Mama Mia!!! This place is awesome!! I went in for lunch on a Saturday and received a warm greeting from their General Manager,Leo. They were able to seat me quickly and I was immediately welcomed by Carley. Carley has a great personality and took great care of me! The food and atmosphere all wonderful! I will definitely be back! read more

See all

I've been to the Chocolate Shoppe across from Luigi's many times and had wondered about the pizza place. We ordered a 12" with double crust takeout. We started eating it within minutes, outside, but it was just a mess. The square slices are a bit weird but not the end of the world. The soggy bottom was a real problem though. It wasn't like the pizza had been sitting steaming for half an hour, it was less than 5 min from when someone handed us the box. I also wasn't particularly impressed with the double crust/sauce - which I wanted because the menu says thin crust and I like pizza with enough chewy crust to feel like I'm actually eating something. The part underneath the toppings felt like standard crust though, while the thick part was heftier (although strangely puffed because it's 2 layers). The toppings themselves were just ok, not all that flavorful. I'm not sure what went wrong with the crust since even in the restaurant it would come out on a pan. Maybe their double crust just doesn't work? read more

Luigi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Good pizza (I had the Buffalo Chicken personal pan size) in a rather unfriendly atmosphere. The BIG turn off was to be asked if we wanted Parmesan cheese and when we said yes to be served with very tiny little individual packets of rock hard Parmesan in individual sealed packets. Would it kill this place to serve it like ANY OTHER Italian or pizza joint... in a glass shaker? read more

Quite possibly my favorite pizza in Madison? Tucked along Midvale in Sequoya Commons on the west side of Madison, Luigi's offers high-quality pizza with a great thin crust and a good variety of different options. The Maximus, Il Capo, Fugetaboutit, the Margherita - I have yet to be disappointed. It is a little more pricey (when compared to Novanta, for example), which is the only thing keeping Luigi's from five stars. I have yet to dine in person (that COVID thing), but the takeout/delivery experience has overall been pretty good, although they do get busy on Friday evenings, so there may be a line for pickup. As far as delivery apps, they are on Eatstreet, Doordash, and GrubHub. read more

Went here on a Thursday night. The place wasn't super busy for inside seating, but there were plenty of takeout orders happening. The not busy was nice since we had kids with and the waiter was pretty helpful in accommodating them. Note to parents, none of the food comes out quickly, so have snacks if the kids are hungry on arrival. We ended up ordering a meatball appetizer right away along with a kids cheese pizza. When the appetizer came out, we ordered a couple salads and the spicy Italian sandwich. This was our first time not ordering pizzas when coming here. The meatballs were pretty good, but there are only 4 of them to the plate. Next to come out was the fancy salad and the kids pizza with a very generous portion of fruit. The salad was fine, but was smaller than expected. The cheese pizza was very tasty with a crispy crust and a very good ratio of sauce to cheese to bread. Good value for kids. After a few more minutes the Arthur salad came out. It was also fine, but felt like there should have been more pasta. Also the prosciutto was more like thick cut bacon and it was a little too salty for my taste preferences. It was also too overly dressed do that the greens were soggy. I should have probably asked for dressing on the side. Finally the sandwich came out and it was a favorite. We'll packed with meat and the chili aioli gave a nice kick. It was also large enough to have some leftovers. Overall, I would say stick to ordering pizzas and sandwiches as those were the favorites. It also seemed kind of odd that our main dishes didn't come out at the same time, which made for awkward eating. Might just stick to takeout in the future. read more

Luigi's Pizza - The Arthur - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

I have passed this restaurant many times thinking I should stop in and have a meal. I had heard lots of great things about the pizzas being delicious. We stopped in for dinner and we met with a sign that stated that it would be counter service only due to lack of staff. That was fine. The staff was friendly. There were a lot of folks that were ordering carry out, so there was a bit of a wait for our food. They had nice choices of drinks, including Italian sodas and some wine and beer. The ambience had some jazzy music playing in the background and gave it a cool vibe. The pizzas were delicious the barbecue chicken was very tasty. My husband had a build your own pizza with a few toppings. The amount that is charged per additional topping was pretty expensive. Looking at others reviews I'm not the only one that feels this way. While the pizza was good, it is overpriced compared to somewhere like Salvatore's. My rating would be a 3.5 for this place. Definitely a place that is good to eat at but be aware if you're building your own pizza it's going to be very pricey. read more

Luigi's Pizza - 12" BBQ Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

It's easy to not know about this place. It's kind of off-the-beaten path. The place is dark with the requisite jazz/Sinatra/40s Italian music playing. The pizza menu is large, and the pizza is good. Thin crust, topped well, and very flavorful. The staff was lovely. The prices were not extreme. It's a solid little pizza place. There's better pizza places in Madison, but not many. Definitely worth a return trip someday. read more

