ordered our food online thinking it would be easier to make sure everything was correct. The order is below. 1) Cheese Ravioli with Tomato/basil and a side salad. 2) A 1/2lb cheeseburger with tomatoes, lettuce and ketchup. 3) 10 wings plain with Ranch dressing on the side. A pretty simple order. We showed up to pickup our food, the receipt clearly stated all the items were included and in the bags. We also asked twice if everything was in the two bags before we drove away. We were assured that all of our items were in the bags. Nope! The side salad and ranch dressing for the wings were both missing. But ketchup and mayo packets were in the bag which neither of us asked for. My girlfriend called the location immediately, it was a 10 minute drive home so we had just been inside the location. She was told they couldn't refund the side salad because of a server issue? They offered to deliver the side salad within the hour or give it to us on our next order? Our next order? That was our last order, ever, from this location. You can't refund $1.85 because we ordered online? Or is it because of a server issue? Either way, avoid this location at all costs. On top of that the food pales in comparison to the Oconomowc location. Don't waste your time or money, there's much better options out there. -Former customer. read more

Love Rosatti Pizza. Delivery is reliable, and pizza always dependable good. Great thin crust. Crunchy and crispy in all the right places, and NOT floppy or doughy anywhere. My favorite specialty pizza is the Valentino (the sauce is a blend of their regular pizza sauce and bbq sauce, mmm...) topped with italian beef sausage, hot peppers (oh yeah!!) onions, and tomatoes. All those toppings are blanketed with melted cheese. Heavenly. They cut their pizza into squares, (if that matters to anyone reading this), and all the pizzas (from what I've experienced thus far) have the toppings underneath the cheese, vs. on the top of the cheese. We've only ever ordered a couple times, anything else from their menu, like pasta, salads, etc. Nothing too notable here, bad or good. Just average. The pizza is why we order from Rosatti's. Highly recommended. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Valentino pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Extra star after the reply to let me know they have online ordering. Unfortunately they do not exist in Santa Cruz, but next time I'm in Madison I will need to order up!! read more

Delicious! Large Lunch business meeting order. Delivered to hotel meeting room. Hot and great quality ingredients. Very fast considering we ordered 6 extra large pizzas and one large salad. A couple opportunities: A serving spoon was not included with the party salad. Envision trying to get lettuce out of the large pan with a standard fork. The pepperoni wasn't marked and looked just like the cheese pizza. read more

Place sucks, John is a wise crack joke. Won't return. Bad service, poor product. Go elsewhere.

I'm not from this area, but I'm here for a few days. I had a hankering for Italian food so I ordered from Rosati's. The food is excellent! I ordered the fettuccine alfredo and mozzarella sticks on the first day. Yum! Today I ordered the cheese lasagna and a personal pizza. Again yum! And the delivery drivers are awesome. I will definitely be ordering from this place again if I'm ever in the area. read more

I love their thin crust pizza but I always feel a little ripped off which keeps me from ordering from them often. They charge a steep delivery fee which if not taken form the tip makes a pizza almost 28 bucks. Other places around here have bullshit delivery fees (along with bitchy statements about not taking the fee out of your tip, as if the person buying the food is responsible for the shitty wage the store pays or the tacked on fee that apparently does not actually support delivery) but they are usually less. read more

I was in town for the weekend with my son (13) and his friend. asked the front desk at my hotel if there was any good Chicago style pizza places in Madison. I was directed to rosati's. such a disappointment. very bland & the crust...just no. the teenagers even thought it was mediocre. we each tried a slice, put the rest in the hall & called a different place. read more

Pretty good sandwiches, and thin crust pizza. Dont care for their Chicago deep dish,stuffed,or pan style pizza,because it tastes like they use margerine in the crust instead of half margerine, half butter, which is the way I like the Chicago deep dish crust to be made. Try the Valentino, on thin crust,and it will spin your cap for sure,and they have a good italian beef sandwich,and sausage sandwich.Overall,its a bit pricey,but they do have some very good choices. They also charge 2.50 for a delivery fee! read more