Went here for valentines with my partner. I got the chicken Alfredo pizza, he got the fig and prosciutto pizza. Both amazing!! We got garlic cheese bread to share which was perfect and dessert knots afterwards which weren't my favorite but just fine. Service was on the slower side but seemed like there was only 1 server and he did a great job! Definitely will be coming back!! read more

Luigi's Pizza - 12" Chicken Alfredo 12" Fig & Prosciutto - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Staff seemed to be poorly trained. Called to order Valentine's Day special (heart shaped pizza + bottle of wine) and guy who answered the phone didn't know what it was, if it could be ordered for take out vs dine-in only, or how to ring it up (couldn't find button on register). I said I would pick up the pizza at 4:30pm and when I got there I waited 15+ min and had about 7 workers just standing around staring at me. Pizza was alright read more

Luis- I can not respond to you privately can you email me at kluybern@gmail.com Thank you Nicole read more

Luigi's Pizza - a container of tomatoes and mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Pizzas are so good! You have the option of doing half and half as well which is cool - that allows to try different types of pizza if you have a hard time choosing. Came on a Saturday night with a group of 4 adults and a baby. We were quoted 20-30 minutes for a table, but it only took 5! The restaurant was busy and we sat near the kitchen and saw the to-go orders being cranked out. Service was pretty slow, but our server was such a sweetheart! We ordered two large pizzas, one Sequoya Bomber/Fugetaboutit and one The Goods/The Racket. All of them were so good! My favorite was The Racket with white sauce, sausage, mushroom, and truffle oil, even though it was on the greasier side. The lights in the booths are uncomfortably bright. We ended up unscrewing ours for the meal. read more

Cozy, out of the way place. Friendly, casual but prompt service. Abundant choices, unique flavors, very reasonable prices. We'll make it a point to return when we're back in Madison! read more

We like their pizzas very much--among the best in the Madison area . We go there often. Kudos!

It's a solid place for tasty pizza and good beers on tap. The day we went they seem short staffed but the crew that was present was working super hard. The food took a little longer than usual but was delicious. Easy parking. They do a lot of take out business. Patio available for nice days. read more

Luigi's Pizza - Beer flight - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

This cauliflower pizza crust is amazing! Crispy and crunchy with excellent toppings! Our server was friendly and organized. Luigi's isn't the fanciest restaurant but the food makes up for it! read more

Luigi's Pizza - The cauliflower crust pizza is AMAZING! I highly recommend Luigi's for Keto friendly pizza. Crisp and just like flour pizza crust! - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Really good pizza! Crust was perfect and service fantastic. Need to mention, it was also ready in 15 minutes.

Came with a gift card, and were happy with our experience! They only had one server, but she did so well at balancing a busy Saturday night! All of our food was just mouth-watering and delicious! We had Mac and cheese, lasagna, a thin crust pizza and a pizza with the cauliflower crust. We will definitely be back to try a few more things off their delicious menu! read more

See all

$33 Dollar pizza that had slices with no toppings!!! $2.50 for 11 pieces of banana peppers!!! Black olives were worse, only put in the very middle. Who made this shit pizza??? FUCK THIS CHEAP ASS PLACE!!! 12" Maximus * Red Sauce & Pesto* (+ $1.00) * Shredded Parmesan* (+ $2.50) * Fresh Mozzarella* (+ $2.50) * Mozzarella * Extra Mozzarella* (+ $2.00) * Black Olives* (+ $2.50) * Banana Peppers* (+ $2.50) * Pepperoni* (+ $2.50) * Bacon* (+ $2.50) read more

I didn't love this pizza. My mom liked it but she likes burnt food. I thought it was cooked/browned a little too long. The cheese bread also felt like a prank, it was sooooooooo small. Only real positive is that it was made fairly quick read more

I don't understand the hype. There was a sign for counter service only, seat yourself. Almost every table was filled with dirty plates but luckily we got one of the last clean tables. We ordered at counter, 2 pizzas and 2 kids meals. Pizzas were brought out, room temp and crust was soggy. Crust also had no flavor. Kids meals took an extra 10 minutes after we asked where it was. One was buttered noodles, one was supposed to be spaghetti and meatballs. On the printed paper menus in the front, there was no kid menu but saw online. The noodles were in a puddle of oil. The "spaghetti and meatballs" were actually "cavatappi and meatball (singular) with red sauce". The red sauce wasn't even mixed, it was cold noodles with sauce and meatball placed on top. The whole meal was not worth $50. Dissatisfied and disappointed. read more

Ok outside dining nice pizza. Thin crust which I like. Service prompt and efficient and friendly. read more