I ordered a stuffed (Pie) pizza for carryout. When I got home and opened the lid on the box I knew immediately that this was not going to be a good experience. There was very little sauce on top of the pizza to the point where I could see the cheese/dough on about half of the pizza. While having a slice I found out that it was not even cooked completely. I lifted up the layer of cheese and the crust's top third of the dough was not done and had the raw playdough feel with a darker tint to it. I had to call the store about this because I was not going to pay for this. I asked for the manager and he was going to make another one for us but I did not want to wait for another 45 minutes. I was thinking about getting a different type of pizza but the manager was kind of cold over the phone and wanted us to come in again to pick up another pizza. At that point they lost me and it only got worse. I wanted a refund so he instructed me to either come in that night or the next day with the pizza for the refund. So I took the pizza in and showed it to him and explained my dissatisfaction with it. He told me "This is how this pizza is". I know for a fact that this was not true. I used to work in pizza for many years when I was younger for a good amount of time as a kitchen manager/baker. I think I can tell if a pizza is raw or not. I did not want to argue with him in the store, for he has already wasted a good amount of our time and I knew he already had is mind set that we were wrong. He was even rude with his staff while we were there. Not until we were about to leave did he even apologize. Even then it was not sincere and was more a part of the refund transaction. If "this is how their pizza is" then there are many better options in Madison since this place is going in the wrong direction. If you want a good Chicago style or stuffed pizza pie I would suggest Pizza Extreme. Otherwise glass Nikel for your other types of pizza cravings. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Raw Pizza Dough - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Ordered pick up from here twice now. It's more of a 3.5 star place. Guy who took my phone order both times was super friendly (was the same guy in may 2014 and aug 2014). Double checked that I was for sure trying to call the E side place on Commercial. Smart. The first time we were moving and were super starving and it was AMAZING (as former residents of Champaign, IL we had high expectations.... when it comes to college student 'za anyways) and I have no strong memories of either way. We only ordered pick up both times because we live soooooooooo close to this location....... way too close to justify a steep delivery fee. If I had paid an extra 3 bucks for delivery for this, I'd probably be bitching more. Their prices are a bit steep.... This last time a few days ago we ordered the spinach, garlic and tomato pizza. My husband swore up and down the spinach came from a can. I trust him about this and everything so I back him. The garlic was super heavy and strong on some slices and absent on some pieces. Spread it out more evenly!!!! Otherwise delicious. The thin crust and the cheese were delicious. Even the next day for lunch. Will order again. Join their Pizza Eclub online and get an email for 15% off your next order!!!! PS. I never had anything from Rosatis other than pizza.....and I probably wouldn't recommend you do, either, Pizza is where they are at. read more

We ordered two thin crust pizzas on Sunday afternoon. Rosati's has been our go to pizza place for many years. I will not be going back. We ordered a supreme and we had to hunt for any additional toppings. I like lots of toppings on my pizza, so I was very disapointed in the hunt for an olive or green pepper. I am really sad to see the quality go down. read more

I have a coupon for free 12 inch pizza when purchasing 18 inch pizza. It doe NOT specify that it is only good at the Madison WI west location. The east side Madison WI location refused to honor it. The coupon just says "Rosati's" with their logo. Boo shame on them. read more

I must say perfect... I travel for work and it was great to check into my room, find Rosati's on Yelp and have them here within 30 minutes. The food was much more than I anticipated... A MUST try. Very well seasoned and the service was great from the phone call to the delivery... 5 stars all around! The Spinach and Tomato Garlic bread was delicious! read more

See all

again - our delivery wrong on both sandwiches - an order of $27 with tip and they only offered a $10 credit - avoid this place

LOVE the chief sandwich! Their pies are really good too! Both locations are solid and we usually order as take out.