Luigi's Pizza - Salad - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

BBQ chicken pizza (lunch size 6") was perfect size for me. Pineapples and onions were fresh. Flight option was okay. They gave me a fourth option since they were out of the one I wanted. Peanut butter Porter was delicious! (Stevens Point?) Social distancing is being practiced and the employees were wearing masks. Also, gloves were worn to our table. read more

See all

Got a variety of items to go on a cold winter evening: the wiseguy pizza, the spaghetti and meatballs, and pizza pinwheels. Can you say carboloading? My favorite was the pinwheels. They reminded me of Stella's spicy cheese bread with the gooey cheese baked into the bread. Addictive! The pizza was tasty. Very thin crust with plentiful sausage and spicy chilies. I would maybe take more cheese on top, but that's coming from an Uber Wisconsinite here. We have leftovers - look forward to eating those. Spaghetti was alright. Not a super flavorful sauce but a few good, hearty meatballs and a decent serving size. Friendly and quick service. Another good Food Fight experience! read more

Valentine's Day special where no more in restaurant orders are taken cause they have taken too many pickup orders. Also can't place an order for the rest of the night at about 6pm? Pretty sick and well planned if you ask me. Thanks for making a fun little non-serious valentines ruined! Don't advertise 35 dollar valentines deals if you are incapable of accommodating, and don't stop serving in restaurant before you stop taking call-ins and online orders like you are currently doing despite telling us to our faces you weren't. Managers really screwed your staff on this one. read more

We went on a Thursday night recently and the place was not too busy. We were heavy disappointed that night. Tables still had dirty dishes and were not cleaned. Took a while for someone to seat and serve us. The pizza's were burned and other patrons had the same experience with burned pizza when we asked. This is not what we expect from Luigi's. The quality of service and food has always been good. If this is the new way Luigi's is run, we will definitely not be back. read more

Met some friends here for supper when I was up here for a work trip. None of us had been here before. The mask mandate was in effect, so masks were required when not seated. The service was quick and friendly. Drinks came quickly and the cheesy bread and pizza were very good. I got the Racket, which the mushrooms were delicious and the rest was pretty good, as well. I'd recommend this if you're looking for some decent pizza in the area. read more

Excellent lasagna! The best I've ever had! And, awesome spaghetti and meatballs! A perfect blend of herbs and spices. The Regular Fancy salad is delicious, too! Dessert rocked! We had the LEMON CREAM ITALIAN CAKE (fabulous!!!) and the Chocolate Layer Cake. We love coming here! Try it! You'll love it! read more

There was a problem, and they politely/promptly corrected it. Im very grateful for them, Thank you!

Most relevant A patient of mine recommended we go here as her family goes once a week. So on a weekday , my grandson birthday and being very close to my house we decided to go here. My son , grandson and myself arrived first . We go in and the lady says to another gentleman where would you like them to sit ? This gentleman says I dont care sit them anywhere, I tell her it'll be 6 of us , mind you we walk in with gift bags and balloons , the lady sits us at a table , there is only one other couple in a booth and a employee pushing tables together . The employee comes over to our table and says I'm gonna need you to move we have a party of 7 coming in and we need these tables . I said she sat us here , he was up to the hostess and tell her so the guy who says he don't care where we sit comes over to us and tells us we have to get up cause they need our table. I ask him where should we sit he says find a seat anywhere, I said the booth isn't big enough for us, so he says go outside. I tell him I find it very rude that he kicks us out from our table. So we go outside and sit it's a couple at tge table next to us talking to us .. my daughter and her 2 children show up and I say they haven't brung water , menues or anything to us , so my daughter goes inside to ask and they tell her we will bring you menues later just sit down cause it'll be awhile . My daughter tells us what was said and the couple next to us hand us their menus . I tell them no we will just leave they was very apologetic on behalf of the restaurant. I don't know If the staff was just racist or rude , either way clearly they didnt want to service me and my family so we definitely won't go back again read more

We ordered takeout from Luigi's for national pizza day. Ordering is so easy - very straightforward, and it took only 15-20 min until our order was ready. I got a text alert and email, and was able to text a number when we got there to have them bring our order out. I mentioned we had our dog with us, so they took a picture for Instagram. We're proud to be part of the "dogs of Luigi's" pack! The pizza was delicious and really hit the spot. The only downside was the growling of our stomachs on the drive home. That fresh pizza smell was killing us! We realized we should have just eaten it in the parking lot. read more

Luigi's Pizza - Bacon, Fresh Mozzarella and Caramelized Onion Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

We enjoyed our dinner at Luigi's. My daughter got the Margarita Pizza and she was very happy with the flavor of the sauce and the crispness of the crust. I had a house salad and I loved the dressing! We shared a pitcher of the Red Sangria and it was delicious! I will order it again for sure! The outside seating was nothing special but it was a beautiful night and the adjoining parking lot wasn't too busy so it did not affect our evening. read more

We tried the Pizza pinwheels as a side and have sense ordered them 5 more times as our entree. The regular pizza is great as well but the pinwheels are unreal! read more

Overall: Luigi's is a great option for a local pizzaria, just be wary of the $$$. The good: Ordered take-out and it was ready in a little over 10 minutes, and was hot and ready when it arrived at the house. The dough knots were fluffy and large and tasted great. We got 3 pizzas, the wiseguy, marg, and chicken alfredo, and each one was delicious in its own way. The wiseguy was spicy yet not overwhelming and the alfredo wasn't too powerful with the chicken, and the cornmeal-dusted crust was great on all fronts. The not-so-good: Only issue is the price. $20+ per pizza is a bit excessive. read more

Excellent crust flavor and texture. We have been searching for a good thin crust pizza in Madison, and this is a rare one!

In one word: "oof". Risked going to luigis after loads of anecdotes about the "50/50" of having a good experience and sadly fell on the wrong side of 50 (mostly due to horrendouss staff/customer service experience). Ordered 3 pizzas and a side and upon going to grab it (per the eta) the staff could not find our order. After finding it, instead of being told "our bad, we missed it" we were told we needed to wait another 20 mins and that "website eta was wrong on waittimes because eatstreet doesn't put their stuff in correctly". 20 minutes later, not one of our pizzas were ready. Tried to ask a staff member and he put a single "wait" finger to my face, typed into the POS system then turned around and walked away. It wasn't until we asked another staff member until he told us "5 more minutes" (this continued)....30 minutes later we has 2 of the 3 and was told there was a back up in the kitchen. After 45 minutes of standing and waiting in the restaurant (after being given a 15 minute eta after our original 20 minute eta), we were fortunate to speak to the manager who is the only reason the review is a 2 versus a 1. He was open and honest, comped the meal, and told us the kitchen originally missed our order and then also had to remake one pizza after burning it. (Which is fine, just be honest with your customer) Long story short, had various staff members lie to our face about "why" the delay was happening, kept us waiting in 5 minute increments for close to an hour, and eventually also gave us a pizza of which had raw dough as the crust (we did order a thicker dough for that pizza, but it still shouldn't come out straight raw). 4 years in madison, and one of the worst, and most disrespectful customer services experiences to date. read more

I came here for my fathers birthday and let me tell you I wasn't disappointed compared to my prior visit! Our pizzas came out fast! The gluten free accommodations were impressive with the cauliflower crust and vegan crust both being gluten free. They also had vegan mozzarella which was subpar in flavor, but not bad whatsoever. The raspberry lemonade was great and the service was just as good if not better. My only complaint would be that for the price, our gluten free pizzas were small. It's a 2 dollar up charge for a crust that is 2" smaller than the standard. Overall quality was there! Just some minor tweaks and a 5 star review is guaranteed! read more

Service was absolutely horrible. We were waiting 25 minutes just to be seated when there were multiple seats available. Some some seats were clean, so my family didn't see why we weren't seated. About half of the seats still had dirty plates and napkins on them, from the staff we saw, no one came over to seat us and they were distracted talking to each other. When a worker finally came to us, he briefly pointed to a seat and left us. Our waiter brought us our menus a few minutes later. My family and I had decided what we wanted soon after, but our waiter never returned. Two other tables were served that arrived after us. My family waited 40 minutes before leaving. We were so disappointed with the service here. As we headed to the car to leave, we saw our waiter at the ice cream shop across the street. Clearly the staff were not doing their job and were heavily slacking. Extremely disappointed, never coming back. read more

I ordered take out for lunch the lasagna and Hawaii Pie-O. The thin crust pizza is super delicious and crunchy. The lasagna cheese is melted and crispy on top of the pasta. The delivery was quick and the food was kept warm. I have never dined in however this is my 3rd take out with them and they never disappoint! read more

Luigi's Pizza - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Okay a few months ago I was here and had a great experience the pizzas were amazing. Last week I dropped in with my 2 kiddos and I think they gave me yesterday's pizza reheated. The sauce was fried and didn't have any flavor. I really can't believe it dried sauce but the bottom wasn't crisp. The only reason would be the pizza sat for hours. They just went from a 5 to a 2. Watch out customers. My one child's cheese pizza was a tad wonkey with dehydrated sauce and a funny color to the pizza. While my other child's pepperoni pizza seemed on. I'm not sure what the deal was but I wasn't able to eat mine. read more

See all

Easy pick up curbside and great pizza ! Can't beat a great cheese pizza. Thin with good crisp. Updated now on keto diet and the cauliflower crust was amazing and one of the only places in town with it thank read more